A Retrospective Review of Differences in Complication Rates between Dorsal Percutaneous and Mini-Open Surgical Fixation of Scaphoid Fractures

Abstract

Objective We retrospectively reviewed the complications of 80 cases of scaphoid screw fixation in acute fractures and early nonunions comparing dorsal percutaneous and mini-open approaches.

Methods We performed a chart review of all patients who underwent surgical fixation of a scaphoid fracture or a nascent nonunion using a dorsal percutaneous or dorsal mini-open technique by a single surgeon. We collected data on patient demographics, including age and smoking status, time to surgery, fracture type, union, and the major and minor complications that occurred in each group. Fisher's exact tests were used to compare the complication rates between the groups.

Results We identified 80 patients who underwent surgical fixation. Of these, 44 underwent percutaneous fixation and 36 underwent mini-open fixation. All fractures went on to heal. There was a total of five complications identified. There were no major complications in the percutaneous group, but one major complication in the mini-open group (a delayed union that eventually healed at 6 months). There were two minor complications in each group. There was no statistically significant difference in total, major, or minor complication rates between the groups.

Conclusions This study suggests that a dorsal percutaneous surgical technique for scaphoid fracture repair does not affect the complication rate despite prior literature to the contrary. Both techniques analyzed produce excellent rates of union with very low complication rates. Surgeon-specific technique rather than operative approach or exposure may be responsible for previously reported complication rates in the fixation of scaphoid fractures.

Level of Evidence This is a level III, therapeutic study.

Keywords

dorsal percutaneous approach - scaphoid fracture - scaphoid screw - arthroscopy

Publication History

Received: 26 April 2020

Accepted: 04 August 2020

Article published online:
14 September 2020

• References

• 1 Steinmann SP, Adams JE. Scaphoid fractures and nonunions: diagnosis and treatment. J Orthop Sci 2006; 11 (04) 424-431
• 2 Alnaeem H, Aldekhayel S, Kanevsky J, Neel OF. A systematic review and meta-analysis examining the differences between nonsurgical management and percutaneous fixation of minimally and nondisplaced scaphoid fractures. J Hand Surg Am 2016; 41 (12) 1135-1144.e1
• 3 Pinder RM, Brkljac M, Rix L, Muir L, Brewster M. Treatment of scaphoid nonunion: a systematic review of the existing evidence. J Hand Surg Am 2015; 40 (09) 1797-1805.e3
• 4 Ibrahim T, Qureshi A, Sutton AJ, Dias JJ. Surgical versus nonsurgical treatment of acute minimally displaced and undisplaced scaphoid waist fractures: pairwise and network meta-analyses of randomized controlled trials. J Hand Surg Am 2011; 36 (11) 1759-1768.e1
• 5 Li H, Guo W, Guo S, Zhao S, Li R. Surgical versus nonsurgical treatment for scaphoid waist fracture with slight or no displacement: a meta-analysis and systematic review. Medicine (Baltimore) 2018; 97 (48) e13266
• 6 Bushnell BD, McWilliams AD, Messer TM. Complications in dorsal percutaneous cannulated screw fixation of nondisplaced scaphoid waist fractures. J Hand Surg Am 2007; 32 (06) 827-833
• 7 Alshryda S, Shah A, Odak S, Al-Shryda J, Ilango B, Murali SR. Acute fractures of the scaphoid bone: systematic review and meta-analysis. Surgeon 2012; 10 (04) 218-229
• 8 Adamany DC, Mikola EA, Fraser BJ. Percutaneous fixation of the scaphoid through a dorsal approach: an anatomic study. J Hand Surg Am 2008; 33 (03) 327-331
• 9 Bedi A, Jebson PJ, Hayden RJ, Jacobson JA, Martus JE. Internal fixation of acute, nondisplaced scaphoid waist fractures via a limited dorsal approach: an assessment of radiographic and functional outcomes. J Hand Surg Am 2007; 32 (03) 326-333
• 10 Drac P, Cizmar I, Manak P. et al. Comparison of the results and complications of palmar and dorsal miniinvasive approaches in the surgery of scaphoid fractures. A prospective randomized study. Biomed Pap Med Fac Univ Palacky Olomouc Czech Repub 2014; 158 (02) 277-281
• 11 Gürbüz Y, Kayalar M, Bal E, Toros T, Küçük L, Sügün TS. Comparison of dorsal and volar percutaneous screw fixation methods in acute type B scaphoid fractures. Acta Orthop Traumatol Turc 2012; 46 (05) 339-345
• 12 Jeon IH, Micic ID, Oh CW, Park BC, Kim PT. Percutaneous screw fixation for scaphoid fracture: a comparison between the dorsal and the volar approaches. J Hand Surg Am 2009; 34 (02) 228-36.e1
• 13 Slade III JF, Grauer JN, Mahoney JD. Arthroscopic reduction and percutaneous fixation of scaphoid fractures with a novel dorsal technique. Orthop Clin North Am 2001; 32 (02) 247-261
• 14 Slade III JF, Gutow AP, Geissler WB. Percutaneous internal fixation of scaphoid fractures via an arthroscopically assisted dorsal approach. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2002; 84-A (Suppl. 02) 21-36
• 15 DeGeorge Jr BR, Shin AY. Volar approach to percutaneous fixation of acute nondisplaced fractures of the scaphoid. Tech Hand Up Extrem Surg 2019; 23 (01) 6-9
• 16 Evans S, Brantley J, Brady C, Salas C, Mercer D. Structures at risk during volar percutaneous fixation of scaphoid fractures: a Cadaver study. Iowa Orthop J 2015; 35: 119-123
• 17 Geissler WB, Adams JE, Bindra RR, Lanzinger WD, Slutsky DJ. Scaphoid fractures: what's hot, what's not. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2012; 94 (02) 169-181
• 18 Inoue G, Shionoya K. Herbert screw fixation by limited access for acute fractures of the scaphoid. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1997; 79 (03) 418-421
• 19 Yassaee F, Yang SS. Mini-incision fixation of nondisplaced scaphoid fracture nonunions. J Hand Surg Am 2008; 33 (07) 1116-1120