Predictive Factors for Vision Recovery after Optic Nerve Decompression for Chronic Compressive Neuropathy: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Abstract

Objectives Surgical optic nerve decompression for chronic compressive neuropathy results in variable success of vision improvement. We sought to determine the effects of various factors using meta-analysis of available literature.

Design Systematic review of MEDLINE databases for the period 1990 to 2010.

Setting Academic research center.

Participants Studies reporting patients with vision loss from chronic compressive neuropathy undergoing surgery.

Main outcome measures Vision outcome reported by each study. Odds ratios (ORs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) for predictor variables were calculated. Overall odds ratios were then calculated for each factor, adjusting for inter study heterogeneity.

Results Seventy-six studies were identified. Factors with a significant odds of improvement were: less severe vision loss (OR 2.31[95% CI = 1.76 to 3.04]), no disc atrophy (OR 2.60 [95% CI = 1.17 to 5.81]), smaller size (OR 1.82 [95% CI = 1.22 to 2.73]), primary tumor resection (not recurrent) (OR 3.08 [95% CI = 1.84 to 5.14]), no cavernous sinus extension (OR 1.88 [95% CI = 1.03 to 3.43]), soft consistency (OR 4.91 [95% CI = 2.27 to 10.63]), presence of arachnoid plane (OR 5.60 [95% CI = 2.08 to 15.07]), and more extensive resection (OR 0.61 [95% CI = 0.4 to 0.93]).

Conclusions Ophthalmologic factors and factors directly related to the lesion are most important in determining vision outcome. The decision to perform optic nerve decompression for vision loss should be made based on careful examination of the patient and realistic discussion regarding the probability of improvement.

Keywords

optic nerve - optic nerve decompression - skull base meningioma - skull base surgery - vision loss

• References

• 1 Reese RG. Successful removal of the orbital portion of the optic nerve for a primary intradural tumor, with preservation of the eyeball and motility, by the Krönlein method. Trans Am Ophthalmol Soc 1920; 18: 238-243
• 2 Sinha S, Sharma BS. Giant pituitary adenomas—an enigma revisited. Microsurgical treatment strategies and outcome in a series of 250 patients. Br J Neurosurg 2010; 24: 31-39
• 3 Tabaee A, Anand VK, Barrón Y , et al. Predictors of short-term outcomes following endoscopic pituitary surgery. Clin Neurol Neurosurg 2009; 111: 119-122
• 4 Schick U, Jung C, Hassler WE. Primary optic nerve sheath meningiomas: a follow-up Study. Cen Eur Neurosurg 2010; 71: 126-133
• 5 Galal A, Faisal A, Al-Werdany M, El Shehaby A, Lotfy T, Moharram H. Determinants of postoperative visual recovery in suprasellar meningiomas. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 2010; 152: 69-77
• 6 Kawamata T, Amano K, Aihara Y, Kubo O, Hori T. Optimal treatment strategy for craniopharyngiomas based on long-term functional outcomes of recent and past treatment modalities. Neurosurg Rev 2010; 33: 71-81
• 7 Jane Jr JA, Kiehna E, Payne SC, Early SV, Laws Jr ER. Early outcomes of endoscopic transsphenoidal surgery for adult craniopharyngiomas. Neurosurg Focus 2010; 28: E9
• 8 Jane Jr JA, Prevedello DM, Alden TD, Laws Jr ER. The transsphenoidal resection of pediatric craniopharyngiomas: a case series. J Neurosurg Pediatr 2010; 5: 49-60
• 9 de Oliveira JG, Borba LA, Rassi-Neto A , et al. Intracranial aneurysms presenting with mass effect over the anterior optic pathways: neurosurgical management and outcomes. Neurosurg Focus 2009; 26: E3
• 10 Raper DM, Besser M. Clinical features, management and recurrence of symptomatic Rathke's cleft cyst. J Clin Neurosci 2009; 16: 385-389
• 11 Sadiq SA, Lim MK, Jones NS. Ophthalmic manifestations of paranasal sinus mucocoeles. Int Ophthalmol 2009; 29: 75-79
• 12 Tan YC, Yu CC, Chang CN, Ma L, Chen YR. Optic nerve compression in craniofacial fibrous dysplasia: the role and indications for decompression. Plast Reconstr Surg 2007; 120: 1957-1962
• 13 Bulters DO, Shenouda E, Evans BT, Mathad N, Lang DA. Visual recovery following optic nerve decompression for chronic compressive neuropathy. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 2009; 151: 325-334
• 14 Miller NR. Predicting visual recovery following optic nerve decompression for chronic optic neuropathy. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 2009; 151: 1729
• 15 Amrith S, Pham T, Chee C, Chan TK. Visual recovery following transethmoidal optic nerve decompression in traumatic optic neuropathy. Ophthalmic Surg 1993; 24: 49-52
• 16 Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG. PRISMA Group. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. PLoS Med 2009; 6: e1000097
• 17 Stroup DF, Berlin JA, Morton SC , et al. Meta-analysis of observational studies in epidemiology: a proposal for reporting. Meta-analysis Of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (MOOSE) group. JAMA 2000; 283: 2008-2012
• 18 Berman NG, Parker RA. Meta-analysis: neither quick nor easy. BMC Med Res Methodol 2002; 2: 10
• 19 Suri A, Narang KS, Sharma BS, Mahapatra AK. Visual outcome after surgery in patients with suprasellar tumors and preoperative blindness. J Neurosurg 2008; 108: 19-25
• 20 Pamir MN, Ozduman K, Belirgen M, Kilic T, Ozek MM. Outcome determinants of pterional surgery for tuberculum sellae meningiomas. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 2005; 147: 1121-1130 , discussion 1130
• 21 Zevgaridis D, Medele RJ, Müller A, Hischa AC, Steiger HJ. Meningiomas of the sellar region presenting with visual impairment: impact of various prognostic factors on surgical outcome in 62 patients. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 2001; 143: 471-476
• 22 Mathiesen T, Kihlström L. Visual outcome of tuberculum sellae meningiomas after extradural optic nerve decompression. Neurosurgery 2006; 59: 570-576 , discussion 570–576
• 23 Nozaki K, Kikuta K, Takagi Y, Mineharu Y, Takahashi JA, Hashimoto N. Effect of early optic canal unroofing on the outcome of visual functions in surgery for meningiomas of the tuberculum sellae and planum sphenoidale. Neurosurgery 2008; 62: 839-844 , discussion 844–846
• 24 Fahlbusch R, Schott W. Pterional surgery of meningiomas of the tuberculum sellae and planum sphenoidale: surgical results with special consideration of ophthalmological and endocrinological outcomes. J Neurosurg 2002; 96: 235-243
• 25 Kim TW, Jung S, Jung TY, Kim IY, Kang SS, Kim SH. Prognostic factors of postoperative visual outcomes in tuberculum sellae meningioma. Br J Neurosurg 2008; 22: 231-234
• 26 Yaşargil MG, Curcic M, Kis M, Siegenthaler G, Teddy PJ, Roth P. Total removal of craniopharyngiomas. Approaches and long-term results in 144 patients. J Neurosurg 1990; 73: 3-11
• 27 Kaptain GJ, Vincent DA, Sheehan JP, Laws Jr ER. Transsphenoidal approaches for the extracapsular resection of midline suprasellar and anterior cranial base lesions. Neurosurgery 2001; 49: 94-100 , discussion 100–101
• 28 de Divitiis E, Cavallo LM, Cappabianca P, Esposito F. Extended endoscopic endonasal transsphenoidal approach for the removal of suprasellar tumors: Part 2. Neurosurgery 2007; 60: 46-58 , discussion 58–59
• 29 Lee JH, Jeun SS, Evans J, Kosmorsky G. Surgical management of clinoidal meningiomas. Neurosurgery 2001; 48: 1012-1019 , discussion 1019–1021
• 30 Park CK, Jung HW, Yang SY, Seol HJ, Paek SH, Kim DG. Surgically treated tuberculum sellae and diaphragm sellae meningiomas: the importance of short-term visual outcome. Neurosurgery 2006; 59: 238-243 , discussion 238–243
• 31 Otani N, Muroi C, Yano H, Khan N, Pangalu A, Yonekawa Y. Surgical management of tuberculum sellae meningioma: role of selective extradural anterior clinoidectomy. Br J Neurosurg 2006; 20: 129-138
• 32 Minamida Y, Mikami T, Hashi K, Houkin K. Surgical management of the recurrence and regrowth of craniopharyngiomas. J Neurosurg 2005; 103: 224-232
• 33 Dehdashti AR, Ganna A, Witterick I, Gentili F. Expanded endoscopic endonasal approach for anterior cranial base and suprasellar lesions: indications and limitations. Neurosurgery 2009; 64: 677-687 , discussion 687–689
• 34 Cui H, Wang Y, Yin YH, Fei ZM, Luo QZ, Jiang JY. Surgical management of anterior clinoidal meningiomas: a 26-case report. Surg Neurol 2007; 68 (Suppl. 02) S6-S10 , discussion S10
• 35 Saeed P, Rootman J, Nugent RA, White VA, Mackenzie IR, Koornneef L. Optic nerve sheath meningiomas. Ophthalmology 2003; 110: 2019-2030
• 36 Li KK, Lucarelli MJ, Bilyk JR, Joseph MP. Optic nerve decompression for compressive neuropathy secondary to neoplasia. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1997; 123: 425-429
• 37 Chicani CF, Miller NR. Visual outcome in surgically treated suprasellar meningiomas. J Neuroophthalmol 2003; 23: 3-10
• 38 Yoon TM, Kim K, Lim SC. Visual outcome after endoscopic decompression surgery for sphenoid sinus disease: how we do it. Clin Otolaryngol 2008; 33: 480-484
• 39 Jallo GI, Benjamin V. Tuberculum sellae meningiomas: microsurgical anatomy and surgical technique. Neurosurgery 2002; 51: 1432-1439 , discussion 1439–1440
• 40 Heran NS, Song JK, Kupersmith MJ , et al. Large ophthalmic segment aneurysms with anterior optic pathway compression: assessment of anatomical and visual outcomes after endosaccular coil therapy. J Neurosurg 2007; 106: 968-975
• 41 Golshani KJ, Lalwani K, Delashaw JB, Selden NR. Modified orbitozygomatic craniotomy for craniopharyngioma resection in children. J Neurosurg Pediatr 2009; 4: 345-352
• 42 Abrams LS, Repka MX. Visual outcome of craniopharyngioma in children. J Pediatr Ophthalmol Strabismus 1997; 34: 223-228
• 43 Yumoto E, Hyodo M, Kawakita S, Aibara R. Effect of sinus surgery on visual disturbance caused by spheno-ethmoid mucoceles. Am J Rhinol 1997; 11: 337-343
• 44 Fatemi N, Dusick JR, de Paiva Neto MA, Malkasian D, Kelly DF. Endonasal versus supraorbital keyhole removal of craniopharyngiomas and tuberculum sellae meningiomas. Neurosurgery 2009; 64 (5) (Suppl. 02) 269-284 , discussion 284–286
• 45 Kitano M, Taneda M, Nakao Y. Postoperative improvement in visual function in patients with tuberculum sellae meningiomas: results of the extended transsphenoidal and transcranial approaches. J Neurosurg 2007; 107: 337-346
• 46 Russell SM, Benjamin V. Medial sphenoid ridge meningiomas: classification, microsurgical anatomy, operative nuances, and long-term surgical outcome in 35 consecutive patients. Neurosurgery 2008; 62 (3) (Suppl. 01) 38-50 , discussion 50
• 47 Leu CH, Hu TL, Shen CC, Wang YC. Tuberculum sellae meningiomas: clinical manifestation, radiologic diagnosis, surgery and visual outcome. Zhonghua Yi Xue Za Zhi (Taipei) 1998; 61: 1-7
• 48 Schick U, Hassler W. Surgical management of tuberculum sellae meningiomas: involvement of the optic canal and visual outcome. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2005; 76: 977-983
• 49 Margalit NS, Lesser JB, Moche J, Sen C. Meningiomas involving the optic nerve: technical aspects and outcomes for a series of 50 patients. Neurosurgery 2003; 53: 523-532 , discussion 532–533
• 50 Jacob M, Raverot G, Jouanneau E , et al. Predicting visual outcome after treatment of pituitary adenomas with optical coherence tomography. Am J Ophthalmol 2009; 147: 64-70 , e2
• 51 Sullivan LJ, O'Day J, McNeill P. Visual outcomes of pituitary adenoma surgery. St. Vincent's Hospital 1968-1987. J Clin Neuroophthalmol 1991; 11: 262-267
• 52 Marcus M, Vitale S, Calvert PC, Miller NR. Visual parameters in patients with pituitary adenoma before and after transsphenoidal surgery. Aust N Z J Ophthalmol 1991; 19: 111-118
• 53 Weiner HL, Wisoff JH, Rosenberg ME , et al. Craniopharyngiomas: a clinicopathological analysis of factors predictive of recurrence and functional outcome. Neurosurgery 1994; 35: 1001-1010 , discussion 1010–1011
• 54 Schaller B. Gender-related differences in non-functioning pituitary adenomas. Neuroendocrinol Lett 2003; 24: 425-430
• 55 Ganna A, Dehdashti AR, Karabatsou K, Gentili F. Fronto-basal interhemispheric approach for tuberculum sellae meningiomas; long-term visual outcome. Br J Neurosurg 2009; 23: 422-430
• 56 Nakamura M, Roser F, Jacobs C, Vorkapic P, Samii M. Medial sphenoid wing meningiomas: clinical outcome and recurrence rate. Neurosurgery 2006; 58: 626-639 , discussion 626–639
• 57 Nakamura M, Roser F, Struck M, Vorkapic P, Samii M. Tuberculum sellae meningiomas: clinical outcome considering different surgical approaches. Neurosurgery 2006; 59: 1019-1028 , discussion 1028–1029
• 58 Jen SL, Lee LS. Suprasellar meningiomas: analysis of 32 cases. Zhonghua Yi Xue Za Zhi (Taipei) 1997; 59: 7-14
• 59 Goel A, Muzumdar D, Desai KI. Tuberculum sellae meningioma: a report on management on the basis of a surgical experience with 70 patients. Neurosurgery 2002; 51: 1358-1363 , discussion 1363–1364
• 60 Zuccaro G. Radical resection of craniopharyngioma. Childs Nerv Syst 2005; 21 (8-9) 679-690
• 61 Villani RM, Tomei G, Bello L , et al. Long-term results of treatment for craniopharyngioma in children. Childs Nerv Syst 1997; 13: 397-405
• 62 el-Mahdy W, Powell M. Transsphenoidal management of 28 symptomatic Rathke's cleft cysts, with special reference to visual and hormonal recovery. Neurosurgery 1998; 42: 7-16 , discussion 16–17
• 63 Puchner MJ, Fischer-Lampsatis RC, Herrmann HD, Freckmann N. Suprasellar meningiomas—neurological and visual outcome at long-term follow-up in a homogeneous series of patients treated microsurgically. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 1998; 140: 1231-1238
• 64 Cristante L. Surgical treatment of meningiomas of the orbit and optic canal: a retrospective study with particular attention to the visual outcome. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 1994; 126: 27-32
• 65 Petruson B, Jakobsson KE, Elfverson J, Bengtsson BA. Five-year follow-up of nonsecreting pituitary adenomas. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1995; 121: 317-322
• 66 Peter M, De Tribolet N. Visual outcome after transsphenoidal surgery for pituitary adenomas. Br J Neurosurg 1995; 9: 151-157
• 67 Suharwardy J, Elston J. The clinical presentation of children with tumours affecting the anterior visual pathways. Eye (Lond) 1997; 11 (Pt 6) 838-844
• 68 Rüther K, Ehlich P, Philipp A, Eckstein A, Zrenner E. Prognostic value of the pattern electroretinogram in cases of tumors affecting the optic pathway. Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol 1998; 236: 259-263
• 69 Chacko AG, Babu KS, Chandy MJ. Value of visual evoked potential monitoring during trans-sphenoidal pituitary surgery. Br J Neurosurg 1996; 10: 275-278
• 70 Parmar DN, Sofat A, Bowman R, Bartlett JR, Holder GE. Visual prognostic value of the pattern electroretinogram in chiasmal compression. Br J Ophthalmol 2000; 84: 1024-1026
• 71 el-Azouzi M, Black PM, Candia G, Zervas NT, Panagopoulos KP. Transsphenoidal surgery for visual loss in patients with pituitary adenomas. Neurol Res 1990; 12: 23-25
• 72 Danesh-Meyer HV, Papchenko T, Savino PJ, Law A, Evans J, Gamble GD. In vivo retinal nerve fiber layer thickness measured by optical coherence tomography predicts visual recovery after surgery for parachiasmal tumors. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2008; 49: 1879-1885
• 73 Arai H, Sato K Okuda, et al. Transcranial transsphenoidal approach for tuberculum sellae meningiomas. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 2000; 142: 751-756 , discussion 756–757
• 74 Chi JH, Parsa AT, Berger MS, Kunwar S, McDermott MW. Extended bifrontal craniotomy for midline anterior fossa meningiomas: minimization of retraction-related edema and surgical outcomes. Neurosurgery 2006; 59 (4) (Suppl. 02) ONS426-ONS433 , discussion ONS433–ONS434
• 75 Raco A, Bristot R, Domenicucci M, Cantore G. Meningiomas of the tuberculum sellae. Our experience in 69 cases surgically treated between 1973 and 1993. J Neurosurg Sci 1999; 43: 253-260 , discussion 260–262
• 76 Hudson H, Rissell C, Gauderman WJ, Feldon SE. Pituitary tumor volume as a predictor of postoperative visual field recovery. Quantitative analysis using automated static perimetry and computed tomography morphometry. J Clin Neuroophthalmol 1991; 11: 280-283
• 77 Elliott RE, Hsieh K, Hochm T, Belitskaya-Levy I, Wisoff J, Wisoff JH. Efficacy and safety of radical resection of primary and recurrent craniopharyngiomas in 86 children. J Neurosurg Pediatr 2010; 5: 30-48
• 78 Dolenc VV. Transcranial epidural approach to pituitary tumors extending beyond the sella. Neurosurgery 1997; 41: 542-550 , discussion 551–552
• 79 Goel A, Nadkarni T, Muzumdar D, Desai K, Phalke U, Sharma P. Giant pituitary tumors: a study based on surgical treatment of 118 cases. Surg Neurol 2004; 61: 436-445 , discussion 445–446
• 80 Sade B, Lee JH. High incidence of optic canal involvement in clinoidal meningiomas: rationale for aggressive skull base approach. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 2008; 150: 1127-1132 , discussion 1132
• 81 Sade B, Lee JH. High incidence of optic canal involvement in tuberculum sellae meningiomas: rationale for aggressive skull base approach. Surg Neurol 2009; 72: 118-123 , discussion 123
• 82 Mehrazin M, Mirfalah R. Early post operative visual outcome in microsurgically treated suprasellar meningiomas predict long-term visual outcome. Turk Neurosurg 2008; 18: 380-386
• 83 Chakrabarti I, Amar AP, Couldwell W, Weiss MH. Long-term neurological, visual, and endocrine outcomes following transnasal resection of craniopharyngioma. J Neurosurg 2005; 102: 650-657
• 84 Fahlbusch R, Honegger J, Paulus W, Huk W, Buchfelder M. Surgical treatment of craniopharyngiomas: experience with 168 patients. J Neurosurg 1999; 90: 237-250
• 85 de Divitiis E, Esposito F, Cappabianca P, Cavallo LM, de Divitiis O. Tuberculum sellae meningiomas: high route or low route? A series of 51 consecutive cases. Neurosurgery 2008; 62: 556-563 , discussion 556–563
• 86 Sleep TJ, Hodgkins PR, Honeybul S, Neil-Dwyer G, Lang D, Evans B. Visual function following neurosurgical optic nerve decompression for compressive optic neuropathy. Eye (Lond) 2003; 17: 571-578
• 87 Bateman BT, Pile-Spellman J, Gutin PH, Berman MF. Meningioma resection in the elderly: nationwide inpatient sample, 1998-2002. Neurosurgery 2005; 57: 866-872 , discussion 866–872