Keywords
neurodegenerative diseases - traditional Chinese medicine - network pharmacology -
therapeutic targets
Introduction
Network pharmacology is an emerging discipline initially proposed by the British pharmacologist
Andrew L. Hopkins in 2007 [1]. This discipline integrates systems biology, network biology, computational simulation,
and chemoinformatics to construct a “drug–component–target–disease” network model,
aiming to reveal the multidimensional therapeutic mechanisms of complex diseases.
Network pharmacology enhances the multitarget and multi-pathway analysis, which is
particularly well suited for research on traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), aligning
with the multicomponent and multi-pathway therapeutic characteristics of TCM, and
compensating for the limitations of traditional single-target pharmacological research
[2], [3].
Neurodegenerative diseases include Alzheimerʼs disease (AD), Parkinsonʼs disease (PD),
Huntingtonʼs disease (HD), and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) [4]. These diseases can gradually result in the degeneration of central nervous system
functions, which is manifested in a decline in memory, motor control, and cognitive
ability [5], [6]. For example, AD is identified as the leading cause of dementia in the elderly,
while PD is primarily characterized by motor dysfunction [7]. Current treatments mainly focus on slowing down disease progression with medication,
while their efficacy is limited and cannot cure any of these diseases [8]. For instance, AD treatments mainly focus on slowing down cognitive decline, but
their long-term effects remain uncertain, and side effects are common [9]. Emerging therapies such
as stem cell therapy and gene therapy have aroused wide attention; meanwhile, lifestyle
factors including diet, exercise, and sleep are increasingly recognized for their
roles in preventing and managing these diseases [10], [11]. With the global population aging, the incidence of neurodegenerative diseases is
rising significantly, especially in developed countries [12], [13]. Although the current treatments can delay disease progression to some extent, the
complexity of these diseases presents major clinical challenges. Therefore, the search
for more effective treatments has become an urgent priority. The multitarget and multi-pathway
analysis methods of network pharmacology provide novel possibilities for studying
neurodegenerative diseases. Numerous effective components and formulations in TCM
have already been illustrated through network pharmacology to show
their mechanisms of action in treating these diseases [14]. The relationship between digestive diseases and network pharmacology is shown in
[Fig. 1].
Fig. 1 Relationship between digestive diseases and network pharmacology.
Commonly Used Network Pharmacology Databases
Commonly Used Network Pharmacology Databases
Traditional Chinese medicine systems pharmacology database and analysis platform
Traditional Chinese medicine systems pharmacology (TCMSP) is a systems pharmacology
database developed for TCM research, integrating chemical information, biological
activities, targets, and pharmacokinetic parameters of TCM components [16]. Covering 499 herbal medicines, 29 384 compounds, and 3311 targets, it is widely
used for screening multicomponent and multitarget drugs and exploring mechanisms of
action [17], [18]. TCMSP offers tools for identifying potential effective components and predicting
their absorption, distribution, metabolism, and excretion (ADME) properties [19], [20]. For example, active components in Scrophularia ningpoensis were found to modulate
40 targets related to β-amyloid and tau proteins in AD [21]. Effective components in Suanzaoren decoction were identified as
modulating pathways associated with insulin resistance and inflammation, improving
AD-related diabetes symptoms [22]. Data from TCMSP also revealed that BM25 (Ershiwuwei Shancorawan) exhibited neuroprotection
and anti-inflammatory activities by regulating multiple targets, reducing β-amyloid and tau protein accumulation, and delaying cognitive decline in AD [23]. In addition, TCMSP was used for analyzing the mechanisms of Jianpi Huatan Quyu
decoction in treating chronic heart failure, exhibiting its cardiovascular protection
and anti-inflammatory effects by regulating several pathways [24] ([Table 1]).
Table 1 Public databases related to TCM network pharmacology.
Type
|
Name
|
Description
|
Website of database or tool
|
TCM-related database
|
TCMSP
|
A database that can retrieve and screen for the key TCM compounds and target information.
|
http://tcmspw.com/tcmsp.php
|
Drug-related database
|
KEGG
|
A database for understanding the high-level functions and utilities of biological
systems, such as cells and organisms.
|
https://www.genome.jp/kegg/
|
Drug-related database
|
STITCH
|
A database containing the known and predicted chemical compounds and protein interactions.
|
http://stitch.embl.de/
|
Target-related database
|
STRING
|
A database of known or predicted interactions between proteins.
|
https://string-db.org/
|
Drug-related database
|
PubChem
|
A free chemistry database maintained by the National Center for Biotechnology Information
(NCBI), which provides information on chemical molecules and their activities in biological
assays.
|
https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/
|
Drug-related database
|
ChEMBL
|
A database integrating bioactive substances that possess drug-like characteristics.
|
https://www.ebi.ac.uk/chembl
|
The Kyoto encyclopedia of genes and genomes database
Kyoto encyclopedia of genes and genomes (KEGG) is an integrative bioinformatics database
encompassing gene, protein, disease, and metabolism data. Through investigating signal
transduction and metabolic pathways, KEGG helps researchers reveal drug mechanisms
in complex diseases. In addition, it is widely used in network pharmacology to investigate
how TCM components regulate sophisticated pathways. KEGG analysis suggested that active
components of Asparagus officinalis mitigated fluorosis-induced oxidative stress and
inflammation, protecting brain cells through antioxidative and anti-inflammatory mechanisms
[25]. Mahboob et al. employed KEGG to identify AD-related genes and pathways, highlighting
their roles in apoptosis, neuroinflammation, and oxidative damage [10]. These findings demonstrate the critical role of KEGG in clarifying mechanisms underlying
neurodegenerative diseases.
The search tool for interactions of chemicals database
Search tool for interactions of chemicals (STITCH) integrates interaction data between
genes, proteins, and chemicals, including over 2.6 million proteins and 30 000 small
molecules from 1133 species [26], [27]. Through the combination of computational predictions, experimental validation,
and literature-based associations, STITCH provides compound-target interaction networks,
helping researchers explore multitarget mechanisms of chemicals. This database is
widely used in drug discovery and target screening, allowing researchers to predict
compound effects in multitarget diseases by examining interactions with multiple protein
targets. STITCH identified AD-related differentially expressed genes (DEGs) and several
key pathways through enrichment analysis [28]. Olatunde et al. employed STITCH to construct protein-compound networks, showing
multitarget, multicomponent mechanisms of TCM in
treating complex diseases including diabetes and cancer [29]. STITCH offers Application Programming Interfaces (API) and interactive network
views for investigating protein-chemical interactions in biological processes [30]. These studies emphasize the value of STITCH in illuminating the multitarget mechanisms
of TCM.
The search tool for the retrieval of interacting genes/proteins database
Search tool for the retrieval of interacting genes/proteins (STRING) is a database
concentrates on protein-protein interactions, integrating experimental verification
and predictive data to provide insights into functional and physical relationships
between proteins. It has been widely applied to explore drug targets and construct
protein regulatory networks. Using STRING, researchers can identify direct and indirect
protein interactions and examine their potential impacts on disease development, making
it especially significant for research on multitarget disease mechanisms. In network
pharmacology research, STRING is usually used for analyzing interaction networks between
effective TCM components and disease-related proteins. By constructing multitarget
protein interaction networks, STRING contributes to uncovering the multidimensional
regulatory mechanisms of TCM in complex disorders, further elucidating the associated
TCM mechanisms and potential therapeutic targets. For
example, in a study on Andrographis paniculata for the treatment of AD, the authors
utilized both STITCH and STRING databases to construct protein-compound interaction
networks, identifying key AD-related pathways, including NF-κB and PI3K-Akt. Experimental verification showed that effective compounds from A. paniculata
significantly lowered inflammatory proteins, including PTGS2 (COX2) and BACE1, consequently
suppressing the progression of AD [31]. This study underscores the importance of STRING in unveiling the multitarget mechanisms
of TCM.
PubChem
PubChem is a public chemical information database established by the U. S. National
Institutes of Health. It integrates chemical structures, biological functions, properties,
and pharmacological effects, covering millions of compounds and experimental bioactivity
data. As one of the largest open-access chemical databases, PubChem exerts an essential role in drug discovery, compound screening, and bioactivity
analysis, especially for drug development and repositioning. In network pharmacology,
PubChem is widely used to obtain detailed chemical information and analyze interactions
with disease-related genes or proteins in combination with other databases. In addition,
it enables large-scale compound screening and evaluation of their therapeutic potential.
For example, in an AD study, PubChem was used to screen AD-related compounds, and
network pharmacology revealed compound-target gene interactions, exhibiting their
role in reducing neuroinflammation and mitigating
neural injury [32]. Similarly, PubChem was used to identify ALS-related compounds and investigate their
impacts on ALS pathology [33]. These studies underscore PubChemʼs importance in comprehending complex disease
mechanisms.
ChEMBL
ChEMBL, developed by the European Bioinformatics Institute, concentrates on bioactive
compounds and offers extensive data on drugs and their targets [34]. With millions of bioactivity data entries for small molecules, it is widely used
for drug discovery and target prediction, enabling researchers to explore drug-target
interactions and screen potential drug candidates. In network pharmacology, ChEMBL
provides bioactivity data for compounds and protein targets, supporting the analysis
of interactions between small molecules or TCM components and disease-related genes.
This helps uncover multitarget TCM mechanisms and advances network pharmacology-based
drug development. ChEMBL also promotes research on neurodegenerative diseases by exploring
multitarget compound bioactivity, particularly through datasets of animal disease
models and phenotypic endpoints for translational medicine research [35].
Application of Network Pharmacology in Traditional Chinese Medicine Research
Application of Network Pharmacology in Traditional Chinese Medicine Research
Network pharmacology research techniques
Network pharmacology combines the updated approaches like high-throughput technology,
molecular docking, and systems biology to assist researchers in analyzing the multitarget,
multi-pathway TCM mechanisms. Among them, high-throughput technology can process a
variety of samples concurrently, rapidly producing massive biological data, like protein
interactions, gene expression profiles, or metabolite changes. It has been frequently
adopted for screening effective TCM components and the possible associations with
disease targets. For instance, in a study concerning AD, high-throughput technology
was used to analyze different TCM compounds, and finally, multiple effective components
with therapeutic effects were identified [36]. Molecular docking can simulate the drug molecule-target protein binding patterns
and predict the corresponding interactions. It contributes to validating binding sites
and action mechanisms of TCM components with
corresponding targets. For example, in a study regarding PD, molecular docking was
used to discover the effective binding of ligustrazine to proteins associated with
the PI3K-Akt pathway, demonstrating the neuroprotection [37]. Systems biology integrates multilevel biological data (including proteins, genes,
and metabolites) to illustrate interactions inside the complicated biological networks.
In network pharmacology, it is applied to analyze the multidimensional mechanisms
of TCM formulations. The combined application of these techniques can help researchers
uncover the multitarget mechanisms of TCM formulations in treating complex diseases,
transforming complex network interactions into visualized networks, and facilitating
the modernization of TCM and the development of precision medicine.
Steps in network pharmacology research and construction of biological networks
The typical steps in network pharmacology research are as follows: at first, bioactive
components are screened from TCM. Second, the potential targets of these components
are identified using relevant databases. Third, a “drug–component–target–disease”
network model is constructed based on these targets and components, and network analysis
is performed to identify key regulatory nodes [38]. Finally, these results should be validated by conducting biological experiments,
aiming to ensure the reliability of the research. The construction and analysis of
the network model are central to the research process, as they can reveal the complex
mechanisms of TCM formulations and provide theoretical support for new drug development.
[Fig. 2] shows the flowchart of network pharmacology analysis.
Fig. 2 Flowchart of network pharmacology analysis.
Applications of network pharmacology
Through systematic analysis using network pharmacology, researchers can predict new
indications for TCM beyond its therapeutic effects. This process depends on the constructed
biological networks. Relevant signaling pathways and targets can be identified. For
instance, by examining the associations of TCM effective components with disease pathways,
the possible therapeutic efficacy of TCM can be predicted under the novel pathology
condition, which provides important support for new indication discovery [39]. Researchers can explore the multitarget effects of TCM formulations, screen for
quality markers of TCM, further elucidate the mechanisms of TCM components, assess
the safety of TCM, and explore the synergistic effects between TCM and modern drugs.
These research directions can comprehensively enhance the scientific foundation and
clinical application value of TCM, thereby promoting the modernization of TCM.
Finally, these results need to be validated through biological experiments to ensure
the reliability of the study. Experimental validation is an indispensable part of
network pharmacology research, as the results predicted by models are obtained solely
through computational tools. Their accuracy and biological relevance need to be further
confirmed. Common validation methods include cell experiments, animal studies, and
molecular biology techniques. For example, in a study performed on the inhibitory
potential of Lasunadya Ghrita (LG) extract against β-amyloid aggregation in AD, the anti-AD potential of the water extract of Lasunadya
Ghrita (LGWE) was explored. However, an insufficient logical connection between network
pharmacology and experimental validation in the antioxidant mechanism existed. Although
the study emphasized that LGWEʼs complex components may regulate antioxidant pathways
(such as Nrf2, HO-1, SOD1) through multiple targets, it did not systematically
employ network pharmacology tools to predict specific target genes and pathway associations,
causing a lack of solid theoretical foundation [40]. While the experiments demonstrated the phenomenon that LGWE inhibited β-amyloid-induced reactive oxygen species generation, deeper verification on predicted
targets, such as Nrf2 or mitochondrial dysfunction, was not conducted, therefore leaving
the mechanistic study at a superficial level. As a key tool for multitarget therapy,
network pharmacology predictions require experimental validation to close the loop,
otherwise, logical gaps may occur. The lack of network pharmacology integration and
the limitations of experimental validation in this study weakened the comprehensive
understanding of LGWEʼs antioxidant mechanisms. Moreover, research should integrate
target prediction and validation tools, clarify the relationship between active components
and antioxidant pathways, as well as supplement
experiments related to antioxidant pathways to enhance the logical integrity and practical
utility of the study.
Application of Network Pharmacology in Neurodegenerative Diseases
Application of Network Pharmacology in Neurodegenerative Diseases
Application of traditional Chinese medicine in Alzheimerʼs disease
AD is a major neurodegenerative disorder affecting the elderly population globally,
with the primary symptoms including memory loss, cognitive decline, and abnormal behavior.
Approximately 50 million people globally suffer from dementia, and 60 – 70% of them
develop AD. The number is expected to reach 100 million by 2050 [41]. With the acceleration of global aging, the incidence of AD exhibits a significantly
increasing trend, making it urgent to develop new treatment methods [36]. The pathological mechanisms of AD are complex and are suggested to involve β-amyloid aggregation, neuroinflammation, oxidative stress, and neuronal apoptosis
[42], [43]. Although acetylcholinesterase inhibitors and N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor
antagonists are currently the main therapeutic agents for the treatment of AD, they
only temporarily alleviate symptoms and are
accompanied by side effects, without halting disease progression [44]. Therefore, the develop of multitarget treatments for AD is urgently needed. Recently,
due to its multicomponent and multitarget characteristics, TCM has attracted widespread
attention in AD treatment. Through network pharmacology analysis, researchers predicted
the potential active compounds and targets in the Hengqing II formula for treating
AD, exerting anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, and neuroprotective effects mainly by
regulating signaling pathways such as PI3K-Akt, NF-κB, and MAPK [45]. In another study, network pharmacology analysis was used to identify 30 candidate
targets related to AD for the compound paeoniflorin, which were enriched into the
oxidative stress and inflammation pathways. Moreover, the key targets identified included
Nrf2 (encoded by NFE2L2) and TLR4, which were closely associated with oxidative stress
and
neuroinflammation. In vivo experiments also confirmed the neuroprotective effects of paeoniflorin on AD [46]. Network pharmacology analysis was conducted to identify 15 active compounds and
135 potential targets in the QZZD (Qin-Zhi-Zhu-Dan) formulation. In vitro experiments demonstrated the impact of this formulation on alleviating neuroinflammation
and slowing down neuronal death, exerting significant neuroprotective effects against
AD [47]. Qiu et al. used network pharmacology and molecular docking techniques to explore
the potential mechanisms of Acorus calamus in AD treatment, identifying four active components associated with multiple AD-related
targets (e.g., AKT1 and MAPK14) that regulated the oxidative stress and anti-inflammatory
pathways. Molecular docking further validated the binding abilities of these components
to their targets, indicating the neuroprotective potential of A.
calamus in AD [48]. Soleimani Zakeri et al. constructed protein-protein interaction networks to explore
the gene complexes in AD and proposed drug repositioning candidates. Through bioinformatics
analysis, they identified several key AD-related gene pathways and recommended two
new potential treatments, namely, raloxifene and gentian violet [49]. These studies demonstrate the scientific significance of TCM in AD treatment, and
the application of network pharmacology combined with in vitro experimental validation provides a better understanding of the multicomponent, multitarget,
and multi-pathway therapeutic properties of TCM. In addition, this offers a theoretical
basis and support for future drug research and development for AD.
Application of traditional Chinese medicine in Parkinsonʼs disease
PD is a common neurodegenerative disease that primarily affects the elderly. Globally,
the incidence of PD significantly increases with age, and it affects approximately
1% of people aged over 60 years and up to 3% of people over 80 years old [50]. With the global population aging, the incidence of PD is expected to rise further
in the future [51]. The pathological mechanisms of PD are the progressive loss of dopaminergic neurons
in the substantia nigra and the formation of Lewy bodies, which may be caused by abnormal
aggregation of α-synuclein [52]. Mitochondrial dysfunction, oxidative stress, neuroinflammation, and immune responses
are key factors for the pathogenesis of PD [53]. Existing treatments, including dopamine replacement therapy (like levodopa), dopamine
receptor agonists, and MAO-B inhibitors, can temporarily relieve motor symptoms. However,
as the disease progresses, the drug efficacy gradually decreases, and long-term use
of these drugs may lead to side effects, including motor complications [54]. Against this backdrop, developing the multitarget treatments that can delay neurodegeneration
and protect dopaminergic neurons has become a research focus. Network pharmacology
can provide vital support for multitarget, multi-pathway TCM treatment for PD. For
example, Liu et al. used network pharmacology to identify effective components and
PD-related targets in Tianqi Pingchan granules (TPG), discovering that these targets
were mainly related to inflammatory responses through Gene Ontology (GO).
and KEGG pathway analyses. In vivo experiments showed that TPG could regulate gut microbiota, reduce peripheral inflammatory
factors, inhibit microglial activation, alleviate neuroinflammation, and delay PD
progression [55]. Wu et al. utilized transcriptome sequencing to identify DEGs between PD patients
and healthy individuals. Combined with network pharmacology analysis, the authors
determined the relationship between active compounds in Cordyceps sinensis capsules and PD targets and constructed a “compound–disease–target” network. Quercetin
and kaempferol, identified as the major anti-PD effective components, were found to
exert anti-neuroinflammatory and neuroprotective effects by binding to key targets,
including matrix metalloproteinase-9 (MMP9) [56]. Another study employed network pharmacology combined with molecular docking analysis
to analyze 97 effective components of ginseng and 168 potential
PD-related targets. Based on their experimental results, these targets were involved
in regulating biological processes such as cellular metabolism and apoptosis, while
further analysis indicated that the MAPK signaling pathway and AGE-RAGE signaling
pathway might be associated with the treatment mechanisms for PD [57]. Wu et al., through network pharmacology, identified that the IL-17 signaling pathway
and neuroactive ligand-receptor interaction were the key targets. In vivo experiments showed that DiHuangYin (DHY) reduced peripheral inflammation and central
nervous system inflammation, thus protecting neurons [58]. Lin et al., by using network pharmacology and molecular docking techniques, revealed
the main effective components of Liuwei Dihuang Wan, including quercetin, β-sitosterol, and kaempferol, which were closely related to multiple targets (such
as AKT1, VEGFA, and IL6). Experimental studies
indicated that Liuwei Dihuang Wan had potential neuroprotective effects against PD
via the multitarget, multi-pathway mechanisms, particularly in regulating neuronal
death, oxidative stress, and inflammatory responses [59]. The above results scientifically confirm the multitarget, multi-pathway mechanisms
of TCM in PD treatment. Integrating network pharmacology and in vitro experiments can shed novel light on the complicated mechanisms and establish a solid
basis for developing and applying PD-related drugs.
Application of traditional Chinese medicine in Huntingtonʼs disease
HD refers to an uncommon inherited neurodegenerative disease. Its global incidence
is approximately 5 – 10/100 000 individuals, and it usually occurs in middle age [60]. HD shows the representative characteristics of involuntary movements, psychiatric
symptoms, and cognitive decline. The pathology includes mutant huntingtin protein
aggregation, resulting in excessive neuronal apoptosis and serious central nervous
system injury [61]. There are few treatments for HD, which mainly focus on managing its symptoms, including
applying antipsychotics in controlling psychiatric and motor symptoms. Nevertheless,
these treatments cannot prevent disease progression and may lead to significant adverse
reactions [62]. Therefore, developing treatments that can delay and reverse HD pathology is becoming
the research focus. Network pharmacology offers a novel research direction to explore
whether TCM can
be applied to treat HD. Using the multitarget, multi-pathway methods can uncover the
effects of TCM components on regulating inflammation and neuroprotection. The HDNetDB
database combines HD-related gene expression profiles and molecular interactions,
contributing to exploring the complicated molecular mechanisms underlying HD and accelerating
the systematic study of HD [63]. For example, network pharmacology studies have illustrated interactions among several
TCM effective components and HD-related biological targets, especially those related
to apoptosis and neuroprotection pathways like PI3K/Akt, NF-κB, and MAPK. Molecular docking and Quantitative Structure-Activity Relationship (QSAR)
models can be used to predict the possible effects of TCM components in treating HD,
aiming to provide a theoretical foundation for the multitarget application in the
clinic [64]. Likewise, according to network pharmacology
research, natural compounds can regulate critical targets of HD, particularly via
the gene-protein interaction networks, which can investigate NF-κB and PI3K/Akt pathways within neuroinflammation. The above compounds are verified
with neuroprotection through molecular dynamics simulations and in vitro experimental verification [65]. For instance, network pharmacology research suggests interactions of several TCM
effective components with HD-related biological targets, especially by establishing
the drug–target–disease networks, contributing to exploring the efficacy of TCM chemical
components in treating diseases by modulating several pathways, including MAPK and
PI3K/Akt [66]. Therefore, integrating network pharmacology with in vitro experimental verification can validate the multicomponent, multitarget TCM mechanisms
in treating HD. The method provides a novel direction for analyzing the effect
of TCM in treating HD and lays a solid foundation for drug development and clinical
application [67].
Application of traditional Chinese medicine in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis
ALS represents an uncommon neurodegenerative disorder, whose incidence is around 1.9/100 000
individuals annually in the world. Patients usually die in 2 – 5 years after being
diagnosed [68]. It is pathologically characterized by progressive motor neuronal degeneration,
which causes muscle weakness and atrophy, finally leading to respiratory failure-related
death [69]. ALS has a complicated etiology that involves different pathological processes,
like mitochondrial dysfunction, glutamate toxicity, neuroinflammation, and oxidative
stress [70]. At present, although there are few treatments available for ALS, and just two drugs
are approved by the FDA (riluzole and edaravone) for delaying its progression, they
can achieve limited therapeutic effects and are incapable of reversing neuronal injury
[71]. Therefore, it is vital to search for multitarget treatments.
Network pharmacology provides novel avenues for the application of TCM in treating
ALS. For example, Li et al. employed network pharmacology for analyzing the multitarget,
multi-pathway mechanisms of Bushen Jianpi (BSJP) formulation in mitigating ALS symptoms
like muscle atrophy, hypoxia-related conditions, and oxidative stress. As reported
in a later randomized, double-blind, multicenter clinical study, BSJP significantly
improved lung capacity and muscle strength among ALS cases, and delayed ALS progression,
with no significant adverse reactions. This formulation may bring benefits by modulating
the level of vitamin D3 in serum and recovering renal and hepatic functions [72]. Lin et al. analyzed the multitarget mechanisms of effective components in BSJP
using network pharmacology analysis. Their findings suggest that effective components
like kaempferol and quercetin were vital for neuroprotection by modulating mitochondrial
activity,
anti-inflammatory response, and oxidative stress. Clinical studies indicated the therapeutic
effect of this formulation on mitigating ALS symptoms, especially for alleviating
neuronal injury and delaying ALS progression [73]. Through molecular docking and network pharmacology analyses, the possible mechanisms
by which nux vomica-treated ALS were explored. The main components were examined and
shown to mitigate oxidative stress and neuroinflammation in ALS through pathways such
as Ras, MAPK, and PI3K-Akt. Moreover, in vitro experiments demonstrated that nux vomica components showed great affinity to key
targets, demonstrating that nux vomica displayed neuroprotection in ALS and might
be developed as an anti-ALS treatment [74]. Using molecular docking and network pharmacology analyses, Li et al. [75] revealed that the major components of Rehmannia glutinosa, including
glutathione and phytosterols, interacted with targets such as PTGS2, ESR1, and PPARG
to regulate neuroprotection and oxidative stress pathways, especially via the estrogen
receptor pathway. This reduced glutamate toxicity and neuroinflammation, suggesting
the potential of R. glutinosa in the treatment of ALS [75]. Network pharmacology and molecular docking techniques were used to explore the
therapeutic potential of the TCM “R. glutinosa” in ALS. This study revealed its possible therapeutic mechanisms by analyzing the
interactions of the effective components of R. glutinosa with different ALS-related targets and signaling pathways [76]. Noor et al. demonstrated that constructing the multilevel networks between drug
components, targets, and diseases using network pharmacology helped reveal the multitarget
properties of herbs. This multitarget, multi-pathway feature was especially vital
for the
treatment of multifactorial diseases such as ALS. The study also highlighted the immense
potential of TCM and Ayurvedic herbs in treating complex diseases, including ALS [77]. Another study introduced network pharmacology as a new “green” strategy, and demonstrated
how predicting the behaviors of metabolites revealed the mechanisms of natural products
as drug candidates. Through the combination of omics data, computational modeling,
and chemical biology, this multidisciplinary approach contributed to elucidating the
multitarget actions of drugs and guided drug discovery, especially in complex multicomponent
natural medicines, revealing their potential in ALS treatment [78]. Collectively, these studies demonstrate the significant multitarget, multi-pathway
effects of TCM in treating ALS. The application of network pharmacology combined with
in vitro experiments can provide a scientific basis for fully uncovering
the therapeutic mechanisms of TCM and open novel avenues for developing new drugs
for ALS treatment.
Application of traditional Chinese medicine in multiple sclerosis
Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a chronic central nervous system disease, which primarily
affects young adults, especially women. Approximately 2.5 million people worldwide
suffer from MS. The disease is characterized by demyelination within the central nervous
system, causing various neurological dysfunctions, including motor impairment, sensory
abnormalities, and cognitive decline [79]. The pathogenesis of MS is complex, involving immune system abnormalities, neuroinflammation,
and axonal damage [80]. Existing treatments for MS mainly depend on immunomodulatory drugs such as interferon-β and corticosteroids. While these drugs can delay disease recurrence, they cannot
stop its progression, and long-term use may cause severe side effects [81]. Therefore, developing multitarget therapeutic strategies, particularly those based
on natural compounds, has been a research focus. Noor et al.
constructed a drug–target–disease network, finding that the key effective components
of Yishen Daluo decoction included quercetin and kaempferol. Protein-protein interaction
network analysis revealed that IL-6 and AKT1 were the key targets. In vitro experiments suggested that Yishen Daluo decoction reduced lipopolysaccaride-induced
inflammatory responses, revealing its potential therapeutic mechanisms in MS [82]. To sum up, integrating network pharmacology and in vitro experimental verification can efficiently discover TCM targets for MS treatment,
and provide the targeted treatments. The integrated method illustrates the TCM mechanisms
in MS treatment and establishes a solid foundation for individualized treatments and
drug development. The network pharmacology of TCM in treating neurodegenerative diseases
is presented in [Table 2].
Table 2 Network pharmacology of TCM in treating neurodegenerative diseases.
Reference
|
Disease
|
Formulas and herbs
|
Subjects
|
Main compounds
|
Main target
|
Main signaling pathway
|
Outcome
|
[46]
|
AD
|
Paeoniflorin
|
In vivo experiment
|
Paeoniflorin
|
Multiple targets
|
PI3K-AKT
|
Demonstrates neuroprotective effects
|
[47]
|
AD
|
Qin-Zhi-Zhu-Dan formula
|
Network pharmacology analysis
|
Multiple effective components
|
Multiple targets
|
PI3K-AKT
|
Enhances neuroprotective effect of the formulation
|
[48]
|
AD
|
Arisaema Rhizome
|
Molecular docking in network pharmacology
|
Active compounds of Arisaema Rhizome
|
Multiple targets
|
Multiple pathways
|
Reveals the potential therapeutic effects of Arisaema Rhizome
|
[49]
|
AD
|
Drug repurposing strategy
|
Protein-protein interaction networks
|
Multiple drugs
|
Multiple protein networks
|
Protein interaction pathways
|
Identifies the potential therapeutic drugs for AD
|
[55]
|
PD
|
Tianma Pingchan granules
|
Rat model
|
Multiple effective components
|
Neural junction-related pathways
|
PI3K-AKT
|
Alleviates symptoms related to PD
|
[56]
|
PD
|
Jichuan decoction
|
Transcriptome analysis
|
Multiple effective components
|
Key genes
|
Critical signaling pathways
|
Reduces inflammation and neurodegenerative factors
|
[57]
|
PD
|
Ginseng
|
Neuron cell model
|
Ginseng extracts
|
Multiple targets
|
PI3K-AKT
|
Inhibits apoptosis and protects neurons
|
[58]
|
PD
|
Dihuang decoction
|
Animal model
|
Multiple active ingredients
|
Neuroprotective targets
|
NF-κB
|
Shows significant neuroprotective effects
|
[59]
|
PD
|
Liuwei Dihuang pills
|
Neuron cell model
|
Components of Liuwei Dihuang pills
|
Multiple targets
|
Inflammation pathway
|
Reduces inflammation and inhibits apoptosis
|
[63]
|
HD
|
TCM compound formula
|
Network pharmacology analysis
|
Multiple compounds
|
Multiple targets
|
Inflammation pathways
|
Reduces inflammation and improves symptoms
|
[64]
|
HD
|
Novel TCM formula
|
Molecular docking and in vitro experiments
|
Multiple compounds
|
Multiple targets
|
Inflammation and neuroprotection pathways
|
Demonstrates significant neuroprotective effects
|
[65]
|
HD
|
Natural compounds from Dictyostelium discoideum
|
Neuronal cell model
|
Multiple compounds
|
Multiple targets
|
Apoptosis and inflammation pathways
|
Demonstrates significant cell protective effects
|
[66]
|
HD
|
Active components of TCM
|
Network pharmacology analysis
|
Multiple TCM components
|
Multiple targets
|
Neuroprotection and apoptosis pathways
|
Shows strong neuroprotective effects
|
[72]
|
ALS
|
Bu-Shen-Jian-Pi decoction
|
Neuron and muscle cell models
|
Multiple effective components
|
Multiple targets
|
Oxidative stress and inflammation pathways
|
Relieves hypoxia and muscle atrophy, improves motor function
|
[73]
|
ALS
|
Bu-Shen-Jian-Pi decoction
|
ALS rat model
|
Multiple components
|
Multiple targets
|
Neuroinflammation and oxidative stress pathways
|
Delays disease progression and improves motor function
|
[74]
|
ALS
|
Strychnos nux-vomica
|
Neuron cell model
|
Extract of Strychnos nux-vomica
|
Multiple targets
|
Neuroinflammation pathways
|
Demonstrates significant neuroprotective effects
|
[75]
|
ALS
|
Prepared rehmannia
|
Cell model
|
Extracts of prepared rehmannia
|
Multiple targets
|
Inflammation and apoptosis pathways
|
Inhibits apoptosis and inflammation significantly
|
[81]
|
MS
|
Yishen Daluo decoction
|
Immune cell model and animal experiments
|
Multiple components
|
Multiple targets
|
PI3K-AKT
|
Reduces inflammation and protects neurons
|
[82]
|
MS
|
Nigella sativa
|
Neuroinflammation model
|
Extract of Nigella sativa
|
Multiple targets
|
Immune pathways
|
Demonstrates strong anti-inflammatory effects and reduces inflammatory cytokines
|
Limitations and Improvement Directions of Network Pharmacology
Limitations and Improvement Directions of Network Pharmacology
Although network pharmacology has shown significant potential in elucidating the complex
mechanisms of TCM in treating neurodegenerative diseases, its development still faces
the challenges. Firstly, existing databases suffer from outdated information and limited
coverage, making it difficult to comprehensively reflect the multidimensional characteristics
of Chinese herbal medicine. Future research should concentrate on dynamically updating
and expanding databases to incorporate omics data such as genomics, proteomics, and
metabolomics, while also enhancing data standardization to guarantee the integrity
and consistency of compound information.
Secondly, most network pharmacology models are static and fail to simulate the dynamic
processes of drugs in vivo, particularly in multicomponent TCM formulas where time-dependent effects and synergistic
actions have not been fully explored. The introduction of dynamic pharmacokinetic
models, time-series analysis, and multiscale modeling will help to uncover the metabolic
pathways and dynamic synergistic effects of TCM components in vivo, therefore providing more accurate theoretical support for multitarget therapies.
Moreover, the variability of TCM formulations, which results from differences in origin,
processing methods, and storage conditions, can lead to discrepancies in model predictions.
Standardized analysis using chemical fingerprinting and metabolomics techniques, integrating
variability data, and establishing dynamic adjustment mechanisms in models can effectively
improve the reliability and applicability of predictions.
Insufficient experimental validation is another limiting factor. The lack of experimental
support for computational predictions may restrict their clinical translation value.
Combining efficient experimental systems such as organoid models, microfluidic chips,
as well as cell experiments and animal models, can provide multilayered validation
of network pharmacology predictions, providing strong support for practical applications.
Finally, personalized medicine is a vital direction for future development. Current
models have not adequately considered the impact of individual genetic differences
on responses to TCM treatments. Future research should integrate genomics and epigenetics
to build personalized models, enabling the development of precise treatment plans
that enhance efficacy and minimize adverse reactions. By integrating multi-omics data,
dynamic modeling, and efficient experimental validation, network pharmacology is poised
to further advance the modernization of TCM and precision medicine, thus offering
innovative solutions for neurodegenerative diseases.
Contributorsʼ Statement
Data collection: Q. Chen, G. H. Chen; Design of the study: Q. Chen, Q. Y. Wang; Statistical
analysis: Q. Chen; Analysis and interpretation of the data: Q. Chen, G. H. Chen, Q. Y.
Wang; Drafting the manuscript: Q. Chen, G. H. Chen; Critical revision of the manuscript:
Q. Y. Wang.