Key-words:
Chiari malformation type I - endoscopic third ventriculostomy - foramen of Magendie
- fourth ventricle outlet obstruction - hydrocephalus
Introduction
Hydrocephalus by the fourth ventricle outlet obstruction (FVOO) associated with a
Chiari malformation type I (CM-I) and syringomyelia is a well-known entity, but a
rare situation in clinical practice.[[1]] FVOO can be congenital or acquired. In adults, the occlusion is acquired rather
than congenital, related to infection, head injury, intraventricular hemorrhage, tumors,
or Chiari malformation.[[2]] Conventionally, this association is treated by suboccipital craniectomy with the
opening of the obstruction membrane.[[3]] However, since the advent of neuroendoscopic techniques, endoscopic third ventriculostomy
(ETV) has been successfully used to treat hydrocephalus as well as CM-I and syringomyelia.[[1]],[[3]],[[4]] We report a case that illustrates the success of neuroendoscopic treatment in this
combination.
Case Report
A 23-year-old male student in the English department at the university presented with
intense headaches, nausea, dizziness, and visual blur that had been gradually developing
over the past 11 months. No specific pathological history was found during the interview.
The patient reported worsening of these symptoms during the past 3 months, with a
significant decrease in visual acuity, forcing him to drop out of school. On admission
to the neurosurgery department, the neurological examination found a conscious cephalalgic
patient, without a neurological sensory-motor deficit. A slight exaggeration of the
osteotendinous reflexes in all four limbs was noted. The fundus objectified a bilateral
papillary edema stage 2.
Cerebral computed tomography scan revealed hydrocephalus with significant dilatation
of all ventricles, including the fourth ventricle, and obliteration of the retrocerebellar
space of the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) [[Figure 1]]a. Complementary craniocervical magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) confirmed tetraventricular
hydrocephalus and showed CM-I and cervical syringomyelia extending to C3 [[Figure 1]]b and [[Figure 1]]c. The interpeduncular and prepontine cisterns were significantly compressed and
reduced in volume by the very large dilatation of the fourth ventricle [[Figure 1]].
Figure 1: Sagittal (a) Computed tomography scan demonstrating dilation of all ventricles. Sagittal
(b and d) T1.weighted, sagittal (c) T2.weighted magnetic resonance imaging showing
dilation of all ventricles, Chiari malformation type I, obliteration of the retrocerebellar
cerebrospinal fluid space, and syringomyelia
Faced with this radio-clinical symptomatology, an emergent endoscopic operation was
planned. A right transventricular approach was used with an entry point located 1
cm anterior to the coronal suture and 3 cm off the midline. Using a 30°rigid endoscope,
a ventriculocisternostomy of the floor of the third ventricle (ETV) was performed.
Perforation was performed in the region of the tuber cinereum with a blunt perforator
and then dilated with the Fogarty balloon. The endoscope was introduced into the prepontine
cistern to check that the procedure was complete. Endoscopic observations of the lateral
ventricle, the third ventricle, and the prepontine cistern did not reveal any abnormalities
suggestive of previous infection or hemorrhage.
The postoperative course was favorable, with a spectacular improvement in clinical
symptomatology and resumption of schooling from the 1st month. The control MRI at
8 months postoperatively showed a virtual disappearance of syringomyelia, the ascension
of the cerebellar tonsils, and the resolution of hydrocephalus [[Figure 2]]. Seen as an outpatient at 11 months postoperatively, the patient was well and had
no neurological disturbance.
Figure 2: Sagittal (a) T1-weighted and Sagittal (b) T2-weighted postoperative magnetic resonance
images showing complete disappearance of Chiari malformation type I and Syringomyelia
with a resolution of hydrocephalus
Discussion
FVOO is a rare but well-established cause of obstructive tetraventricular hydrocephalus.[[5]] Although numerous studies on FVOO have been published, the pathogenic mechanism
of this condition remains unclear. Tetraventricular hydrocephalus by FVOO is usually
either acquired, caused by an inflammatory process, or congenital, caused by abnormalities
of the posterior fossa, such as Dandy–Walker Syndrome, Chiari malformation, and tuberous
sclerosis.[[2]],[[6]],[[7]] In adults, the occlusion is acquired rather than congenital, often related to infection,
head trauma, intraventricular hemorrhage, tumors, or Chiari malformation.[[2]]
FVOO is a rare syndrome that is associated with hydrocephalus and syringomyelia, which
are frequently found in patients with CM-I; such an obstruction is caused by the chronic
tonsillar herniation.[[8]] The mechanisms precipitating the onset of hydrocephalus associated with CM-I in
adults are unknown. Some authors have proposed that meningoencephalitis, infraclinical
inflammation, or even connective tissue proliferation without inflammatory changes
may cause obstruction of the exit of the fourth ventricle.[[1]]
In a combination of CM-I and hydrocephalus by FVOO, the most difficult question is
whether CM-I is the cause or consequence of obstructive hydrocephalus. We know that
hydrocephalus can cause pressure on the cerebellar tonsils causing them to descend
into the foramen magnum. However, overt hydrocephalus is reported in only 7%–10% of
patients with symptomatic CM-I.[[4]] It has been argued that CM-I is primarily a developmental abnormality of the posterior
fossa with subsequent arachnoid adhesions. Therefore, any associated hydrocephalus
may be due to an obstructive phenomenon at the exit of the fourth ventricle CSF pathway.[[9]] Some authors believe that in cases of pronounced dilatation of the fourth ventricle
with an increase in the size of the lateral cavities and no history of inflammation
or hemorrhage, the diagnosis of Luschka's and Magendie's foramina atresia is most
likely.[[2]],[[6]],[[10]],[[11]]
Our case had no known medical history and the endoscopic appearance of the lateral
ventricles and the third ventricle showed no evidence of previous meningitis or hemorrhage.
In addition, the lack of intraoperative endoscopic or macroscopic exploration of the
fourth ventricle exits in our case does not permit to confirm that the hydrocephalus
was primary to the FVOO.
The onset of clinical symptoms in adulthood, as in our case, would be explained by
a late noncompensation of a constitutional “partial” imperforation of the Magendie
foramen which was semi-permeable, obstructing the exit pathways of the CSF. However,
the reason for this evolution remains uncertain.[[7]] Longatti et al. reported ten cases of primary obstruction of the fourth ventricle
outflow. These authors endoscopically revealed a type of primitive stenosis such as
restriction of the Magendie's contour with a thick and opaque membrane, transparent
spiderweb-like membrane, and dense membrane with fissure acting as a valve.[[7]]
Orakdogen et al. reported a series of four patients who all had CM-I, tetraventricular
dilatation, and syringomyelia. All four patients had a membrane obstructing the Magendie
foramen visible intraoperatively after posterior fossa cerebral decompression and
exploration.[[12]]
The treatment of these malformations is still controversial. Different approaches
have been described for the treatment of hydrocephalus due to FVOO, such as ventriculoperitoneal
shunt, ETV, fourth endoscopic ventriculostomy, suboccipital craniectomy with a simple
opening of the obstructing membrane or placement of a catheter to maintain its permeability
to the cisterna magna or the subarachnoid space of the anterolateral superior cervical
spinal cord.[[5]],[[6]]
It is now well established that ETV is the standard treatment for obstructive hydrocephalus.
Although recent studies have suggested that ETV is a less invasive treatment and an
effective strategy for treating hydrocephalus with FVOO.[[7]],[[13]],[[14]],[[15]],[[16]] However, in cases associated with CM-I and syringomyelia, some prefer other options
that focus on decompression of the foramen magnum. Indeed, posterior fossa craniotomy
and membrane excision are still advocated by some.[[12]],[[17]]
Orakdogen et al. suggest that suboccipital craniectomy with the opening of the obstructing
membrane and placement of a catheter is the most physiological approach, restoring
the original pathway of CSF circulation.[[5]],[[12]] However, this technique is far from being minimally invasive. In addition, the
ventriculo-subarachnoid shunt is a foreign material that can be responsible for complications
such as infection and catheter migration.[[10]]
The principle of ETV is essentially to allow the passage of CSF from the ventricular
system to the basal cisterns without the need for the CSF to pass through the fourth
ventricle. Therefore, ETV should be beneficial in the case of hydrocephalus due to
obstruction at the CSF outlet and the foramen magnum region.[[3]] The good issue of our case following ETV suggested that primary hydrocephalus was
the etiology of the CMI. It has been successfully used by several authors and has,
as in our case, solved all pathologies such as CM-I, hydrocephalus, and syringomyelia.[[1]],[[3]],[[4]],[[7]],[[13]],[[14]] In fact, ETV has many advantages. It is a safe physiological procedure and a minimally
invasive technique with a low risk of infection and a low recurrence rate.[[13]] However, some distortions can make it difficult and risky to perform. Among these
distortions is an anteriorly dislodged brain stem making the suprasellar and prepontine
cisterns very narrow and a basilar trunk very close to the floor of the third ventricle.
However in our opinion, inexperienced hands, even under these conditions, ETV is most
often achievable.
Endoscopic foraminoplasty by direct fenestration of the membranous obstruction at
the exit of the fourth ventricle is another reported treatment option.[[5]],[[7]],[[18]]
Although there have been reports of good results with this more demanding technique,
it should be considered only when ETV is difficult or ineffective and should be performed
by experienced neuro-endoscopists.[[16]]
Conclusion
In this case, a pathological association of hydrocephalus by FVOO, CM-I, and syringomyelia
is described in an adult without a pathological history. The effectiveness obtained
in our case suggests that ETV may be sufficient to treat hydrocephalus as well as
CM-I and syringomyelia and could be considered as a first-line treatment in the management
of this entity, pending completion of further randomized control trials.
Declaration of patient consent
The authors certify that they have obtained all appropriate patient consent forms.
In the form, the legal guardian has given his consent for images and other clinical
information to be reported in the journal. The guardian understands that names and
initials will not be published and due efforts will be made to conceal identity, but
anonymity cannot be guaranteed.
