Download PDF
CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 · Avicenna J Med 2017; 07(02): 35-45
DOI: 10.4103/2231-0770.203608
REVIEW ARTICLE

Do not resuscitate, brain death, and organ transplantation: Islamic perspective

Hassan Chamsi Pasha
Department of Cardiology, King Fahd Armed Forces Hospital, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia
,
Mohammed Ali Albar
Department of Medical Ethics, International Medical Center, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia
› Author Affiliations Financial support and sponsorship Nil.
› Further Information
  PDF Download Permissions and Reprints

Abstract

Muslim patients and families are often reluctant to discuss and accept fatal diagnoses and prognoses. In many instances, aggressive therapy is requested by a patient's family, prolonging the life of the patient at all costs. Islamic law permits the withdrawal of futile treatment, including life support, from terminally ill patients allowing death to take its natural course. “Do not resuscitate” is permitted in Islamic law in certain situations. Debate continues about the certainty of brain death criteria within Islamic scholars. Although brain death is accepted as true death by the majority of Muslim scholars and medical organizations, the consensus in the Muslim world is not unanimous, and some scholars still accept death only by cardiopulmonary criteria. Organ transplantation has been accepted in Islamic countries (with some resistance from some jurists). Many fatwas (decrees) of Islamic Jurisprudence Councils have been issued and allowed organs to be donated from living competent adult donor; and from deceased (cadavers), provided that they have agreed to donate or their families have agreed to donate after their death (usually these are brain-dead cases). A clear and well-defined policy from the ministry of health regarding do not resuscitate, brain death, and other end-of-life issues is urgently needed for all hospitals and health providers in most (if not all) Muslim and Arab countries.

Keywords

Brain death - do not resuscitate - ethics - Islam - organ transplantation


Publication History

Article published online:
09 August 2021

© 2017. Syrian American Medical Society. This is an open access article published by Thieme under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonDerivative-NonCommercial-License, permitting copying and reproduction so long as the original work is given appropriate credit. Contents may not be used for commercial purposes, or adapted, remixed, transformed or built upon. (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).

Thieme Medical and Scientific Publishers Private Ltd.
A-12, Second Floor, Sector -2, NOIDA -201301, India

 

  • References

  • 1 Albar MA. Seeking remedy, abstaining from therapy and resuscitation: An Islamic perspective. Saudi J Kidney Dis Transpl 2007;18:629-37.
  • 2 Chamsi-Pasha H, Albar MA. Ethical dilemmas at the end of life: Islamic perspective. J Relig Health 2016. [Epub ahead of print]. DOI:10.1007/s10943-016-0181-3.
  • 3 Jan MM. The decision of do not resuscitate in pediatric practice. Saudi Med J 2011;32:115-22.
  • 4 Rodriguez KL, Young AJ. Perceptions of patients on the utility or futility of end-of-life treatment. J Med Ethics 2006;32:444-9.
  • 5 Ibn 'Abd al-Salam I: Qawaed Al Ahkam (The bases of Law) commented by Nazih Hammad and Othman Dhamariyah. Dar Al Qalam, Damascus, Syria, 2000;1:8.
  • 6 Permanent Committee for Scholarly Research and Ifta. Ruling on Resuscitating the Patient if he is Dead, His Health Condition is not fit for Resuscitation or His Disease is Incurable. Fatwa Number 12086; 1989. Available from: http://www.alifta.net/Fatawa/FatawaChapters.aspx?View=Page&PageID=299&PageNo=1&BookID=17. [Last accessed on 2016 Aug 18].
  • 7 The Saudi Commission for Health Specialties. Code of Ethics for Healthcare Practitioners. Translated by: Hussein GM. Riyadh: Saudi Commission for Health Specialties; 2014.
  • 8 Islamic Medical Association of North America (IMANA), & Ethics Committee. Islamic medical ethics: The IMANA perspective. J Islamic Med Assoc North Am 2005;37:33-42.
  • 9 Saeed F, Kousar N, Aleem S, Khawaja O, Javaid A, Siddiqui MF, et al. End-of-life care beliefs among Muslim physicians. Am J Hosp Palliat Care 2015;32:388-92.
  • 10 Miller AC. Opinions on the legitimacy of brain death among Sunni and Shi'a Scholars. J Relig Health 2016;55:394-402.
  • 11 Al-Bar MA, Chamsi-Pasha H. Contemporary Bioethics: Islamic Perspective. Springer; 2015. Available from: http://link.springer.com/book/10.1007%2F978-3-319-18428-9. [Last accessed on 2016 Dec 20].
  • 12 Gardiner D, Shemie S, Manara A, Opdam H. International perspective on the diagnosis of death. Br J Anaesth 2012;108 Suppl 1:i14-28.
  • 13 Diagnosis of brain death statement issued by the honorary secretary of the Conference of Medical Royal Colleges and their Faculties in the United Kingdom on 11 October 1976. Br Med J 1976;2:1187-8.
  • 14 A Code of Practice for the Diagnosis and Confirmation of Death Academy of the Medical Royal Colleges, London; 2008. Available from: http://www.odt.nhs.uk/pdf/code-of-practice-for-the-diagnosis-and-confirmation-of-death.pdf. [Last accessed on 2016 Dec 20].
  • 15 Smith M. Brain death: Time for an international consensus. Br J Anaesth 2012;108 Suppl 1:i6-9.
  • 16 Pallis C. Whole-brain death reconsidered – Physiological facts and philosophy. J Med Ethics 1983;9:32-7.
  • 17 Wijdicks EF, Varelas PN, Gronseth GS, Greer DM; American Academy of Neurology. Evidence-based guideline update: Determining brain death in adults: Report of the Quality Standards Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology. Neurology 2011;76:1911-8.
  • 18 Al-Hilali MT, Khan MM. The Translation of the Meanings of the Noble Quran 6:151. Madina (KSA): King Fahd Complex for Printing the Holy Quran; 2005.
  • 19 Al-Hilali MT, Khan MM. The Translation of the Meanings of the Noble Quran 5:32. Madina (KSA): King Fahd Complex for Printing the Holy Quran; 2005.
  • 20 Rady MY, Verheijde JL, Ali MS. Islam and end-of-life practices in organ donation for transplantation: New questions and serious sociocultural consequences. HEC Forum 2009;21:175-205.
  • 21 Al-Hilali MT, Khan MM. The Translation of the Meanings of the Noble Quran 2:132–133. Madina (KSA): King Fahd Complex for Printing the Holy Quran; 2005.
  • 22 Al-Hilali MT, Khan MM. The Translation of the Meanings of the Noble Quran 39:42. Madina (KSA): King Fahd Complex for Printing the Holy Quran; 2005.
  • 23 Al Albani MN. Sunan Ibn Majah. Book 23, Hadith 2751. Vol. 1. Dar Al Kotob Al Elmiah, Beirut; 1975. p. 233.
  • 24 Al Ashgar MS. Nihayat al hayat (End of Life). Islamic Fiqh Acad J 1987;3:2.
  • 25 Padela AI, Arozullah A, Moosa E. Brain death in Islamic ethico-legal deliberation: Challenges for applied Islamic bioethics. Bioethics 2013;27:132-9.
  • 26 Miller AC, Ziad-Miller A, Elamin EM. Brain death and Islam: The interface of religion, culture, history, law, and modern medicine. Chest 2014;146:1092-101.
  • 27 Albar MA. Islamic ethics of organ transplantation and brain death. Saudi J Kidney Dis Transpl 1996;7:109-14.
  • 28 Padela AI, Shanawani H, Arozullah A. Medical experts & Islamic scholars deliberating over brain death: Gaps in the applied Islamic bioethics discourse. Muslim World 2011;101:53-72.
  • 29 Grundmann J. Shari'ah, brain death, and organ transplantation: The context and effect of two Islamic legal decisions in the near and middle east. Am J Islamic Soc Sci 2005;22:1-25.
  • 30 Bedir A, Aksoy S. Brain death revisited: It is not 'complete death' according to Islamic sources. J Med Ethics 2011;37:290-4.
  • 31 Hamdy S. Not quite dead: Why Egyptian doctors refuse the diagnosis of death by neurological criteria. Theor Med Bioeth 2013;34:147-60.
  • 32 Rady MY, Verheijde JL, Ali MS. The practice of medicine and the utilitarian redefinition of the beginning and end of human life. Saudi Med J 2010;31:718-20.
  • 33 Rodríguez-Arias D, Smith MJ, Lazar NM. Donation after circulatory death: Burying the dead donor rule. Am J Bioeth 2011;11:36-43.
  • 34 Al Sayyari AA. The history of renal transplantation in the Arab world: A view from Saudi Arabia. Am J Kidney Dis 2008;51:1033-46.
  • 35 Gutmann E. Bitter harvest: China's 'organ donation' nightmare. World Aff 2012;175:49-56.
  • 36 Rady MY, Verheijde JL. A response to the legitimacy of brain death in Islam. J Relig Health 2016;55:1198-205.
  • 37 Al-Hilali MT, Khan MM. The Translation of the Meanings of the Noble Quran 36:78. Madina (KSA): King Fahd Complex for Printing the Holy Quran; 2005.
  • 38 Al-Hilali MT, Khan MM. The Translation of the Meanings of the Noble Quran 37:16. Madina (KSA): King Fahd Complex for Printing the Holy Quran; 2005.
  • 39 Joffe AR, Kolski H, Duff J, deCaen AR. A 10-month-old infant with reversible findings of brain death. Pediatr Neurol 2009;41:378-82.
  • 40 Wijdicks EF, Varelas PN, Gronseth GS, Greer DM. There is no reversible brain death. Crit Care Med 2011;39:2204-5.
  • 41 Shore PM. Following guidelines for brain death examinations: A matter of trust. Pediatr Crit Care Med 2013;14:98-9.
  • 42 Segal E. Religious objections to brain death. J Crit Care 2014;29:875-7.
  • 43 Chamsi-Pasha H, Albar MA. Kidney transplantation: Ethical challenges in the Arab world. Saudi J Kidney Dis Transpl 2014;25:489-95.
  • 44 Schmidt VH. Transplant medicine as borderline medicine. Med Health Care Philos 2003;6:319-21.
  • 45 Al Nawawi MS, Al Majmou Sharh Al Mohazab. In: Al Mutteei M, editor. Vol. 1. Cairo: Al Fajalah Press; 1969. p. 293.
  • 46 Asshirbini M. Mughni, al muhtaj (Resource for the needy). Beirut: Dar Al Fikir; 1973. p. 190-1.
  • 47 Al Qawzini Z. Ajayib al makhlohat (Wonder of creatures). Dar Al Afaaq Al Jadidah; 1978. p. 422.
  • 48 Al Qushairi M. Sahih Muslem. Vol. 12. Beirut: Dar Al Fikir; 1972. p. 37.
  • 49 Ibn Hanbal A, Musnad Ahmad. Cairo: Dar Almaarif Publishing Co.; 1958. 1;338.
  • 50 Chamsi-Pasha H, Albar MA. Western and Islamic bioethics: How close is the gap? Avicenna J Med 2013;3:8-14.
  • 51 Sharafuddin A. Al Ahkam Asriyah Lil-Amal Attibiyah National Council for Culture, Arts, and Literature. Kuwait; 1983. p. 89-160.
  • 52 Fiqh Academy Book of Decrees, Decree No. 5, 3rd Conference of Islamic Jurists (Amman: 11-6 October 1986). Jeddah: Figh Academy and Islamic Organization of Medicine Sciences; 1988. p. 34. Available from: http://www.iifa-aifi.org/cs. [Last accessed on 2016 Dec 20].
  • 53 The Islamic Fiqh Council of Islamic World League Held in Makkah Al Mukaramah, Decree No. 2. (10th session); December, 1987. Available from: http://themwl.org/downloads/Resolutions-of-Islamic-Fiqh-Council-1.pdf. [Last accessed on 2016 Dec 20].
  • 54 Seminar on New Issues in Organ Transplantation (Kuwait: October 1989). Jeddah: Fiqh Academy and Islamic Organization of Medical Sciences (not yet published); & Fiqh Academy Decree and Recommendations for the 6th Conference of Islam Jurists (Jeddah, 14-20 March 1990). Decrees No. 56/5/6; 58/8/6. Available from: http://www.iifa-aifi.org/cs. [Last accessed on 2016 Dec 20].
  • 55 Islamic Fiqh Council, Islamic World League, Makkah-Saudi Arabia, Session 17, 2003, Fatwa No. 3, Book of Resolutions. 17th Session, 13-17 December 2003, Makkah: Islamic World League; 2003. p. 33-5. Available from: http://themwl.org/downloads/Resolutions-of-Islamic-Fiqh-Council-1.pdf. [Last accessed on 2016 Dec 20].
  • 56 Ghaly M. The ethics of organ transplantation: How comprehensive the ethical framework should be? Med Health Care Philos 2012;15:175-9.
  • 57 Van den Branden S, Broeckaert B. The ongoing charity of organ donation. Contemporary English Sunni fatwas on organ donation and blood transfusion. Bioethics 2011;25:167-75.
  • 58 Buskens L. An Islamic triangle. Changing relationships between Shari'a, state law, and local customs. ISIM Newsl 2000;5:8.
  • 59 Hafzalah M, Azzam R, Testa G, Hoehn KS. Improving the potential for organ donation in an inner city Muslim American community: The impact of a religious educational intervention. Clin Transplant 2014;28:192-7.