Critical Swimming Speed Does not Represent the Speed at Maximal Lactate Steady State

Abstract

Critical power and critical swimming speed (CSS) are mathematically defined as intensities that could theoretically be maintained indefinitely without exhaustion. Several investigations have been conducted to attribute a physiological meaning to these variables, but results in swimming remain equivocal. Thus, the purpose of this study was to compare CSS with direct determination of the speed at maximal lactate steady state (S_MLSS). Eight well-trained swimmers (aged 18.6 ± 1.9 years) performed four tests to exhaustion (95, 100, 105, and 110 % of maximal aerobic speed [MAS]) in order to determine CSS from the distance-time relationship. S_MLSS was determined from four sub-maximal 30-min constant intensity tests (ranging from 75 % to 90 % MAS). CSS (92.7 ± 2.6 % MAS) was significantly higher than S_MLSS (88.3 ± 2.9 % of MAS) and the bias ± 95 % limits of agreement for comparisons between CSS and S_MLSS (0.07 ± 0.13 m · s^-1) indicated that the extent of disagreement was too great to use these two variables interchangeably. However, CSS and S_MLSS were strongly correlated (r = 0.87; SEE = 0.033 m · s^-1; p < 0.01). Results from the present study demonstrate that in swimming, CSS does not represent the maximal speed that can be maintained without a continuous rise of blood lactate concentration and direct determination of S_MLSS is necessary if precision is required in experimental studies.

Key words

Aerobic endurance - intensity domains - threshold - swimming performance

References

• 1 Atkinson G, Reilly T. Circadian variation in sports performance.  Sports Med. 1996;  21 292-312
• 2 Baron B, Dekerle J, Robin S, Neviere R, Dupont L, Matran R, Vanvelcenaher J, Robin H, Pelayo P. Maximal lactate steady state does not correspond to a complete physiological steady state.  Int J Sports Med. 2003;  24 582-587
• 3 Beneke R. Anaerobic threshold, individual anaerobic threshold, and maximal lactate steady state in rowing.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1995;  27 863-867
• 4 Bland J M, Altman D G. Statistical methods for assessing agreement between two methods of clinical measurement.  Lancet. 1986;  1 307-310
• 5 Brickley G, Doust J, Williams C A. Physiological responses during exercise to exhaustion at critical power.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 2002;  88 146-151
• 6 Brooks G A. Lactate shuttles in nature.  Biochem Soc Trans. 2002;  30 258-264
• 7 Bull A J, Housh T J, Johnson G O, Perry S R. Effect of mathematical modelling on the estimation of critical power.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2000;  31 526-530
• 8 Capelli C, Pendergast D R, Termin B. Energetics of swimming at maximal speeds in humans.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 1998;  78 385-393
• 9 Carter H, Jones A M, Barstow T J, Burnley M, Williams C, Doust J H. Effect of endurance training on oxygen uptake kinetics during treadmill running.  J Appl Physiol. 2000;  89 1744-1752
• 10 Casaburi R, Storer T W, Ben-Dov I, Wasserman K. Effect of endurance training on possible determinants of VO₂ during heavy exercise.  J Appl Physiol. 1987;  62 199-207
• 11 Cazorla G, Dufort C, Montpetit R, Cervetti J P. The influence of active recovery from swimming exhaustion work on the lactate metabolism. Terauds J, Bedingfield W Biomechanics and Medicine in Swimming. International Series on Sport Sciences. Vol. 14. Baltimore; University Park Press 1983: 244-250
• 12 Chatard J C, Lavoie J M, Lacour J R. Analysis of determinants of swimming economy in front crawl.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 1990;  61 88-92
• 13 Dekerle J, Baron B, Dupont L, Vanvelcenaher J, Pelayo P. Maximal lactate steady state, respiratory compensation Threshold and critical power.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 2003;  89 281-288
• 14 Dekerle J, Pelayo P, Delaporte B, Gosse N, Hespel J M, Sidney M. Validity and reliability of critical speed, critical stroke rate and anaerobic capacity in relation to front crawl swimming performances.  Int J Sports Med. 2002;  23 93-98
• 15 Dekerle J, Pelayo P, Clipet B, Lefevre T, Depretz S, Sidney M. Stroking parameters in front crawl swimming and maximal lactate steady state speed.  Int J Sports Med. 2004;  in press
• 16 Denadai B S, Greco C C, Teixeira M. Blood lactate response and critical speed in swimmers aged 10 - 12 years of different standards.  J Sports Sci. 2000;  18 779-784
• 17 di Prampero P E. The concept of critical velocity: a brief analysis.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 1999;  80 162-164
• 18 Gladden L B. Muscle as a consumer of lactate.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2000;  32 764-771
• 19 Hill D W. The critical power concept.  Sports Med. 1993;  16 237-254
• 20 Hill A V, Steward R P, Lane C J. Application of the critical power concept to young swimmers.  Ped Exerc Sci. 1995;  7 281-293
• 21 Hill D W, Ferguson C S. A physiological description of critical velocity.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 1999;  79 290-293
• 22 Jenkins D G, Quigley B M. Blood lactate in trained cyclists during cycle ergometry at critical power.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 1990;  61 278-283
• 23 Jones A M, Doust J H. The validity of the lactate minimum test for determination of the maximal lactate steady state.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1998;  30 1304-1313
• 24 Lavoie J M, Montpetit R R. Applied physiology in swimming.  Sports Med. 1986;  3 165-189
• 25 Londeree B R, Ames S A. Maximal lactate steady-state versus states of conditioning.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 1975;  34 1-10
• 26 Lucas R D, Caputo F, Mancini E, Denadai B S. The validity of critical speed determine from track cycling for identification of the maximal lactate steady state.  Biol Sport. 2002;  19 239-249
• 27 Martin L, Whyte G P. Comparison of critical swimming velocity and velocity at lactate threshold in elite triathletes.  Int J Sports Med. 2000;  21 366-368
• 28 Matsunami M, Taguchi M, Taimura A, Suyama M, Suga M, Shimonagata S, Aoyagi M, Taba S. Comparison of swimming speed and exercise intensity during non-invasive test and invasive test in competitive swimming. Keskinen K, Komi PV, Hollander AP Biomechanics and Medicine in Swimming VIII. Jyväskylä; Gummerus Printing 1999: 245-248
• 29 McLellan T M, Cheung K S. A comparative evaluation of the individual anaerobic threshold and the critical power.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1992;  24 543-550
• 30 Pepper M L, Housh T J, Johnson G O. The accuracy of the critical velocity test for predicting time to exhaustion during treadmill running.  Int J Sports Med. 1992;  2 121-124
• 31 Poole D C, Ward S A, Whipp B J. The effects of training on the metabolic and respiratory profile of high-intensity cycle ergometer exercise.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 1990;  59 421-429
• 32 Pringle J SM, Jones A M. Maximal lactate steady state, critical power and EMG during cycling.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 2002;  88 214-226
• 33 Rodriguez F A, Moreno D, Keskinen K L. Validity of a two-distance simplified testing method for determining critical swimming velocity. Chatard JC Biomechanics and Medicine in Swimming IX. Saint-Etienne; University of Saint Etienne 2003: 385-390
• 34 Scherrer J, Monod H. Le travail musculaire local et la fatigue chez l'homme. Paris; Masson et Compagnie 1960
• 35 Smith D J, Norris S R, Hogg J M. Performance evaluation of swimmers.  Sports Med. 2002;  32 539-554
• 36 Swensen T C, Harnish C R, Beitman L, Keller B A. Non invasive estimation of the maximal lactate steady state in trained cyclists.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1999;  31 742-746
• 37 Taylor S A. Comparison of critical swimming velocity and velocity at lactate threshold in elite triathletes.  Int J Sports Med. 2001;  21 366-368
• 38 Toussaint H M, Hollander A P, Berg C, Vorontsov A. Biomechanics of swimming. Garett WE, Kirkendall DT Exercise and Sport Science. Philadelphia; Lippincott Williams and Wilkins 2000: 639-660
• 39 Vandewalle H, Vautier J F, Kachouri M, Lechevalier J M, Monod H. Work-exhaustion time relationships and the critical power concept.  J Sports Med Phys Fitness. 1997;  37 89-102
• 40 Wakayoshi K, Ikuta K, Yoshida T, Udo M, Moritani T, Mutoh Y, Miyashita M. Determining and validity of critical velocity as an index of swimming performance in the competitive swimmer.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 1992;  64 153-157
• 41 Wakayoshi K, Yoshida T, Udo M, Kasai T, Moritani T, Mutoh Y, Miyashita M. A simple method for determining critical speed as swimming fatigue threshold in competitive swimming.  Int J Sports Med. 1992;  13 367-371
• 42 Wakayoshi K, Yoshida T, Udo M, Harada T, Moritani T, Mutoh Y, Miyashita M. Does critical swimming velocity represent exercise intensity at maximal lactate steady state?.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 1993;  66 90-95
• 43 Wakayoshi K, D'Acquisto L J, Cappaert J M, Troup J P. Relationship between oxygen uptake, stroke rate and swimming velocity in competitive swimming.  Int J Sports Med. 1995;  16 19-23
• 44 Womack C J, Davis S E, Blumer J L, Barrett E, Weltman A L, Gaesser G A. Slow component of O₂ uptake during heavy exercise: adaptation to endurance training.  J Appl Physiol. 1995;  79 838-845
• 45 Wright B, Smith D J. A protocol for the determining of critical speed as an index of swimming endurance performance.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1994;  39 55-59