The Ethical Challenges of Providing Fertility Care to Patients with Chronic Illness or Terminal Disease

ABSTRACT

The field of fertility is rapidly evolving, bringing opportunities for improvement in our patients' quality of life as well as bringing new ethical dilemmas. As medical science continues to advance, significant numbers of the reproductive-aged population are living with chronic and/or terminal conditions but have reasonable odds of lengthy survival and wish to have children. Likewise, there are adolescents diagnosed with cancer who are increasingly expected to achieve an improved, if not normal, life expectancy after treatment. Oftentimes these children are told they must sacrifice their ability to later have genetically related offspring; however, technologies to preserve fertility are changing this prognosis. Patients with chronic infection are living longer, more normal lives and are increasingly seeking reproductive assistance. Moreover, there is an increasing number of patients' families desiring posthumous use of gametes, which also raises ethical and legal issues. This article discusses ethical principles of bioethics and then highlights specific ethical issues through four plausible cases that may be seen in a fertility practice providing medical care to patients with chronic illness or terminal disease. It concludes that prompt referral of patients to the reproductive endocrinologist, along with a multidisciplinary approach to care, provides increased chances of successful treatment of this group of patients.

KEYWORDS

Fertility preservation - cancer - infection - transplantation - ethics

REFERENCES

• 1 Reinmuth S, Liebeskind A K, Wickmann L et al. Having children after surviving cancer in childhood or adolescence—results of a Berlin survey.  Klin Padiatr. 2008;  220(3) 159-165
• 2 Chen J L, Philips K A, Kanouse D E, Collins R L, Miu A. Fertility desires and intentions of HIV-positive men and women.  Fam Plann Perspect. 2001;  33(4) 144-152, 165
• 3 Beauchamp T L, Childress J F. Principles of Biomedical Ethics, 6th ed. New York, NY; Oxford University Press 2009: 2-13
• 4 Paasche-Orlow M K, Jacob D M, Hochhauser M, Parker R M. National survey of patients' bill of rights statutes.  J Gen Intern Med. 2009;  24(4) 489-494
• 5 Holm S. Not just autonomy—the principles of American biomedical ethics.  J Med Ethics. 1995;  21(6) 332-338
• 6 Rauprich O. Common morality: comment on Beauchamp and Childress.  Theor Med Bioeth. 2008;  29(1) 43-71
• 7 Voo T C. Editorial comment: the four principles and cultural specification.  Eur J Pediatr. 2009;  168(11) 1389
• 8 Davis R B. The principlism debate: a critical overview.  J Med Philos. 1995;  20(1) 85-105
• 9 Gillon R. Defending “the four principles” approach to biomedical ethics.  J Med Ethics. 1995;  21(6) 323-324
• 10 American Cancer Society .Cancer statistics 2009: a presentation from the American Cancer Society. http://Available at: www.cancer.org/docroot/PRO/content/PRO_1_1_Cancer_Statistics_2009_Presentation.asp Accessed July 12, 2009
• 11 Kaspers G J, Zwaan C M. Pediatric acute myeloid leukemia: towards high-quality cure of all patients.  Haematologica. 2007;  92 519-532
• 12 Jahnukainen K, Ehmcke J, Nurmio M, Schlatt S. Irradiation causes acute and long-term spermatogonial depletion in cultured and xenotransplanted testicular tissue from juvenile nonhuman primates.  Endocrinology. 2007;  148(11) 5541-5548
• 13 Wallace W HB, Anderson R A, Irvine D S. Fertility preservation for young patients with cancer: who is at risk and what can be offered?.  Lancet Oncol. 2005;  6(4) 209-218
• 14 Leiper A D, Grant D B, Chessells J M. Gonadal function after testicular radiation for acute lymphoblastic leukaemia.  Arch Dis Child. 1986;  61(1) 53-56
• 15 Shetty G, Wilson G, Huhteniemi I, Shuttlesworth G A, Reissman T, Meistrich M L. Gonadotropin-releasing hormone analogs stimulate and testosterone inhibits the recovery of spermatogenesis in irradiated rats.  Endocrinology. 2000;  141 1735-1745
• 16 Mitchell R T, Saunders P TK, Sharpe R M, Kelnar C JH, Wallace W HB. Male fertility and strategies for fertility preservation following childhood cancer treatment.  Endocr Dev. 2009;  15 101-134
• 17 Castillo L A, Craft A W, Kernahan J, Evans R G, Aynsley-Green A. Gonadal function after 12-Gy testicular irradiation in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia.  Med Pediatr Oncol. 1990;  18(3) 185-189
• 18 Brougham M FH, Kelnar C JH, Sharpe R M, Wallace W HB. Male fertility following childhood cancer: current concepts and future therapies.  Asian J Androl. 2003;  5(4) 325-337
• 19 Hovatta O, Foudila T, Siegberg R, Johansson K, von Smitten K, Reima I. Pregnancy resulting from intracytoplasmic injection of spermatozoa from a frozen-thawed testicular biopsy specimen.  Hum Reprod. 1996;  11(11) 2472-2473
• 20 Keros V, Hultenby K, Borgström B, Fridström M, Jahnukainen K, Hovatta O. Methods of cryopreservation of testicular tissue with viable spermatogonia in pre-pubertal boys undergoing gonadotoxic cancer treatment.  Hum Reprod. 2007;  22(5) 1384-1395
• 21 Tesarik J. Overcoming maturational arrest by in vitro spermatogenesis: search for the optimal culture system.  Fertil Steril. 2004;  81 1427-1419
• 22 Snedaker A K, Honaramooz A, Dobrinski I. A game of cat and mouse: xenografting of testis tissue from domestic kittens results in complete cat spermatogenesis in a mouse host.  J Androl. 2004;  25(6) 926-930
• 23 Aldhous P. Stem cells. Panacea, or Pandora's box?.  Nature. 2000;  408(6815) 897-898
• 24 Georgiou I, Pardalidis N, Giannakis D et al. In vitro spermatogenesis as a method to bypass pre-meiotic or post-meiotic barriers blocking the spermatogenetic process: genetic and epigenetic implications in assisted reproductive technology.  Andrologia. 2007;  39(5) 159-176
• 25 Deepinder F, Agarwal A. Technical and ethical challenges of fertility preservation in young cancer patients.  Reprod Biomed Online. 2008;  16(6) 784-791
• 26 Lee K J, Havens P L, Sato T T, Hoffman G M, Leuthner S R. Assent for treatment: clinician knowledge, attitudes, and practice.  Pediatrics. 2006;  118(2) 723-730
• 27 Grundy R, Larcher V, Gosden R G et al. Fertility preservation for children treated for cancer (2): ethics of consent for gamete storage and experimentation.  Arch Dis Child. 2001;  84(4) 360-362
• 28 Fujita K, Ohta H, Tsujimura A et al. Transplantation of spermatogonial stem cells isolated from leukemic mice restores fertility without inducing leukemia.  J Clin Invest. 2005;  115(7) 1855-1861
• 29 Georgiou I, Syrrou M, Pardalidis N et al. Genetic and epigenetic risks of intracytoplasmic sperm injection method.  Asian J Androl. 2006;  8(6) 643-673
• 30 Palermo G D, Neri Q V, Takeuchi T, Squires J, Moy F, Rosenwaks Z. Genetic and epigenetic characteristics of ICSI children.  Reprod Biomed Online. 2008;  17(6) 820-833
• 31 Pinborg A, Loft A, Aaris Henningsen A K, Rasmussen S, Nyboe Andersen A. Infant outcome of 957 singletons born after frozen embryo replacement: The Danish National Cohort Study 1995–2006.  Fertil Steril. 2009;  , article in press
• 32 Andersson M, Juel K, Ishikawa Y, Storm H H. Effects of preconceptional radiation on mortality and cancer incidence in the offspring of patients given injections of Thorotrast.  J Natl Cancer Inst. 1994;  86(24) 1866-1867
• 33 Hawkins M M, Draper G J, Smith R A. Cancer among 1,348 offspring of survivors of childhood cancer.  Int J Cancer. 1989;  43(6) 975-978
• 34 Winther J F, Boice Jr J D, Frederiksen K et al. Radiotherapy for childhood cancer and risk for congenital malformations in offspring: a population-based cohort study.  Clin Genet. 2009;  75(1) 50-56
• 35 Nagarajan R, Robison L L. Pregnancy outcomes in survivors of childhood cancer.  J Natl Cancer Inst Monogr. 2005;  34(34) 72-76
• 36 Green D M, Sklar C A, Boice Jr J D et al. Ovarian failure and reproductive outcomes after childhood cancer treatment: results from the Childhood Cancer Survivor Study.  J Clin Oncol. 2009;  27(14) 2374-2381
• 37 Anderson R A, Weddell A, Spoudeas H A et al. Do doctors discuss fertility issues before they treat young patients with cancer?.  Hum Reprod. 2008;  23(10) 2246-2251
• 38 Nieman C L, Kinahan K E, Yount S E et al. Fertility preservation and adolescent cancer patients: lessons from adult survivors of childhood cancer and their parents.  Cancer Treat Res. 2007;  138 201-217
• 39 Tschudin S, Steimann S, Bitzer J et al. Round-table multidisciplinary counselling of couples with HIV prior to assisted reproduction.  Reprod Biomed Online. 2008;  17(2) 167-174
• 40 Barshes N R, Udell I W, Lee T C et al. The natural history of hepatitis C virus in pediatric liver transplant recipients.  Liver Transpl. 2006;  12(7) 1119-1123
• 41 Rinella M E. Pregnancy after liver transplantation.  Ann Hepatol. 2006;  5(3) 212-215
• 42 Scarborough J E, Tuttle-Newhall J E, Pietrobon R et al. Supply and demand for liver transplant surgery: are we training enough surgeons?.  HPB (Oxford). 2008;  10(1) 25-29
• 43 Horslen S, Barr M L, Christensen L L, Ettenger R, Magee J C. Pediatric transplantation in the United States, 1996–2005.  Am J Transplant. 2007;  7(5 Pt 2) 1339-1358
• 44 Bizollon T, Ahmed S NS, Radenne S et al. Long term histological improvement and clearance of intrahepatic hepatitis C virus RNA following sustained response to interferon-ribavirin combination therapy in liver transplanted patients with hepatitis C virus recurrence.  Gut. 2003;  52(2) 283-287
• 45 Mass K, Quint E H, Punch M R, Merion R M. Gynecological and reproductive function after liver transplantation.  Transplantation. 1996;  62(4) 476-479
• 46 Douglas N C, Shah M, Shah M, Sauer M V. Fertility and reproductive disorders in female solid organ transplant recipients.  Semin Perinatol. 2007;  31(6) 332-338
• 47 Armenti V T, Daller J A, Constantinescu S et al. Report from the National Transplantation Pregnancy Registry: outcomes of pregnancy after transplantation [abstract].  Clin Transpl. 2006;  57-70
• 48 Airoldi J, Berghella V. Hepatitis C and pregnancy.  Obstet Gynecol Surv. 2006;  61(10) 666-672
• 49 Englert Y, Moens E, Vannin A S et al. Impaired ovarian stimulation during in vitro fertilization in women who are seropositive for hepatitis C virus and seronegative for human immunodeficiency virus.  Fertil Steril. 2007;  88(3) 607-611
• 50 Englert Y, Lesage B, Van Vooren J P et al. Medically assisted reproduction in the presence of chronic viral diseases.  Hum Reprod Update. 2004;  10(2) 149-162
• 51 Katz-Jaffe M G, McReynolds S, Gardner D K, Schoolcraft W B. The role of proteomics in defining the human embryonic secretome.  Mol Hum Reprod. 2009;  15(5) 271-277
• 52 Steinbock B. Payment for egg donation and surrogacy.  Mt Sinai J Med. 2004;  71(4) 255-265
• 53 Nagy S, Bush M C, Berkowitz R, Fishbein T M, Gomez-Lobo V. Pregnancy outcome in liver transplant recipients.  Obstet Gynecol. 2003;  102(1) 121-128
• 54 Sauer M V. Providing fertility care to those with HIV: time to re-examine healthcare policy.  Am J Bioeth. 2003;  3(1) 33-40
• 55 Vernazza P. HAART improves quality of life: should we care about the quality of spermatozoa?.  AIDS. 2008;  22(5) 647-648
• 56 Dulioust E, Du A L, Costagliola D et al. Semen alterations in HIV-1 infected men.  Hum Reprod. 2002;  17(8) 2112-2118
• 57 Ochsendorf F R. Sexually transmitted infections: impact on male fertility.  Andrologia. 2008;  40(2) 72-75
• 58 Bujan L, Sergerie M, Moinard N et al. Decreased semen volume and spermatozoa motility in HIV-1-infected patients under antiretroviral treatment.  J Androl. 2007;  28(3) 444-452
• 59 Meseguer M, Garrido N, Gimeno C, Remohí J, Simón C, Pellicer A. Comparison of polymerase chain reaction-dependent methods for determining the presence of human immunodeficiency virus and hepatitis C virus in washed sperm.  Fertil Steril. 2002;  78(6) 1199-1202
• 60 Kato S, Hanabusa H, Kaneko S et al. Complete removal of HIV-1 RNA and proviral DNA from semen by the swim-up method: assisted reproduction technique using spermatozoa free from HIV-1.  AIDS. 2006;  20(7) 967-973
• 61 Sauer M V, Wang J G, Douglas N C et al. Providing fertility care to men seropositive for human immunodeficiency virus: reviewing 10 years of experience and 420 consecutive cycles of in vitro fertilization and intracytoplasmic sperm injection.  Fertil Steril. 2009;  91(6) 2455-2460
• 62 Nakhuda G S, Pena J E, Sauer M V. Deaths of HIV-positive men in the context of assisted reproduction: five case studies from a single center.  AIDS Patient Care STDS. 2005;  19(11) 712-718
• 63 Phelps J Y. Restricting access of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-seropositive patients to infertility services: a legal analysis of the rights of reproductive endocrinologists and of HIV-seropositive patients.  Fertil Steril. 2007;  88(6) 1483-1490
• 64 Gershenson D M. Fertility-sparing surgery for malignancies in women.  J Natl Cancer Inst Monogr. 2005;  34(34) 43-47
• 65 Wright J D, Shah M, Mathew L et al. Fertility preservation in young women with epithelial ovarian cancer.  Cancer. 2009;  115(18) 4118-4126
• 66 Winter-Roach B A, Kitchener H C, Dickinson H O. Adjuvant (post-surgery) chemotherapy for early stage epithelial ovarian cancer [review].  Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2009;  8(3) CD004706
• 67 Chan J K, Urban R, Cheung M K et al. Ovarian cancer in younger vs older women: a population-based analysis.  Br J Cancer. 2006;  95(10) 1314-1320
• 68 Duska L R, Chang Y C, Flynn C E et al. Epithelial ovarian carcinoma in the reproductive age group.  Cancer. 1999;  85(12) 2623-2629
• 69 Ayhan A, Celik H, Taskiran C, Bozdag G, Aksu T. Oncologic and reproductive outcome after fertility-saving surgery in ovarian cancer.  Eur J Gynaecol Oncol. 2003;  24(3-4) 223-232
• 70 Schilder J M, Thompson A M, DePriest P D et al. Outcome of reproductive age women with stage IA or IC invasive epithelial ovarian cancer treated with fertility-sparing therapy.  Gynecol Oncol. 2002;  87(1) 1-7
• 71 Benjamin I, Morgan M A, Rubin S C. Occult bilateral involvement in stage I epithelial ovarian cancer.  Gynecol Oncol. 1999;  72(3) 288-291
• 72 Trimbos J B, Vergote I, Bolis G EORTC-ACTION collaborators. European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer-Adjuvant ChemoTherapy in Ovarian Neoplasm et al. Impact of adjuvant chemotherapy and surgical staging in early-stage ovarian carcinoma: European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer-Adjuvant ChemoTherapy in Ovarian Neoplasm trial.  J Natl Cancer Inst. 2003;  95(2) 113-125
• 73 Gurgan T, Salman C, Demirol A. Pregnancy and assisted reproduction techniques in men and women after cancer treatment.  Placenta. 2008;  29(Suppl) S152-S159
• 74 Rosendahl M, Andersen C Y, la Cour Freiesleben N, Juul A, Lossl K, Andersen A N. Dynamics and mechanisms of chemotherapy-induced ovarian follicular depletion in women of fertile age.  Fertil Steril. 2009 March 31;  , [Epub ahead of print]
• 75 Nozaki Y, Furubo E, Matsuno T et al. Collaborative work on evaluation of ovarian toxicity. 6) Two- or four-week repeated-dose studies and fertility study of cisplatin in female rats.  J Toxicol Sci. 2009;  34(Suppl 1) SP73-SP81
• 76 Dudzinski D M. Ethical issues in fertility preservation for adolescent cancer survivors: oocyte and ovarian tissue cryopreservation.  J Pediatr Adolesc Gynecol. 2004;  17(2) 97-102
• 77 Brewer M, Gershenson D M, Herzog C E, Mitchell M F, Silva E G, Wharton J T. Outcome and reproductive function after chemotherapy for ovarian dysgerminoma.  J Clin Oncol. 1999;  17(9) 2670-2675
• 78 Nishio S, Ushijima K, Fukui A et al. Fertility-preserving treatment for patients with malignant germ cell tumors of the ovary.  J Obstet Gynaecol Res. 2006;  32(4) 416-421
• 79 Ayhan A, Bildirici I, Günalp S, Yuce K. Pure dysgerminoma of the ovary: a review of 45 well staged cases.  Eur J Gynaecol Oncol. 2000;  21(1) 98-101
• 80 Tangir J, Zelterman D, Ma W, Schwartz P E. Reproductive function after conservative surgery and chemotherapy for malignant germ cell tumors of the ovary.  Obstet Gynecol. 2003;  101(2) 251-257
• 81 Park J Y, Kim D Y, Suh D S et al. Outcomes of fertility-sparing surgery for invasive epithelial ovarian cancer: oncologic safety and reproductive outcomes.  Gynecol Oncol. 2008;  110(3) 345-353
• 82 Paskulin G A, Gazzola Zen P R, de Camargo Pinto L L, Rosa R, Graziadio C. Combined chemotherapy and teratogenicity.  Birth Defects Res A Clin Mol Teratol. 2005;  73(9) 634-637
• 83 Fey M F, Surbek D. Leukaemia and pregnancy.  Recent Results Cancer Res. 2008;  178 97-110
• 84 Hughes E G, Neal M S. Ovulation suppression to protect against chemotherapy-induced ovarian toxicity: helpful or just hopeful?.  Hum Reprod Update. 2008;  14(6) 541-542
• 85 Oktay K, Sonmezer M. Gonadotropin-releasing hormone analogs in fertility preservation—lack of biological basis?.  Nat Clin Pract Endocrinol Metab. 2008;  4(9) 488-489
• 86 Farthing A. Conserving fertility in the management of gynecologic cancers.  Br J Obstet Gynaecol. 2006;  113(2) 129-134
• 87 Vergote I. Prognostic factors in stage I ovarian carcinoma.  Verh K Acad Geneeskd Belg. 2001;  63(3) 257-271; discussion 272–276
• 88 Trimbos J B, Timmers P. Chemotherapy for early ovarian cancer.  Curr Opin Obstet Gynecol. 2004;  16(1) 43-48
• 89 Oktay K, Sönmezer M. Fertility preservation in gynecologic cancers.  Curr Opin Oncol. 2007;  19(5) 506-511
• 90 Noyes N, Porcu E, Borini A. Over 900 oocyte cryopreservation babies born with no apparent increase in congenital anomalies.  Reprod Biomed Online. 2009;  18(6) 769-776
• 91 Oktay K, Cil A P, Bang H. Efficiency of oocyte cryopreservation: a meta-analysis.  Fertil Steril. 2006;  86(1) 70-80
• 92 Kim S S, Radford J, Harris M et al. Ovarian tissue harvested from lymphoma patients to preserve fertility may be safe for autotransplantation.  Hum Reprod. 2001;  16(10) 2056-2060
• 93 Practice Committee of American Society for Reproductive Medicine . Practice Committee of Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology . Ovarian tissue and oocyte cryopreservation.  Fertil Steril. 2008;  90(5 Suppl) S241-S246
• 94 Menon U, Harper J, Sharma A et al. Views of BRCA gene mutation carriers on preimplantation genetic diagnosis as a reproductive option for hereditary breast and ovarian cancer.  Hum Reprod. 2007;  22(6) 1573-1577
• 95 Ethics Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine . Fertility preservation and reproduction in cancer patients.  Fertil Steril. 2005;  83(6) 1622-1628
• 96 Tu L, He J, Lu G X. Practice and evaluation of ethical governance in assisted reproductive technologies.  J Int Bioethique. 2008;  19(4) 83-93 162-163