Keywords
cerebral aneurysm - computational fluid dynamics - preoperative illustration - preoperative
planning
Introduction
The architecture or configuration of an aneurysm must be understood by studying its
three-dimensionality preoperatively.[1] Preoperative illustration is part of important exercise to study the configuration,
direction, presence of any perforations and the weakest point in the wall of the cerebral
aneurysm. The same illustration is used to study the surrounding brain structures
to decide the best and safe surgical approach prior to any surgical procedure. With
the evolution of the aneurysm wall study and study of flow dynamic within the involved
artery and its aneurysm wall using computational fluid dynamics (CFD), a better surgical
plan can be formulated to improve the flow dynamics. As one of the clinical applications
of CFD, we propose a study using a composite image that combines preoperative illustration
and CFD, which is traditionally widely used in neurosurgery.
This spatial construct must be viewed from an intraoperative perspective by taking
into account the limitations of the surgical corridor (based on the selected surgical
approach), and to anticipate the most suitable sizes, shapes, and positions of clips.[1] The understanding and utilization of CFD in real life practice among European neurosurgeons
were low in a study conducted by Singh et al in 2009.[2] The early identification of the region of aneurysm sac which is a high risk of intraoperative
rupture is essential to avoid such incidence during surgery. A study showed intraoperative
rupture cases have resulted in a 3.21-fold risk of unfavorable outcome compared with
those without it.[3]
Methods and Materials
We study the use of illustrations of the unruptured cerebral aneurysm of internal
carotid-posterior communicating (ICPC) artery and anterior communicating artery (AcomA)
treated at our hospital. The combinations of both preoperative illustrations and CFD
images by using “Ipad Pro” were used.
Data Acquisitions
Preoperative computed tomography (CT) angiography (CTA) was acquired in Digital Imaging
and Communications in Medicine (DICOM) format at the planning station (Amin Corporation
ZIO station2). Subsequently the constructed images were sent to another software,
Hemoscope to generate the CFD images.
Preoperative Illustrations
-
Illustration equipment used, application:
-
CFD equipment used, application:
-
Amin Corporation ZIO station2 and Hemoscope.
-
Parameters: pressure, WSS, streamline, vector.
-
Combination of both images
CFD Evaluation
The first study of CFD to learn about the origin and growth of intracranial aneurysms,
was done by Gonzalez et al, using non-Newtonian viscosity of blood and other hemodynamic
data via computer simulation.[4] He found that due to the pressure changes during systolic and diastolic, these rapid
changes of blood flow direction result in rapid changes in wall shear stress (WSS)
and pressure at the proximal and distal walls of the cavity, rendering continuous
damage to the intima at the cavity neck. More work has been done since then by the
application of Newtonian viscosity in computing cerebral aneurysm hemodynamically.
Since CFD is a three-dimensional (3D) image, the amount of information is very large,
and evaluating only CFD may lead to misjudgment. The evaluation may be more useful
with the study of the anatomical relationship with surrounding brain structures. An
example of the image generated using CFD is shown below ([Fig. 1]). The colors used are related to the blood flow velocity within the vessel. Most
modelling are using 3D CTA images. While four-dimensional (4D) CTA images allow wall
motion analysis which lead to a more accurate prediction of rupture,[5] however, if the heterogeneous material properties and thicknesses of the aneurysm
wall during cardiac cycles are to be known, the wall motion can be predicted. Other
imaging modalities to generate CFD data include two-dimensional phase contrast magnetic
resonance imaging (pcMRI) and 4D MRI.[6]
[7] Time-averaged WSS is used to predict the wall degradation and remodelling.[7]
[8] WSS “vector,” is used to indicate the viscous force vector per unit area of the
aneurysm wall. The oscillatory shear index (OSI) is used to quantify the changing
direction of the WSS vector over the cardiac cycle.[8] However, the software Hemoscope does not have the OSI value for the study in this
paper.
Fig. 1 Single image of vessels with computational fluid dynamics (CFD). Limited information
on the side (right/left), approach (pterional, interhemispheric) and vessels involved
(middle cerebral artery, MCA, or AcomA).
Case 1: Internal Carotid-Posterior Communicating (ICPC) Artery Aneurysm
We showed an example of preoperative evaluation of an unruptured ICPC artery aneurysm.
The cranial CT angiogram showed a saccular aneurysm of the left ICPC artery pointing
toward the inferio-posterio-lateral temporal lobe ([Fig. 2])
Fig. 2 Left ICPC artery saccular aneurysm. ICPC, internal carotid-posterior communicating.
Based on the CT angiogram, a CFD study was performed using the Amin Corporation ZIO
station2 and Hemoscope. The analyses of the wall pressure, WSS, streamline, and vector
were made ([Fig. 3]). To obtain a proper CFD analysis, the truncated parent vessel plays an important
role especially in posterior communicating artery (PcomA) and AcomA aneurysms where
upstream curvature was substantial. Hence the inclusion of the upstream portion of
the parent vessel of cerebral aneurysms is necessary in the CFD study for accurate
analyses of the intra-aneurysmal hemodynamics.[9] Hence long truncated internal carotid vessel was included in the CFD study of ICPC
artery aneurysm as shown below.
Fig. 3 Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) using the Amin Corporation ZIO station2 and Hemoscope.
(A) Wall pressure showed higher wall pressure compared with the distal vessel. (B) The wall shear stress (WSS) showed low WSS indicating high risk of rupture especially
over lateral wall of the dome. (C) The vector WSS showed divergent vectors indicating turbulence flow with the aneurysm
sac. (D) The streamline indicating laminar flow directions within the aneurysm sac.
The images generated using the Hemoscope was extracted as a single vessel ([Fig. 4]).
Fig. 4 The extracted wall shear stress image of the ICPC artery aneurysm. ICPC, internal
carotid-posterior communicating.
An anatomical illustration of the surrounding brain structures viewed from the pterional
approach was made using the iPad pro (10.5 inch), Apple Pencil, and Procreate ([Fig. 5]).
Fig. 5 An anatomical illustration of the surrounding brain structures viewed from the pterional
approach was made using the iPad pro (10.5 inch), Apple Pencil, and Procreate.
The next step was combining both the images from the illustration and the vessels
generated with CFD according to the CT angiogram using the Adobe Photoshop MIX ([Fig. 6]).
Fig. 6 Combined images of CFD images of the ICPC artery aneurysm with the brain structures.
(A) Combined images showed high wall pressure over the whole aneurysm sac with wide
neck. (B) Combined images showed an aneurysm dome with low WSS indicating risk of rupture
pointing toward the temporal lobe and the cranial nerve (CN) III (below the aneurysm
sac). (C) The combined vector. (D) The streamline within the ICPC artery aneurysm. CFD, computational fluid dynamics;
ICPC, internal carotid-posterior communicating; WSS, wall shear stress.
In the actual surgical procedure with pterional approach, the exact anatomical relationship
of the ICPC artery aneurysm and the surrounding brain structures was found ([Fig. 7]).
Fig. 7 The comparison with the preoperative medical illustration and the actual microscopic
view.
Case 2: Left Anterior Communicating Artery (AcomA) Aneurysm (Right Pterional Approach)
The same steps were used in the second illustrated case of an unruptured AcomA aneurysm.
The CTA is shown below ([Fig. 8]).
Fig. 8 AcomA saccular aneurysm pointing right side in the top view.
After CFD of the aneurysm was performed, the illustration of the brain according to
the surgical approach was made, and combination of both images can be visualized as
shown below ([Fig. 9]).
Fig. 9 The illustration of the structures seen in right pterional approach (left) and combination of both images including the one generated by CFD (right). CFD, computational fluid dynamics.
Discussion
The study of CFD has become an important preoperative step to determine the best surgical
approach. A high-quality 3D dataset is fundamental and high-resolution images such
as digital subtraction angiography or CT angiography are widely used.[10] In our cases, we used CT angiogram Digital Imaging and Communications in Medicine
(DICOM) images to generate the CFD images. CFD simulations are for the prediction
of aneurysm rupture. The geometry might have changed after a rupture, which will produce
hemodynamic differences.[10] Few assumptions are made to generate simulated flow dynamics. Those assumptions
include incompressible laminar flow, blood material properties, and boundary conditions.[10]
WSS is a frictional force on the arterial wall produced by blood flow in a direction
toward a local tangent plane. Although the relationship of the WSS value to the growth
of the aneurysm sac was inconsistent in many reports, majority of studies found a
low WSS associated with higher risk of rupture. This is because aneurysm wall could
no longer sustain the arterial pressure due to the degeneration and thinning of the
arterial walls caused by low WSS.[10]
High WSS at the blood flow jet impingement zone is related to the initiation of aneurysms.[10]
[11] After aneurysm initiation, a high WSS causes degeneration of the cellular matrix
and cell apoptosis. While at low WSS, the aneurysm may become larger because inflammation
caused by slow recirculation and a disturbed flow environment promote the formation
of atherosclerotic plaques, which exacerbate the effects on inflammatory cells.[10]
[11]A low WSS may trigger aneurysm rupture. The change in the geometry of an aneurysm
may also be affected by the different types of tissue and/or bone structures neighboring
the aneurysm.
Choice of Imaging
Pre-rupture aneurysm imaging is selected for CFD study as to predict future rupture
because the geometries reconstructed from the rupture arterial images have different
values in CFD parameters.[10] In another study of CFD modelling using cases of ruptured cerebral aneurysm, the
modified Krieger model found that ruptured aneurysms are usually correlated with lower
WSS values than unruptured ones.[12]
Aneurysmal Wall Properties
Wall stress due to the blood flow within a cerebral vessel and the mechanical properties
of the arterial wall are the predominant factors for the rupture of aneurysm.[13] A thin aneurysm sac wall was associated with low WSS, with higher risk of rupture.[14] Between two saccular aneurysm with the same size of dome, the rupture risk is higher
in the one with a larger diameter of the aneurysm neck.[13] Aneurysm rupture occurs when the tissue stress exceeds the tissue strength. The
CFD analyses provide an estimate of the intrasaccular hemodynamics based on rigid
wall of aneurysm sac with no parameter of stress within the aneurysm wall.[8] Newtonian assumption was used in almost 90% of published studies in a meta-analysis
by Saqr et al.[15] However, as too many assumptions are taken into account in the CFD analyses, especially
in blood viscosity using either Newtonian and non-Newtonian CFD Models, more researches
are needed to further characterize the nature of blood flow which contribute to the
improved understanding of the formation and growth of cerebral aneurysms.[16] Nevertheless, CFD models are useful in improving the understanding of these mechanisms,
and highlight the great potential of patient-specific computational models for clinical
use in the assessment of aneurysm rupture risk and patient management.[11] A meta-analysis showed that decreased local WSS may be an important predictive parameter
of intracranial aneurysm rupture.[17] The differences in shape and geometry on aneurysms affect the hemodynamic trends.[18]
The Need to Have Preoperative Planning
The transition from large craniotomies to smaller ones provided a more tailored approach
that minimizes brain exposure while continuing to provide adequate visualization without
marginalizing safety.[19] To achieve this, surgeons must have the ability to create a mental visualization
of the aneurysm with the surrounding structures such as both proximal and distal vessels,
perforators, cranial nerves, veins and brain parenchymal via the selected surgical
approach. With a tailored approach, proximal and distal control, dissection of perforators
and the aneurysm neck, and close and obliterate the aneurysm can be achieved by the
surgeon without minimize risk to the patient.[19] 3D DSA simulation alone or 3D DSA simulation with printed model may be used for
simulation of the best operative approach and selection of the most suitable aneurysm
clips in the preoperative plan.[20]
[21]
[22] However, the limitation of this 3D printed model or 3D DSA simulation images is
the lack of other surrounding brain structures.
Preoperative Three-Dimensional Planning
A proper patient selection and preoperative planning and surgical simulation are indeed
very important. A poor patient selection and proper preoperative planning may result
in surgical mishaps.[23] A complete understanding of the 3D anatomy of the case preoperatively is important.
The knowledge of the location of any perforators or main arterial branch is relative
to the neck and dome of the aneurysm is important especially if located behind the
operative field.[19]
Preoperative simulation with the presence of surrounding brain structures will enable
the surgeon to choose a better head position which will allow the displacement of
the brain after arachnoid dissection. This allows retractorless surgery to be performed.
The placement of retractors can result in ischemia due to microcirculation spasms.[19] The use of an endoscope allows for the final inspection of the anatomy around the
aneurysmal neck before and after clipping in small deep spaces.[19]
Most current commercially available software with virtual reality workstation for
the planning clipping procedures preoperatively, the generated images mainly concerning
the arterial blood vessels and the bone (such as the Dextroscope virtual reality),[1] while the surrounding structures such as cranial nerves, veins and brain parenchymal
are not well constructed. Hence the option to utilize a cheaper option with preoperative
illustration as shown in this paper may be applied.
The surgical outcomes associated with the clipping of ruptured aneurysms are usually
poorer than those seen in unruptured cases.[1] Hence in our institution, early detection and treatment are the goals of the department.
Those patients with symptomatic or asymptomatic but with risk factors such as advanced
age and hypertension should be investigated with magnetic resonance angiogram. The
success rate with no surgical morbidity and minimal morbidity can be achieved with
surgical treatment of unruptured cerebral aneurysm by utilizing a proper preoperative
evaluation and surgical strategies.
Conclusion
It is considered that it will be easier to compare and examine the intraoperative
image by synthesizing and incorporating CFD in the illustration, and we propose it
as one of the clinical utilization methods of CFD.
