Post-exercise Heart Rate Variability: Whole-body Cryotherapy vs. Contrast Water Therapy

Abstract

High-intensity training sessions are known to alter cardiac autonomic modulation. The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of whole-body cryotherapy, contrast water therapy and passive recovery on the time course of cardiac autonomic markers following a standardized HIT session. Eleven runners completed a high intensity session followed by one of the following recovery interventions: whole-body cryotherapy, contrast water therapy or passive recovery. Changes in cardiac autonomic modulation were assessed in supine and standing positions during an active tilt test at pre-, post-14 h and post-38 h. In supine, high-frequency power increased from pre- to post-14 h following whole-body cryotherapy (1661.1±914.5 vs. 2799.0±948.4 ms², respectively; p=0.023) and contrast water therapy (1906.1±1327.9 vs. 4174.3±2762.9 ms², respectively; p=0.004) whereas high frequency power decreased in response to passive recovery (p=0.009). In standing, low-frequency power increased from pre-to post-38 h (1784.3 ± 953.7 vs. 3339.8±1862.7 ms², respectively; p=0.017) leading to an increase in total power from pre- to post-38 h (1990.8 ± 1089.4 vs. 3606.1±1992.0 ms², respectively; p=0.017). Spectral analysis revealed that contrast water therapy appears to be a more efficient recovery strategy than whole-body cryotherapy in restoring cardiac autonomic homeostasis.

Key words

recovery strategy - cryotherapy - contrast water therapy - cardiac autonomic homeostasis

Publication History

Received: 23 July 2020

Accepted: 12 November 2020

Publication Date:
18 March 2021 (online)

• References

• 1 White GE, Wells GD. Cold-water immersion and other forms of cryotherapy: physiological changes potentially affecting recovery from high-intensity exercise. Extrem Physiol Med 2013; 2: 26
• 2 Hausswirth C, Louis J, Bieuzen F. et al. Effects of whole-body cryotherapy vs. far-infrared vs. passive modalities on recovery from exercise-induced muscle damage in highly-trained runners. PLoS One 2011; 6: e27749
• 3 Machado AF, Ferreira PH, Micheletti JK. et al. Can water temperature and immersion time influence the effect of cold water immersion on muscle soreness? A systematic review and meta-analysis. Sports Med 2016; 46: 503-514
• 4 Ihsan M, Watson G, Abbiss CR. What are the physiological mechanisms for post-exercise cold water immersion in the recovery from prolonged endurance and intermittent exercise?. Sports Med 2016; 46: 1095-1109
• 5 Alba BK, Castellani JW, Charkoudian N. Cold-induced cutaneous vasoconstriction in humans: Function, dysfunction, and the distinctly counterproductive. Exp Physiol 2019; 104: 1202-1214
• 6 Mawhinney C, Low DA, Jones H. et al. Cold-water mediates greater reductions in limb blood flow than whole body cryotherapy. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2017; 49: 1252-1260
• 7 Mourot L, Bouhaddi M, Gandelin E. et al. Cardiovascular autonomic control during short-term thermoneutral and cool head-out immersion. Aviat Space Environ Med 2008; 79: 14-20
• 8 Pump B, Shiraishi M, Gabrielsen A. et al. Cardiovascular effects of static carotid baroreceptor stimulation during water immersion in humans. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 2001; 280: H2607-H2615
• 9 de Oliveira Ottone V, de Castro Magalhães F, de Paula F. et al. The effect of different water immersion temperatures on post-exercise parasympathetic reactivation. PLoS One 2014; 9: e113730
• 10 Stanley J, Buchheit M, Peake JM. The effect of post-exercise hydrotherapy on subsequent exercise performance and heart rate variability. Eur J Appl Physiol 2012; 112: 951-961
• 11 Goldberger JJ, Le FK, Lahiri M. et al. Assessment of parasympathetic reactivation after exercise. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 2006; 290: H2446-H2452
• 12 Schaal K, Le Meur Y, Bieuzen F. et al. Effect of recovery mode on postexercise vagal reactivation in elite synchronized swimmers. Appl Physiol Nutr Metab 2012; 38: 126-133
• 13 Holmes M, Willoughby DS. The effectiveness of whole body cryotherapy compared to cold water immersion: implications for sport and exercise recovery. International Journal of Kinesiology and Sports Science 2016; 4: 32-39
• 14 Higgins TR, Greene DA, Baker MK. Effects of cold water immersion and contrast water therapy for recovery from team sport: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Strength Cond Res 2017; 31: 1443-1460
• 15 Versey NG, Halson SL, Dawson BT. Water immersion recovery for athletes: effect on exercise performance and practical recommendations. Sports Med 2013; 43: 1101-1130
• 16 Cochrane DJ. Alternating hot and cold water immersion for athlete recovery: A review. Phys Ther Sport 2004; 5: 26-32
• 17 Ménétrier A, Mourot L, Degano B. et al. Effects of three postexercice recovery treatments on femoral artery blood flow kinetics. J Sports Med Phys Fitness 2015; 55: 258-266
• 18 Schmitt L, Regnard J, Desmarets M. et al. Fatigue shifts and scatters heart rate variability in elite endurance athletes. PLoS One 2013; 8: e71588
• 19 Schmitt L, Regnard J, Millet GP. Monitoring fatigue status with HRV measures in elite athletes: an avenue beyond RMSSD?. Front Physiol 2015; 6: 343
• 20 Harriss DJ, MacSween A, Atkinson G. Ethical standards in sport and exercise science research: 2020 update. Int J Sports Med 2019; 40: 813-817
• 21 Foster C. Monitoring training in athletes with reference to overtraining syndrome. Med Sci Sports Exerc 1998; 30: 1164-1168
• 22 Singh N, Moneghetti KJ, Christle JW. et al. Heart rate variability: an old metric with new meaning in the era of using mhealth technologies for health and exercise training guidance. part one: physiology and methods. Arrhythm Electrophysiol Rev 2018; 7: 193-198
• 23 Douzi W, Dupuy O, Tanneau M. et al. 3-min whole body cryotherapy/cryostimulation after training in the evening improves sleep quality in physically active men. Eur J Sport Sci 2019; 19: 860-867
• 24 Pichot V, Busso T, Roche F. et al. Autonomic adaptations to intensive and overload training periods: A laboratory study. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2002; 34: 1660-1666
• 25 Stanley J, Peake JM, Buchheit M. Cardiac parasympathetic reactivation following exercise: implications for training prescription. Sports Med 2013; 43: 1259-1277
• 26 Schuitema K, Holm B. The role of different facial areas in eliciting human diving bradycardia. Acta Physiol Scand 1988; 132: 119-120
• 27 Kinoshita T, Nagata S, Baba R. et al. Cold-water face immersion per se elicits cardiac parasympathetic activity. Circ J 2006; 70: 773-776
• 28 Buchheit M. Monitoring training status with HR measures: do all roads lead to Rome?. Front Physiol 2014; 5: 73
• 29 Schmitt L, Regnard J, Parmentier AL. et al. Typology of “fatigue” by heart rate variability analysis in elite nordic-skiers. Int J Sports Med 2015; 36: 999-1007
• 30 Ravé G, Fortrat J-O. Heart rate variability in the standing position reflects training adaptation in professional soccer players. Eur J Appl Physiol 2016; 116: 1575-1582
• 31 Bompa TO, Buzzichelli C. Human Kinetics. Sixth Edition. 2018
• 32 Mann TN, Lamberts RP, Lambert MI. High responders and low responders: factors associated with individual variation in response to standardized training. Sports Med 2014; 44: 1113-1124