A comparative study of treatment of chronic subdural hematoma — burr hole drainage versus continuous closed drainage

Abstract

The incidence of chronic subdural hematoma (CSDH) is about 5 per 100000 per year in the general population & is higher for those aged 70 years and older. The recurrence rates after the initial drainage procedure range from 5% to 30%, and the treatment strategies for reducing the recurrence rates are the focus of the current research. The aim of this study was to evaluate the results of treatment, especially in terms of recurrence, following surgery for the CSDH obtained with “one time burr-hole drainage” (OTD) vs “continuous closed drainage”, using subdural drain (CD). Patients with diagnosis of CSDH, operated at our center during the period from September 2008 through March 2010 were prospectively studied. The patients randomized to two arms, group 1 underwent OTD and group 2 underwent CD. Patients were analyzed by evaluating their hospital clinical, laboratory and radiological data. Recurrence of CSDH was defined as reappearance of clinical symptoms after a minimum period of one month post surgery, with evidence of CSDH in the same site on plain CT head. Clinical outcome was measured using Glasgow outcome score (GOS). Fifty one patients with chronic subdural hematoma were randomized. OTD was done in 26 patients and 25 patients underwent CD. Males outnumbered the females (45 vs. 6). Age ranged from 17 to 85 years (mean 53 ± 15 years). While 47 patients had GCS of 9–15, remaining 4 (7%) had GCS of 8 or less. Deranged coagulation profile was recorded in 9 patients. Imaging showed 9% patients with bilateral CSDH and in 14% patients had isodense CSDH. Hospital stay ranged from 2 to 24 days (mean 3 ± 4 days). Patients with deficit at admission usually had neurological deficit at discharge. GOS at 6 months was better in continuous drainage group (48% vs 44%) but had more complications. Symptomatic recurrence was noticed in 10 (19%) patients; recurrence was lower in the patients in CD group (n= 4, 16%) than in the OTD group (n= 6, 23%) but this was not statistically significant (p value - 0.60). Our study shows that continuous drainage of chronic subdural hematoma does not offer any advantage over simple burr hole drainage.

Abbreviations

Chronic subdural hematoma (CSDH) - one time burr hole drainage (OTD) - continuous closed drainage (CD)

Keywords

burr hole - chronic subdural hematoma - subdural drain

• References

• 1 Mckissock W, Richardson A, Walsh L. Anterior Communicating Aneurysms: A Trial of Conservative and Surgical Treatment. Lancet 1965; 01: 874-876
• 2 Weigel R, Schmiedek P, Krauss JK. Outcome of contemporary surgery for chronic subdural haematoma: evidence based review. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatr 2003; 74: 937-943
• 3 Santarius T, Kirkpatrick PJ, Ganesan D, Chia HL, Jalloh I, Smielewski P. et al Use of drains versus no drains after burrhole evacuation of chronic subdural haematoma: a randomised controlled trial. Lancet 2009; 374: 1067-1073
• 4 Santarius T, Lawton R, Kirkpatrick PJ, Hutchinson PJ. The management of primary chronic subdural haematoma: a questionnaire survey of practice in the United Kingdom and the Republic of Ireland. Br J Neurosurg 2008; 22: 529-534
• 5 Asano Y, Hasuo M, Takahashi I, Shimosawa S. Surgical outcome of 32 cases in traumatic subdural hygroma. No To Shinkei 1992; 44: 1127-1131
• 6 Lind CRP, Lind CJ, Mee EW. Reduction in the number of repeated operations for the treatment of subacute and chronic subdural hematomas by placement of subdural drains. J Neurosurg 2003; 99: 44-46
• 7 Ramachandran R, Hegde T. Chronic subdural hematomas—causes of morbidity and mortality. Surg Neurol 2007; 67: 367-372
• 8 Tsutsumi K, Maeda K, Iijima A, Usui M, Okada Y, Kirino T. The relationship of preoperative magnetic resonance imaging findings and closed system drainage in the recurrence of chronic subdural hematoma. J Neurosurg 1997; 87: 870-875
• 9 Wakai S, Hashimoto K, Watanabe N, Inoh S, Ochiai C, Nagai M. Efficacy of closed-system drainage in treating chronic subdural hematoma: a prospective comparative study. Neurosurgery 1990; 26: 771-773
• 10 Cenic A, Bhandari M, Reddy K. Management of chronic subdural hematoma: a national survey and literature review. Can J Neurol Sci 2005; 32: 501-506
• 11 Zumofen D, Regli L, Levivier M, Krayenbühl N. Chronic subdural hematomas treated by burr hole trepanation and a subperiostal drainage system. Neurosurgery 2009; 64: 1116-1121
• 12 Markwalder TM, Seiler RW. Chronic subdural hematomas: to drain or not to drain?. Neurosurgery 1985; 16: 185-188
• 13 Kansal R, Nadkarni T, Goel A. Single versus double burr hole drainage of chronic subdural hematomas. A study of 267 cases. J Clin Neurosci 2010; 17: 428-429
• 14 Rughani AI, Holmes CE, Penar PL. A novel association between a chronic subdural hematoma and a fibrinolytic pathway defect: case report. Neurosurgery 2009; 64: E1192
• 15 Suzuki K, Sugita K, Akai T, Takahata T, Sonobe M, Takahashi S. Treatment of chronic subdural hematoma by closed-system drainage without irrigation. Surg Neurol 1998; 50: 231-234
• 16 Nagata K, Asano T, Basugi N, Tango T, Takakura K. Studies on the operative factors affecting the reduction of chronic subdural hematoma, with special reference to the residual air in the hematoma cavity. No Shinkei Geka 1989; 17: 15-20
• 17 Markwalder TM, Steinsiepe KF, Rohner M, Reichenbach W, Markwalder H. The course of chronic subdural hematomas after burr-hole craniostomy and closed-system drainage. J Neurosurg 1981; 55: 390-396
• 18 Frontera JA, de los Reyes K, Gordon E, Gowda A, Grilo C, Egorova N. et al Trend in outcome and financial impact of subdural hemorrhage. Neurocrit Care 2011; 14: 260-266
• 19 Gökmen M, Sucu HK, Ergin A, Gökmen A, Bezircio Lu H. Randomized comparative study of burr-hole craniostomy versus twist drill craniostomy; surgical management of unilateral hemispheric chronic subdural hematomas. Zentralbl. Neurochir 2008; 69: 129-133
• 20 Erol FS, Topsakal C, Faik Ozveren M, Kaplan M, Tiftikci MT. Irrigation vs. closed drainage in the treatment of chronic subdural hematoma. J Clin Neurosci 2005; 12: 261-263
• 21 Lega BC, Danish SF, Malhotra NR, Sonnad SS, Stein SC. Choosing the best operation for chronic subdural hematoma: a decision analysis. J Neurosurg 2010; 113: 615-621