Keywords
diaphragm - trauma - empyema
Traumatic diaphragmatic injury, which was first described by Sennertus in 1541, remains
a diagnostic challenge for surgeons.[1] It occurs in ∼3 to 7% cases of abdominal or thoracic trauma.[2] Traumatic diaphragmatic injury is caused by blunt traumas in 75% of the cases and
by penetrating traumas in 25% of the cases.[3] In penetrating traumas of the lower thoracic region, diaphragmatic injuries are
observed in 15% cases of stab wounds and 46% cases of gunshot wounds.[4] As traumatic diaphragmatic injuries are difficult to diagnose, a delayed diagnosis
is common; the delay may extend from a few days to decades, even to 50 years.[5] These injuries involve the herniation of abdominal contents into the thorax. The
symptoms of delayed traumatic diaphragmatic hernia are mainly related to gastroenterological
obstruction, such as nausea or vomiting.[3] We present the rare case of delayed traumatic diaphragmatic hernia masquerading
as empyema without any gastroenterological symptoms.
Case Report
A 55-year-old man presented with left chest pain and intermittent spiking fever for
2 days. The chest pain was aggravated on taking a deep breath or on changing the body
position. He had dyspnea but no coughing, nausea, or vomiting. His previous medical
history included penetrating trauma of the left posterior lower chest, which was caused
by a screwdriver, complicated with hemothorax 20 years ago. At that time, he underwent
chest tube insertion and then recovered without any operation.
At admission, the patient was 163 cm in height and 71 kg in weight. His temperature
was 39.4°C. His blood pressure was 120/90 mm Hg; pulse rate was 124 beats/min with
sinus tachycardia; and respiratory rate was 24 breaths/min. Physical examination showed
a decrease in breath sounds in the left lower chest with dullness on percussion. He
had a leucocyte count of 20,800/µL with 84% neutrophils, hemoglobin level of 13.6
g/dL, and platelet count of 24.1 × 104/µL. Results of the liver function, renal function,
and electrolyte tests were normal. A chest roentgenogram showed blunting of the left
costophrenic angle ([Fig. 1]). Chest sonography showed anechoic, complex, and nonseptated pleural fluid inside
the enlarged cavity in the left lower chest ([Fig. 2]). An ultrasound-guided thoracentesis was done, and muddy-brownish, foul-smelling
fluid was aspirated. Pleural fluid analysis showed a leucocyte count of 27,330/uL
with 97% neutrophils, glucose concentration of 14 mg/dL, lactic dehydrogenase (LDH)
level of 3278 IU/mL, and total protein concentration of 5 g/dL. The fluid was gram
positive, and the culture was positive for Klebsiella pneumoniae and group D Enterococcus. The initial diagnosis was left-side empyema on the basis of the clinical symptoms,
images, and the pleural fluid analysis. Owing to the patient’s respiratory distress,
we could not perform chest computed tomography. Due to his unstable and septic condition,
he was referred to a thoracic surgeon for decortication.
Figure 1 Chest roentgenogram showed left costophrenic angle blunting.
Figure 2 Chest sonography showed anechoic, complex, and nonseptated pleural fluid inside the
enlarged cavity in the left lower chest.
The patient underwent left posterolateral thoracotomy instead of video-assisted thoracic
surgery, because the patient could not tolerate one-lung ventilation. Much dark-reddish
turbid fluid inside the left chest cavity was removed. Then, a huge gangrenous stomach
herniating into the left chest cavity was observed during the operation. The herniated
stomach was resected via thoracoabdominal 55 stapler. A substantial amount of turbid,
foul-smelling fluid was observed within the gangrenous stomach. A 4-cm defect in the
left hemidiaphragm was found after the resection of the strangulated stomach ([Fig. 3]). The defect was primarily repaired with nonabsorbable sutures, and a chest tube
was placed in the left chest cavity. The postoperative course was uneventful. He was
discharged 18 days after the operation.
Figure 3 The opened, huge, dark-reddish strangulated stomach, 14 cm in maximal length, with
blackish necrotic mucosae.
Discussion
Traumatic diaphragmatic injury is a recognized consequence of high-velocity blunt
and penetrating trauma to the abdomen or chest.[6] However, delayed diagnoses are common in patients with minor traumas or multiple
injuries. Patients may present with nonspecific symptoms and complain of chest pain,
abdominal pain, dyspnea, tachypnea, and cough.[7] In 1974, Grimes described the three phases of traumatic diaphragmatic injuries,
namely, acute phase, latent phase, and obstructive phase.[8] The acute phase extends from the time of original trauma to the diaphragm to the
apparent recovery from the incurred injuries. Subsequently, the latent phase follows,
wherein the intra-abdominal viscera occupy the defect and variably herniate into the
thoracic cavity. The obstructive phase is complicated by the signs of visceral obstruction
or strangulation, which manifest as herniation. Due to associated injuries, shock,
respiratory insufficiency, coma, and the obscure nature of diaphragmatic injuries,
the diagnosis of diaphragmatic injuries is frequently missed in the acute phase, and
it is only diagnosed after presentation of obstructive symptoms.[3]
The patient had a past medical history of penetrating trauma in the left lower chest.
Traumatic diaphragmatic injury occurred and progressed to the latent phase wherein
a portion of the stomach, supposedly the fundus, herniated into the chest cavity.
The herniation probably enabled the smooth passage of food through the stomach. This
was the reason that he did not have any obstructive symptoms of the gastrointestinal
tract. After 20 years, the herniated stomach was enlarged and strangulated with turbid
fluid inside. The diaphragmatic herniation was not suspected before because the patient
did not present any gastroenterological symptoms. The sonographic pattern of empyema
was mimicked by the herniated stomach. Ultrasound-guided thoracentesis was performed,
and fluid analysis met the criteria for empyema, that is, leukocytosis, low pH (<7.20),
low glucose concentration (<60 mg/dL), high LDH, elevated protein levels, and the
presence of gram-positive infectious organisms. Empyema was misdiagnosed according
to clinical symptoms, findings of chest sonography, and analysis of thoracentesis.
In the first step of investigation, chest roentgenogram could diagnose 40.7% of diaphragmatic
hernia.[3] The diagnostic findings are gas bubbles in the chest, a nasogastric tube in the
chest, irregularity of the diaphragmatic outline, elevated diaphragm, mediastinal
shift without pulmonary or intrapleural causes, and compression atelectasis of the
lower lobe.[3]
[5] A gastrografin swallow X-ray, showing an outline of the esophagus and stomach, would
also have resulted in the correct preoperative diagnosis of diaphragmatic hernia.[3] Generally, chest computed tomography facilitates the diagnosis of diaphragmatic
hernia.[1] The common signs of diaphragmatic hernia on chest computed tomography are herniation
of intra-abdominal organs into the hemithorax, absent diaphragm sign, and a defect
of the diaphragm.[1] Unfortunately, because of respiratory distress, the patient did not undergo gastrografin
swallow X-ray and chest computed tomography before the operation. He underwent thoracotomy
for empyema, but the strangulated stomach herniating into the pleural cavity was seen
intra-operatively.
In conclusion, the diagnosis of diaphragmatic injury in trauma patients remains a
challenge for surgeons. Lower chest and abdominal traumas are associated with high
risks of diaphragmatic injury, especially in penetrating traumas. Delayed diagnosis
of traumatic diaphragmatic injury can lead to traumatic diaphragmatic hernia after
a long time. Surgical management is the only option for such patients. Irrespective
of the symptoms presented, delayed traumatic diaphragmatic hernia should always be
suspected in patients with a past medical history of lower chest or abdominal trauma
that may have occurred many years ago. A gastrografin swallow X-ray and a chest computed
tomography should be performed in these patients to exclude delayed traumatic diaphragmatic
hernia.
