Keywords
cerebrospinal fluid - pneumonitis - endoscopic - endonasal - aspiration
Introduction
Spontaneous cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) fistula of the skull base is an uncommon condition
associated with multiple etiologies and can have a variable presentation. Of note,
obese, middle-aged, and multiparous women most commonly develop this condition.[1]
[2] Intractable, watery discharge from the nose (rhinorrhea) that tests positive for
β2-transferrin is pathognomonic.[1] However, the quality and quantity of discharge may result in misdiagnosis as allergic
rhinitis or sinusitis and delay treatment, particularly if the condition presents
with atypical complications. We present the first known case of spontaneous CSF rhinorrhea
complicated by chronic pneumonitis secondary to CSF aspiration, which was successfully
resolved by endoscopic endonasal repair, and discuss the relevant literature associated
with the complications of spontaneous CSF rhinorrhea.
Case Report
History and Presentation
A 44-year-old woman presented with 4 months of progressive cough, exertional dyspnea,
hoarseness, and intermittent fluid drainage from the right nostril. She was initially
evaluated by a pulmonologist, who noted that she was otherwise healthy besides being
obese (body mass index: 36.5 kg/m2) and having diminished lung sounds bilaterally at the bases. Computed tomography
(CT) imaging of the chest ([Fig. 1]) showed patchy opacities in both lower lung lobes. Bronchoscopy with lavage was
performed with nondiagnostic results. Multiple courses of oral antibiotics were unsuccessful
in improving her symptoms. She was also prescribed codeine, formoterol/budesonide,
prednisone, albuterol, montelukast, and fluticasone in various unsuccessful attempts
to alleviate her pulmonary symptoms.
Fig. 1 Preoperative CT image of the paranasal sinuses (A) showing meningocele with fluid
collection in the right ethmoid sinus (arrows) and of the chest (B) showing lung opacities
(circles). CT, computed tomography.
Because of the persistent pneumonitis, she was referred to a thoracic surgeon for
further evaluation. Due to the uncertain, persistent, and the progressive nature of
her lung findings, a thoracoscopic wedge resection of the superior right upper lobe
was recommended and performed. The specimen showed acute bronchopneumonia, a 1.5-mm
chemodectoma, and acute on chronic inflammation, but no further etiology was determined.
She was then referred to an otolaryngologist for evaluation of the persistent nasal
drainage and postnasal drip, which was a major stimulant of her cough and severe enough
to force her to sleep upright. The nasal fluid was more pronounced during a forward
tilt test, and was collected and tested positive for β2-transferrin. This was an unexpected
finding, as a spontaneous CSF fistula with chronic aspiration has not been previously
recognized as a cause of lung disease.
The patient was referred to our otolaryngology and neurosurgery services for evaluation
of her spontaneous CSF rhinorrhea. She denied any trauma or previous nasal surgery.
She was afebrile with no meningitic or focal neurological signs. She had clear and
persistent fluid rhinorrhea from the right nostril when leaning forward. Endoscopic
evaluation of her nasal cavity in the clinic setting did not identify a site of CSF
leakage. CT imaging of the paranasal sinuses ([Fig. 1]) showed bony dehiscence of the skull base and a meningocele extending into the right
ethmoid sinus. Although the cause of her spontaneous CSF leak and skull base defect
was unknown, it was likely related to her body habitus and idiopathic intracranial
hypertension. The patient was informed of her treatment options and elected for urgent
surgical repair.
Operation and Postoperative Course
The CSF leak was repaired via a right endoscopic endonasal approach. Following administration
of intrathecal fluorescein through a lumbar drain, a small bony defect and brisk CSF
fistula were identified in the region of the right fovea ethmoidalis. The bony and
dural defects were repaired using a two-layer reconstruction with autologous fascia
lata (fascial apposition method) followed by a pedicled nasal-septal flap.
The patient's postoperative course was unremarkable with no further CSF rhinorrhea.
The lumbar drain was removed on postoperative day 3. Following surgery, her pneumonitis
resolved and she remained free of any pulmonary symptoms at 11-month follow-up. CT
imaging of the chest ([Fig. 2]) showed resolution of the bilateral opacities and pneumonitis.
Fig. 2 Postoperative CT imaging of the chest showing resolution of the lung opacities (circles).
CT, computed tomography.
Discussion
Diagnosis and treatment of spontaneous CSF rhinorrhea are straightforward, but can
be delayed significantly if it presents with atypical complications. Upon review of
the literature, the most common and clinically relevant complications are meningitis
and pneumocephalus.[3]
[4] Meningitis is of primary concern for all CSF leaks regardless of origin. Nasopharyngeal
CSF leaks are especially prominent sources of meningitis, as pneumococci are responsible
for greater than 80% of CSF leak-related meningitis.[5] Other complications, such as intermittent herniation, empty sella syndrome, and
spontaneous intracranial hypotension are much rarer.[6]
[7]
[8] Our report of chronic pneumonitis due to CSF aspiration is the first reported instance
of this significant and clinically relevant complication.
While our case did not present this issue, difficulties with identifying the skull
base defect on standard neuroimaging studies can also result in treatment delay.[9] CT imaging is standard and magnetic resonance imaging can be used if CT results
are nondiagnostic.[10] However, it remains that some scans will not clearly identify the responsible skull
base defect.[11] Regardless of imaging, β2-transferrin positive nasal discharge is sufficient cause
for endoscopic endonasal exploration and repair[1]; use of intrathecal fluorescein dye will help identify the leak under direct visualization.[10]
Once the location of the CSF fistula is accurately identified, multiple surgical repair
options exist. If a meningoencephalocele is identified, it should be reduced and repaired
accordingly. Autologous fat and fascial grafting is commonly used to fill in any dead
space and create a dural reconstruction, respectively. We prefer to utilize a two-layer
“fascial apposition” method, in which the first fascial layer is inserted as a dural
inlay and the second is placed in apposition as a dural overlay and bony inlay.[12] We prefer not to use a rigid buttress unless the defect is exceptionally large,
but routinely prepare and rotate a pedicled nasal-septal flap for broad coverage of
the defect as described by Hadad et al,[13] and popularized by Kassam et al.[14] Lumbar drainage may be utilized conservatively to temporarily reduce CSF pressure
for 2 to 3 days following the operation along with facilitating intraoperative intrathecal
fluorescein administration.
In this case, the increased diagnostic complexity related to the pronounced pulmonary
complications resulted in unnecessary interventions and treatment delays. This is
a meaningful example of why prompt recognition of spontaneous CSF leaks by practitioners
of all types is essential to prevent potentially harmful complications including meningitis,
pneumocephalus, and even lung disease caused by chronic CSF aspiration.
