A randomized study of twist drill versus burr hole craniostomy for treatment of chronic subdural hematomas in 100 patients

Abstract

Chronic subdural hematoma (CSDH) has been treated by a variety of surgical approaches like twist drill craniostomy (TDC), burr hole craniostomy (BHC), craniotomy, etc. There are large variations in cure rates and recurrence rates among the surgical options in literature and like all surgical techniques, there is a paucity of well-designed trials to sort out the issue. It is an accepted fact of surgery that the least invasive approach will often be the best approach. We set out with the hypothesis that TDC is as safe and as effective as BHC for CSDH treatment. A prospective randomized controlled trial for 100 patients was done to compare the results of TDC and BHC (both with drain) in patients of unilateral CSDH. Recurrence rate was the primary outcome variable evaluated. A strict clinic-radiological criteria was used to avoid ambiguity in the study. Forty-eight patients underwent TDC and 52 patients underwent BHC. Mortality was 2% (patients in low GCS), and 2% unexpected mortality occurred (unrelated causes). Complication rate was 14% overall and was similar in both groups. Overall outcome (primary and secondary) was comparable across both groups with no significant difference. Cost, invasiveness and duration of surgery was significantly less in the TDC group. The cure rate, recurrence rate, mortality and morbidity of TDC with drain is significantly similar to that of BHC with drain for treatment of defined patients of unilateral sub-acute and chronic subdural hematoma. The cost, duration and invasiveness of TDC surgery is significantly less than that for BHC surgery.

Keywords

burr hole - chronic subdural hematoma - twist drill

• References

• 1 Wilberger J. Pathophysiology of evolution and recurrence of chronic subdural hematoma. Neurosurg Clin N Am 2000; 11: 435-438
• 2 Bozkurt G, Ahyan S, Akbay A, Palaoglu S. Treatment of chronic subdural hematoma by twist drill craniostomy with irrigation. Turkish Neurosurgery 2006; 16: 19-24
• 3 Gastone P, Fabrizia C, Homere M, Francesco C, Alberto M, Nicola D. Chronic subdural hematoma: Results of a homogeneous series of 159 patients operated on by residents. Neurol India 2004; 52: 475-477
• 4 Seçer Hi, Düz B, Kirik A, Solmaz I, Ýzci Y, Gönül E. Chronic subdural hematoma treated by two burr-hole craniostomy and closed- system drainage in elderly patients. J Nervous Sys Surgery 2008; 01: 220-228
• 5 Weigel R, Schmiedek P, Krauss JK. Outcome of contemporary surgery for chronic subdural haematoma: evidence based review. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2003; 74: 937-943
• 6 Sun TFD, Boet R, Poon WS. Non-surgical primary treatment of chronic subdural hematoma: preliminary results of using dexamethasone. Br J Neurosurg 2005; 19: 327-333
• 7 Markwalder TM, Steinsiepe KF, Rohner M, Reichenbach W, Markwalder H. The course of chronic subdural hematomas after burr-hole craniostomy and closed-system drainage. J Neurosurg 1981; 55: 390-396
• 8 Gurunathan J. Treatment of chronic subdural Hematoma with burr hole craniostomy and irrigation. Ind J Nneurotrauma 2005; 02: 127-130
• 9 Camel M, Grubb RL. Treatment of chronic subdural hematoma by twist-drill craniostomy with continuous catheter drainage. J Neurosurg 1986; 65: 183-187
• 10 Cenic A, Bhandari M, Reddy K. Management of chronic subdural hematoma: A national survey and literature review. Canadian J Neurol Sci 2005; 32: 501-506
• 11 Hwang SC, Im SB, Kim BT, Shin WH. Safe entry point for twist-drill craniostomy of a chronic subdural hematoma. J Neurosurg 2009; 110: 1265-1270
• 12 Ibrahim I, Maarrawi J, Jouanneau E, Guenot M, Mertens P, Sindou M. Evacuation of chronic subdural hematomas with the twist-drill technique: Results of a randomized prospective study comparing 48-h and 96-h drainage duration. Neurochirurgie 2010; 56: 23-27
• 13 Ito H, Yamamoto S, Komai T, Mizukoshi H. Role of local hyperfibrinolysis in the etiology of chronic subdural hematoma. J Neurosurg 1976; 45: 26-31
• 14 Jones S, Kafetz K. A prospective study of chronic subdural haematomas in elderly patients. Age and Ageing 1999; 28: 519-521
• 15 Nakajima H, Yasul T, Nishikawa M, Kishi H, Kan M. The role of postoperative patient posture in the recurrence of chronic subdural hematoma: a prospective randomized trial. Surg Neurol 2002; 58: 385-387
• 16 Ahmed S, Agrawal D, Kale SS, Mahapatra AK. A comparative study of treatment of chronic subdural hematoma — burr hole drainage versus continuous closed drainage. Ind J Neurotrauma 2011; 08: 17-24
• 17 Lega BC, Danish SF, Malhotra NR, Sonnad SS, Stein SC. Choosing the best operation for chronic subdural hematoma: a decision analysis. J Neurosurg 2010; 113: 615-621
• 18 Rughani AI, Lin C, Dumont TM, Penar PL, Horgan MA, Tranmer BI. A case comparison study of the subdural evacuating port system in treating chronic subdural hematomas. J Neurosurg 2010; 113: 609-614
• 19 Gokmen M, Sucu HK, Ergin A. Randomized comparative study of burr-hole versus twist drill craniostomy; surgical management of unilateral hemispheric chronic subdural hematomas. Zentralbl Neurochir 2008; 69: 129-133 Epub 2008 Jul 29.
• 20 Horn EM, Feiz-Erfan I, Bristol RE. et al Bedside twist drill craniostomy for chronic subdural hematoma: A comparative study. Surg Neurol 2006; 65: 150-153
• 21 Smely C, Madlinger A, Scheremet R. Chronic subdural Haematoma—a comparison of two different treatment modalities. Acta Neurochir 1997; 139: 818-825
• 22 Mori K, Maeda M. Surgical treatment of chronic subdural hematoma in 500 consecutive cases: clinical charecteristics, surgical outcome, complications, and recurrence rates. Neurol Med Chir (Tokyo) 2001; 41: 371-381