Lower Body Negative Pressure Treadmill Exercise is More Comfortable and Produces Similar Physiological Responses as Weighted Vest Exercise

Abstract

Lower body negative pressure (LBNP) treadmill exercise can generate a hypergravity load on the lower body that may improve athlete performance by mechanical and cardiovascular adaptations. This study compared the cardiovascular responses, subjective exertion and discomfort levels produced by LBNP exercise with those generated by a weighted vest (WV). We hypothesized that LBNP exercise is more comfortable than WV exercise at comparable levels of exercise. Nine subjects exercised on a treadmill at nine conditions, at 5.5 mph for 15 minutes, in which they ran in random order to avoid confounding effects: 100 %, 110 %, 120 %, 130 %, and 140 % body weight (BW), the latter four conditions were achieved by either LBNP chamber or WV. Heart rate (HR) and oxygen consumption (V·O₂) were monitored continuously using ECG and open circuit spirometry. At the end of each test, subjects were asked to give discomfort and exertion scores using a ten-point visual analog scale (10 = maximal discomfort and exertion). For both HR and V·O₂, no significant differences were observed between LBNP and WV. Subjects reported significantly higher discomfort levels when exercising with the WV than with the LBNP at 120 % BW (5.1 ± 0.55 vs. 3.1 ± 0.64; p < 0.05), 130 % BW (6.2 ± 0.42 vs. 2.3 ± 0.44; p < 0.01) and 140 % BW (6.9 ± 0.27 vs. 4.7 ± 0.60; p < 0.01), while maintaining similar exertions at all conditions. Based on these results, LBNP exercise is more comfortable than standard WV exercise, while maintaining similar exertion, HR and V·O₂ values.

Key words

Exercise - pain - hypergravity - weighted vest - oxygen consumption - heart rate

References

• 1 Bean J, Herman S, Kiely D K, Callahan D, Mizer K, Frontera W R, Fielding R A. Weighted stair climbing in mobility-limited older people: a pilot study.  J Am Geriatr Soc. 2002;  50 663-670
• 2 Bean J, Herman S, Kiely D K, Frey I C, Leveille S G, Fielding R A, Frontera W. Increased velocity exercise specific to task (InVEST) training: a pilot study exploring effects on leg power, balance, and mobility in community-dwelling older women.  J Am Geriatr Soc. 2004;  52 799-804
• 3 Boda W L, Watenpaugh D E, Ballard R E, Hargens A R. Supine lower body negative pressure exercise simulates metabolic and kinetic features of upright exercise.  J Appl Physiol. 2000;  89 649-654
• 4 Borg G AV. Psychophysical bases of perceived exertion.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1982;  14 377-381
• 5 Bosco C, Rusko H, Hirvonen J. The effect of extra-load conditioning on muscle performance in athletes.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1986;  18 415-419
• 6 Costill D L, Jansson E, Gollnick P D, Saltin B. Glycogen utilization in muscles of men during level and uphill running.  Acta Physiol Scand. 1974;  91 475-481
• 7 Cureton K J, Sparling P B. Distance running performance and metabolic responses to running in men and women with excess weight experimentally equated.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1980;  12 288-294
• 8 De Merode A. International Olympic Committee Medical Commission prohibited classes of substance and methods of doping. Bowers LD Anti-Doping Agency Guide to Prohibited Classes of Substances and Prohibited Methods of Doing. Colorado Springs; United States Anti-Doping Agency 2000
• 9 Evans O M, Zerbib Y, Baria M H, Monod H. Physiological responses to load holding and load carriage.  Ergonomics. 1983;  26 161-171
• 10 Gordon M J, Goslin B R, Graham T, Hoare J. Comparison between load carriage and grade walking on a treadmill.  Ergonomics. 1983;  26 289-298
• 11 Groppo E R, Eastlack R K, Mahar A, Hargens A R, Pedowitz R A. Simulated hypergravity running increases skeletal and cardiovascular loads.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2005;  37 262-266
• 12 Hargens A R, Whalen R T, Watenpaugh D E, Schwandt D F, Krock L P. Lower body negative pressure to provide load bearing in space.  Aviat Space Environ Med. 1991;  62 934-937
• 13 Hargens A R, Groppo E R, Lee S MC, Watenpaugh D E, Schneider S, O'Leary D, Hughson R L, Shoemaker K, Smith S M, Steinbach G, Tanaka K, Kawai Y, Bawa M, Kimura S, Macias B R, Boda W L, Meyer R S. The gravity of LBNP exercise: preliminary lessons learned from identical twins in bed for 30 days.  J Gravit Physiol. 2002;  9 59-62
• 14 Lee S MC, Bennett B S, Hargens A R, Watenpaugh D E, Ballard R E, Murthy G, Ford R S, Fortney S M. Upright exercise or supine lower body negative pressure exercise maintains exercise responses after bed rest.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1997;  29 892-900
• 15 Murthy G, Watenpaugh D E, Ballard R E, Hargens A R. Supine exercise during lower body negative pressure effectively simulates upright exercise in normal gravity.  J Appl Physiol. 1994;  76 2742-2748
• 16 Puthoff M L, Darter B J, Nielsen D H, Yack H J. The effect of weighted vest walking on metabolic responses and ground reaction forces.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2006;  38 746-752
• 17 Raab D M, Smith R T, Smith El, Gilligan C. Energy cost of wearing weighted bands while walking and jogging.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1985;  17 268
• 18 Rusko H, Bosco C. Metabolic response of endurance athletes to training with added load.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 1987;  56 412-418
• 19 Shaw J M, Snow C M. Weighted vest exercise improves indices of fall risk in older women.  J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci. 1998;  53 M53-M58
• 20 Sloniger M A, Cureton K J, Prior B M, Evans E M. Lower extremity muscle activation during horizontal and uphill running.  J Appl Physiol. 1997;  83 2073-2079
• 21 Soule R G, Goldman R F. Energy cost of loads carried on the head, hands, or feet.  J Appl Physiol. 1969;  27 687-690
• 22 Stray-Gunderson J, Chapman R F, Levine B D. “Living high-training low” altitude training improves sea level performance in male and female elite runners.  J Appl Physiol. 2001;  91 1113-1120
• 23 Udassin R, Shoenfeld Y, Shapiro Y, Birenfeld C, Sohar E. Serum glucose and lactic acid concentration during prolonged and strenouns exercise in man.  Am J Phys Med. 1977;  56 249-256
• 24 Wang Y, Pascoe D D, Weimar W. Evaluation of book backpack load during walking.  Ergonomics. 2001;  44 858-869
• 25 Watenpaugh D E, Ballard R E, Schneider S M, Lee S MC, Ertl A C, William J M, Boda W L, Hutchinson K J, Hargens A R. Supine lower body negative pressure exercise during bed rest maintains upright exercise capacity.  J Appl Physiol. 2000;  89 218-227
• 26 Watenpaugh D E, Ballard R E, Stout M S, Murthy G, Whalen R T, Hargens A R. Dynamic leg exercise improves tolerance to lower body negative pressure.  Aviat Space Environ Med. 1994;  65 412-418
• 27 Watenpaugh D E, Hargens A R. The cardiovascular system in microgravity. Fregly MJ, Blatteis CM Handbook of Physiology: Environmental Physiology. III: The Gravitational Environment, 1: Microgravity, Chapter 29. New York; Oxford University Press 1996: 631-674
• 28 Whaley M H. ACSM's Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription. 7th edn. Philadelphia; Lippincott, Williams, and Wilkins 2000: 77-78
• 29 Wilber R L. Current trends in altitude training.  Sports Med. 2001;  31 249-265