INTRODUCTION
Cerebral oedema per se is not a disease entity. It is a clinico-pathological state that is characterised
by an increase in brain water content (above the normal brain water content of approximately
80%). It usually occurs in response to brain insult which is seen in a variety of
neurological and non-neurological conditions. Cerebral oedema increases brain volume.
Because brain is confined within rigid skull, increase in brain water content ultimately
results in raised intracranial pressure (ICP). Raised ICP decreases cerebral perfusion
pressure leading to cerebral ischemia. In addition, cerebral oedema may result in
brain herniation due to the associated mass effect. Management of cerebral oedema
is a great challenge for both the neurosurgeons and neuroanaesthetists as current
treatment modalities are largely symptomatic. They range from general measures to
osmotherapy, barbiturate coma, steroids and decompressive craniectomy. Though oedema-targeted
therapies are being specifically designed, they remain more or less as experimental
models.
HISTORY
Cerebral oedema and brain oedema both are similar entities. However, brain oedema
is commonly confused with brain swelling. Therefore, Reichardt used the term brain
oedema to differentiate these two pathological conditions.[1] Brain swelling was believed to originate from cerebral vascular engorgement. Pappius
(1974) defined brain oedema as net increase in brain water content which leads to
an increase in tissue volume. Traditionally, cerebral oedema was divided into two
groups by Klatzo.
He used a ‘cold injury’ model to describe the cytotoxic or vasogenic oedema related
to cellular injury or blood brain barrier (BBB) breakdown, respectively.[2] Later, Fishman added third type as ‘interstitial oedema’ which is commonly associated
with hydrocephalus.[3]
CLASSIFICATION
Cerebral oedema can be classified into the following types:
-
Vasogenic oedema
-
Cytotoxic/ionic/cellular oedema
-
Interstitial/hydrocephalic oedema
-
Osmotic/hypostatic oedema
-
Hydrostatic oedema.
Although most of the times brain insult involve an overlap of different types of cerebral
oedema, one type can predominate over other depending on the type and duration of
brain injury.
PATHOPHYSIOLOGY
The pathophysiology of cerebral oedema is complex [Figure 1]. Irrespective of the underlying cause, cascade of events initiate at molecular level
which results in the accumulation of fluid in the brain’s intracellular and extracellular
spaces. There are four fluid compartments in the brain-blood (cerebral vessels), cerebrospinal
fluid (CSF) (ventricular system), interstitial fluid (brain parenchyma) and intracellular
fluid (neurons and glial cells). These compartments are interlinked and under normal
physiological conditions, there is tight control of movement of fluid and solute particles
from one compartment to other.
Figure 1: Depiction of pathophysiological mechanisms of cerebral oedema
Vasogenic oedema
This is the most common form of cerebral oedema and it is primarily due to the breakdown
of BBB secondary to mechanical disruption (brain trauma, acute malignant hypertension,
radiation) or chemical mediators (tumours, inflammation and infection).
BBB consists of endothelial cells, basement membrane and foot processes of astrocytes.
Cerebral endothelial cells have two unique features – presence of tight junctions
along inter endothelial region (which limit movement of plasma protein and compounds
with molecular weight - 60,000 and high) and fewer caveolae (plasmalemmal vesicles
which either by fluid-phase transcytosis or transendothelial channels allow protein
passage).[4] Initially, during BBB injury, there is an increase in caveolae and later tight junction
breakdown followed by endothelial cell injury. During BBB injury, there is an activation
of glial cells. Activated glial cells produce various mediators such as bradykinin,
serotonin, histamine, complement, arachidonic acid, nitric oxide and leucotrienes.
Thus, BBB injury results in the movement of protein rich exudates into extracellular
space.[5] In this type of oedema, white matter is more affected (low cell density, multiple
parallel axonal tracts and loose extracellular fluid) as compared to grey matter (high
cell density and multiple interconnected axonal tracts).
Cytotoxic oedema
This is also known as cellular or ionic oedema where BBB is intact. Basis of cytotoxic
oedema is, ‘Cellular energy failure with disrupted ionic pump with anaerobic metabolism’
which is either due to hypoxia or ischaemia.[6] It is commonly seen after acute arterial infarction and lacunar infarcts. During
cerebral ischaemia, there is cessation of blood flow either complete or partial leading
to disturbance of Na-K-ATPase pump which is responsible for pumping sodium and potassium
into extracellular and intracellular compartment, respectively (3Na+:2K+). To understand the pathogenesis of cytotoxic oedema, various models such as ischaemic
models (focal and global) and water intoxication model have been described.[7] The best among them is the focal ischaemic model, which is being discussed here.
Focal ischaemic model describes cessation of blood flow to brain. When blood flow
decreases to <20 ml/min/100 g, there is failure of ATP dependent ionic pump. Within
seconds of pump failure, Na+ ions get accumulated into intracellular compartment followed by inward water movement
to maintain iso-osmotic state. In addition, Na+ ions are accompanied by inward flow of Ca+, H+, HCO3
− ions and outward flow of K+ ions. These changes are reversible if blood is immediately restored within 3–4 min.
Beyond 6 min of ischaemia, irreversible injury occurs with ischaemic core formation.
Ischaemic core is surrounded by penumbra zone where blood flow if restored within
certain time limits (3 h), then the tissue is potentially salvageable.
Excitatory neurotransmitter glutamate is normally released in the synaptic cleft for
neurotransmission and then immediately removed by energy dependent uptake pathways.
During ischaemia/hypoxia, energy dependent pathways fail and there is accumulation
of glutamate to toxic levels which causes abnormal surge of neuronal activity through
N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA), AMPA, metabotrophic glutamate and high affinity kinate
receptors. Out of all these, most important is NMDA receptor which play central role
in Ca2+ influx into cytoplasm. Persistently activated NMDA receptor causes gradual, slow
but excessive rise in intracellular Ca2 ions. Also, activated AMPA receptors cause Na+ dependent depolarisation and further voltage gated Ca2 entry into cells. Hence, during normal and abnormal neuronal activity, there is cotransport
of 3Na+, 1Cl−, 1H+ and antiport 1K+ ion per glutamate molecule along with water molecule. Normally, ATP-dependent pumps
maintain high concentration of Ca2+ in extracellular space compared to intracellular space. But, during energy depletion,
this mechanism also fails. Excess intracellular Ca2+ causes mitochondrial swelling and further ATP production gets impaired. Thus, vicious
cycle comes into play. Therefore, neuronal and glial cell efforts to maintain ionic
homeostasis ultimately fails resulting in cellular oedema and activation of Ca2+ mediated intracellular secondary cascades and free oxygen radical productions and
arachidonic acid metabolites. Normally, glucose is anaerobically metabolised into
pyruvate and then it enters into Krebs cycle to produce ATPs, but during hypoxia,
pyruvate is converted into lactate. High concentration of lactate further causes neuronal
injury and promotes cellular swelling.[8]
Cellular oedema involves swelling of astrocytes, neurons and dendrites, but astrocytes
are more prone to cytotoxic swelling than neurons (astrocytes are 20 times more in
number and have ability to swell 5 times their normal size).[9]
[10] This oedema fluid is protein-free and contains electrolytes.
Interstitial oedema
This type of oedema is also known as hydrocephalic oedema. During hydrocephalus, intraventricular
pressure increases which cause breakdown of ventricular ependymal lining and hence
transependymal migration of CSF into extracellular space.[11]
[12] Common causes include meningitis, subarachnoid haemorrhage, normal pressure hydrocephalus
and obstructing mass in relation to ventricular outflow. Here, oedema fluid composition
resembles CSF composition.
Osmotic oedema
This type of oedema is characterised by imbalance of osmolality between serum plasma
and brain parenchyma. Here, cellular and BBB integrity is maintained. Conditions which
either decrease serum osmolality or increase brain tissue osmolality will produce
abnormal osmotic pressure gradient with net flow of fluid into the brain parenchyma.
Clinically, most important example is syndrome of in appropriate antidiuretic hormone
(SIADH) secretion where serum hypo-osmolality causes osmotic brain oedema. Other example
is traumatic brain injury (TBI) where necrotic tissue in contused brain is hyper osmolal
and if reperfusion is carried out with isotonic fluid, then it aggravates osmotic
oedema.[13] Here, oedema fluid is rich in electrolytes.
CLINICAL PRESENTATION
Monro-kellie doctrine states that skull is a closed space with fixed volume and whenever
there is increase in one component, brain tries to compensate by decreasing other
component but to limited extent (CSF translocation or decrease in blood volume).[14] Cerebral oedema does not cause clinical features until it reaches to stage where
brain compensatory mechanism fails and rise in ICP occur. Thus, clinical presentation
is secondary to raised ICP, mass effects and cerebral ischemia. Clinical features
are non-specific and have varied presentation. These features may include headache,
projectile vomiting, lethargy, altered level of sensorium, cranial nerve palsies (abducent
nerve palsy-false localising sign), extensor plantar, hypertension, bradycardia, altered
respiratory pattern, ultimately coma and death.
MANAGEMENT OF CEREBRAL OEDEMA
MANAGEMENT OF CEREBRAL OEDEMA
Following cerebral injury, consequences of cerebral oedema lead to unnecessary prolong
hospital stay and add to mortality. Thus, it is imperative to treat cerebral oedema.
Available treatment modalities involve step-wise algorithmic approach. It starts with
general measures (optimal head and neck position, adequate oxygenation and maintenance
of normotension) to specific interventions (short term hyperventilation, use of osmotic
agents, diuretics and corticosteroids). Mannitol and hypertonic saline form the basis
of osmotherapy.[16]
[17] These agents draw fluid into the intravascular space via an osmotic gradient. If
all these measures fail, then last resort is decompressive craniectomy, high dose
barbiturates (cerebral metabolic suppression) and decompressive laparotomy (severe
TBI + inhibitor of apoptosis protein >20 mm Hg). Currently available treatment modalities
either remove oedema fluid by osmotherapy or accommodate oedema fluid by decreasing
cerebral blood volume. None of the available treatment modalities target oedema formation.
With advancement in research field, some targets are identified at molecular level
which helps in the oedema formation.
EXPERIMENTAL THERAPIES FOR CEREBRAL OEDEMA
EXPERIMENTAL THERAPIES FOR CEREBRAL OEDEMA
In the last two decades, lot of emphasis have been placed for the search drugs which
help in the prevention of oedema fluid formation as well as resolution of already
formed oedema. Various mediators involved either in the formation or aggravation of
cerebral oedema are identified. These mediators are arachidonic acid, bradykinins,
Ca2+, glutamate, free oxygen radicals etc. Modulations of some of these mediators were
found useful in the experimental studies but clinically no beneficial effects or unacceptable
side effects were seen. In this section, we will discuss anti-oedema drugs with promising
results in animal studies.
NKCC1 ANTAGONISTS
NKCC1 is an intrinsic membrane protein seen at various sites in central nervous system
(CNS) such as luminal surface of endothelial cells, neurons, glial and choroid plexus.[18] The primary function is transportation of Na+, K+, Cl− ions into cells (1 Na+:1 K+:2 Cl−).[19] To maintain electrical neutrality, Na-K-ATPase pump present on albuminal surface
move sodium into extracellular space. In animal model, it was found that during brain
insult there is upregulation of NKCC1 cotransporter secondary to increased potassium,
glutamate levels (in cortical neurons) and cytokines interleukin-6 (capillaries).
Since it is secondary, active transporter energy is provided by ATP for its smooth
functioning; hence its increased activity is seen during early stages of ischaemia
and during reperfusion phase. Bumetanide is known as high efficacy diuretic which
belongs to sulfamoyl group.[20] Small size molecule of bumetanide and its good lipid solubility confers an ability
to cross BBB. In CNS, it acts as NKCC1 inhibitor at low dose without causing diuresis.[21] Thus, these properties are utilised in various studies to assess its role in the
treatment of various neurological diseases such as trauma,[22] TBI[23]
[24] and stroke (ischaemic/haemorrhagic).[25] Role of another diuretic agent torsemide in decreasing cerebral oedema through NKCC1inhibitor
was also studied.[26]
SULFONYL UREA RECEPTOR 1/TRANSIENT RECEPTOR POTENTIAL MELASTATIN 4 CHANNEL INHIBITORS
SULFONYL UREA RECEPTOR 1/TRANSIENT RECEPTOR POTENTIAL MELASTATIN 4 CHANNEL INHIBITORS
Sulfonyl Urea Receptor 1/Transient Receptor Potential Melastatin 4 (SUR1/TRPM4) is
a non-selective monovalent cation channel with two important features.[27] First, it gets activated when intracellular energy is exhausted and second it needs
intracellular calcium for its opening. Exhausted ATP levels results in the opening
of these channels, sodium influx, membrane depolarisation and cytotoxic oedema formation.
In animal models, it was found that SUR1/TRPM4 channel is normally not present, but
whenever there is ischaemic injury (exhausted ATP levels e.g.: TBI, tumours), they
get transcriptionally upregulated.[28] Also, SUR1 is an important part of ATP sensitive K channels. In type 2 diabetics,
second generation sulfonylurea inhibitors (glibenclamide) are used as oral hypoglycaemic
agents to decrease blood sugar. Glibenclamide act on SUR1 regulatory subunit of ATP
sensitive K channels in pancreas. Therefore, role of these drugs in the inhibition
of cerebral cytotoxic oedema formation has been studied in animal models.[29] In a rat model of malignant stroke, there was 50% decreased cerebral oedema formation
by glibenclamide and improvement in stroke outcome.[30] Hence, inhibition of this channel can offer new treatment modality to decrease and
hence treat cerebral oedema.
VASOPRESSIN RECEPTOR ANTAGONIST
VASOPRESSIN RECEPTOR ANTAGONIST
Various CNS diseases are linked with increased ADH levels. Increased ADH levels in
SIADH causes anti diuresis which result in fluid retention and hyponatraemia. If serum
sodium level is <120 mmol/L, there is a decrease in serum osmolality and thus water
enters into the brain and results in osmotic oedema. SIADH is commonly associated
with aneurysmal subarachnoid haemorrhage where available treatment modalities are
fluid restriction, sodium administration either by enteral salt addition or by hypertonic
saline, fludrocortisone administration.[31] Since each of these therapies have certain drawbacks, for example, fluid restriction
will cause hypovolaemia and hence vasospasm and fludrocortisone causes volume overload
with limited role in hyponatraemia, and hypertonic saline is not useful in hypervolaemic
hyponatraemia. Normally, there are 2 types of vasopressin receptors present in the
body. V1A receptors are present in smooth muscle of vessels while V1B is present in
anterior pituitary. V2 receptors are primarily located in renal collecting ducts.
It promotes free water reabsorption through cyclic adenosine monophosphate pathway.
Conivaptan is a Food and Drug Administration approved vasopressin receptor (V1A/V2)
antagonist drug for euvolaemic hyponatraemia correction.[32] Antagonism of V2 receptors promotes water excretion (aquaresis) from the body without
affecting serum sodium level.[33] It does not cause any change in blood pressure through V1A receptor antagonism.
In various trials, it was found that conivaptan was effective in treating patients
with euvolaemic or hypervolaemic hyponatraemia and raise serum sodium level by 6.3
and 9 mmol/L with daily dose of 40 and 80 mg, respectively, in neurocritical care
units.[34]
[35] Very few studies were conducted in brain injured patients with hyponatraemia where
drug was found useful in raising serum sodium levels and decreasing raised ICP after
single bolus dose.[36]
AQUAPORIN4 INHIBITORS AND ACTIVATORS
AQUAPORIN4 INHIBITORS AND ACTIVATORS
Aquaporins (AQPs) 1, 4, 5 and 9 were found to be located in astrocytes in association
with ependyma, neurons and blood vessels.[37] But among all, AQP4 is most important bidirectional transmembrane water channel
in brain.[38] It acts along with inward rectifying K+ channels at astrocytic foot ends. AQP4 modulators play a crucial role in aggravation/resolution
of cytotoxic and vasogenic brain oedema.[39]
[40] Various AQP4 inhibitors (brain protection in cytotoxic oedema) and activators (facilitate
oedema fluid clearance in vasogenic and hydrocephalic oedema) have been studied in
mice models,[41]
[42] but their role in humans still need further studies.
MATRIX METALLOPROTEINASE INHIBITORS
MATRIX METALLOPROTEINASE INHIBITORS
In various rodent models, during vasogenic oedema, matrix metalloproteinase (MMP)
inhibitors were used and it was found that they restore BBB integrity in early phase,
but not after 48 h. But, they have major drawback that they delayed recovery due to
their role in angiogenesis and neurogenesis.[43]
[44]
VASCULAR ENDOTHELIAL GROWTH FACTOR INHIBITORS AND FACILITATORS
VASCULAR ENDOTHELIAL GROWTH FACTOR INHIBITORS AND FACILITATORS
In ischaemic rodent model, administration of vascular endothelial growth factor-A
(VEGF) inhibitors or recombinant angiopoietin 1 decreased BBB breakdown whereas VEGF-B
facilitators provide protection against BBB breakdown.[45]
[46] Therefore, they may play role in the treatment of vasogenic oedema.
ENDOTHELIN RECEPTOR TYPE B
ENDOTHELIN RECEPTOR TYPE B
Endothelins are vasoconstrictive peptides which exert their action through receptors
- endothelin receptor type A (ETA) and ETB-R. In CNS, ETB-R is present on resting
astrocytes. Stimulation of these receptors activate astrocytes which exert their action
through production of MMP9 and VEGF-A.[47]
[48] In mice model, selective ETB-R antagonists such as BQ788 and IRL-2500 attenuated
cold injury-induced BBB disruption and vasogenic brain oedema.[49]
SUMMARY
Cerebral oedema, irrespective of its type, is potentially devastating consequence
of brain injury with significant morbidity and mortality. The primary brain insult
either alter membrane permeability (BBB and neuroglial) or cause ionic disruption
or both which ultimately result in perturbation of brain fluid homeostasis. Disturbances
in the brain fluid homeostasis result in grave consequences due to rigid bony calvarias.
Treatment of cerebral oedema currently resides in primitive era with only symptomatic
management. In experimental animal models, various mediators and newer ion channels
were found to play significant role in the pathogenesis of cerebral oedema. Pharmacological
modulation of new ion channels and mediators helps in prevention and resolution of
cerebral oedema in animal models. These innovations in research help in understanding
complex molecular mechanism in cerebral oedema formation and provide new horizons
in newer anti-oedema treatment modalities. However, the challenge lies in translating
this advancement from animal models to clinical settings.
Financial support and sponsorship
Nil.
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
