J Wrist Surg 2023; 12(01): 046-051
DOI: 10.1055/s-0042-1751077
Scientific Article

A Biomechanical Comparison of Fixation Techniques in Metacarpal Shaft Fractures

1   Department of Orthopedic Surgery, SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, New York
,
Michael J. Schreck
1   Department of Orthopedic Surgery, SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, New York
,
1   Department of Orthopedic Surgery, SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, New York
,
Garrett W. Esper
1   Department of Orthopedic Surgery, SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, New York
,
1   Department of Orthopedic Surgery, SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, New York
› Author Affiliations
Funding This work was supported by a materials donation grant from DePuy Synthes as a part of a Resident Initiated Research Grant (# 347911).

Abstract

Background Typically, metacarpal shaft fractures are treated with closed reduction percutaneous pinning, intramedullary nails, or plate fixation. Recently some surgeons have begun using intramedullary headless compression screws.

Questions/Purposes The purpose of this study was to compare intramedullary screw fixation to K-wire fixation, which is the standard of care in a transverse metacarpal midshaft fracture, using a cadaveric model. Our hypothesis was that intramedullary screw fixation would have a biomechanical advantage (higher stiffness and peak load to failure) when compared with dual Kirschner wire fixation of transverse metacarpal shaft fractures.

Methods Four-point bend testing was performed to compare stiffness and failure load values of seven paired 2nd and 3rd metacarpals instrumented with headless intramedullary compression screw fixation or Kirschner wire fixation. Similar testing was performed on 14 unpaired 4th metacarpals.

Results There was no significant difference in peak load (p = 0.60) or stiffness (p = 0.85) between fixation groups for the 2nd and 3rd instrumented metacarpals. For the instrumented 4th metacarpals, there was no significant difference in peak load (p = 0.14), but the stiffness was significantly greater (p = 0.01) for the compression screw group compared with the Kirschner wire fixation.

Conclusions/Clinical Relevance In this study, the load to failure was not different between the two fixation methods and likely both techniques can sustain physiologic loads needed for rehabilitation. The greater stiffness in the 4th metacarpal compression screw group may be related to the smaller canal morphology than in the 2nd and 3rd metacarpals. Larger diameter screws may be needed to obtain a better fit particularly in the 2nd and 3rd metacarpals.



Publication History

Received: 21 January 2022

Accepted: 24 May 2022

Article published online:
14 July 2022

© 2022. Thieme. All rights reserved.

Thieme Medical Publishers, Inc.
333 Seventh Avenue, 18th Floor, New York, NY 10001, USA

 
  • References

  • 1 del Piñal F, Moraleda E, Rúas JS, de Piero GH, Cerezal L. Minimally invasive fixation of fractures of the phalanges and metacarpals with intramedullary cannulated headless compression screws. J Hand Surg Am 2015; 40 (04) 692-700
  • 2 Doarn MC, Nydick JA, Williams BD, Garcia MJ. Retrograde headless intramedullary screw fixation for displaced fifth metacarpal neck and shaft fractures: short term results. Hand (N Y) 2015; 10 (02) 314-318
  • 3 Ruchelsman DE, Puri S, Feinberg-Zadek N, Leibman MI, Belsky MR. Clinical outcomes of limited-open retrograde intramedullary headless screw fixation of metacarpal fractures. J Hand Surg Am 2014; 39 (12) 2390-2395
  • 4 Siddiqui AA, Kumar J, Jamil M, Adeel M, Kaimkhani GM. Fixation of metacarpal fractures using intramedullary headless compression screws: a tertiary care institution experience. Cureus 2019; 11 (04) e4466
  • 5 Tobert DG, Klausmeyer M, Mudgal CS. Intramedullary fixation of metacarpal fractures using headless compression screws. J Hand Microsurg 2016; 8 (03) 134-139
  • 6 Couceiro J, Ayala H, Sanchez M, De la Red MLA, Velez O, Del Canto F. Intramedullary screws versus kirschner wires for metacarpal fixation, functional, and patient-related outcomes. Surg J (NY) 2018; 4 (01) e29-e33
  • 7 Avery III DM, Klinge S, Dyrna F. et al. Headless compression screw versus kirschner wire fixation for metacarpal neck fractures: a biomechanical study. J Hand Surg Am 2017; 42 (05) 392.e1-392.e6
  • 8 Beutel BG, Ayalon O, Kennedy OD, Lendhey M, Capo JT, Melamed E. Crossed k-wires versus intramedullary headless screw fixation of unstable metacarpal neck fractures: a biomechanical study. Iowa Orthop J 2018; 38: 153-157
  • 9 Jones CM, Padegimas EM, Weikert N, Greulich S, Ilyas AM, Siegler S. Headless screw fixation of metacarpal neck fractures: a mechanical comparative analysis. Hand (N Y) 2019; 14 (02) 187-192
  • 10 Curtis BD, Fajolu O, Ruff ME, Litsky AS. Fixation of metacarpal shaft fractures: Biomechanical comparison of intramedullary nail crossed k-wires and plate-screw constructs. Orthop Surg 2015; 7 (03) 256-260
  • 11 Melamed E, Hinds RM, Gottschalk MB, Kennedy OD, Capo JT. Comparison of dorsal plate fixation versus intramedullary headless screw fixation of unstable metacarpal shaft fractures: a biomechanical study. Hand (N Y) 2016; 11 (04) 421-426
  • 12 Boulton CL, Salzler M, Mudgal CS. Intramedullary cannulated headless screw fixation of a comminuted subcapital metacarpal fracture: case report. J Hand Surg Am 2010; 35 (08) 1260-1263
  • 13 Eisenberg G, Clain JB, Feinberg-Zadek N, Leibman M, Belsky M, Ruchelsman DE. Clinical outcomes of limited open intramedullary headless screw fixation of metacarpal fractures in 91 consecutive patients. Hand (N Y) 2020; 15 (06) 793-797
  • 14 Warrender WJ, Ruchelsman DE, Livesey MG, Mudgal CS, Rivlin M. Low rate of complications following intramedullary headless compression screw fixation of metacarpal fractures. Hand (N Y) 2020; 15 (06) 798-804
  • 15 Ketchum LD, Thompson D, Pocock G, Wallingford D. A clinical study of forces generated by the intrinsic muscles of the index finger and the extrinsic flexor and extensor muscles of the hand. J Hand Surg Am 1978; 3 (06) 571-578
  • 16 Okoli M, Lutsky K, Rivlin M, Katt B, Beredjiklian P. Metacarpal bony dimensions related to headless compression screw sizes. J Hand Microsurg 2020; 12 (Suppl. 01) S39-S44
  • 17 Hoang D, Vu CL, Jackson M, Huang JI. An anatomical study of metacarpal morphology utilizing ct scans: evaluating parameters for antegrade intramedullary compression screw fixation of metacarpal fractures. J Hand Surg Am 2021; 46 (02) 149.e1-149.e8