Keywords
posttraumatic nasal deformity - rhinoplasty - nasal bone fracture
Nasal bone fractures are the most common facial fractures and account for 40 to 50%
of bony injuries to the facial skeleton.[1]
[2]
[3] As the most prominent anterior feature of the face, the nose is easily subject to
trauma. Nasal bone injuries are often accompanied by cartilaginous and soft tissue
injuries as well. While often thought of as minor injuries, nasal bone fractures can
have lingering long-term effects. In fact, the incidence of posttraumatic nasal deformity
varies from 14 to 50%,[4] and posttraumatic nasal deformities can often be very challenging to address and
resolve. In this article, we discuss the tools and techniques available for acute
and delayed management of nasal bone fractures and posttraumatic nasal deformities.
Anatomy
The nose is the most prominent anterior feature of the face. The nose contains a bony
vault, upper cartilaginous vault, and lower cartilaginous vault. The bony vault is
composed of paired nasal bones, the ascending process of the maxilla and the nasal
process of the frontal bone.[5] The nasal bones articulate with the upper lateral cartilages which form the upper
cartilaginous vault. This vault contains the internal nasal valve which is bordered
by the nasal septum, the upper lateral cartilage, the head of the inferior turbinate,
and the nasal floor. The upper lateral cartilages overlap the nasal bone by 6 to 8 mm
providing a strong support between the bony and cartilaginous portions of the nose.
Caudally, the upper lateral cartilages articulate with the cephalic edge of the lower
lateral cartilage in the scroll region[5] (see [Fig. 1]). The septum acts as a “tent pole” to support the nasal tip and nasal dorsum and
becomes thicker posteriorly, basally and caudally where it attaches to the bony framework
of the nose.[6]
Fig. 1 The bony vault of the nose is composed of paired nasal bones, the ascending process
of the maxilla and the nasal process of the frontal bone. The nasal bones articulate
with the upper lateral cartilages which in turn articulate with the lower lateral
cartilage. The internal nasal valve is depicted in blue and the external nasal valve
is depicted in green.
Overlying the cartilaginous and bony support of the nose is the skin soft tissue envelope
of the nose which has distinct tissue layers. These are the epidermis, dermis, subcutaneous
fat, muscle and fascia, areolar tissue, and periosteum or perichondrium. The skin
overlying the nose can have variable type, texture, and sebaceous content. This is
important for the rhinoplasty surgeon to consider as thick skin requires more aggressive
modification of the bony/cartilaginous framework of the nose to achieve desired contours
of the nose, while thin skin will show off the slightest imperfections of contour,
asymmetry, and underlying graft material.[7]
[8]
[9]
[10]
[11]
[12]
[13]
[14]
[15]
Evaluation
The preoperative assessment of the nose begins with a good history and physical examination.
A detailed nasal history should include the history of injury, the timing of injury,
mechanism of injury, object responsible for injury, direction of injury, and force
of injury. For acute nasal bone injury, a history of epistaxis indicates concurrent
laceration of the nasal mucosa. Epistaxis without obvious nasal deformity may be the
only clinical finding in some nasal bone fractures. The history should also include
previous nasal surgery, functional status of the nose, nasal airway obstruction, and
change in the appearance of the nose. Preinjury photos may be useful in ascertaining
postinjury changes to the appearance of the nose.
A detailed physical examination should follow. The physical examination should start
with an external examination of the nose. The external examination includes notation
of any deviation to the nose, C-shape or S-shape deformity, bony width, alar rim morphology,
dorsal profile, saddle nose deformity, and tip definition/projection. Any palpable
step-offs or mobility of the nasal bone, swelling, fresh or well-healed lacerations,
and changes in the shape of the nose should be noted. An internal examination should
follow with a good headlight, decongestant, topical anesthesia if indicated, suction,
and endoscope. Topical decongestant may assist in the examination as there may be
significant post-injury swelling. The internal examination should make note of the
septum, septal fractures, septal deviations, septal dislocations, inferior turbinate
size, internal nasal valve patency, and nasal airflow. A modified Cottle examination
should also be done to assess nasal valve competency. In the event of an acute injury,
a complete evaluation of the septum should be done, and septal hematoma should be
ruled out. If a septal hematoma is present, it should be addressed promptly to avoid
subsequent septal distortion, infection, necrosis, and saddle nose deformity. The
septal mucosa is examined to assess for tears and fracture. A rigid endoscope may
be used to better assess the septum, especially posteriorly. Rigid endoscopy can also
assist in detecting other defects and previous septal injuries including septal fractures,
posterior spurs, and septal perforations.
For acute nasal bone fracture evaluation, imaging may supplement a good history and
physical examination. Plain radiographs are not necessary or cost-effective in the
diagnosis of nasal bone fractures.[15] Plain radiographs have poor sensitivity and poor specificity and can cloud the clinical
picture. Computed tomography imaging can be obtained for patients who have significant
swelling that prevents a good clinical examination of the nose, a history of high
impact injury, cerebrospinal fluid rhinorrhea, or suspicion for other facial fractures
based on physical examination.
Acute Treatment of Nasal Bone Fractures
Acute Treatment of Nasal Bone Fractures
There are three considerations to make when deciding on appropriate treatment for
nasal bone fractures. The first is the timing of repair, the second is the choice
of anesthetic, and the third is closed versus open reduction. In the first few days
following nasal bone fracture, soft tissue swelling usually masks the underlying bony
injury. For this reason, the timing of repair is generally completed within the first
10 to 14 days after injury.[16]
[17]
[18] In the pediatric population, some authors have recommended performing the reduction
within 7 days as bone healing can occur more quickly in the pediatric population.[6] The indications for closed reduction are (1) unilateral or bilateral nasal bone
fracture and (2) fracture of the nasal-septal complex with nasal deviation less than
one-half width of the nasal bridge. The indications for open repair are (1) extensive
fracture or dislocation of the nasal bones and septum, (2) nasal deviation that is
greater than one-half width of the nasal bridge, (3) fracture and dislocation of the
caudal septum, (4) open septal fracture, and (5) persistent nasal deformity after
closed reduction.[6]
Closed nasal bone reductions can be done under local or general anesthesia. Numerous
studies have demonstrated that local anesthesia is just as effective as general anesthesia
and less expensive than general anesthesia.[19]
[20]
[21] Following adequate analgesia, digital pressure can then be applied to reduce the
nasal bone. For more complicated fractures, instrumentation may aid reduction—the
Boies elevator is often less traumatic and less likely to cause mucosal damage and
epistaxis. In this technique, the Boies elevator is inserted into the nose and the
surgeon's thumb is placed over the nasal bones to detect bony mobilization and assist
reduction. A Walsham forceps may be used to correct and reduce impacted nasal bones,
while an Asch forceps may be used to reduce the nasal septum.
For more complicated fractures and septal injuries, open reduction of the nasal bones
should be performed. Open reductions can be accomplished by a variety of approaches.[22] Complete exposure of the septum is obtained, and the septum is relocated onto the
anterior nasal spine. In cases where the septum cannot be reduced and adequately secured,
submucous resection of the septum is performed. This includes resection of the fractured
portions of the cartilage and bone (vomer, perpendicular plate of the ethmoid).[14] Following reduction, intranasal splints and external splints are applied to stabilize
the reduction and allow for healing.
Delayed Treatment of Posttraumatic Nasal Deformity
Delayed Treatment of Posttraumatic Nasal Deformity
Nasal deformity following nasal trauma is one of the most common reasons that patients
seek open septorhinoplasty. In cases where acute and primary treatment of the nasal
bone fracture or nasal deformity are not possible, delayed reconstruction may be done
to address functional deficiencies, asymmetries, and deformities of the nose. In general,
reconstruction and open septorhinoplasty are performed 6 to 12 months after injury
to allow time for the scar tissue to mature and the deformity to stabilize. The incidence
of posttraumatic nasal deformity ranges from 14 to 50% and the two most commonly seen
posttraumatic nasal deformities are the crooked nose and the saddle nose deformity.[7]
[8]
[9] Bony deviation from traumatic injury to the septum and to the nasal bones can result
in a crooked nose. Inadequately treated septal fractures or unrecognized septal injury
can also lead to a crooked nose. The septum is the key structure to correct to minimize
secondary deformity and a crooked nose.[5] Unrepaired septal injuries can cause progressive distortion of the septum and cause
the nasal bones to heal in a deviated position, pulled to one side or another by the
nasal septum. The age-old adage “as the septum goes, so goes the nose”[23] applies in these scenarios. For simple injuries involving the distal portion of
the quadrangular cartilage, closed reduction with intranasal splints results in satisfactory
outcomes.[12] Complex septal fractures are better addressed through an open approach.[11]
[13]
[14] The saddle nose deformity is another common posttraumatic nasal deformity and is
the result of loss of septal support. This may occur secondary to untreated septal
hematoma. The saddle nose deformity is characterized by a scooped out profile, step-off
between the bony and cartilaginous vaults and widened nasal width on frontal view.
The Crooked Nose
To fully address the crooked nose, the surgeon must address the bony vault, septum,
and the lower two-thirds of the nose. When closed reduction is ineffective, and posttraumatic
deformity persists, an open septorhinoplasty can be performed 6 to 12 months following
injury. This allows time for scar tissue to mature and the deformity to stabilize
so an accurate operative plan can be executed.
The Bony Vault
Open reduction of the bony vault may be performed via an endonasal or external rhinoplasty
approach. There are various osteotomy types that can be performed to achieve this
([Fig. 2]). They include the lateral osteotomy, intermediate osteotomy, medial osteotomy,
and transverse osteotomy. The purpose of an osteotomy is to mobilize the bony pyramid
so that it can be reset in a more anatomically favorable position. A medial osteotomy
is often necessary to create a controlled back fracture for the lateral nasal bone.
To perform a medial osteotomy, a narrow straight osteotome is engaged in the nasal
bone at the junction of the septum and nasal bone. The osteotome is then directed
in a cephalic direction and faded laterally in a paramedian, medial oblique, or superior
oblique direction. There are various approaches and methods for performing lateral
osteotomies. Various points of access have been described, but[5]
[24]
[25] the two most common approaches are the internal continuous lateral osteotomy and
the perforated percutaneous lateral osteotomy.[5] In the internal continuous lateral osteotomy technique, a 3-mm stab incision is
made in the nasal vestibule just anterior to the insertion of the head of the inferior
turbinate. A curved osteotome with a guard on the lateral edge is inserted into the
incision and using tactile feedback, the curved osteotome is engaged with the edge
of the piriform aperture. The guard on the lateral edge of the osteotome is then used
as a guide to move the blade in the desired direction to perform a high-low-high,
low-to-high, or low-to-low lateral osteotomy.[5]
[26] The lateral osteotomy should not extend past the medial canthus cephalically. At
the end of the osteotomy, the osteotome is directed back to create a fracture and
mobilize the lateral nasal bone.
Fig. 2 Osteotomies: Medial, intermediate, and lateral osteotomies may be necessary to correct
a severely deviated bony vault. In patients who have had a bony hump takedown with
open roof, a medial osteotomy may be unnecessary to mobilize the nasal bone.
In the perforated percutaneous technique, a small stab incision is made externally
over the nasal bone and a 2-mm osteotome is inserted at the mid-portion of the bony
pyramid along the planned fracture line. A series of small discontinuous osteotomies
are made in a postage-stamp fashion along the planned osteotomy line. In cases where
there is significant deviation, concavity or convexity to the nasal bones, an intermediate
osteotomy may also need to be performed ([Fig. 2]). In these cases, the intermediate osteotomy should be done first to preserve stable
bone on which to perform the lateral osteotomy. An external nasal splint is placed
at the end of the procedure to help hold the reduced nasal bones in place during healing.
Middle Vault and Tip
In some patients with a crooked nose, osteotomies and repositioning of the bony vault
will also straighten the nose. If the upper lateral cartilage, septum, and lower vault
are intact and stable, bony repositioning can pull the entire cartilaginous vault
into midline position. In cases where osteotomy does not reposition or straighten
the nose, it is likely that there are more complex underlying septal deviations that
need to be corrected and addressed. In general, asymmetries of the middle vault will
parallel the asymmetries in the dorsal septum and upper lateral cartilages. Asymmetries
of the nasal tip will follow deviation of the anterior septal angle and asymmetries
in the medial crura and columellar deviation will parallel the caudal septal margin.
To address these asymmetries in the cartilaginous vault of the nose, these respective
portions of the septum need to be carefully assessed and corrected.[27]
Middle Vault Asymmetry
Middle vault asymmetry often results from asymmetry in the upper lateral cartilages
and dorsal septum. Addressing these asymmetries is best accomplished through an open/external
rhinoplasty approach. After the nose is opened, the dorsal septum is carefully examined.
Deviations in the dorsal septum can be addressed with spreader grafts. Spreader graft
dimensions can vary from 10 to 20 mm × 2 to 3 mm × 2 to 4 mm.[28] Spreader grafts can open the nasal valve and camouflage asymmetries in the middle
vault. Asymmetric spreader grafts can be fashioned and placed on either side of the
deviated dorsal septum to address cosmetic asymmetries. Typically, a thicker spreader
graft may be placed on the concave side of the deviation and the thinner graft on
the convex side. Unilateral spreader graft placement is not recommended because the
unilateral graft will tend to be pulled by the septum in the direction of deviation.
It is the inward force exerted by bilateral graft placement that will help correct
the deviated septum.[27] An ethmoid bone graft harvested from the perpendicular plate of the ethmoid during
septoplasty can also be fashioned into a spreader graft to splint the deviated dorsal
septum into midline position.[27]
[29] While the ethmoid bone graft provides a strong and stable splint for the deviated
septum without widening the nose, one limitation of the ethmoid bone graft is a tendency
for the bone to resorb over time leading to recurrence of functional and cosmetic
issues.
The Nasal Tip and Lower Third
Deviation of the nasal tip and lower third can often be traced to caudal septal deviation.
Correcting deviations in the caudal septum is challenging but crucial to reset the
nasal tip in the midline. In cases where the caudal septum is straight but dislocated
off the anterior nasal spine, nasal tip deviation may be addressed by repositioning
the posterior septal angle over the nasal spine. If there is buckling of the caudal
septum after repositioning due to excessive septal height, the excess can be trimmed
along the posterior angle inferiorly and the septum repositioned over the nasal spine.
Deflections of the caudal septum that are mild can be addressed with various techniques.
A mild deflection can be treated with scoring of the cartilage to combat the memory
in the cartilage. Once the cartilage is scored, it can then be straightened and a
cartilage graft can be sutured to the convex side to act as a splint to hold the caudal
septum straight. If the cartilage graft has a curvature to it, the graft can be strategically
placed so that the natural curvature opposes the deflection in the caudal septum to
act as a splint to keep it straight. Ethmoid bone can also be harvested and used to
splint the caudal septum to remove the curvature and straighten the deflection. While
the ethmoid bone can act as an excellent splint to hold the cartilage straight, the
bone may resorb over time with recurrence of the septal deviation and deflection.[27]
For those patients who have a shortened nose, uprotated tip or retracted columella,
a septal extension graft can be used to lengthen the nose, rotate the tip, and set
the nasal tip in the midline. The caudal septal extension graft is overlapped with
the caudal septum and sutured in place using two horizontal mattress sutures. Care
should be taken to ensure the nasal airway is not obstructed by the overlapping septal
extension graft. If there is a slight curve to the septal extension graft, this curve
can be used to counteract the deflection in the existing caudal septum. Once the septal
extension graft is placed, the medial crura are sutured to the graft, and the columellar
base and nasal tip are set in the midline. The septal extension graft can be used
to alter the length of the nose, tip projection, tip rotation, nasolabial angle, and
columellar show.[30]
Extracorporeal Septoplasty
For the severely deviated septum that involves the caudal septum and dorsal septal
strut, the techniques described earlier may not be sufficient. In these cases, an
extracorporeal septoplasty should be done to correct deviations in the middle vault
and nasal tip. Exposure of the septum is completed via an external rhinoplasty approach.
The entire septum including the caudal septum is then removed en bloc and the entire
L strut is reconstructed. When removing the septum, a remnant of the dorsal septum
is left attached at the osseocartilaginous junction/keystone area to leave a cartilaginous
remnant for reattachment of the replacement graft. The longer the dorsal remnant,
the easier the repair will be. If possible, leaving at least 1.5 cm of dorsal remnant
will be ideal and ensuring the dorsal attachment of the cartilaginous septum to the
bony septum remains intact is ideal.[27] The attachment of the cartilaginous septum to the bony septum is what will provide
dorsal stability for the septal reconstruction. If the native septum does not offer
enough cartilage for reconstruction, additional cartilage may be harvested from the
ear or the rib. Once the replacement septal graft is fashioned, it is overlapped with
the remaining dorsal strut and secured to the dorsal strut with horizontal mattress
sutures. The caudal portion of the graft is then secured to the periosteum of the
nasal spine or the posterior septal angle remnant if one is left ([Fig. 3]). Once the L-strut and septal replacement graft are inset, spreader grafts can be
placed to stabilize the septal replacement graft to the mid-vault, fine tune cosmetic
asymmetry in the mid-vault, and restore function of the internal nasal valve.
Fig. 3 Extracorporeal septoplasty. (A) Preoperative view of posttraumatic nasal deformity showing deviation and C-shape
deformity to the nose. (B) Postoperative view demonstrating correction of the nasal deviation and deformity.
(C) Intraoperative dissection demonstrating severe deviation of the cartilaginous septum.
(D) Reconstructed septum with caudal septal replacement graft fashioned from septal
cartilage. A portion of the dorsal cartilaginous strut has been maintained and preserved
for securing the caudal septal replacement graft. (E) Deviated portion of septum including portions of the L strut completely excised.
(F) Note the severe deviation and curve in the dorsal septal strut.
Saddle Nose Deformity
Saddle nose deformity after nasal trauma results from a loss of septal support and
structure. This may result from untreated septal hematoma which may lead to an abscess
that results in cartilage resorption and loss of septal support. Saddle nose deformity
is characterized by a distinct scooped out profile, step-off between the bony and
cartilaginous vaults, widened nasal width on frontal view, and functional nasal obstruction
due to collapse of the internal nasal valve from collapsing upper lateral cartilages
([Fig. 4]).
Fig. 4 Posttraumatic saddle nose deformity. (A) Frontal view of a patient with posttraumatic saddle nose deformity showing step-off
between the bony and cartilaginous vaults and widened nasal width. (B) Preoperative profile view showing scooped out appearance of the nose on profile
view. (C, D) Postoperative photos showing narrowed bony vault on frontal view and correction
of scooped out profile and step-off between the bony and cartilaginous vaults. (E) Autologous rib cartilage carved for dorsal augmentation. (F) The graft is placed in a tight subperiosteal pocket to provide dorsal augmentation.
There are various methods available to augment the nasal dorsum. For more mild cases
of deformity where only a few millimeters of augmentation are needed, dorsal onlay
grafts can be used for augmentation. Dorsal onlay grafts can be fashioned from septal,
auricular, or costal cartilage. The cartilage is carved into a canoe shape and the
edges are beveled to better camouflage any sharp edges under the skin. Depending on
the amount of augmentation needed, multiple segments may need to be carved, stacked,
and sutured together to achieve the desired height. A subperiosteal pocket is then
created and the graft is inserted into this pocket and the graft is secured to the
remaining dorsal septum. A transcutaneous suture can be placed to stabilize the graft
cephalically.[31]
For severe saddle nose deformities and cases that require significant augmentation,
costal cartilage should be harvested as grafting material. The rib cartilage is carved
en bloc into a canoe-shaped structure and placed along the dorsum to augment and correct
the saddle nose deformity ([Fig. 4]). The canoe-shaped graft is typically concave on the undersurface and has an 8:2:1
length to width to height ratio.[32] Contouring the rib to avoid sharp edges is important to improve the cosmetic outcome
and prevent palpable edges or visible edges in the graft. This is particularly important
in thin-skinned individuals. When insetting the monobloc rib graft, the underlying
septum must be strong enough to support the graft. In patients with severe septal
compromise, caudal support of the tip will also need to be reconstructed to support
the graft and the nasal tip. In these patients, a caudal septal replacement graft
or caudal septal extension graft can be fashioned and fixed to the anterior nasal
spine to provide tip support. This caudal septal graft is then incorporated into the
dorsal monobloc graft. The dorsal graft is then stabilized cephalically by the nasal
bone and caudally by the caudal septal extension graft. A subperiosteal pocket is
then created over the nasal bones and the dorsal graft is inserted snugly into this
pocket and can be fixed with a Kirschner wire cephalically. Caudally, the dorsal graft
is secured to the caudal septal extension or replacement graft.
Another option for dorsal augmentation is diced cartilage. Diced cartilage for nasal
augmentation was revived by Erol's publication on the use of the “Turkish delight”
graft.[33] Daniel and Calvert recommended the use of autologous temporalis fascia as the wrap
for the diced cartilage.[34]
[35] In this technique, cartilage is diced into 0.5 to 1 mm cubes. The grafts are then
wrapped in temporalis fascia or placed in a 1-mL syringe for easy insertion of the
diced cartilage into the fascial wrap. The grafts remain palpable postoperatively
and are malleable for 10 to 14 days postoperatively. Due to lack of absorption, the
graft can be used to achieve the ideal shape of the nose at the time of surgery, and
no overcorrection is necessary.[34]
Due to the drawbacks of temporalis fascia harvest, various methods have been developed
to simplify the use of the diced cartilage graft in dorsal augmentation. Modifications
of this procedure and experimentation with other materials to wrap and prepare the
diced cartilage graft have been described. Other materials used to wrap the diced
cartilage include acellular cadaveric dermis and oxidized regenerated cellulose.[36] Tasman et al described the use of two-component fibrin glue to hold the diced cartilage
together in a malleable graft that may be used to augment the nasal dorsum. In this
technique, the cartilage is diced into 0.5 to 1 mm sized cubes and placed in a 3-mL
syringe that has been fashioned into a boat. Fibrin glue is applied over the cartilage
([Fig. 5]), and the graft is unmolded and inserted into a tight subperiosteal pocket. The
graft is malleable and can be molded to the desired shape on the table. This technique
has reduced operative time and the grafts have demonstrated good longevity[37] and good results in dorsal augmentation.
Fig. 5 Diced cartilage glue graft for correction of saddle nose deformity. (A) Preoperative profile view of saddle nose deformity with decreased dorsal height
and step-off between bony and cartilaginous vaults. (B) Postoperative view demonstrating improved dorsal height and correction of step-off
between the bony and cartilaginous vaults. (C) Diced cartilage placed in a 1-mL syringe. (D) Fibrin glue applied to diced cartilage. (E) Diced cartilage glue graft unmolded from the syringe for insertion into the nasal
dorsum. The graft holds its shape but continues to be malleable following placement
in the nose.
Summary/Conclusion
While considered a mild injury, nasal bone fractures can have long-lasting consequences
on the cosmetic and functional form of the nose. Even with prompt treatment and early
closed reduction, posttraumatic nasal deformity can result. The two most common posttraumatic
deformities are the crooked nose and the saddle nose. Both require attention to the
bony and cartilaginous vaults of the nose and careful attention to the septum. Good
reduction and adequate treatment often involve carefully planned osteotomies and reconstruction
of the L-strut of the nose to reconstitute the middle vault and reset the nasal tip
in the midline. There are many techniques available to the rhinoplasty surgeon to
accomplish this. By understanding the anatomy of the nose, the relation between the
bony and cartilaginous vaults, and the anatomy of the L-strut, the rhinoplasty surgeon
can address these difficult deformities while maintaining the cosmetic and functional
integrity of the nose.
