Are There Limits to Swimming World Records?

Abstract

The purpose of this article was to investigate whether swimming world records are beginning to plateau and whether the inequality between men and women's swimming performances is narrowing, similar to that observed in running world records. A flattened “S-shaped curve” logistic curve is fitted to 100-m, 200-m, and 400-m front-crawl world-record swimming speeds for men and women from 1 May 1957 to the present time, using the non-linear least-squares regression. The inequality between men and women's world records is also assessed using the ratio, Women's/Men's world record speeds. The results confirm that men and women's front-crawl swimming world-record speeds are plateauing and the ratio between women's and men's world records has remained stable at approximately 0.9. In conclusion, the logistic curves provide evidence that swimming world-record speeds experienced a period of “accelerated” growth/improvements during the 1960 - 1970s, but are now beginning to plateau. The period of acceleration corresponded with numerous advances in science and technology but also coincided with the anecdotal evidence for institutionalised doping. Also noteworthy, however, is the remarkably consistency in the women's/men's world record ratio, circa 0.9, similar to those observed in middle and long distance running performances. These finding supports the notion that a 10 % gender inequality exists for both swimming and running.

Key words

logistic curve - non‐linear regression - world‐record swimming speeds - women's/men's world record performance ratio - period of acceleration

References

• 1 Ackland T R, Mazza J C, Carter L, Ross W D. A survey of physique of world champion athletes.  Sports Coach. 1991;  14 10-11
• 2 Besford P. Encyclopaedia of Swimming. London, UK; Robert Hale and Company 1971: 218-221
• 3 Blest D C. Lower bounds for athletic performance.  Statistician. 1996;  45 243-253
• 4 Box G EP, Cox D R. An analysis of transformations (with Discussion).  J Roy Stat Soc B. 1964;  26 211-252
• 5 Chatterjee S, Chatterjee S. New lamps for old - an exploratory analysis of running times in Olympic games.  J Roy Stat Soc C‐App. 1982;  31 14-22
• 6 Cheuvront S N, Carter R, DeRuisseau K C, Moffatt R J. Running performance differences between men and women.  Sports Med. 2005;  35 1017-1024
• 7 Colwin C. Breakthrough Swimming. Illinois, USA; Human Kinetics 2002: 223-225
• 8 Furlong J, Szreter R. The trend of the performance difference between leading men and women athletes, 1951 - 1967.  Statistician. 1975;  24 115-128
• 9 Gastin P B. Energy system interaction and relative contribution during maximal exercise.  Sports Med. 2001;  31 725-741
• 10 Hopkins S R, Harms C A. Gender and pulmonary gas exchange during exercise.  Exerc Sport Sci Rev. 2004;  32 50-56
• 11 Keil I, Wix D. In the Swim: The Amateur Swimming Association from 1869 to 1994. Loughborough, UK; Swimming Times Publications Ltd 1996: 66-68
• 12 Maglischo E W. Swimming Fastest. Champaign, IL; Human Kinetics 2003
• 13 Mognoni P, Lafortuna C, Russo G, Minetti A. An analysis of world records in 3 types of locomotion.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 1982;  49 287-299
• 14 Nevill A M, Whyte G. Are there limits to running world records?.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2005;  37 1785-1788
• 15 Nevill A M, Whyte G. Are women narrowing the gender gap in elite sport performance. Taylor N, Groeller H, McLennan P Physiological Bases of Human Performance During Work and Exercise. Edinburgh; Elsevier (in press)
• 16 Pyne D B, Anderson M E, Hopkins W G. Monitoring changes in lean mass of elite male and female swimmers.  Int J Sport Physiol Perf. 2006;  1 14-26
• 17 Rushall B. http://coachsci.sdsu.edu/swimming/bodysuit/table.htm. Sports Science Journal. Online swimming coaching resource. 2001: 222-225
• 18 Sharp R L, Troup J P, Costill D L. Relationship between power and sprint freestyle swimming.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1982;  14 53-56
• 19 Sheel A W, Richards J, Foster G, Guenette J. Sex differences in respiratory exercise physiology.  Sports Med. 2004;  34 567-579
• 20 Smith D J, Norris S R, Hogg J M. Performance evaluation of swimmers.  Sports Med. 2002;  32 539-554
• 21 Sparling P B, O'Donnell E M, Snow T K. The gender difference in distance running performance has plateaued: an analysis of world rankings from 1980 to 1996.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1998;  30 1725-1729
• 22 Whipp B J, Ward S A. Will women soon outrun men?.  Nature. 1992;  355 25
• 23 Whyte G, George K, Sharma S, Firoozi S, Stephens N, Senior R, McKenna W J. The upper limit of physiologic cardiac hypertrophy in elite male and female athletes: The British experience.  Eur J Appl Physiol. 2004;  31 592-597