Theoretical Considerations on the Health Checkup Accuracy of Combination Testing

Summary

Objectives: To find basic theoretical evidence for an optimum combination of multi-phasic health checkup testing obtained by considering how the health checkup accuracy changes with the number of tests (n) and kinds of combination methods (A, B, C, D and E).

Methods: To find how the health checkup accuracy changes with the number of tests and type of combination method, generalized formulas as functions of the number of tests, are obtained to calculate the over-all health checkup accuracy which is defined by sensitivity ( ), specificity ( ) and odds-ratio ( ), based on the two-by-two table. Five kinds of combination methods were considered: A) Sequential tests. B) Sequential tests after changing the order in A. C) Simultaneous tests using the Believe-the-Negative Rule. D) Simultaneous tests using the Believe-the-Positive Rule. E) Simultaneous tests using the Believe-all-Positive-all-Negative Rule.

Results: It was provend that combination methods A, B and C are “equivalent” for health checkup accuracy. Therefore, the five methods could be summarized into three patterns. For A, B and C:andincreased but a decreased with increasing n. For D:increased butanddecreased with n. For E:,andincreased with n.

Conclusion: Health checkup accuracy of combination testing is the best in case of E, although problems exist concerning how to judge the borderline subjects.

Keywords

Sequential tests - simultaneous tests - health checkup (diagnostic) accuracy

• References

• 1 Lusted L. Clinical decision-making, Decision-making and Medical Care. North-Holland Publishing; 1976
• 2 Shibata S. Relations between Combination Method of Diagnostic Test, and Sensitivity and Specificity. In: 19th JCMI. 1999. 1999. p. 828-9.
• 3 Swets J, Pickett R. Evaluation of Diagnostic Systems. New York: Academic Press; 1982
• 4 Polistar P. Reliability, Decision Rules, and Value of Repeated Tests. Medical Decision Making 1982; 2 (Suppl. 01) 47-69.
• 5 Doubilet P, Cain K. The superiority of sequential over simultaneous testing. Medical Decision Making 1985; 5 (Suppl. 04) 447-51.
• 6 Walter S, Irving L, Glaziou P. Meta Analysis of Diagnostic Tests with Imperfect Reference Standards. J Clin Epidemiol 1999; 52 (Suppl. 10) 943-51.
• 7 Shibata S. Theoretical Considerations on the Health Checkup Accuracy of Combination Testing. In: Abstract of Biennial Conference of the IHEA Taipei 2000. International Health Evaluation Association; 1999. p. 47-48.