Key words
skeletal-axial - MR imaging - inflammation - arthritides
Sacroiliitis and Spondyloarthritis
Sacroiliitis and Spondyloarthritis
Sacroiliitis is an important clinical and diagnostic feature of ankylosing spondylitis
(AS) [1] and other forms of spondyloarthritis (SpA) [2]. While sacroiliitis can be diagnosed by conventional radiography in established
disease, a more sensitive diagnostic tool such as magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)
is necessary for evaluating patients with early disease. Demonstration of sacroiliitis
is one of the key criteria for axial SpA in the classification of the Assessments
in Ankylosing Spondylitis (ASAS) group [3].
SpA patients suffer from pain and stiffening of the axial skeleton and also to some
degree the peripheral joints, predominantly the lower extremity. There is a high association
with the HLA-B27 antigene and extraskeletal manifestations such as psoriasis, anterior
uveitis or inflammatory bowel disease may occur.
The clinical key symptom of SpA is inflammatory back pain characterized by onset before
age 40, insidious onset, relief with movement, no improvement with rest, and pain
at night (with improvement after getting up) [4]. Despite this clear definition, the symptoms are often mistaken for chronic low
back pain, and an average of 8.5 years elapse after the onset of clinical symptoms
before the diagnosis of AS – the prototype of SpA – is made in HLA-B27-positive patients
[5]. The delay is even longer, 11.4 years on average, in HLA-B27-negative patients or
in women [5].
To improve on this situation, decision-making trees have been proposed to simplify
and speed up the diagnosis of SpA [6]. This has been widely acknowledged and as a consequence MRI has been approved to
contribute to the classification of SpA in terms of the newly developed ASAS classification
criteria [3]. Sensitivities and specificities of over 90 % [7]
[8]
[9]
[10] and a high positive likelihood ratio of approx. 9.0 [6] clearly indicate that MRI should be used early so that patients may benefit from
early initiation of a rigorous therapeutic regimen [11]. The positive likelihood ratio of MRI of the sacroiliac joints (SIJs) is as high
as that of the HLA-B27 blood test [6]. However, one has to be aware that a reliable MRI diagnosis of sacroiliitis crucially
depends on a thorough clinical history. It has been shown that analysis of MRI alone
has a sensitivity of 64 % and a specificity of 80 %, which increase to 95 % and 98 %,
respectively, when images are interpreted in conjunction with clinical data [12].
Anatomy, Histology and Biochemistry as a Basis for Imaging
Anatomy, Histology and Biochemistry as a Basis for Imaging
Histological examinations of biopsy specimens from the SIJs [13]
[14]
[15]
[16] and autopsy preparations [17] have improved our understanding of the pathogenesis of SpA. These specimens, in
part also presented in this review article, were acquired in the setting of a research
project with approval of the local ethics committee during the course of CT-guided
steroid injections in painful patients [16]. In general, joint biopsies are not needed for routine follow-up of SpA patients.
As a result of these investigations, the demonstration of tumor necrosis factor alpha
(TNF-alpha) messenger ribonucleic acid (mRNA) in cellular infiltrates in these biopsy
specimens [15] opened up a new era of therapy with TNF-alpha inhibitors [18]
[19]
[20]
[21]. MRI of the axial skeleton has an important role in monitoring patients on TNF-alpha
therapy [18]
[22]
[23]
[24].
The complex anatomy of the sacroiliac joints has been described in detail [25]
[26]. MRI of the SIJs is performed in the oblique coronal plane with acquisition of a
T1-weighted turbo spin echo (TSE) sequence, a T1-weighted fat-suppressed 3 D gradient
echo (GRE) sequence for the depiction of cartilage, and a fat-saturated T1-weighted
GRE sequence after contrast administration. The slice thickness should be 1.5 – 2.0 mm
and dynamic, time-resolved MRI sequences are not generally needed for the diagnosis
of sacroiliitis but may be potentially useful in monitoring disease activity [8]
[27]. Alternatively, if contrast medium administration is not possible, a short tau inversion
recovery (STIR) sequence may be used. As a recommendation of the ASAS group, a T1-weighted
TSE sequence and a STIR sequence are sufficient for MRI of the sacroiliac joints [28]. However, these recommendations are intended to be applicable worldwide and therefore
may be regarded as the “minimal standard”.
The SIJ consists of a cartilaginous part and a fibrous (or ligamentous) compartment
with very strong anterior and posterior sacroiliac ligaments [29]. This makes the SIJ an amphiarthrosis with movement restricted to slight rotation
and translation [29]. The articular surface being ear-shaped ([Fig. 1a]), different articular portions will be depicted, depending on the slice position.
Anterior oblique coronal images ([Fig. 1b, e]) only show the cartilaginous joint portion, while more posterior sections ([Fig. 2a, d]) show both cartilaginous and ligamentous portions. Another specific feature of the
SIJs is that two different types of cartilage cover the two articular surfaces. While
the sacral cartilage is purely hyaline, the iliac side is covered by a mixture of
hyaline and fibrous cartilage ([Fig. 1 d]) [29]
[30]. Due to its fibrocartilaginous components, the sacroiliac joint is a so-called articular
enthesis [31].
Fig. 1 Normal anterior anatomy of the sacroiliac joints (SIJ). a Schematic representation of the ear-shaped joint surface and of the oblique coronal
slice. b Oblique coronal section of gross anatomic specimen showing the right SIJ (indicated
by black arrows) as a continuous structure. c Microanatomic detail of the anterior joint space (H&E staining, original magnification
× 10). The articular cartilage on the iliac side (black arrowheads), consisting of
a mixture of hyaline and fibrous cartilage, is altogether thinner than the pure hyaline
cartilage on the sacral side (black double arrowhead). The anterior sacroiliac ligament
(black arrows) gradually blends with the periosteum of the ilium and is therefore
considered an enthesis (discontinuity due to cutting artifact). d Demonstration of iliac fibrocartilage (left) containing collagen fibers and sparse
chondrocytes and sacral hyaline cartilage (right) rich in chondrocytes (H&E staining,
original magnification × 500). e T1-weighted fat-suppressed 3 D gradient echo (GRE) image with high signal intensity
of the articular cartilage.
Abb. 1 Normale anteriore Anatomie der Sakroiliakalgelenke (SIG). a Schematische Darstellung der ohrförmigen Gelenkfläche und der schräg koronaren Schnittführung.
b Schräg koronare anatomische Präparation des rechten SIG (schwarze Pfeile) mit glatter,
durchgängiger Gelenkfläche. c Mikroanatomisches Detail des anterioren Gelenkanteils und der Gelenkkapsel (HE-Färbung,
10fache Vergrößerung). Der iliakale Gelenkknorpel (schwarze Pfeilspitzen), bestehend
aus einer Mischung von hyalinem und Faserknorpel, ist dünner als der rein hyaline
Gelenkknorpel der sakralen Gelenkfläche (schwarze Doppelpfeilspitze). Das anteriore
sakroiliakale Band (schwarze Pfeile) geht kontinuierlich in das Periost des Os ilium
über und entspricht einer Enthese (Unterbrechung aufgrund von Schneideartefakten).
d Darstellung des iliakalen Faserknorpels (links) mit Kollagenfasern und spärlichen
Chondrozyten und dem sakralen hyalinen Knorpel (rechts) reich an Chondrozyten (HE
Färbung, 500fache Vergrößerung). e T1-gewichtete fettsupprimierte wasserverstärkte 3 D Gradientenecho (GRE)-Sequenz
mit hoher Signalintensität des Gelenkknorpels.
Fig. 2 Normal posterior anatomy. a Schematic representation of the angulated oblique coronal section depicting the cartilaginous
portion of the sacroiliac joint superiorly and inferiorly and portions of the fibrous
compartment (retroarticular space) in between, which is due to the ear-shaped joint
surface. b Oblique coronal section of gross anatomic specimen. There is smoothly marginated
articular cartilage in the cartilaginous compartment (indicated by arrows), while
the interosseous ligaments are embedded in fatty tissue in the retroarticular space
(black arrowheads). c Microanatomic overview through the plane indicated in a (H&E staining, original magnification × 10). d T1-weighted TSE image of the right SIJ with its anterior cartilaginous part (white
arrows) and its posterior retroarticular space containing interosseous ligaments (white
arrowheads) and fatty connective tissue.
Abb. 2 Normale posteriore Anatomie. a Schematische Darstellung der schräg koronaren Schnittführung mit Darstellung des
knorpeligen Gelenkkompartiments superior und inferior sowie Teilen des fibrösen Gelenkkompartiments
(Spatium retroarticulare) dazwischen, da die knorpelige Gelenkfläche ohrförmig konfiguriert
ist. b Schräg koronare anatomische Präparation. Der Gelenkknorpel ist glatt begrenzt (Pfeile),
während die interossären Ligamente in das Fettgewebe des Spatium retroarticulare eingebettet
sind (schwarze Pfeilspitzen). c Mikroanatomischer Überblick entsprechend der in a angegebenen Schnittlinie (HE Färbung, 10fache Vergrößerung). d T1-gewichtete TSE Sequenz des rechten SIG mit dem anterioren knorpeligen Gelenkkompartiment
(weiße Pfeile) und dem posterior gelegenen Spatium retroarticulare und den dort befindlichen
interossären Ligamenten (weiße Pfeilspitzen) und fetthaltigem Bindegewebe.
The extracellular matrix of fibrocartilage is rich in proteoglycans and glycosaminoglycans,
which are strongly hydrophilic molecules and attract water, thereby ensuring the stable
elasticity of cartilage [32]. Damage to a joint by inflammatory or degenerative processes leads to a loss of
these negatively charged macromolecules. As a result, there is greater affinity of
gadolinium complexes from paramagnetic contrast agents, which also possess a negative
charge, to the extracellular matrix of fibrocartilage [33]. This is the mechanism underlying late enhancement in damaged joints [34]
[35].
Sacroiliitis and MRI
Unlike conventional radiography and computed tomography, which only demonstrate structural
or chronic changes, MRI depicts both active (acute) and structural signs of sacroiliitis.
Active changes are subsumed under the label of enthesitis and include fibrocartilaginous
enhancement, predominantly at the iliac joint surface, capsulitis, and juxta-articular
osteiitis ([Fig. 4]). Florid, or active, stages of sacroiliitis are characterized by proliferative inflammatory
tissue destroying cartilage and bone ([Fig. 4], [5]). This tissue consists of fibroblasts and fibrocytes, T-cells, and macrophages [16]. Ingrowth of vessels is one of the reasons why there is a signal increase on contrast-enhanced
images ([Fig. 5]). There is controversy about the term “synovitis” because only sparse amounts of
synovial, villus-like tissue are histologically demonstrated between the iliac and
sacral cartilage near the anterior and posterior joint capsules with obliteration
in the further course of the disease [17].
Fig. 3 48-year-old HLA-B27-positive man with early SpA and a three-month history of inflammatory
back pain. a Biopsy specimen (Goldner staining, 250x magnification) showing highly vascularized
fibrous proliferation (P) adjacent to cartilage (C). b 500-fold magnification showing the proliferative tissue adjacent to metaplastic cartilage
(M). APAAP (alkaline phosphatase anti-alkaline phosphatase) technique with monoclonal
antibodies to CD3-positive T-lymphocytes (arrows). c T1-weighted TSE image showing contour irregularities (arrow) and diffuse para-articular
signal decrease of the iliac bone. d T1-weighted oblique coronal fat-saturated image immediately after contrast injection
showing linear enhancement of articular fibrocartilage of the right SIJ with clear
delineation of single erosion of iliac bone (arrow). Slightly increased signal intensity
of the para-articular bone marrow regions suggesting osteitis. Please note normal
left SIJ. e T1-weighted true coronal fat-saturated image acquired 4 min after contrast injection
demonstrates improved depiction of enthesitis with osteitis predominantly on the iliac
side. Arrow indicates same bony erosion as in d (c–e: Original MR images were replaced by equivalent state-of-the-art MR images.)
Abb. 3 48-jähriger HLA-B27 positiver Patient mit früher SpA und entzündlichem Rückenschmerz
seit drei Monaten. a Gelenkbiopsat (Goldner–Färbung, 250fache Vergrößerung) mit stark vaskularisierter
fibröser Proliferation (P) in Nachbarschaft des Knorpels (C). b 500fache Vergrößerung zeigt Proliferationsgewebe metaplastischem Knorpel (M) benachbart.
APAAP (alkaline phosphatase anti-alkaline phosphatase) Technik mit monoklonalen Antikörpern
gegen CD3-positive T-Lymphozyten (Pfeile). c T1-gewichtete TSE Sequenz zeigt Konturunregelmäßigkeiten (Pfeil) und einen diffusen
paraartikulären Signalabfall des Os ilium. d T1-gewichtete schräg koronare fettgesättigte Sequenz unmittelbar nach Kontrastmittelinjektion
mit linearem Enhancement des Faserknorpels des rechten SIG und Darstellung einer singulären
Erosion im Os ilium (Pfeil). Etwas erhöhte Signalintensität das paraartikulären Knochenmarks
hinweisend für Osteitis. Normaler Befund am linken SIG. e T1-gewichtete, streng koronare fettgesättigte Sequenz 4 Min. nach Kontrastmittelinjektion
mit verbesserter Darstellung der Enthesitis und Osteitis insbesondere im Os ilium.
Der Pfeil markiert die gleiche Erosion wie in d (c–e: Die originalen MRT-Aufnahmen wurden durch äquivalentes State-of-the-art Bildmaterial
ersetzt.)
Fig. 4 24-year-old HLA-B27-positive man with early axial SpA and florid sacroiliitis with
erosions and a 12-month history of inflammatory back pain. a H&E staining (original magnification x400) of biopsy specimen of right SIJ. Fibrous
proliferation (P) rich in fibroblasts destroying the cartilage (C) with formation
of so-called lacunae (arrowheads) and reactive chondroblast activation (arrows) b Immunohistological section of the interface between cartilage (C) and fibrous proliferations
(P) with cellular infiltrations (original magnification 250x, APAAP technique, monoclonal
antibodies to CD68-positive macrophages). c T1-weighted TSE image showing a wavy and blurred cortical layer of the iliac joint
surface due to erosions (arrowheads) and patchy iliac subchondral sclerosis on the
right SIJ (S) and slight, linear subchondral sclerosis on the left SIJ. Note that
the sacral joint surfaces are well preserved due to the thicker hyaline cartilage
layer. Fat deposition is evident on both sides of the left SIJ. d Fat-saturated T1-weighted GRE image in oblique coronal plane after contrast administration
showing enhancement of the articular fibrocartilage and of the erosions (arrows) as
well as of the para-articular bone marrow (asterisks). Note that the erosions in the
left SIJ, which are surrounded by a thin zone of sclerosis, display markedly weaker
contrast enhancement. (c, d: Original MR images were replaced by equivalent state-of-the-art MR images.)
Abb. 4 24-jähriger HLA-B27 positiver Patient mit frührer axialer SpA und florider Sakroiliitis
mit Erosionen. Seit 12 Monaten bestehender entzündlicher Rückenschmerz. a HE-Färbung (400fache Vergrößerung) eines Gelenkbiopsats des rechten SIG. Fibröse
Proliferationen (P) mit zahlreichen Fibroblasten, die den Knorpel (C) zerstören und
sogenannte Lakunen (Pfeile) bilden sowie reaktive Aktivierung von Chondroblasten (Pfeile)
b Immunohistologische Darstellung des Übergangs zwischen Knorpel (C) und fibrösen Proliferationen
(P) mit zellulären Infiltraten (250fache Vergrößerung, APAAP Technik, monoklonale
Antikörper gegen CD68-positive Makrophagen). c T1-gewichtete TSE Sequenz mit welliger und unscharfer iliakaler Gelenkkontur aufgrund
von Erosionen (arrowheads) und fleckiger iliakaler subchondraler Sklerose (S) des
rechten SIG und geringer, linearer subchondraler Sklerose des linken SIG. Die sakralen
Gelenkflächen sind gut erhalten aufgrund der dickeren hyalinen Knorpelschicht. Darstellung
von Fettdepositionen iliakal und sakral am linken SIG. d Fettgesättigte, schräg koronare T1-gewichtete GRE Sequenz nach Kontrastmittelapplikation
mit Enhancement des faserknorpeligen Gelenkknorpels und von Erosionen (Pfeile) sowie
paraartikulärer Osteitis (Sterne). Die Erosionen des linken SIG, welche von einer
dünnen Sklerosezone umgeben sind, zeigen ein deutlich schwächeres Kontrastmittelenhancement.
(c, d: Die originalen MRT-Aufnahmen wurden durch äquivalentes State-of-the-art Bildmaterial
ersetzt.)
Fig. 5 39-year-old HLA-B27-positive man with AS (10-year history). There is chronic sacroiliitis
with low inflammatory activity. a H&E staining (original magnification x250). The biopsy specimen of the right SIJ
shows extensive destruction of cartilage (C) with only residual cartilage fragments
and cellular infiltrates and a predominance of trabeculae (B), suggesting formation
of new bone. b T1-weighted TSE image showing para-articular sclerosis of both joints, more pronounced
on the iliac sides. The joint spaces appear blurred as in early ankylosis. c Fat-saturated, oblique coronal T1-weighted GRE image after contrast administration
showing only very sparse enhancement within localized erosions. Corresponding iliac
and sacral erosions are visible in both joints. Erosive damage has lead to pseudodilation
(arrowhead) of the joints. In addition there are bone buds (arrow) as signs of early
ankylosis. (b, c: Original MR images were replaced by equivalent state-of-the-art MR images.)
Abb. 5 39-jähriger HLA-B27 positiver Patient mit AS (10 Jahre Erkrankungsdauer). Chronische
Sakroiliitis mit geringer entzündlicher Aktivität. a HE-Färbung (250fache Vergrößerung). Gelenkbiopsat des rechten SIG zeigt ausgedehnte
Zerstörungen des Gelenkknorpels (C) mit residuellen Knorpelfragmenten und zellulären
Infiltraten aber prädominanten Trabekeln (B), hinweisend für Knochenneubildung. b T1-gewichtete TSE Sequenz mit paraartikulärer Sklerose beider SIG, betont auf der
iliakalen Seite. Die Gelenkspalten erscheinen unscharf wie bei beginnender Ankylose.
c Fettgesättigte, schräg koronare T1-gewichtete GRE Sequenz nach Kontrastmittelapplikation
und nur sehr spärlichem Enhancement innerhalb von einzelnen Erosionen. Korrespondierende
iliakale und sakrale Erosionen beider SIG. Die erosive Zerstörung hat zur Pseudoerweiterung
(Pfeilspitzen) der Gelenke geführt. Zusätzlich Darstellung von Knochenknospen (Pfeile)
als Zeichen einer beginnenden Ankylose. (b, c: Die originalen MRT-Aufnahmen wurden durch äquivalentes State-of-the-art Bildmaterial
ersetzt.)
Enthesitis is depicted as contrast medium enhancement of the joint capsule and within
the articular fibrocartilage and may extend continuously from the joint to the pericapsular
tendon and ligament attachments ([Fig. 3], [4]). Pericapsular soft tissue (fat and muscle) typically shows no enhancement in spondyloarthritis
– which is the case only in septic sacroiliitis (so-called lava cleft phenomenon)
[36].
Early periarticular osteitis denotes inflammation of bone marrow areas adjacent to
the sacroiliac joints predominantly on the iliac side ([Fig. 3]). It represents an extension of inflammation of articular fibrocartilage of the
SIJs. The size of the bone marrow area affected by osteitis is a measure of the inflammatory
activity of sacroiliitis and is graded by using semiquantitative techniques [25]. Osteitis is also currently the only parameter that defines a positive MRI finding
in the classification of the ASAS group, especially when it is present in two or more
slices [28]. The signal intensity of osteitis varies with the interval between image acquisition
and contrast medium injection ([Fig. 3]).
At later stages areas of osteitis are transformed into periarticular deposits of fatty
tissue [25]
[37]. Chronic sacroiliitis is further characterized by erosions, subchondral sclerosis,
transarticular bone bridges, and bone buds ([Fig. 5], [6]). These processes may ultimately lead to complete ankylosis of the sacroiliac joints,
which is seen on MRI as a so-called phantom joint.
Fig. 6 33-year-old HLA-B27-positive patient with a long history of AS. T1-weighted TSE image
showing complete ankylosis of both sacroiliac joints. “Phantom joints” suggest the
former joints (arrows).
Abb. 6 33-jähriger HLA-B27 positiver Patient mit langjährig bekannter AS. T1-gewichtete
TSE Sequenz mit kompletter Ankylose beider SIG. “Phantomgelenke” deuten die ehemaligen
SIG an (Pfeile).
Erosions are depicted on MR images as discontinuities of the cortical bone. Erosions
are contiguous with the joint space. Erosions in sacroiliac arthritis initially tend
to occur on the iliac side of the joint [38], due to its fibrocartilaginous components, and may later progress to corresponding
erosions also on the sacral side ([Fig. 5]). Strong contrast enhancement indicates active erosion, while so-called smooth erosions
display much weaker enhancement and are characterized by the presence of marginal
sclerosis ([Fig. 4]). Several confluent erosions have the appearance of a string of beads and lead to
so-called pseudodilation of the sacroiliac joint as they progress further ([Fig. 5]).
Subchondral sclerosis is seen as areas of low or no signal on all sequences. They
often predominate on the iliac side ([Fig. 4]) and only later affect the periarticular area on the sacral side as well ([Fig. 5]). Sclerosis shows no enhancement after contrast medium administration.
Bone buds ([Fig. 5]) and transarticular bone bridges are the first sign of ankylosing processes of the
SIJ. They are more clearly identified by computed tomography since bony structures
are depicted only indirectly on MR images. The presence of bone bridges leads to increasing
blurring of the joint cleft until complete ankylosis occurs. Transarticular bone bridges
are characterized by low signal intensity on all sequences. When there is complete
ankylosis, the SIJ is seen as a low-intensity line surrounded by deposits of fatty
tissue, which is hyperintense on T1-weighted images. This condition is referred to
as a phantom joint ([Fig. 6]).
Summary
In summary, MRI of the sacroiliac joints sensitively detects both active and structural
changes, making it an ideal imaging modality for early diagnosis and follow-up of
sacroiliitis in axial spondyloarthritis. Some of the changes are subtle and can only
be detected after administration of a paramagnetic contrast agent, especially in early
disease.