Integration of Homeopathy and Complementary Medicine in the Tuscan Public Health System and the Experience of the Homeopathic Clinic of the Lucca Hospital

Abstract

Introduction The healthcare programs of the Region of Tuscany (Italy) have started the process of integration of some types of complementary medicine (CM), including homeopathy, which began in 1996. The Homeopathic Clinic of Lucca was opened in 1998, followed by the Homeopathic Clinic for Women in 2003, and the Clinic for CM and Diet in Oncology in 2013.

Methods Observational longitudinal studies conducted on 5,877 patients (3,937 in the general clinic, 1,606 in the women's clinic and 334 in oncology) were consecutively examined from 2003 to 2016. The Outcome in Relation to Impact on Daily Living (ORIDL) was generally used to assess outcomes.

Results Comparing the clinical conditions before and after homeopathic treatment, improvement was observed in 88.8% of general medicine patients with follow-up (45.1%); in particular, 68.1% of the patients had a major improvement in or resolution (ORIDL +2, +3, +4) of their condition. In women, an improvement was obtained in 74.1% cases and a major improvement in 61.2%. In cancer patients with homeopathic and integrative treatment, a significant improvement was observed for all the symptoms during anti-cancer therapy, particularly for hot flashes, nausea, depression, asthenia, and anxiety.

Conclusions These results suggest that homeopathy can effectively be integrated with allopathic medicine and that the Tuscan experience could provide a useful reference for developing national and European regulations on the use of CM and homeopathy in public healthcare.

Keywords

homeopathy - complementary and integrative medicine - public healthcare - Tuscan regional experience - public homeopathic clinic

• References

• 1 Rossi E, Baccetti S, Firenzuoli F, Belvedere K. Homeopathy and complementary medicine in Tuscany, Italy: integration in the public health system. Homeopathy 2008; 97 (02) 70-75
• 2 Conferenza permanente per i rapporti tra lo Stato, le Regioni e le Province Autonome di Trento e Bolzano (2013). Accordo tra il Governo, le Regioni e le Province autonome di Trento e Bolzano concernente i criteri e le modalità per la formazione ed il relativo esercizio dell'agopuntura, della fitoterapia e dell'omeopatia da parte dei medici chirurghi ed odontoiatri [National Agreement among the State and the Regions and Autonomous Provinces on the rules for education and practice in complementary medicine by medical doctors, dentists, pharmacists and veterinarians]. Codice: 4.10/2013/2 (Servizio III). Accordo ai sensi dell'articolo 4 del decreto legislativo 28 agosto 1997, n. 281. Available at: http://www.statoregioni.it/Documenti/DOC_039735_54%20%20csr%20punto%2010.pdf Accessed December 26, 2017
• 3 Region of Tuscany. Tuscan Regional Law no. 9/2007. Available at: http://jtest.ittig.cnr.it/cocoon/regioneToscana/xhtml?doc=/db/nir/RegioneToscana/2007/urn_nir_regione.toscana_legge_2007–02–19n9&css=&datafine=20121214 . Accessed December 26, 2017
• 4 Region of Tuscany. Giunta Regionale. Delibera n. 49 del 28–01–2008. Modalità di esercizio delle medicine complementari da parte dei medici e odontoiatri, dei medici veterinari e dei farmacisti. Protocollo d'intesa (ex Legge Regionale n. 9 del 19 febbraio 2007) [Practice of complementary medicine by medical doctors and dentists, veterinarians and pharmacists. Memorandum of intent of R. L. no. 9/2007]. Available at: http://www.regione.toscana.it/documents/10180/70874/Delibera%2049_08/98fe234d-6212-4013-99d0-4d1d6e51e7bd . Accessed December 30, 2017
• 5 Region of Tuscany. Giunta Regionale. Delibera n. 175 del 02–03–2015. Protocollo d'intesa di cui all'art. 3 comma 3 L.R. n. 9/2007 che recepisce l'Accordo tra il Governo, le Regioni e le Province Autonome di Trento e di Bolzano del 7 febbraio 2013, concernente i criteri e le modalità per la certificazione di qualità della formazione e dell'esercizio dell'agopuntura, della fitoterapia e dell'omeopatia da parte dei Medici chirurghi, degli odontoiatri, dei Medici veterinari e dei farmacisti [National Agreement among the State and the Regions and Autonomous Provinces on the rules for education and practice in Complementary Medicine by medical doctors, dentists, pharmacists and veterinarians] (Rep. Atti n. 54/CSR). Available at: http://www.regione.toscana.it/bancadati/atti/Contenuto.xml?id=5096704&nomeFile=Delibera_n.175_del_02-03-2015 . Accessed December 26, 2017
• 6 Region of Tuscany. List of public complementary medicine clinics. Available at: http://www.regione.toscana.it/documents/10180/23335/Ambulatori+di+medicine+complementari/0a20215a-3340-45ee-9efb-297295c85992?version=1.1 . Accessed December 30, 2017
• 7 Region of Tuscany. Regional Act no. 1384 of 09/12/2002. Azione di Piano sulle Medicine non Convenzionali (MnC). Rinnovo Commissione regionale MnC. Individuazione Centro regionale di riferimento. Destinazione Fondo PSR a sostegno delle MnC. [Action Plan on Non-Conventional Medicine (MnC). Renewal of MnC Regional Commission. Identification of Regional Reference Center. Allocation of PSR funding to support MnC]. Available at: http://web.rete.toscana.it/attinew/?MIval=_pag2a&accesso=1 . Accessed December 30, 2017
• 8 Region of Tuscany. Regional Act no. 1224 of 29/11/2016. Approvazione del programma di attività triennale 2016–2018 della struttura di riferimento regionale per le medicine complementari e delle sue articolazioni e delle linee di indirizzo alle Aziende USL e AOU per la riorganizzazione delle attività di medicina complementare integrata – prenotazione risorse anno 2016. [Adoption of the 2016–2018 three-year program for the regional reference framework for complementary medicines and its branches and specialties within the USL and AOU agencies for the reorganization of integrated complementary medicine activities – resource allocation 2016]. Available at: http://www.regione.toscana.it/bancadati/atti/Contenuto.xml?id=5132921&nomeFile=Delibera_n.1224_del_29-11-2016 . Accessed December 26, 2017
• 9 Region of Tuscany. Legge Regionale 14 dicembre 2009, n. 75. Legge di manutenzione dell'ordinamento regionale 2009 [2009 maintenance law of the regional system]. Art. 79 (BURT n. 54/2009 pag. 28). Modifiche all'articolo 43 della l.r. 40/2005 1. Available at: http://web.rete.toscana.it/burt/?MIval=burtt_sommario&data=18/12/2009&nb=54&parte=0&ns=0&sid=&bt . Accessed December 26, 2017
• 10 Region of Tuscany. Delibera n. 884 del 03–11–2008. Realizzazione presso l'Ospedale di Pitigliano del primo Centro ospedaliero di medicina integrata della Regione Toscana [Launch at the Hospital of Pitigliano of the first Hospital Center for Integrated Medicine of the Region of Tuscany.]. Available at: http://web.rete.toscana.it/attinew/?MIval=_pag2a&accesso=1 . Accessed December 26, 2017
• 11 Legge Regionale Toscana 28 dicembre 2015, n. 84. Riordino dell'assetto istituzionale e organizzativo del sistema sanitario regionale [Reorganization of the institutional and organizational setup of the regional health system.]. Modifiche alla L.R. N. 40/2005. Bollettino Ufficiale della Regione Toscana N. 58 del 31.12.2015. Available at: http://www.regione.toscana.it/bancadati/BURT/Contenuto.xml?id=10147 . Accessed December 26, 2017
• 12 Region of Tuscany. Legge regionale 24 febbraio 2005, n. 40. Disciplina del servizio sanitario regionale. Bollettino Ufficiale n. 19, parte prima, supplemento n. 40 del 7 marzo 2005 . Available at: http://raccoltanormativa.consiglio.regione.toscana.it/articolo?urndoc=urn:nir:regione.toscana:legge:2005-0224;40&dl_t=text/xml&dl_a=y&dl_id=&pr=idx,0;artic,0;articparziale,1&anc=tit1#not67 . Accessed in December 30, 2017
• 13 Rossi E, Endrizzi C, Panozzo MA, Bianchi A, Da Frè M. Homeopathy in the public health system: a seven-year observational study at Lucca Hospital (Italy). Homeopathy 2009; 98: 142-148
• 14 Rossi E, Bartoli P, Panozzo MA, Bianchi A, Da Frè M. Outcome of homeopathic treatment in pediatric patients: an observational study from 1998 to 2008. Eur J Integr Med 2010; 2: 115-122
• 15 Delibera Giunta Regionale Toscana N. 1384 del 9–12–2002. Azione di Piano sulle Medicine non Convenzionali (MnC). Rinnovo Commissione regionale MnC. Individuazione Centro regionale di riferimento. Destinazione Fondo PSR a sostegno delle MnC [Action Plan regarding Non-Conventional Medicines (MnC). Renewal of the Regional MnC Commission. Identification of the Regional Reference Center. Destination of the PSR Fund in support of MnCs.]. Available at: http://www301.regione.toscana.it/bancadati/atti/Contenuto.xml?id=5015453&nomeFile=Delibera_n.1384_del_09-12-2002 . Accessed December 30, 2017
• 16 Delibera Giunta Regionale Toscana N. 1163 del 28–12–2010. Destinazione fondo finalizzato all'integrazione delle medicine complementari negli interventi per la salute: anno 2010 [Fund allocation aimed at integrating complementary medicines in health interventions: 2010.]. Available at: http://www301.regione.toscana.it/bancadati/atti/Contenuto.xml?id=104671&nomeFile=Delibera_n.1163_del_28-12-2010 . Accessed December 26, 2017
• 17 Reilly D, Mercer SW, Bikker AP, Harrison T. Outcome related to impact on daily living: preliminary validation of the ORIDL instrument. BMC Health Serv Res 2007; 7: 139
• 18 Reilly D, Taylor M. The evidence profile. Developing integrated medicine. Compl Ther Med 1993; 1 (Suppl. 01) 11-12
• 19 Cox JD, Stetz J, Pajak TF. Toxicity criteria of the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) and the European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer (EORTC). Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 1995; 31: 1341-1346
• 20 Panozzo MA, Rossi E, Picchi M, Cervino C, Nurra L, Di Stefano M. Women and complementary medicine: Eleven years of experience at a homeopathic clinic for women in a public hospital. Eur J Integr Med 2016; 8: 423-431
• 21 Rossi E, Baccetti S, Picchi M, Conti T, Firenzuoli F, Guido C, Bosco F. Complementary medicine in oncology: a multicenter retrospective study on 1928 patients with cancer in the Region of Tuscan (Italy). World Congress Integrative Medicine & Healthy Berlin, Germany, 3–5 May 2017. BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine 2017; 17 (Suppl. 01) 333 . Available at: https://bmccomplementalternmed.biomedcentral.com/track/pdf/10.1186/s12906-017-1784-2?site=complementarietà . Accessed December 26, 2017
• 22 Rossi E, Di Stefano M, Baccetti S. , et al. International cooperation in support of homeopathy and complementary medicine in developing countries: the Tuscan experience. Homeopathy 2010; 99: 278-283
• 23 Baccetti S, Rossi E. Moxibustion to correct a breech presentation of the fetus. IDEASS Innovation for development and South-south cooperation. Available at: www.ideassonline.org . Accessed December 2017
• 24 Di Stefano M, Rossi E. Innovation and development in health: Integration of complementary and traditional medicine in public health systems. Proceedings of the International workshop. Firenze, October 28–31, 2008. Suppl. n. 18 of MC Toscana; 2010
• 25 Endrizzi C. Il Corpo psichico [The psychic body]. Roma: Armando Editore; 2010
• 26 Marongiu AMR, Panozzo MA. Sinergie potenziali fra omeopatia e lavoro psicologico. [Potential synergies between homeopathy and psychological work] MC Toscana. Anno X, n. 27; p. 9–10. Available at: http://www.regione.toscana.it/documents/10180/11258623/27_centro_reg_lucca.pdf/4a106a45-51f3-4ba7-aa61-dda8546bcf27 2013 . Accessed December 30, 2017
• 27 Panozzo MA, Vitranu R, Rossi E. Le mille risorse della donna. [The thousand resources of women]. MC Toscana. Anno XI, n. 29; 9–10. Available at: http://www.regione.toscana.it/documents/10180/11870453/29_lucca.pdf/eb527e5e-f169-480f-be19-ae6974b7c998 2014 . Accessed December 30, 2017
• 28 Rossi E, Panozzo MA, Cervino C. L'omeopatia per il parto fisiologico. [Homeopathy for natural birth]. MC Toscana. Anno XII, n. 32; p. 9–10. Available at: http://www.regione.toscana.it/documents/10180/12434948/lucca.pdf/2972ac22-2a29-478c-b9c9-000ca28f6326 . Accessed December 26, 2017
• 29 Endrizzi C, Rossi E, Crudeli L, Garibaldi D. Harm in homeopathy: aggravations, adverse drug events or medication errors?. Homeopathy 2005; 94: 233-240
• 30 Rossi E, Bartoli P, Bianchi A, Endrizzi C, Da Frè M. Homeopathic aggravation with Quinquagintamillesimal, Q (or LM), potencies. Homeopathy 2012; 101: 1-9
• 31 Da Fre M, Voller F. Regional survey on complementary medicine, bio-natural and wellness practices (2010). Unit of Epidemiology, Regional health agency of Tuscany. Collana dei Documenti ARS 56. Available at: https://www.ars.toscana.it/files/pubblicazioni/Volumi/2011/56_medicine_complementari.pdf . Accessed in December 26, 2017
• 32 Centro regionale di riferimento per l'omeopatia. Un questionario per i pazienti. MNC Toscana 2005; 2: 9-10 . Available at: http://www.regione.toscana.it/-/notiziario-regionale-delle-medicine-complementari?redirect=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.regione.toscana.it%2Fcittadini%2Fsalute%2Fmedicine-complementari%3Fp_p_id%3D101_INSTANCE_0MePgWz9xhOz%26p_p_lifecycle%3D0%26p_p_state%3Dnormal%26p_p_mode%3Dview%26p_p_col_id%3D_118_INSTANCE_CI2LeILYbuAL__column-2%26p_p_col_count%3D1
• 33 Rossi E, Picchi M, Bartoli P, Panozzo M, Cervino C, Nurra L. Homeopathic therapy in pediatric atopic diseases: short- and long-term results. Homeopathy 2016; 105: 217-224
• 34 Rossi E, Crudeli L, Endrizzi C, Garibaldi D. Cost-benefit evaluation of homeopathic versus conventional therapy in respiratory diseases. Homeopathy 2009; 98: 2-10
• 35 Rossi E, Picchi M, Bartoli P. , et al. Homeopathy in the Public Health System: Outcome Data from the Homeopathic Clinic of the Campo di Marte Hospital, Lucca (1998–2010). Eur J Integr Med 2014; 6: 39-47