Do concepts of childhood trauma and dissociation provide an epistemological linkage between schizophrenia and PTSD?

C. Peña-Salazar; F. X. Arrufat Nebot; M. J. Alvarez; H. Masramón Fontseré; M. Coll-Negre; P. Roura-Poch; J. Valdés-Stauber

doi:10.1055/s-0037-1616371

Nervenheilkunde, Table of Contents

Nervenheilkunde 2016; 35(04): 242-251
DOI: 10.1055/s-0037-1616371

Übersichtsartikel

Schattauer GmbH

Do concepts of childhood trauma and dissociation provide an epistemological linkage between schizophrenia and PTSD?

Inwiefern leisten die Begriffe Kindheitstrauma und Dissoziation einen wissenschaftstheoretischen Brückenschlag zwischen Schizophrenie und PTSD?

C. Peña-Salazar

¹Vic Hospital Consortium, Spain

,

F. X. Arrufat Nebot

¹Vic Hospital Consortium, Spain

,

M. J. Alvarez

¹Vic Hospital Consortium, Spain

,

H. Masramón Fontseré

²Sant Josep Clinic-Barcelona, Spain

,

M. Coll-Negre

³Cambian Churchill Hospital. Mental Health Services in London, United Kingdom

,

P. Roura-Poch

¹Vic Hospital Consortium, Spain

,

J. Valdés-Stauber

⁴Zentrum für Psychiatrie Südwürttemberg, University of Ulm, Germany

› Author Affiliations

Abstract

Zusammenfassung

Hintergrund: Seit Bleuler und Janet wurde der Betrachtung von Schizophrenie als dissoziatives Phänomen wenig Beachtung geschenkt. Eine strikte Trennung zwischen Schizophrenie als ausschließlich biologischen Prozess und dissoziativen Störungen als alleinige Folge von traumatischen Erlebnissen in der Kindheit ist inzwischen überwunden. Methode: Die Autoren wählen eine narrative Literaturübersicht, die mögliche Zusammenhänge zwischen Kindheitstraumata, dissoziativen Störungen und psychotischen Symptomen in der Allgemeinbevölkerung als auch bei an Schizophrenie leidenden Menschen empirisch untersuchen. Wissenschaftstheoretische Partikularitäten postulierter Zusammenhangsannahmen werden diskutiert. Ergebnisse: Die untersuchte Literatur legt die Annahme nahe, dass schizophrene Menschen, die gleichzeitig dissoziative Störungen aufweisen, unter stärkeren positiven psychotischen Symptomen, häufiger Komorbidität und höherer Krankheitsbelastung leiden. Andererseits weisen Patienten mit „strukturellen dissoziativen Störungen“ phänomenologische Ähnlichkeiten mit schizophrenen Patienten. Gemeinsame biologische als auch psychologische Erklärungsansätze werden diskutiert. Schlussfolgerungen: Anhand der hier diskutierten empirischen Ergebnissen darf beim heutigen Wissensstand davon ausgegangen werden, dass sowohl posttraumatische Belastungsstörungen (PTSD) als auch schizophrene Psychosen auf biologischen als auch auf eine das Selbst vor unerträglichen Bedrohungen schützende Abwehrfunktionen basieren, jedoch klinisch und phänomenologisch unterschiedlich zum Ausdruck kommen.

Summary

Background: The possible nature of schizophrenia as somewhat dissociative has been paid less attention since Bleuler and Janet. Today, the strict dichotomy between schizophrenia as a solely biological process and dissociative disorders as a psychological consequence of traumatic events in childhood has been widely discredited. Method: In this section, there is a discussion on the extensive literature about associations between trauma in childhood, dissociative disorders, and psychotic symptoms in the general population and in people suffering from schizophrenia. Intrinsic epistemological difficulties are discussed. Results: Studies suggest that schizophrenic patients showing dissociative symptoms suffer from more severe positive psychotic symptoms and a higher comorbidity as well as the burden of the disease; otherwise, patients suffering from so-called ‘structural dissociative disorders’ show phenomenological similarities with schizophrenic patients. Different possible biological as well as psychological pathways were discussed. Conclusions: Probably, both posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and schizophrenia stem from a biological basis as well as a dissociative processing of psychological threats for the self, but in a phenomenological different way. The overlapping symptoms and risk factors stated in the literature give an important impetus to the epistemological as well as the ontological discussion in psychiatry and medicine.

Schlüsselwörter

Dissoziation - Wissenschaftstheorie - psychotische Symptome - Schizophrenie - Kindheitstraumata

Keywords

Dissociation - epistemology - psychotic symptoms - schizophrenia - trauma

Full Text

References

References
1 Bob P, Mashour GA. Schizophrenia, dissociation, and consciousness. Consscious Cogn 2011; 20: 1042-9.
2 Van Os J, Linscott RJ, Myin-Germeys I, Delespaul P, Krabbendam L. A systematic review and meta-analysis of the psychosis-contimuum: evidence for a psychosis proneness-persistence-impairment model of psychosis disorder. Psychological Medicine 2009; 39: 179-195.
3 Andreasen NC, Carpenter WT. Diagnosis and classification of schizophrenia. Schizophr Bull 1993; 19: 199-214.
4 Butler LD. Normative dissociation. Psychiatr Clin N Am 2006; 29: 45-62.
5 Tonskowa T, Bob P. Consciousness, awareness of insight and neural mechanisms of schizophrenia. Rev Neurosci 2015; 26: 295-304.
6 Sass LA, Parnas J. Schizophrenia, consciousness, and the self. Schizophr Bull 2003; 29: 427-44.
7 Moskowitz A. Associations and dissociation in the historical concept of schizophrenia. In: Moskowitz A, Schäfer I, Dorahy MJ. (eds.): Psychosis, trauma, and dissociation. Emerging perspectives on severe psychopathology. Clinchester, UK: Wiley; 2008: 35-50.
8 Moskowitz A, Heim G. Eugen Bleuler’s Dementia Praecox or the Group of Schizophenias (1911): A centenary appreciation and reconsideration. Schizophr Bull 2011; 37: 471-479.
9 Bleuler E. 1950. Dementia praecox or the group of schizophrenias. 1st ed.. New York, NY: International University Press;
10 Azorin JM, Kaladjin A, Besnier N, Cermolacce M. Who is called “schizophrenic”?. Therapie 2008; 63: 231-5.
11 Ashok AH, Bangh J, Yeragani VK. Paul Egon Bleuler and the origin of the term schizophrenia (Schizophreniegruppe). Indian J Psychiatry 2012; 54: 95-6.
12 Tölle R. Eugen Bleuler (1857–1939) und die deutsche Psychiatrie. Nervenarzt 2008; 79: 90-8.
13 Maatz A, Hoff P, Angst J. Eugen Bleuler’s schizophrenia – a modern perspective. Dialogues Clin Neurosci 2015; 17: 43-9.
14 Stotz-Ingelath G. Epistemological aspects of Eugen Bleuler’s conception of schizophrenia. Med Health Care Philos 2000; 3: 153-9.
15 Scharffeter C. Eugen Bleuler (1857–1939). Polyphrenie und Schizophrenie. Zürich: vdf Hochschulverlag an der ETH Zürich; 2006
16 Van der Hart O, Horst R. The dissociation theory of Pierre Janet. J Traumatic Stress 1989; 2: 397-412.
17 Carlson ET. The history of dissociation until 1880. In: Queen JM. (ed): Split minds/Split brains. New York: New York University Press; 1986
18 Bleuler E. Affectivity, Suggestibility, Paranoia. Utica, NY: State Hospitals Press; 1912
19 Rosenbaum M. The role of the term schizophrenia in the decline of diagnoses of multiple personality. Gen Psychiatry 1980; 37: 1383-5.
20 Schneider K. Clinical psychopathology. New York, NY: Grune & Stratton; 1959
21 Kluft RP. First-rank symptoms as a diagnostic cueto multiple personality disorder. Am J Psychiatry 1987; 144: 293-8.
22 Van der Kolk BA, van der Hart O. Pierre Janet and the breakdown of adaptation in psychological trauma. Am J Psychiatry 1989; 146: 1530-40.
23 Keupp H. Das Subjekt in der Postmoderne-Zwischen Multiphrenie und Selbstsorge. Psychiat Prax 2003; 29 (Suppl. 01) 3-14.
24 Watkins JG, Watkins HH. Egostates-Theory and Therapy. New York: WW Norton; 1997
24 Panksepp J. Affective neuroscience. The foundations of human and animal emotions. New York: Oxford University press; 1998
25 Nijenhuis ERS, van der Hart O, Steele K. Trauma-related structural dissociation of the personality. Trauma Information Pages. January 2014 http://www.traumapages.com/a/nijenhuis-2004.php
26 Van der Hart, Nijenhuis ERS, Steele K. The haunted self-Structural dissociation and treatment of chronic traumatization. New York: WW Norton; 2006
27 Ross CA, Joshi S, Currie R. Dissociative experiences in the general population. Am J Psychiatry 1990; 147: 1547-52.
28 Ross CA. (ed) Dissociative identity disorder. Diagnosis, clinical features, and treatment of multiple personality. 2nd ed.. New York: John Wiley & Son; 1996
29 Ellason JW, Ross CA, Fuchs DL. Lifetime axis I and II comorbidity and childhood trauma history in dissociative identity disorder. Psychiatry 1996; 59: 255-66.
30 American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. Arlington, VA: American Psychiatric Publishing; 1985
31 Putnam FW. Dissocitation in children and adolescents. A developmental perspective. New York: The Guilford Press; 1997
32 Holowka DW, King S, Saheb D, Pukall M, Brunet A. Childhood abuse and dissociative symptoms in adult schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Research 2003; 60: 87-90.
33 Nelson MD, Saykin AJ, Flashman LA, Riordan HJ. Hippocampal volume reduction in schizophrenia as assessed by magnetic resonance imaging: A meta-analytic study. Archives of General Psychiatry 1998; 55: 433-40.
34 Rudegeair T, Farrelly S. Pharmacotherapy in the collaborative treatment of trauma-induced dissociation and psychosis. In: Moskowitz A, Schäfer I, Dorahy M. (eds.): Psychosis, trauma, and dissociation-Emerging perspectives on severe psychopathology. Clinchester, UK: Wiley; 2009: 307-318.
35 Scharfetter C. Ego-fragmentation in schizophrenia: A severedissociation of self-experience. In: Moskowitz A, Schäfer I, Dorahy M. (eds.): Psychosis, trauma, and dissociation-Emerging perspectives on severe psychopathology. Clinchester, UK: Wiley; 2009: 51-64.
36 Ross CA, Heber S, Norton GR, Anderson D, Anderson G, Barchet P. The dissociative disorder interview schedule: A structured interview. Dissociation: Progress in the Dissociative Disorders 1989; 2: 169-89.
37 Steinberg M. Structured clinical interview for DSM-IV dissociative disorders. Washington DC: American Psychiatric Press; 1993
38 Foote B, Park J. Dissociative identity disorder and schizophrenia: Differential diagnosis and theoretical issues. Current Psychiatry Reports 2008; 10: 217-22.
39 Copolov D, Trauer T, Mackinnon A. On the non-significance of internal versus external auditory hallucinations. Schizophrenia Research 2004; 69: 1-6.
40 Glaser JP, van Os J, Thewissen V, Myin-Germeys I. Psychotic reactivity in borderline personality disorder. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 2010; 121: 125-34.
41 Dorahy MJ, Shannon C, Seagar L, Corr M, Stewart K, Hanna D. et al Auditory hallucinations in dissociative identity disorder and schizophrenia with and without a childhood trauma history: Similarities and differences. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 2009; 197: 892-8.
42 Read J, Van Os J, Morrison AP, Ross CA. Childhood trauma, psychosis and schizophrenia: A literature review with theoretical and clinical implications. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 2005; 112: 330-50.
43 Morgan C, Fisher H. Environment and schizophrenia: Environmental factors in schizophrenia: Childhood trauma – A critical review. Schizophr Bull 2007; 33: 3-10.
44 Spataro J, Mullen PE, Burgess PM, Wells DL, Moss SA. Impact of child sexual abuse on mental health: Prospective study in males and females. The British Journal of Psychiatry 2004; 184: 416-21.
45 Bebbington PE, Bhugra D, Brugha T, Singleton N, Farrell M, Jenkins R. et al Psychosis, victimisation and childhood disadvantage: Evidence from the Second British National Survey of Psychiatric Morbidity. The British Journal of Psychiatry 2004; 185: 220-6.
46 Janssen I, Krabbendam L, Bak M, Hanssen M, Vollebergh W, de Graaf R. et al Childhood abuse as a risk factor for psychotic experiences. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 2004; 109: 38-45.
47 Spauwen J, Krabbendam L, Lieb R, Wittchen HU, van Os J. Impact of psychological trauma on the development of psychotic symptoms: Relationship with psychosis proneness. The British Journal of Psychiatry 2006; 188: 527-33.
48 Álvarez MJ, Roura P, Osés A, Foguet Q, Solà J, Arrufat FX. Prevalence and clinical impact of childhood trauma in patients with severe mental disorders. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 2011; 199: 156-61.
49 Bentall RP, Wickham S, Shevlin M, Varese F. Do specific early-life adversities lead to specific symptoms of psychosis? A study from the 2007 the Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey. Schizophr Bull 2012; 38: 734-40.
50 Shevlin M, Houston JE, Dorahy MJ, Adamson G. Cumulative traumas and psychosis: An analysis of the National Comorbidity Survey and the British Psychiatric Morbidity Survey. Schizophrenia Bulletin 2008; 34: 193-9.
51 Varese F, Smeets F, Drukker M, Lieverse R, Lataster T, Viechtbauer W. et al Childhood adversities increase the risk of psychosis: A meta-analysis of patient-control, prospective – and cross-sectional cohort studies. Schizophrenia Bulletin 2012; 38: 661-71.
52 Read J, Perry BD, Moskowitz A, Connolly J. The contribution of early traumatic events to schizophrenia in some patients: A traumagenic neurodevelopmental model. Psychiatry 2001; 64: 319-45.
53 Alemany S, Arias B, Aguilera M, Villa H, Moya J, Ibanez MI. et al Childhood abuse, the BDNF-Val66Met polymorphism and adult psychotic-like experiences. The British Journal of Psychiatry 2011; 199: 8-42.
54 Kilcommons AM, Morrison AP. Relationships between trauma and psychosis: An exploration of cognitive and dissociative factors. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 2005; 112: 351-9.
55 Perona-Garcelán S, García-Montes JM, Rodríguez-Testal JF, Ruiz-Veguilla M, Benítez Hernández MD, López-Jiménez AM. et al Relationship of absorption, depersonalisation, and self-focused attention in subjects with and without hallucination proneness. Cognitive Neuropsychiatry 2013; 18: 422-36.
56 Bentall RP, Fernyhough C. Social predictors of psychotic experiences: Specificity and psychological mechanisms. Schizophrenia Bulletin 2008; 34: 1012-20.
57 Sideli L, Mule A, La Barbera D, Murray RM. Do child abuse and maltreatment increase risk of schizophrenia?. Psychiatry Investigation 2012; 9: 87-99.
58 van Os J, Krabbendam L, Myin-Germeys I, Delespaul P. The schizophrenia enviroment. Current Opinion in Psychiatry 2005; 18: 141-5.
59 Fawzi MH, Kira IA, Fawzi MMJr, Mohamed HE, Fawzi MM. Trauma profile in Egyptian adolescents with first-episode schizophrenia: Relation to psychopathology and plasma brain-derived neurotrophic factor. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 2013; 201: 23-29.
60 Kilcommons AM, Morrison AP, Knight A, Lobban F. Psychotic experiences in people who have been sexually assaulted. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 2008; 43: 602-11.
61 Moskowitz A, Corstens D. Auditory hallucinations: Psychotic symptom or dissociative expereriences?. Journal of Psychological Trauma 2008; 6: 35-63.
62 Morrison AP, Petersen T. Trauma, metacognition and predisposition to hallucitnations in non-patients. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy 2003; 31: 235-46.
63 Spitzer C, Vogel M, Barnow S, Freyberger HJ, Grabe HJ. Psychopathology and alexithymia in severe mental illness: The impact of trauma and posttraumatic stress symptoms. European Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience 2007; 257: 191-6.
64 Vogel M, Spitzer C, Barnow S, Freyberger HJ, Grabe HJ. The role of trauma and PTSD-related symptoms for dissociation and psychopathological distress in inpatients with schizophrenia. Psychopathology 2006; 39: 236-42.
65 Vogel M, Spitzer C, Kuwert P, Moller B, Freyberger HJ, Grabe HJ. Association of childhood neglect with adult dissociation in schizophrenic inpatients. Psychopathology 2009; 42: 124-30.
66 Gracie A, Freeman D, Green S, Garety PA, Kuipers E, Hardy A. et al The association between traumatic experience, paranoia and hallucinations: A test of the predictions of psychological models. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 2007; 116: 280-9.
67 Freeman D, Fowler D. Routes to psychotic symptoms: Trauma, anxiety and psychosis-like experiences. Psychiatry Research 2009; 169: 107-12.
68 Perona-Garcelán S, Carrascoso-Lopez F, Garcia-Montes JM, Vallina-Fernandez O, Perez-Alvarez M, Ductor-Recuerda MJ. et al Depersonalization as a mediator in the relationship between self-focused attention and auditory hallucinations. Journal of Trauma & Dissociation 2011; 12: 535-48.
69 Perona-Garcelán S, Carrascoso-López F, García-Montes JM, Ductor-Recuerda MJ, Jiménez A, Vallina-Fernández O. et al Dissociative experiences as mediators between childhood trauma and auditory hallucinations. Journal of Traumatic Stress 2012; 25: 323-9.
70 Goff DC, Brotman AW, Kindlon D, Waites M, Amico E. The delusion of possession in chronically psychotic patients. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 1991; 179: 567-71.
71 Goff DC, Brotman AW, Kindlon D, Waites M, Amico E. Self-reports of childhood abuse in chronically psychotic patients. Psychiatry Research 1991; 37: 73-80.
72 Greenfield SF, Strakowski SM, Tohen M, Batson SC, Kolbrener ML. Childhood abuse in first-episode psychosis. The British Journal of Psychiatry 1994; 164: 831-4.
73 Brunner R, Parzer P, Schmitt R, Resch F. Dissociative symptoms in schizophrenia: A comparative analysis of patients with borderline personality disorder and healthy controls. Psychopathology 2004; 37: 281-4.
74 Perona-Garcelán S, Cuevas-Yust C, Garcia-Montes JM, Perez-Alvarez M, Ductor-Recuerda MJ, Salas-Azcona R. et al Relationship between self-focused attention and dissociation in patients with and without auditory hallucinations. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 2008; 196: 190-197.
75 Spitzer C, Haug HJ, Freyberger HJ. Dissociative symptoms in schizophrenic patients with positive and negative symptoms. Psychopathology 1997; 30: 67-75.
76 Read J, Argyle N. Hallucinations, delusions, and thought disorder among adult psychiatric inpatients with a history of child abuse. Psychiatric Services 1999; 50: 1467-72.
77 Ross CA, Anderson G, Clark P. Childhood abuse and the positive symptoms of schizophrenia. Hospital & Community Psychiatry 1994; 45: 489-91.
78 Anketell C, Dorahy MJ, Shannon M, Elder R, Hamilton G, Corry M. et al An exploratory analysis of voice hearing in chronic PTSD: Potential associated mechanisms. Journal of Trauma & Dissociation 2010; 11: 93-107.
79 Perona-Garcelán S, Garcia-Montes JM, Cuevas-Yust C, Perez-Alvarez M, Ductor-Recuerda MJ, Salas-Azcona R. et al A preliminary exploration of trauma, dissociation, and positive psychotic symptoms in a Spanish sample. Journal of Trauma & Dissociation 2010; 11: 284-92.
80 Sar V, Akyuz G, Kugu N, Ozturk E, Ertem-Vehid H. Axis I dissociative disorder comorbidity in borderline personality disorder and reports of childhood trauma. The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 2006; 67: 1583-90.
81 Sar V, Taycan O, Bolat N, Özmen M, Duran A, Öztürk E. et al Childhood trauma and dissociation in schizophrenia. Psychopathology 2010; 43: 33-40.
82 Schäfer I, Harfst T, Aderhold V, Briken P, Lehmann M, Moritz S. et al Childhood trauma and dissociation in female patients with schizophrenia spectrum disorders: An exploratory study. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 2006; 194: 135-8.
83 Schäfer I, Fisher HL, Aderhold V, Huber B, Hoffmann-Langer L, Golks D. et al Dissociative symptoms in patients with schizophrenia: Relationships with childhood trauma and psychotic symptoms. Comprehensive Psychiatry 2012; 53: 364-71.
84 Van der Hart O, Nijenhuis ER, Steele K. Dissociation: An insufficiently recognized major feature of complex posttraumatic stress disorder. Journal of Traumatic Stress 2005; 18: 413-23.
85 Ross CA, Keyes B. Dissociation and schizophrenia. Journal of Trauma & Dissociation 2004; 5: 69-83.
86 Bob P, Glaslova K, Susta M, Jasova D, Raboch J. Traumatic dissociation, epileptic-like phenomena, and schizophrenia. Neuro Endocrinology Letters 2006; 27: 321-26.
87 Vogel M, Meier J, Gronke S, Waage M, Schneider W, Freyberger HJ. et al Differential effects of childhood abuse and neglect: Mediation by posttraumatic distress in neurotic disorder and negative symptoms in schizophrenia?. Psychiatry Research 2011; 189: 121-7.
88 Thornton T. Understanding psychopathology. In: Thornton T. (ed.): Essential philosophy of psychiatry. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2007: 89-122.
89 Parnas J, Sass LA. Varieties of “phenomenology”. On descritption, understanding, and explanation in psychiatry. In: Kendler KS, Parnas J. (eds.): Philosophical issues in psychiatry-Explanation, phenomenology, and nosology. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press; 2008: 239-285.
90 Radden J. Identity-Personal identity, charactization identity, and mental disorders. In Radden J. (ed.) The philosophy of psychiatry. New York: Oxford University Press; 2007: 134-146.