Abstract
Purpose Competently performing the ocular examination is an essential skill of every graduating
medical student. Assessment of competence in performing the ocular examination is
equally essential. Unfortunately, there is a paucity of tools useful in assessing
clinical competence in ophthalmology. The Objective Structured Clinical Examination
(OSCE) format has been shown to be a useful tool to assess clinical competence in
other academic settings. It is hypothesized that the OSCE format can be used to assess
clinical competence in performing the ocular examination. This study presents the
novel use of the OSCE format for assessing competence in obtaining a history of headache
and performing the ocular examination by third and fourth year medical students.
Methods Observational design was used to assess the competence of third and fourth year medical
students in taking a brief history on the chief complaint of headache and performing
the ocular examination. The ophthalmology OSCE was used after a one-week ophthalmology
clerkship at the University of Wisconsin-Madison School of Medicine and Public Health.
Standardized patients were trained by ophthalmology staff prior to the OSCE. The standardized
patients were not dilated for the direct ophthalmoscope portion of the examination.
Results Students were graded on their performance in obtaining a history of headache and
performing the ocular examination. The ocular examination included assessment of ocular
motility, pupils, using confrontation to find a visual field defect, and using the
direct ophthalmoscope to match a standardized patient's optic nerve to one of four
photos in the room. A check box system was used to assess the student's competence.
This was reported as pass, marginal, or fail. Failing students were remediated by
an ophthalmologist. A total of 384 students took the exam from 2008 to 2012. Overall,
84% received a passing score, 11% received a marginal score, and 5% received a failing
score.
Conclusion Establishment of competence and assessment of competence continue to be a major focus
of medical student education. The OSCE format provides a standardized testing platform
to assess competence with performing the ocular examination. Use of standardized patients
provides a more natural format than paper-based or other methods of assessment.
Keywords
OSCE - assessment - medical students - evaluation - fundoscopy
