Spuriously high serum concentrations of TSH due to the use of an automatic pipetting device

Summary:

In a clinically hyperthyroid patient a TSH-value of 0.75 mU/L was measured. Upon retesting TSH was < 0.1 mU/L. The patient's sample initially had been preceded, in the pipetting device, by a grossly hypothyroid patient's sample. Analogous problems were subsequently documented in 10 cases when samples of other hyperthyroid patients were preceded by samples with modestly to markedly elevated TSH. The spurious elevation of TSH (0.12 to 1.18 vs. < 0.1 mU/L) appears to be due to a carryover effect from the respective previous sample within the used automatic pipetting system. This carryover was much larger than previously suggested, and occurred unpredictably.

TSH - carryover - pipetting device

References

• 1 Bartlett W A, Browning M CK, Jung R T. Artefactual increase in serum thyrotropin concentration caused by heterophilic antibodies with specificity for IgG of the family Bovidae.  Clin Chem. 32 2214-2219 1986; 
• 2 Bauer D C, Brown A N. Sensitive thyrotropin and free thyroxine testing in outpatients. Are both necessary?.  Arch Intern Med. 156 2333-2337 1996; 
• 3 Caldwell G, Kellett H A, Gow S M, Beckett G J, Sweeting V M, Seth J, Toft A D. A new strategy for thyroid function testing.  Lancet. 1 1117-1119 1985; 
• 4 Costongs G MPJ, Janson P CW. Comparison of the automated random access immunoassay analysers, ACS-180 (Ciba Corning) and AIA-1200 (Tosoh).  Eur J Clin Chem Clin Biochem. 31 701-706 1993; 
• 5 D'Costa M, Feld R, Laxdal V, Trundle D, Collinsworth W L. A multicenter evaluation of the Boehringer Mannheim ES 300 immunoassay system.  Clin Biochem. 26 51-57 1993; 
• 6 European Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards .Guidelines for the evaluation of analysers in clinical chemistry. ECCLS document Berlin: Beuth Verlag 3 (2) 1986
• 7 Forest J C, Masse J, Lane A. Evaluation of the analytical performance of the Boehringer Mannheim Elecsys 2010 immunoanalyzer.  Clin Biochem. 31 81-88 1998; 
• 8 Hebles-Duvison M, Cruz-Ruiz M, Vazquez-Rubio R, Macarro-Sancho I, Silva-Mejias C, Recio-Quitano F. Evaluation of autodelfia and access automated immunoassay systems for third generation assays for thyrotropin.  Eur J Clin Chemistry Clin Biochem. 33 881-885 1995; 
• 9 Khalil O S, Zurek T F, Tryba J, Hanna C F, Hollar R, Pepe C, Genger K, Brentz C, Murphy B, Abunimeh N, Carver P, Harder P, Coleman C, Robertson E, Wolf-Rogers J. Abbott Prism: a multichannel heterogeneous chemiluminescence immunoassay analyzer.  Clin Chem. 37 1540-1547 1991; 
• 10 Knedel M, Assmann G, Courbe A, van-Impe L, Kattermann R, Keller H, Oellerich M, Kuppers R, Meyer H D, Willnow P. Investigation of the performance of the ES 600 Enzymun-Test system. A multicentre study.  J Clin Chem Clin Biochem. 26 149-162 1988; 
• 11 Letellier M, Lévesque A, Daigle F, Grant A. Performance evaluation of automated immunoassays on the Technicon Immuno I system.  Clin Chem. 42 1695-1701 1996; 
• 12 Nordyke R A, Reppun T S, Madanay L D, Woods J C, Goldstein A P, Miyamoto L A. Alternative sequences of thyrotropin and free thyroxine assays for routine thyroid function testing. Quality and cost.  Arch Intern Med. 158 266-272 1998; 
• 13 Roden M, Nowotny P, Vierhapper H, Waldhäusl W. Diagnostic relevance of suppressed basal concentrations of TSH compared with the negative TRH test in detection and exclusion of hyperthyroidism.  Acta Endocrinol. 124 136-142 1991; 
• 14 Sadler W A, Murray L M, Turner J G. Influence of specimen carryover on sensitive thyrotropin (TSH) assays: is there a problem?.  Clin Chem. 42 593-597 1996; 
• 15 Stockmann W, Bablok W, Luppa P. Analytical performance of Elecsys® 2010 - a multicentre evaluation.  Wien Klin Wochenschr. 3 10-21 1998;