Keywords Muscular Dystrophies, Limb-Girdle - Muscular Diseases - Biopsy - Genetics
Palavras-chave Distrofia Muscular do Cíngulo dos Membros - Doenças Musculares - Biópsia - Genética
INTRODUCTION
Limb-girdle muscular dystrophy (LGMD), a group of myopathies with onset after two
years of life that primarily affects skeletal muscle,[1 ]
[2 ]
[3 ]
[4 ]
[5 ]
[6 ]
[7 ] leads to progressive muscle weakness, predominantly involving the shoulder and pelvic
girdles, caused by a loss of muscle fibers;[1 ]
[2 ]
[3 ]
[4 ]
[5 ]
[6 ]
[7 ] it has a heterogeneous genetic etiology, and more than 30 directly-related genes
have been reported.[2 ]
[4 ]
[5 ]
[6 ]
[8 ]
[9 ]
[10 ] Based on the inheritance pattern, LGMD is classified into two major categories:
LGMD-D, with autosomal dominant inheritance, and LGMD-R, with autosomal recessive
inheritance.[2 ]
[3 ]
[4 ]
[5 ]
[6 ]
[7 ]
[10 ] The recessive type (previously named LGMD-2) is the most common worldwide, especially
calpain3-related LGMD-R1 (MIM#11420), dysferlin-related LGMD-R2 (MIM#603009), α-sarcoglycan-related
LGMD-R3 (MIM#600119), β-sarcoglycan-related LGMD-R4 (MIM#600900), γ-sarcoglycan-related
LGMD-R5 (MIM#608896), δ-sarcoglycan-related LGMD-R6 (MIM#601411), fukutin-related
protein (FKRP)-related LGMD-R9 (MIM#606596), and anoctamin-5(ANO5 )-related LGMD-R12 (MIM#608662).[1 ]
[3 ]
[4 ]
[5 ]
[6 ]
[10 ]
[11 ]
[12 ]
[13 ]
[14 ]
The clinical heterogeneity of LGMD is generally associated with high molecular variability.[3 ]
[14 ] The spectrum of clinical, laboratory, and radiological features of the LGMD subtypes
is broad, but symptoms of limb-girdle muscle weakness associated with increased levels
of serum creatine kinase (CK) and fatty substitution of the muscles on magnetic resonance
imaging (MRI) scans can suggest the disease.[4 ]
[5 ]
[6 ] Therefore, the diagnosis of LGMD may be confirmed by muscle biopsy or genetic studies
identifying pathogenic variants in the related genes.[1 ]
[4 ]
[15 ] Besides a rehabilitation program, no treatments for LGMD are currently available,
despite several ongoing clinical trials.[6 ]
[7 ]
[8 ]
[16 ] However, accurate diagnosis of LGMD-R is important for patients and their families,
to provide genetic counselling and efficient and cost-effective use of medical resources.[7 ]
Studies have described the specific clinical, laboratory, radiological, histological,
and genetic features of LGMD-R in series of Brazilian patients.[1 ]
[11 ]
[12 ]
[17 ] The aim of the present study was to analyze a Southern Brazilian cohort with LGMD-R
to contribute to a better characterization of the disease and to evaluate the relative
proportion of the different subtypes.
METHODS
We selected all cases catalogued as LGMD associated with high levels of CK in the
tertiary referral center for neuromuscular disorders at Complexo do Hospital de Clínicas
of Universidade Federal do Paraná (CHC-UFPR, in the city of Curitiba, Brazil) between
2018 and 2019. Subjects with other neuromuscular disorders (such as, myotonic dystrophy,
facioscapulohumeral dystrophy, Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy, among others)
were excluded. A retrospective analysis of the clinical, laboratory, electrophysiological,
radiological and histological features was performed. All studies were conducted in
accordance with ethical principles after obtaining from the patients informed consent
for muscle biopsies and genetic tests in the outpatient clinic or during hospital
admission for diagnostic investigation. The study was approved by the Ethics Committee
of CHC-UFPR.
Clinical evaluation
Relevant data, including age at onset, gender, parental consanguinity, family recurrence,
symptoms, and course of the disease were collected. Muscle strength was measured by
manual muscle testing (and graded from 0 to 5), according to the Medical Research
Council (MRC). Clinical severity at the last appointment was classified according
to the MRC sumscore (MRC-SS),[18 ] which was defined as the sum of scores of the MRC scale for muscle strength from
6 muscles in the upper and lower limbs on both sides, which ranges from 60 (normal
strength) to 0 (complete paralysis).
Laboratory analysis
The highest serum CK level was recorded (normal level: < 168 U/L).
Electrophysiological indings
The needle electromyography (EMG) pattern, performed at the time of the first evaluation,
was classified as normal, myopathic, neurogenic or mixed (myopathic and neurogenic
or ‘neurogenic-like’ findings), according to standard procedures. The motor and sensitive
nerve conduction studies (NCS) were performed according to standard procedures.
Radiological findings
The muscle MRI pattern was classified as normal or dystrophic (characterized by fatty
substitution of the muscles on imaging) according to standard procedures.
Muscle biopsy analysis
Muscle biopsies were performed by open surgical procedure on the vastus lateralis
or biceps brachialis muscles. The muscle biopsy samples were frozen in liquid nitrogen.
Freshly frozen cryostat sections were stained according to standard procedures.[19 ] The muscle specimens were analyzed by morphological study and immunofluorescence/immunohistochemistry
(IF/IHC) for expression analysis, which involved a panel using antibodies against
the C-terminus of dystrophin, the rod domain of dystrophin, the N-terminus of dystrophin,
dysferlin, α-sarcoglycan, β-sarcoglycan, γ-sarcoglycan, δ-sarcoglycan, calpain-3,
and telethonin (commercial antibodies; specification under request). The results of
the IF/IHC were classified according to four grades: total, partial, mosaic or no
apparent deficiency. The muscle biopsies were performed when genetic testing was not
available or was inconclusive, as well as when differential diagnosis with other myopathies
was necessary.
Molecular analysis
We extracted DNA from dried blood spot or blood samples. A targeted next-generation
sequencing (NGS) panel was performed (commercial test; specification under request).
The panel includes the genes ANO5 , CAPN3 , DYSF , FKRP , SGCA , SGCB , SGCD , SGCG , and TCAP , based on the reported disease frequency in Latin America and Brazil.[11 ]
[12 ] The variants (such as pathogenic, probably pathogenic or variant of uncertain significance)
were classified according to the guidelines of the American College of Medical Genetics
and Genomics (ACMG). Sequence variations were compared with data available in the
genetic databases (Human Gene Mutation Database [HGMD], Leiden Muscular Dystrophy
Database, and ClinVar).
RESULTS
The sample population consisted of 36 (19 female and 17 male) patients from unrelated
families aged between 17 and 71 (median: 39; mean ± standard deviation [SD]: 40.14 ± 14.23)
years at disease diagnosis. The age at onset varied between 2 and 59 years, with a
median of 18 years and mean ± SD of 21.66 ± 14.51 years. The disease duration varied
between 3 and 52 (median: 15; mean ± SD: 18.47 ± 11.92) years. [Table 1 ] summarizes the clinical data of the patients with LGMD-R subtypes.
Table 1
Summarized clinical data of the studied patients with autosomal recessive limb-girdle
muscular dystrophy (LGMD-R)
LGMD subtype
R1(2A)
R2 (2B)
R3–5 (2CDE)
R7 (2G)
R9 (2I)
R12 (2L)
Gene
CAPN3
DYSF
SGCA-B-G
TCAP
FKRP
ANO5
Patients (n)
6
6
3
4
3
1
Affected family member (n)*
3
3
3
1
2
0
Sex (male:female)
2:4
1:5
3:0
3:1
1:2
1:0
Age at onset *(years)**
24.16 ± 10.83
25.16 ± 11.61
7.33 ± 4.04
8.75 ± 3.50
24.33 ± 12.89
29
Disease duration (years)**
18.17 ± 11.41
21 ± 9.67
24.67 ± 11.55
14.25 ± 8.61
22.33 ± 26.08
15
Medical Research Council sumscore**
42.66 ± 9.09
40.33 ± 15.16
42.66 ± 11.01
45.75 ± 13.57
47.33 ± 3.05
14
Clinical manifestation
Cramps
Myalgia
Asymmetric weakness
Shoulder weakness
Pelvic weakness
Anterior leg weakness
Posterior leg weakness
Hand weakness
Scapular atrophy
Shoulder atrophy
Scapular winging
Pectoral atrophy
Hip atrophy
Thigh atrophy
Leg atrophy
Calf hypertrophy
Lordosis
Scoliosis
Joint/tendon contractures
Gowers maneuver
Myopathic gait
0
0
0
6
6
0
0
0
5
5
4
1
3
3
0
4
1
0
0
5
5
2
2
1
6
4
4
2
1
4
4
2
0
1
1
0
1
1
0
0
2
2
0
0
1
3
3
0
0
0
0
3
3
1
2
2
1
2
2
0
1
1
1
2
2
1
2
4
2
1
0
2
2
3
0
3
3
2
2
2
1
2
2
1
1
1
0
3
3
0
0
0
2
2
2
0
2
2
0
3
2
1
0
3
2
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
Wheelchair-bound
1
2
2
1
0
1
Cardiac involvement
1
0
1
0
1
0
Respiratory involvement
0
1
0
0
0
0
Previous misdiagnosis of inflammatory myopathy
1
3
0
0
1
1
Maximum level fo creatine kinase (U/L)**
3446.33 ± 4789.74
3736.66 ± 3225.61
20641 ± 29782.19
1176.25 ± 468.20
3727.33 ± 3288.13
517
Needle electromyography (n(
Normal
Myopathic features
Mixed features***
Myotonic discharge
0
6
0
0
1
4
1
1
0
3
0
0
0
4
0
0
0
2
1
1
0
1
0
0
Muscle biopsy features (n)
Type-1 fiber atrophy
Type-2 fiber atrophy
Type-1 fiber predominance
Hypertrophy of type-1 fiber
Hypertrophy of type-2 fiber
Bordeline myopathic changes
Chronic myopathy
Active and chronic myopathy
Myopathy with denervation
Chronic denervation
Lobulated/trabecular fiber
Target (core-like) fiber
Inflammatory infiltration
0
1
1
0
0
0
3
1
1
0
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
2
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
1
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
2
0
1
0
3
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
Genetic analysis (n)
Definitive
Probable****
4
2
4
2
2
1
3
1
3
0
0
1
Notes: *Presence of family member with similar clinical characteristics but without
definitive diagnosis; **mean ± standard deviation if the calculation was allowed;
***concomitance of myopathic and denervation changes (‘neurogenic-like’); ****only
one pathogenic variant (diagnosis supported by other tests, such as histological analyses).
The targeted NGS panel revealed variants in 23 (64%) patients with LGMD, with homozygous
variants in 7 patients and compound heterozygous variants in 9 patients. However,
the same mutations were also found as a single heterozygous variant in 7 patients.
There were 27 different disease-related variants in the ANO5 , CAPN3 , DYSF , FKRP , SGCA , SGCB , SGCG , and TCAP genes ([Table 2 ]). There were different causal variants in different exons of these genes, except
for the TCAP gene, for which all patients carried the p.Gln53* variant, and the FKRP gene, which showed recurrence of the p.Leu276Ile variant. In this cohort, other affected
family members were reported (52%) for almost all subtypes, and parental consanguinity
was reported in 5 patients (28%). Previously, 6 genetically-confirmed patients (26%)
had been misdiagnosed and treated for polymyositis (1 with calpainopathy, 3 with dysferlinopathy,
‘ with dystroglycanopathy, and 1 with anoctaminopathy).
Table 2
Brief summary of the variants found in the studied patients with autosomal recessive
limb-girdle muscular dystrophy (LGMD-R)#
Gene
Status##
DNA variant
Protein
Number of alleles
CAPN3
Pathogenic
c.328C > T
p.Arg110*
1
CAPN3
Pathogenic
c.550del
p.Thr184Argfs*36
1
CAPN3
VUS
c.680C > T
p.Ala227Val
1
CAPN3
Pathogenic
c.759_761delGAA
p.Lys254del
1
CAPN3
Pathogenic
c.1342C > T
p.Arg448Cys
1
CAPN3
VUS
c.1775G > A
p.Arg592Gln
1
CAPN3
Pathogenic
c.2242C > T
p.Arg748*
1
CAPN3
Pathogenic
c.2243G > A
p.Arg748Gln
2
CAPN3
Pathogenic
c.2362_2363delAGinsTCATCT
p.Arg788Serfs*14
1
DYSF
Pathogenic
c.265C > T
p.Arg89*
2
DYSF
Probably pathogenic
c.1163_1165dupCCG
p.Ala388dup
1
DYSF
VUS
c.2801C > T
p.Pro934Leu
1
DYSF
Pathogenic
c.2875C > T
p.Arg959Trp
1
DYSF
Pathogenic
c.2996G > A
p.Trp999*
1
DYSF
Pathogenic
c.3031 + 2T > C
p.(?)
1
DYSF
VUS
c.3280T > C
p.Trp1094Arg
1
DYSF
Pathogenic
c.3805G > T
p.Glu1269*
2
SGCA
VUS
c.350G > A
p.Arg117Gln
1
SGCB
Pathogenic
c.622–2A > G
p.(?)
1
SGCB
Pathogenic
c.341C > T
p.Ser114Phe
1
SGCG
Pathogenic
c.353C > G
p.Ser118*
1
SGCG
VUS
c.195 + 5G > A
p.(?)
1
TCAP
Pathogenic
c.157C > T
p.Gln53*
7
FKRP
Probably pathogenic
c.826C > A
p.Leu276Ile
4
FKRP
Pathogenic
c.898G > A
p.Val300Met
1
FKRP
Pathogenic
c.899T > C
p.Val300Ala
1
ANO5
VUS
c.1747G > A
p.Val583Ile
1
Abbreviation: VUS, variant of uncertain significance.
Notes: # More data about these variants under request (such as population frequency, in silico
prediction, segregation, conservation, among others); ## According ACMD classification.
Calpainopathy (LGMD-R1/LGMD-2A)
In total, six patients were diagnosed with LGMD-R1 ([Table 1 ]). Other affected family members were reported by three patients. Consanguinity was
reported by one patient. Previously, one patient had been misdiagnosed and treated
for polymyositis.
Shoulder and pelvic girdle weakness occurred in all patients ([Table 1 ]). In the upper limbs, scapular and shoulder atrophy occurred in five patients, scapular
wing atrophy, in four patients, and pectoral atrophy, in one patient ([Figure 1 ]). In the lower limbs, hip and thigh atrophy
Figure 1 Clinical findings selected from patients with genetically confirmed LGMD-R. Notes:
(gene: variants): LGMD-R1 (CAPN3 : p.Arg448Cys / p.Arg788Serfs*14); LGMD-R2 (DYSF : p.Trp999* / p.Glu1269*); LGMD-R4 (SGCB : c.622–2A > G[splicing-site] / p.Ser114Phe); LGMD-R7 (TCAP : p.Gln53* / p.Gln53*); and LGMD-R9 (FKRP : p.Leu276Ile / p.Leu276Ile).
occurred in three patients. Calf hypertrophy was observed in four patients ([Figure 1 ]), and one patient had lordosis. Myopathic gait and Gowers maneuver were observed
in five patients, and one patient was wheelchair-bound. Cardiac involvement was found
in one patient who presented left ventricular hypertrophy on electrocardiography (ECG).
The serum CK levels were elevated in all patients, with the highest level between
536 U/L and 13 thousand U/L ([Table 1 ]). The EMG showed myopathic features in all patients, and the NCS showed axonal neuropathy
of the left deep peroneal nerve in one patient and demyelinating neuropathy of the
bilateral median nerve at the carpal tunnel in another patient, and the remaining
patients were normal. Muscle MRI scans were only performed in one patient; they revealed
fatty substitution predominantly involving the posterior thigh muscles of the lower
limbs. Muscle biopsy was performed in all patients, which disclosed type-2 fiber atrophy
associated with type-1 fiber predominance in one patient, concomitant features of
myopathy and denervation in one patient, chronic myopathy in two patients, chronic
myopathy with lobulated muscle fiber in one patient, and active and chronic myopathy
in another patient. The IF/IHC for calpain in muscle tissue was performed, which confirmed
calpain deficiency ([Figure 2 ]). Based on the IF/IHC analysis for other sarcolemmal proteins, there was partial
deficiency of dysferlin in one patient.
Figure 2 Immunohistochemical analysis of sarcomeric (calpain-3 and telethonin) and sarcolemmal
(dysferlin, α-sarcoglycan, β-sarcoglycan, and γ-sarcoglycan) structures showing reduced
pattern of the immunofluorescence stain in muscle biopsies of the patients with confirmed
LGMD-R compared with controls. Abbreviations: A-SCG, α-sarcoglycan; B-SCG, β-sarcoglycan;
G-SCG, γ-sarcoglycan. Note: Bar = 50 µm.
In total, nine different mutations were identified in the CAPN3 gene ([Table 2 ]). Most mutations were found only once; they were homozygous variants in one patient,
and compound heterozygous variants in three patients. A single heterozygous variant
was found in two patients (muscle tissue from both was subjected to IF/IHC; the results
confirmed calpain deficiency). Our cohort with LGMD-R1 had four patients with a definitive diagnosis and two patients with a probable diagnosis ([Table 1 ]), who had one single variant associated with calpain deficiency on the muscle biopsy.
Dysferlinopathy (LGMD-R2/LGMD-2B)
In total, six patients were diagnosed with LGMD-R2 ([Table 1 ]). Other affected family members were reported by three patients. Consanguinity was
reported by two patients. Previously, three patients had been misdiagnosed and treated
for polymyositis.
Cramps occurred in two patients. Two patients had myalgia. In proximal muscles, weakness
occurred in the shoulder girdle in all patients, and in the pelvic girdle in four
patients. In distal muscles, weakness occurred in the anterior leg muscles in four
patients, in the posterior leg muscles in two patients, and in the hand muscles in
one patient. The weakness was asymmetric in one patient. The MRC-SS was between 20
and 59 in these patients ([Table 1 ]). In the upper limbs, scapular and shoulder atrophy occurred in four patients and
scapular wing atrophy occurred in two ([Figure 1 ]) subjects. Atrophy in the lower limbs, hip and thigh occurred in one patient ([Figure 1 ]). Calf hypertrophy was observed in one patient, and another subject had lordosis.
Myopathic gait and Gowers maneuver were observed in two patients. Two subjects were
wheelchair-bound. Respiratory involvement was found in one patient who presented mild
restrictive pulmonary capacity based on spirometry.
The serum CK levels were elevated in all patients, with the highest level between
782 U/L and 9,257 U/L ([Table 1 ]). The EMG was normal in one patient and showed myopathic features in three patients,
myopathic with myotonic discharges in one patient, and myopathic with neurogenic findings
in one patient. The NCS were normal in all patients. Muscle MRI scans were performed
in two patients, which revealed fatty substitution predominantly involving the anterior
and posterior thigh muscles of the lower limbs in both patients. Muscle biopsy was
performed in all patients, which disclosed concomitant features of myopathy and denervation
in two patients, myopathy with trabecular muscle fibers in one patient, inflammatory
myopathy in one patient, and denervation with type-1 atrophy associated with target
(core-like) muscle fibers and chronic denervation in one patient. The IF/IHC analysis
of muscle tissue was performed, which confirmed dysferlin deficiency in all patients
([Figure 2 ]). In two patients, the IF/IHC analysis also revealed partial deficiency of other
sarcolemmal proteins (sarcoglicans and dystrophin).
In total, eight different mutations were identified in the DYSF gene ([Table 2 ]). Most mutations were found only once or twice; they were homozygous variants in
one patient and compound heterozygous variants in three patients. A single heterozygous
variant was found in two patients (muscle from both were subjected to the IF/IHC analysis,
which confirmed dysferlin deficiency). Our cohort of LGMD-R2 had four patients with
a definitive diagnosis and two patients with a probable ([Table 1 ]) diagnosis, and they had one single variant associated with dysferlin deficiency
on muscle biopsy.
Sarcoglycanopathies (LGMD-R3–R5/LGMD-2C-E)
In total, three patients were diagnosed with sarcoglycanopathies: LGMD-R3 (2D), LGMD-R4
(2E) and LGMD-R5 (2C) were identified in one patient each ([Table 1 ]).
The patient with LGMD-R3 was a male in whom the disease had started at 11 years of
age, and he had had the disease for 27 years. Other affected family members were reported.
The weakness reported in the shoulder and pelvic girdle m uscles were mildly asymmetric.
Scapular winging (asymmetric) and shoulder, pectoral (asymmetric), and leg atrophy
were observed. The EMG showed myopathic features. The NCS showed axonal neuropathy
of the right common peroneal nerve. Muscle biopsy revealed atrophy of type-1 muscle
fiber and hypertrophy of type-1 and -2 muscle fibers. The IF/IHC of muscle tissue
revealed partial deficiency in α-sarcoglycan ([Figure 2 ]). A single heterozygous variant was found in the SGCA gene.
The patient with LGMD-R4 was a male in whom the disease had started at 8 years of
age, and he had had the disease for 10 years. Other affected family members were reported.
The weakness was in the shoulder and pelvic girdle muscles. Scapular winging and atrophy
of muscles of the shoulder, pelvic and thigh were observed, as well as lordosis, calf
hypertrophy, and joint and tendon contractures ([Figure 1 ]). Myopathic gait and Gowers maneuver were observed at onset. The patient was wheelchair-bound
most of the time, and had cardiac involvement (heart failure). The EMG showed myopathic
features, and the NCS was normal. Muscle biopsy revealed active and chronic myopathy.
The IF/IHC of muscle tissue revealed deficiency in β- and γ-sarcoglycan ([Figure 2 ]). The variants in the SGCB gene were compound heterozygous.
The patient with LGMD-R5 was a male in whom the disease had started at 3 years of
age, and he had had the disease for 15 years. Other affected family members were reported.
The weakness was in the shoulder and pelvic girdle muscles. Scapular winging and atrophy
of the muscles of the shoulder, pelvis and thigh were observed. Calf hypertrophy and
lordosis were also present. The patient was wheelchair-bound; the EMG showed myopathic
features, the NCS was normal, and muscle biopsy revealed chronic myopathy. The IF/IHC
of muscle tissue revealed deficiency in γ-sarcoglycan ([Figure 2 ]). The variants in the SGCG gene were compound heterozygous.
Among the subjects with LGMD-R3–5, two patients had a definitive diagnosis and one patient had a probable diagnosis (one single variant associated with α-sarcoglycan deficiency on muscle
biopsy; [Table 1 ]).
Telethoninopathy (LGMD-R7/LGMD-2G)
In total, four patients were diagnosed with LGMD-R7 ([Table 1 ]); one patient reported another affected family member, and another reported consanguinity.
Cramps occurred in two patients, and two subjects had myalgia. In the proximal muscles,
weakness occurred in the shoulder girdle in two patients, and in the pelvic girdle
occurred in all patients. In the distal muscles, weakness occurred in the anterior
leg muscles in two patients, and in the posterior leg muscles in one. The weakness
was asymmetric in one patient. The MRC-SS varied between 34 and 58 in these patients
([Table 1 ]). In the upper limbs, scapular winging and shoulder atrophy occurred in two patients
and scapular winging alone occurred in three ([Figure 1 ]). In the lower limbs, hip and thigh atrophy occurred in three participants, and
leg atrophy occurred in two patients ([Figure 1 ]). Calf hypertrophy was observed in two patients. Two patients had lordosis, and
one had scoliosis ([Figure 1 ]). Joint and tendon contractures occurred in two patients. Myopathic gait was observed
in one patient, and Gowers’ maneuver occurred in two patients. One subject was wheelchair-bound.
Serum CK levels were elevated in all patients, with the highest level between 662
U/L and 1,710 U/L ([Table 1 ]). The EMG showed myopathic features in all patients, and the NCS was normal. Muscle
biopsy was performed in every patient, which disclosed chronic myopathy with trabecular
muscle fibers in two patients ([Figure 3 ]), concomitant features of myopathy and denervation associated with trabecular muscle
fibers in one patient, and borderline to myopathic features (muscle fibers with variation
in size and increased acid phosphatase reaction) in one patient. The IF/IHC analysis
on muscle tissue was performed, which confirmed telethonin deficiency in all patients
([Figure 2 ]).
Figure 3 Morphological features of the muscle biopsy showing trabecular (lobulated) fibers
in a patient with LGMD-R7 (nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide dehydrogenase stain).
Note: Bar = 50 µm.
Only one mutation (p.Gln53*) was identified in the TCAP gene ([Table 2 ]); it was a homozygous variant in three patients, and as single heterozygous variant
in one patient. As for LGMD-R7, three patients had a definitive diagnosis, and one patient had a probable diagnosis (one single variant associated with teletonin deficiency on muscle biopsy)
([Table 1 ]).
Fukutin-related proteinopathy (LGMD-R9/LGMD-2I)
In total, three patients were diagnosed with LGMD-R9, which is also named dystroglycanopathy
by fukutin-related proteinopathy ([Table 1 ]). Other affected family members were reported by two patients, and consanguinity
was reported by one patient. Previously, one patient had been misdiagnosed and treated
for polymyositis, and two patients had undergone spinal surgery to correct scoliosis.
Cramps occurred in one patient, and another patient had myalgia. Weakness occurred
in the shoulder and pelvic girdle in all patients. The MRC-SS was between 44 and 50
in these patients ([Table 1 ]). In the upper limbs, scapular winging, as well as scapular and shoulder atrophy,
occurred in two patients ([Figure 1 ]). In the lower limbs, hip and thigh atrophy occurred in two patients ([Figure 1 ]). Calf hypertrophy was observed in all patients ([Figure 1 ]). Two patients had lordosis, and one had scoliosis ([Figure 1 ]). Myopathic gait was observed in two patients, and Gower maneuver occurred in all
patients. One patient had cardiac involvement (myocardiopathy).
The serum CK levels were elevated in all patients, with the highest level between
1,800 U/L and 7,524 U/L ([Table 1 ]). The EMG showed myopathic features in one patient, myopathic features with myotonic
discharges in one patient, and myopathic with neurogenic findings in one patient.
The NCS was normal. Muscle MRI was performed in two patients, which revealed fatty
substitution involving the thigh muscles of the lower limbs (predominantly posterior)
in two patients, and paraspinal muscles in one patient. Muscle biopsy was performed
in all patients, which disclosed active and chronic myopathy in one patient, chronic
denervation in one patient, and atrophy of type-1 and type-2 muscle fibers in one
patient. The IF/IHC of muscle tissue revealed partial deficiency (mosaic pattern)
in dysferlin and dystrophin in one patient.
In total, only three mutations were identified in the FKRP gene ([Table 2 ]); they were homozygous variants in two patients and a compound heterozygous variant
in one patient. All patients with LGMD-R9 had a definitive diagnosis ([Table 1 ]).
Anoctaminopathy (LGMD-R12/LGMD-2L)
One patient was diagnosed with probable ANO5 -related LGMD ([Table 1 ]). The patient was a male in whom the disease had started at 29 years of age, and
he had had it for 15 years. Previously, the patient had been misdiagnosed and treated
for polymyositis. Weakness occurred in the shoulder and pelvic girdle muscles. Shoulder
and thigh atrophy were observed, as well as lordosis The patient was wheelchair-bound;
The EMG showed myopathic features, the NCS was normal, and the muscle biopsy disclosed
atrophy of type-1 fibers with inflammatory endomysial infiltration. The IF/IHC analysis
of muscle tissue showed partial deficiency of dysferlin. A single heterozygous variant
was found in the ANO5 gene. The patient was classified with a probable diagnosis ([Table 1 ]).
Negative group
The targeted NGS panel did not reveal variants related to LGMD in 13 patients (36%)
of the cohort, who were called the negative group : 7 female and 6 male subjects, from unrelated families, aged between 27 and 71 (median:
40; mean ± SD: 43.38 ± 13.69) years at disease diagnosis. The age at onset varied
between 2 and 59 years, with a median of 23 years and mean ± SD of 25 ± 18.46 years.
The disease duration varied between 6 and 43 (median: 12; mean ± SD: 18.38 ± 12.75)
years. The MRC-SS was between 36 and 60 (median: 48; mean ± SD: 46 ± 7.48) in these
patients. The serum CK levels were elevated in 12 patients and normal in 1 patient
(median: 495 U/L; mean ± SD: 2,769.84 ± 3,664.89 U/L).
DISCUSSION
In the present study, there were variations in the prevalence of LGMD subtypes according
to the ethnic background and geographic origin of the subjects, as well as based on
founder mutations.[3 ]
[6 ]
[7 ] In a large American study[8 ] that employed a 35-gene NGS panel and examined patients with clinical suspicion
of LGMD, most subjects had variants in the CAPN3 (17%), DYSF (16%), FKRP (9%), and ANO5 (7%) genes. In 290 participants of the MYO-SEQ project, which is a Europe-wide project
using whole exome sequencing (WES) to diagnose patients with unexplained limb girdle
weakness from over 50 centres, calpainopathy (77 patients) was the most frequently
diagnosed subtype of LGMD, followed by dysferlinopathy (48), anoctaminopathy (31),
titinopathy (25), and sarcoglycanopathy (16 patients).[4 ] In addition, a total of 24 patients of this project were diagnosed with dystroglycanopathies
based on pathogenic variants in 5 of the relevant genes (FKRP , POMT1 , POMT2 , FKTN and GMPPB ).[4 ] A study[15 ] from Italy found the most common groups were calpainopathy (28.4%), followed by
dysferlinopathy (18.7%), sarcoglycanopathies (18.1%), and fukutin-related proteinopathy
(6.4%). Another multicentre study[14 ] confirmed that calpainopathy (30%) and dysferlinopathy (22.6%) are the most frequent
subtypes in Italy, followed by sarcoglycanopathies (21.3%), fukutin-related proteinopathy
(8.7%), and anoctaminopathy (4.2%). In an Australian cohort,[20 ] based on the traditional methods of histopathology and candidate gene sequencing,
calpainopathy was the most common LGMD-R, followed by dysferlinopathy and fukutin-related
proteinopathy, sarcoglycanopathies, anoctaminopathy, and telethoninopathy. However,
even though these cohorts have similarities in the frequencies of the LGMD-R subtypes,
the prevalence of subtypes varies in different countries.[12 ] A cohort from the Netherlands[9 ] was screened by Sanger sequencing; calpainopathy was the most prevalent LGMD-R subtype
(28%), but sarcoglycanopathy occurred in 27% of the patients, anoctaminopathy, in
26%, dysferlinopathy, in 10%, and fukutin-related proteinopathy, in 9% of the patients.
In Northern England,[13 ] calpainopathy was the most common (26.5%), followed by fukutin-related proteinopathy
(19.1%), sarcoglycanopathy (11.7%), and dysferlinopathy (5.9%). In a Danish cohort,[21 ] fukutin-related proteinopathy was the most common (36.8%), followed by sarcoglycanopathy
(22.3%), calpainopathy (11.6%), and dysferlinopathy (1.9%).
Although recent studies that evaluated LGMD genetics reported a Brazilian profile
of LGMD-R, there is great heterogeneity in ethnic backgrounds in Brazil. Hence, the
genetic profile could be quite different among regions.[11 ] In Brazil, calpainopathy and dysferlinopathy are the most frequent subtypes, with
rates between 20% and 30%.[1 ]
[11 ] Sarcoglycanopathies are usually the third most frequent subtype, with rates around
20%.[1 ]
[11 ] Telethoninopathy and fukutin-related proteinopathy have similar rates that vary
between 5% and 10%.[1 ]
[11 ] Anoctaminopathy has also been ‘emerging’ as a frequent subtype of LGMD-R in Brazil,
but with rates around 5%.[11 ]
[22 ] In a recent Latin American study[12 ] which included Brazilian patients, the researchers found different rates of variants,
with dysferlinopathies (39.8%) being the most frequent subtype, followed by calpainopathy
(21%), sarcoglycanopathies (13.5%), anoctaminopathy (8.6%), fukutin-related proteinopathy
(5.2%), and telethoninopathy (3.5%). Even with the small size of the present study,
the frequencies of the most common LGMD-R subtypes reported for our cohort are similar
to the those reported for other Brazilian cohorts, mainly from the Southeast and Midwest
regions.[11 ]
In a previous analysis performed in our center[17 ] (based only on the IF/IHC analysis), sarcoglycanopathies were the most frequent
LGMD-R subtype (32%), followed by dysferlinopathy (14.3%), and calpainopathy (8.9%),
but they occurred in different proportions in the current study. At that time, other
studies in Brazil[23 ]
[24 ]
[25 ] (mainly with patients from the Southeast region) had reported a higher proportion
of sarcoglycanopathies, based on Sanger sequencing and/or IF/IHC analysis, followed
by dysferlinopathy and calpainopathy. After that, patients carrying two pathogenic
mutations were reported with apparently normal IF/IHC (such as calpain and dysferlin),
suggesting that the relative proportion of some subtypes screened through protein
analysis might be underestimated.[1 ]
[13 ]
[15 ]
[26 ] Indeed, the correlation between protein expression based on IF/IHC (and/or western
blot) and the probability of identifying mutations in a specific gene has been reported
to be higher for sarcoglycans and dysferlin than for calpain.[6 ]
[15 ] We speculate that this phenomenon has contributed to the different frequencies of
LGMD-R, which, in the previous studies, had been determined mainly by IF/IHC. In addition,
sarcoglycanopathies have been reported as conditions with onset in childhood, usually
before 10 years of age, and this LGMD-R subtype has been reported mostly in children
(68% of the patients).[2 ]
[9 ]
[10 ] In the present study, the age at onset of sarcoglycanopathies and telethoninopathy
was younger than for other LGMD-R subtypes, which confirms that the onset of these
subtypes usually occurs in childhood. It is also possible that the previous studies
included younger patients, a factor that would justify the different proportions of
LGMD-R subtypes (such as sarcoglycanopathy).
Notwithstanding these diagnostic difficulties, calpainopathy and dysferlinopathy showed
remarkable genetic heterogeneity in our cohort, with nine different mutations in the
CAPN3 gene and eight in the DYSF gene ([Table 2 ]). This genetic heterogeneity for these subtypes has also been observed worldwide.[14 ] Interestingly, 18% of our patients had telethoninopathy, which has been considered
an ultrarare subtype worldwide. The frequency of this subtype in our cohort was higher
than in other Brazilian and international cohorts, including an Italian cohort that
found this subtype in only 0.2% of patients.[8 ]
[11 ]
[12 ]
[14 ]
[23 ] This subtype was first described in Brazilian families that carry the homozygous
p.Gln53* variant in the TCAP gene.[27 ] This was the only variant in our patients with telethoninopathy ([Table 2 ]), a finding that suggests this variant is recurrent in this LGMD-R subtype. Fukutin-related
proteinopathy (LGMD-R9) is the most common of the dystroglycanopathies.[3 ] In the United Kingdom and Denmark, fukutin-related proteinopathy is one of the most
frequent subtypes, with rates between 18% and 38%, whereas in North America, Italy
and the Netherlands, the rate is between 6.7% and 9%.[8 ]
[9 ]
[13 ]
[15 ]
[21 ] This subtype also has lower rates in Brazil.[11 ]
[12 ] In our cohort, the genetic analysis revealed the recurrence of the p.Leu276Ile variant
in the FKRP gene. This variant is the most common mutation for this subtype.[1 ]
[9 ]
[21 ]
[28 ] A recent analysis of clinical and genetic data from the Global FKRP Registry[28 ] has demonstrated that patients with fukutin-related proteinopathy who are homozygous
for the common mutation (p.Leu276Ile) are more likely to have a milder phenotype and
later disease onset than patients who are compound heterozygous for the common mutation,
or who have a mutation other than the common mutation. Based on our cohort, the TCAP and FKRP genes have low allelic heterogeneity (based on the number of unique pathogenic variants).
Anoctaminopathy-related LGMD-R has been reported as the most common phenotype in Brazilian
patients with mutations in the ANO5 gene, with a mild disease compared with other common subtypes, such as calpainopathy,
dysferlinopathy or sarcoglycanopathy.[22 ] Our patient had only a single variant of uncertain significance and was classified
as possibly having anoctaminopathy; however, more studies must be performed to genetically
confirm the anoctaminopathy as the cause of his LGMD phenotype.
The serum CK levels can vary during the course of disease. They are usually more elevated
in the preclinical or initial stages of the disease, and tend to present a gradual
decline according to the progression of the disease, because of the gradual loss of
muscle bulk.[4 ]
[14 ]
[17 ] The CK increase is mild in telethoninopathy (LGMD-R7), but it is generally higher
in others recessive forms.[1 ]
[6 ]
[11 ]
[27 ] This phenomenon occurred in our cohort: although CK levels were increased in all
LGMD-R subtypes, the increase was not as large in the patients with telethoninopathy.
The progressive loss of the muscle fibers results in the generation of short-duration
and small-amplitude motor unit potentials with early recruitment in weak muscles seen
on EMG.[7 ]
[10 ]
[14 ]
[17 ] However, neurogenic motor unit potentials can also be observed in areas with clustering
or fiber hypertrophy, due to motor unit remodelling caused by segmentary necrosis,
which can isolate the distal portions of the muscular fibers from the endplate.[14 ]
[29 ] This might be why ‘neurogenic-like’ motor unit potentials have been described in
calpainopathy, dysferlinopathy, and sarcoglycanopathies.[14 ]
[17 ] In our cohort, myopathic motor unit potentials were found often in all LGMD-R subtypes,
but this feature was concomitant with myotonic discharges or ‘neurogenic-like’ findings
only in some patients with dysferlinopathy and fukutin-related proteinopathy.
The implementation of genetic diagnosis for LGMD has reduced the use of muscle biopsies.
However, muscle biopsy is still performed in the investigation of LGMD when the genetic
analysis is not available, as functional evidence of pathogenicity for novel variants
(usually by IHC for the codified protein) or in the differential diagnosis of other
myopathies. The dystrophic changes observed with muscle biopsy, usually characterized
by variations in the size of the muscle fibers, necrosis/regeneration, and an increase
in the endomysial and perimysial connective tissue, are the landmark of LGMD.[4 ]
[14 ]
[17 ]
[21 ]
[30 ]
[31 ] Although the dystrophic changes do not characterize any specific subtype of LGMD-R,
some features can provide diagnostic clues. The existence of structural alterations
is a nonspecific finding for LGMD-R, but there have been reports[5 ]
[17 ]
[27 ]
[31 ]
[32 ] of the formation of rimmed vacuoles in telethoninopathy and lobulated (trabecular)
fibers mainly in calpainopathy and telethoninopathy, among others. Our patients with
telethoninopathy presented lobulated muscle fibers. Eosinophilic infiltrates, with
or without peripheral blood hypereosinophilia resembling eosinophilic myositis, may
be an early and transient feature in calpainopathy.[5 ]
[6 ] Inflammatory reaction on muscle biopsy can be found in some LGMD-R subtypes (such
as calpainopathy, dysferlinopathy, fukutin-related proteinopathy, and anoctaminopathy),
which contains inflammatory cells and interstitial infiltrates, as observed in our
patients with dysferlinopathy and anoctaminopathy.[3 ]
[5 ]
[6 ]
[14 ]
[31 ]
[32 ]
[33 ] Muscle biopsy may show prominent inflammatory exudates, mimicking an inflammatory
myopathy in dysferlinopathy, or it may demonstrate vasculitis in anoctaminopathy,
which are both LGMDs with defective membrane repair.[5 ] Indeed, the patients with dysferlinopathy and anoctaminopathy in our cohort had
been misdiagnosed and treated for inflammatory myopathy. In LGMD-R, muscle IHC analyses
can be used either as a diagnostic standard or as functional evidence of pathogenicity,
mainly for novel or single variants. The IF/IHC is a useful method to phenotypically
classify patients with LGMD-R.[14 ]
[17 ]
[31 ] Muscle IHC analysis may provide a clear and highly specific result in sarcoglycanopathy,
dysferlinopathy and telethoninopathy.[6 ]
[15 ] In dystroglycanopathies, a secondary reduction of laminin-a2 and the glycosylated
epitope of α-dystroglycan may be observed on the muscle IF/IHC analysis, reflecting
the common pathological feature of these disorders.[6 ] In calpainopathy, western blot analysis with the presence of abnormal calpain can
be useful in the histological diagnosis, mainly in inconclusive cases by IF/IHC or
genetic analysis.[1 ]
[17 ]
[26 ]
[31 ] The western blot analysis can be also helpful in other subtypes, such as dysferlinopathy
and telethoninopathy.[1 ]
[17 ]
[26 ]
[31 ]
The diagnosis of LGMD-R has always been challenging. Besides the traditional methods
(such as Sanger sequencing and muscle IHC), new methods (like the NGS) have been added
to the diagnostic tools. There are several approaches to NGS, including whole genome
sequencing (WGS), WES, and multigene target panels.[10 ] Screening using multigene targeted NGS panels has emerged as the first-line investigation
in patients with LGMD-R, but the success rate in the final diagnosis varies greatly
among populations.[6 ]
[11 ]
[12 ] Although it is difficult to compare the success rate in studies on the diagnosis
of LGMD-R that used targeted NGS panel, some studies have reported rates between 10.8%
and 59.8% in the identification of mutations using targeted NGS panels in cohorts
of patients with LGMD-R.[3 ]
[6 ]
[8 ]
[12 ]
[14 ]
[34 ]
[35 ] That difficulty is due to the difference in the inclusion criteria and/or in the
number of genes included in the panel profile. The 9-gene targeted NGS panel used
in the present study identified variants in 64% of the patients. In comparison, a
Latin American study and an Argentinian study that used a similar targeted NGS panel
identified mutations in 55.8% and 10.8% of the cohort respectively.[12 ]
[34 ]
To date, several distinct mutations that cause LGMD-R have been described in the genes;
they can be found in different databases, such as ExAC, ClinVar, HGMD and LOVD. However,
sometimes the mutant alleles cannot be identified by NGS. Among the 36 patients in
our cohort, 23 had genetically-confirmed LGMD-R, 7 (30%) of whom with only a single
mutation, diagnosed in the CAPN3 , DYSF , SCGA, TCAP , and ANO5 genes. Therefore, even through genetic analysis is the gold standard for the diagnosis
of calpainopathy, previous reports[13 ]
[26 ]
[32 ] have demonstrated that only a single pathogenic mutation is identified in ∼ 10%
to 16% of the patients with calpainopathy, many CAPN3 mutations located in a deep intronic position, for example, that could be missed
during routine gene sequencing. In this situation, other diagnostics tools (such as
multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification[MLPA] and muscle IF/IHC) could be
helpful, especially to identify a second allele defect, when heterozygous variants
were initially detected by NGS analysis and muscle biopsy has dystrophic changes.[6 ] Indeed, in some of our patients with single variants, the diagnosis was also based
on the analysis of protein expression by muscle IHC. The MLPA method has been reported
to help in the work-up of LGMD-R, for screening whole-exon deletions/duplications,
but other genetic methods could be helpful as well, mainly when only a single variant
is found on NGS.[9 ] Our patients with single variants did not undergo other genetic analyses (such as
MLPA). As diagnostic tools for LGMD-R, both protein analysis and genetic tests are
complex and require careful interpretation in light of the clinical findings.
The small size of the cohort has limited the present study. However, some authors
discuss that this is also a strong point, because it represents the real-world frequency
of LGMD-R subtypes in our region, and it contributes to better understand LGMD-R in
Brazil.
In conclusion, these results are of great importance to understand the epidemiology
of LGMD-R in Brazil. The present study has shown that the frequency of LGMD-R subtypes
in Southern Brazil is similar to what has been reported in Southeastern and Midwestern
Brazil as well as North America, it but differs from that found in Latin America and
some European countries.[9 ]
[13 ]