Key words
adolescence - hormone replacement - puberty - disturbance of puberty
Schlüsselwörter
Adoleszenz - Hormonsubstitution - Pubertät - Störung der Pubertät
Introduction and Status of Research
Introduction and Status of Research
Physical symptoms
KS is part of the clinical picture of hypogonadotropic hypogonadism (HH) [3], [4]. A congenital genetic
defect causes the bodyʼs own oestrogen production (or testosterone production in
affected men) to be disrupted [3], [4]. The prevalence of KS is 1 : 40 000 among women
[5]. It is diagnosed much more rarely in women
than in men (prevalence 1 : 8000 to 1 : 10 000) [6].
KS differs from other forms of HH due to a limited or absent sense of smell
(anosmia) [5], [7], [8]. Women with KS have very low LH (luteinising
hormone) levels and FSH (follicle-stimulating hormone) levels in their blood.
The reason for this is a lack of GnRH (gonadotropin-releasing hormone), which in
turn is the cause of female ovary dysfunction [9], [10]. The physical effects of this
lack of sex hormones are insufficiently developed secondary sexual
characteristics [9], [10].
The symptoms experienced by affected women are a lack of menstruation (primary
amenorrhea), no breast development [8], [11], small ovaries, an absence of folliculogenesis,
and no development of gametes [11]. Normal pubic hair
can also be absent due to the lack of oestrogen or nevertheless develop due to
the hormones of the adrenal gland [8], [12]. The lack of oestrogen causes vaginal dryness,
which is often painful and unpleasant for those affected. The sex hormone
deficiency leads to lower sexual needs, less sexual contact and infertility
[13]. Prepubescent growth is normal. However,
affected women fall behind in growth during puberty [11], [14]. The absent pubescent growth
spurt is nevertheless made up for during the time following puberty [8], [14]. As a result of the
lack of oestrogen, osteoporosis occurs frequently in sufferers [8].
KS in women (as well as in men) is treated with sex hormones. In order to
stimulate the physical development of sexual characteristics, the administering
of oestrogen is begun, initially at a low dose of 1 mg of oestradiol, then
slowly increasing in dose [8], [12], [15]. From the 2nd year of treatment,
the oestradiol is supplemented with chlormadinone acetate [12], [15]. If there is a desire for
pregnancy, treatment with GnRH is recommended to stimulate the production of LH
and FSH. The chances of success of this treatment are estimated as good [10]. Alternatively, LH or FSH can be administered
directly [8], [10].
It is possible to diagnose KS prior to puberty; the absence of a sense of smell
(anosmia) can be an indicator here [15]. It is
important to test the sense of smell using a smell test [8] in order to distinguish KS from delayed puberty and other forms of
HH [8], [12]. The symptoms
of KS become apparent during puberty if no physical pubescent development occurs
after the 13th year of life. However, a medical investigation is advised if no
breast growth has yet occurred in girls by the age of 14.5 years at the latest
[12]. Primary amenorrhea is found in 90 % of
women with HH [15]. KS is diagnosed by investigating
the development of secondary sexual characteristics, by examining the family
history, and using a cranial CT or MRI. The concentrations of LH, FSH, PBI and
oestradiol in the blood of those affected are examined, as these are very low in
KS [15]. Kallmann Syndrome is also diagnosed in women
in connection with investigations into an unfulfilled desire to have children
[16].
Mental impacts
Medical research is primarily concentrated on the somatic backgrounds and aspects
of KS. Studies of the physical symptoms of KS enable conclusions to be drawn
that mental impairment and pressures also occur as a result of the absent
physical pubescent development and lack of oestrogen in KS.
Tsimaris, Vrachnis, Iliodromiti and Deligeorglou [13]
indicate the difficult situation of pubescent girls diagnosed with HH. The
emotions of the girls and parents are described as “shocked”, “confused” and
“devastated” ([13], S. 2). This is caused by the fear
of infertility and stigmatisation due to the illness [13]. Parental understanding and encouragement are advised to support
girls during mood swings. The risk that those affected can become insecure and
withdrawn due to HH is highlighted [14]. In
connection with delayed puberty, Land [14] shows that
delayed physical maturation in children can cause “considerable mental conflict
situations” (p. 633). It is also advised that affected girls are encouraged not
to seek the causes of HH within themselves [13].
Young women feel significantly restricted in their sexuality due to the low
libido caused by KS [13]. This can lead to severe
psychosexual pressures in later life. Well-coordinated oestrogen treatment and,
where necessary, sex therapy are recommended as support [13]. The treatment guidelines of the German Society of Paediatrics
and Adolescent Medicine [15] and Han and Bouloux
[17] advise that girls and boys with KS receive
psychotherapy in severe cases. Individual example cases from studies of men with
KS [18], [19], [20], [21], [22] show insecurities, self-esteem problems and social
exclusion as an indirect consequence of the lack of physical development.
As there is a sex hormone disturbance in KS, it could be assumed that a gender
identity disorder is possible. There are hardly any research findings into an
atypical development of sexual identity in women with KS. Meyenburg and Sigusch
[24] report on just two cases where gender
identity developed atypically in men, so, analogously to this, it can be assumed
that an undisturbed and unremarkable gender identity also develops in women with
KS.
The British psychotherapist Neemuchwala described in his case reports [20], [21], [22] that patients experience both mental and social
difficulties as a result of the disrupted physical development, caused by
insecurities with regard to their own bodies. The insecurity of patients ranges
from feelings of shame to an impairment in self-image and self-esteem [20], [21], [22]. Neemuchwala [20], [21], [22]
and Bobrow et al. [19] report on exclusion and
harassment by peers. Hefner et al. [18] indicate
difficulties in mental and sexual development as well as self-doubt resulting
from eunuchoid habitus due to negative experiences of sexual development. Even
though there is a lack of corresponding findings in women with regard to the
consequences of KS, it seems likely that such experiences and limitations are
also perceived by women.
In a field report written in the form of a first-person account [23], a female student reports on her experiences with
KS. During the pubescent period, she developed strong feelings of alienation
from her peers when these underwent further physical developments. The author
disguised herself to appear “normal” (ibid., p. 9). She developed a high level
of dissatisfaction with her body and, subsequently, self-esteem problems. She
stated that the absent puberty was something to which she “was not entitled”
(ibid.). The author described her confusion about this and her inability to
express the lack of development in words, as well as to talk about her shame and
fear regarding her lack of physical development. The mental pressures also
remained when she was diagnosed and received hormone treatment. The author
emphasises that she never experienced pain due to the somatic stress, and the
stresses caused by KS were of a purely psychosocial nature. The impairments
became clear to her in a social setting and could not be rectified using hormone
therapy. Ultimately, the author was able to work on her mental difficulties with
the help of psychotherapy.
In order to gain more data material on these mental accompanying symptoms and the
experience of KS among patients, which is essential for the targeted support of
patients, a study was conducted on the mental impacts of KS at the University
Medical Centre Hamburg-Eppendorf. A qualitative approach was chosen for this
research project in order to investigate the stresses experienced from the
viewpoint of patients. The present investigation complements the study on men
with KS. [1]. Research findings from a comparison
between the mental impacts of KS in men and women are also being prepared for
publication.
The central research questions for the investigations into the mental impacts of
KS in women are:
-
What experiences and stresses are perceived by women with KS in the areas
of life affected by KS? Here, there is the key question of which areas
of life are influenced by the absent physical and sexual development in
KS?
-
Which coping strategies with regard to the lack of physical development
prove to be successful from the womenʼs viewpoint?
Methodology
The present investigation is part of a larger research project by the University
Medical Centre Hamburg-Eppendorf into the mental impacts of Kallmann Syndrome. The
Ethics Commission of the Hamburg Chamber of Psychotherapists has approved this
project.
A qualitative research design was chosen in order to produce the largest possible
quantity of data to explore and structure the field. Open interviews were conducted
with the study participants in a two-person setting. In addition to this qualitative
data collection, data were collected with questionnaires, the results of which will
be published elsewhere. The questionnaires looked at demographic and social aspects,
physical characteristics and their development, diagnosis and treatment measures,
the experience of puberty, and sexuality. The following standardised questionnaires
were also presented to the participants for completion: Questionnaires on Gender
Identity, Bem Sex-Role Inventory, Fbek, BSI, Dissociation Questionnaire (DIS-Q),
Questionnaire on Life Satisfaction (FLZ).
Acquisition of participants
Prior to the study, practice-based doctors and hospital-based doctors in the
fields of Endocrinology, Gynaecology and Reproductive Medicine throughout
Germany were informed and consulted about the project. The aim was to find men
and women diagnosed with KS to participate in interviews. Contacts with
self-help groups were used as an additional acquisition source. An information
sheet was published on websites and newsgroups relating to KS, hypogonadism, a
desire to have children, and endocrinology in order to draw attention to the
study, provide information on the study and obtain participants.
Implementation
To collect the individual experiences of those affected, individual interviews
(two-person setting) were conducted with the aid of a concept map ([Fig. 1]) developed specially for this project.
Fig. 1 Concept Map.
This “map”, which is based on previous research findings, was presented to the
interviewees after the introductory phase to encourage the narrative flow and
permit additional topic-focussed information to be obtained [25]. This technique proved to be particularly helpful
in order to give some structure to the topic area and yet enable the interview
partners to report on their own experiences in as open and free a manner as
possible. It was explicitly highlighted that the Concept Map was intended to
provide suggestions, but the interview partners were not restricted to the
stated areas.
The interview technique enabled the participants (Ps) to represent their
experiences in a very personal way, as well as to highlight and address relevant
aspects [26], [27]
subjectively. All the key subjects were generally tackled by the Ps without
prompting, which is a good indication that the key topics in the Concept Map
largely match the experiences of the Ps. More in-depth questions were also asked
where required. These questions were developed based on literature research. The
interviews were conducted in neutral settings. The interviews lasted 45 to
109 min (range 64 min, average duration 65 min) and were recorded with digital
recording equipment. The transcription was performed according to the
transcription rules of Lucius-Hoene and Deppermann [28].
Random sample description
Five women diagnosed with KS took part in the study between April 2009 and
December 2009. Three of these were acquired over the Internet, two joined on the
recommendation of their doctors. The average age of the Ps was 30.8 years. KS
was diagnosed on average at 22.8 years. All the Ps had obtained their German
school-leaving qualifications (Abitur). The initial diagnosis states the age at
which the Ps first attracted medical attention. Despite the small patient sample
(n = 5), average ages and the standard deviation were calculated. The detailed
data can be found arranged in [Table 1].
Table 1 Age and time of diagnosis for the Ps at the time
the women were surveyed
Participant No.
|
Name/synonym
|
Age in years
|
Age at initial diagnosis in years
|
Age at KS diagnosis in years
|
* KS was diagnosed in the patient directly after KS was
diagnosed in her brother.
|
1
|
Jeannette
|
24
|
11
|
15
|
2
|
Laura
|
31
|
10
|
21
|
3
|
Marie
|
44
|
18
|
35
|
4
|
Paula
|
31
|
16
|
31
|
5
|
Stephanie*
|
24
|
12
|
12
|
Mean value
|
|
30.8
|
13.4
|
22.8
|
Standard deviation
|
|
7.30
|
3.07
|
8.91
|
Median
|
|
31
|
12
|
21
|
Range
|
|
20
|
7
|
23
|
Evaluation
The evaluation took place following the qualitative content analysis according to
Mayring [2] and with the aid of the MAXQDA 10 (MAX
Qualitative Data Analysis) evaluation programme. Interview sequences were
allocated to categories. Both inductive and deductive logic were applied in the
course of this. Some of the categories were developed from research concepts
based on the Concept Map and guiding questions (see [Fig. 1], e.g. according to experiences during diagnosis). The
interviews enabled the topics suggested by the Concept Map to be substantiated
or elaborated using individual experience. Other categories only arose when the
Ps mentioned them and thus represented new aspects that had been given little
consideration until that time. The results are shown below.
Results
The responses to the first question are shown below according to category. Each
section represents a category; a summary is given in [Table
3]. Personal experiences are shown using quotations in the words of the
interview partners. A summary of results is given in [Table
4].
Table 2 Age at first sexual intercourse and first sexual
experience without SI.
Participant No.
|
Name/synonym
|
Age 1st SI
|
Age 1st sexual experience without SI
|
1
|
Jeannette
|
19
|
19
|
2
|
Laura
|
21
|
19
|
3
|
Marie
|
21
|
16
|
4
|
Paula
|
17
|
14
|
5
|
Stephanie
|
19
|
18
|
|
|
|
|
Mean value
|
|
19.4
|
17.2
|
Standard deviation
|
|
1.50
|
1.93
|
Median
|
|
19
|
18
|
Range
|
|
4
|
5
|
Table 3 Categories of qualitative assessment.
|
Categories
|
1. The path to diagnosis and the diagnosis of Kallmann
Syndrome
|
|
2. Medical treatment following diagnosis
|
-
Medication
-
Treatment effect
|
3. Individual somatic symptoms of KS
|
-
Height
-
Sense of smell
-
Fertility
-
Sexuality
|
4. Mental and psychosocial effects of KS
|
-
Self-worth
-
Social relationships
|
5. Coping strategies
|
|
Table 4 Study results at a glance.
Body perception and shame
|
-
Confusion and insecurities regarding the absence of
expected pubescent development
-
First inklings and fears about delayed development, which
are difficult for the Ps to address
-
Delaying of a medical clarification; hope of being a
“late bloomer”
-
Shame regarding lack of physical development
(particularly menstruation)
-
In some cases, problems with growth
-
Anosmia of little concern
|
Effects of hormone therapy on the psyche
|
|
Diagnosis and treatment
|
-
In some cases, initial diagnosis of oestrogen
deficiency
-
Fear, shock, but also relief and hope for a cure due to
medical diagnosis
-
Examinations are perceived as stressful, as too little
attention is paid to the mental aspects, in
particular
-
Treatment of KS with hormone therapy (no difference to
treatment for oestrogen deficiency); change to hormone
therapy following KS diagnosis for only one P
|
Physical development following hormone treatment
|
|
Sexuality
|
-
Sexual disinterest prior to hormone therapy
-
In some cases, very low sexual interest, even during
hormone treatment
-
Feelings of shame and inhibitions in allowing
intimacy
|
Fertility
|
|
Coping strategies, resources and assistance in handling KS
|
-
Conversations
-
Emphasis on normal physical development
-
Good dissemination of information
-
Physical development through hormone therapy
-
Where required, offers of psychotherapy or sex
therapy
|
Desire for better handling of KS
|
-
Comprehensive view of KS, including its mental and
psychosocial impacts
-
More sensitive explanation by doctors
-
Where required, assistance through psychotherapy or sex
therapy
|
Body perception and shame
When asked how they perceived their bodies before starting hormone therapy, the
Ps reported on confusion and insecurity regarding the absence of their expected
pubescent physical development. The women also said that they had an “inkling”
that they “were different”. As it became clear that the other girls had “passed
them by” in their physical development, they became aware that their development
was lagging behind.
And then they all pulled away and I stayed still, in every respect: height,
build, interests. All the things that happen then. (Jeannette, 24 years)
I was twelve, thirteen at this summer camp. When I saw my past best friend in
the shower, and that she was also wearing a bra, it felt like such a
betrayal. As in: oh, no, not you as well, donʼt you leave me now too.
Because I noticed that they were changing in a way that I couldnʼt keep up
with. (Jeannette, 24 years)
I always thought that I just wasnʼt a normal woman. (Laura, 31 years)
In addition to the lack of physical development, the absence of menstruation
played a crucial role as, for the Ps, it was a symbol of the absence of their
maturation into women. The childlike body was not feminine enough for them and
they were therefore ashamed of it. This was expressed in shyness towards their
peers. Three Ps said that they also remained childlike in terms of their
interests and did not share the pubescent interests of their peers (“Boys,
make-up, buying bras, fashion”) (Jeannette, 24 years). One P reported that she
still “feels like a little girl” today (Paula, 31 years).
Iʼll never have periods and I found that really embarrassing, as this makes
me different as well. I was so shy. I wasnʼt really a huge outsider,
but inside I really felt like that. (Marie, 44 years)
The Ps told themselves they were a “late bloomer” (Paula, 31 years) to explain
their condition. A medical diagnosis was initially delayed in the hope of a
simple solution, which was supposed to appear in a natural way without the
patients doing anything.
I am now 31 and, of course, I didnʼt just notice yesterday that something
isnʼt right. I didnʼt have any periods that began on their own and the other
physical developments that occur some time at the beginning of puberty, they
didnʼt happen either. Of course, I then asked myself: “Why? How come? What
for?” – “Oh, itʼll happen. Youʼre just a late bloomer.” (Paula, 31
years)
Late developer, weʼre all late in our family. We all look a bit younger.
Itʼll still happen. (Stephanie, 24 years)
As a central source of stress, all the surveyed women highlighted that they had
noticed at an early stage that something was not right in their development but
were unable to express this in words, and they were also lacking a suitable
point of contact.
I was 21 and then went and got the diagnosis. I asked whether it was
necessary that I have periods. Then he (the doctor, addition by interviewer)
said: “No, itʼs just a matter of hormones.” Then I pretty much just put up
with it for ten years and didnʼt have any more periods. (Laura, 31
years)
For three of the Ps, the absence of growth during puberty led to insecurities and
teasing. However, once they began hormone therapy, growth continued.
Anosmia was not perceived as a major impairment by the Ps. They do not consider
the lack of a sense of smell to be a major deficit. Despite this, the Ps spoke
of insecurities in terms of hygiene and fears of not noticing dangers in good
time, such as gas leaks or smoke. Nevertheless, this barely represented a
constraint on their quality of life.
But having this fact that you canʼt smell and you also canʼt change it,
youʼve just got to come to terms with it. (Laura, 31 years)
Interaction between hormone therapy and psyche
In addition to feelings of shame with regard to her own body and the resulting
insecurities when approaching her peers, one P spoke of severe mood swings and
feelings of depression as part of hormone therapy.
I was first given Trisequens. Six months later the effect had subsided. So,
none of the positive effects remained, apart from the periods. Then there
was Trisequens Forte. This also had a positive effect for six months, at
least on the way I felt in general. And then that was it. … After Trisequens
Forte, when they didnʼt want to give me anything else, after that things
pretty much went downhill with my physical health and self-perception, as
well as my psyche and everything else. (Paula, 31 years)
During the consultation, I explained to him (the doctor, addition by
interviewer) that things werenʼt going well for me at all. (Paula, 31
years)
Diagnosis and treatment
KS was diagnosed among the Ps at 22.8 years on average. For three women, a lack
of oestrogen was diagnosed beforehand. For one P, anosmia was diagnosed at the
age of 10. However, no connection with KS was seen at that time. For one
participant, KS was diagnosed directly as a result of the diagnosis of KS in her
brother.
On average, the Ps first attracted attention in connection with KS at 13.4 years.
KS was only diagnosed on average 9.4 years later (c. f. [Table 1]).
Of course, weʼd known for a long time that I have hormone problems. I was
first given substitution when I was 16. We either never told the
Gynaecologist that I canʼt smell because we didnʼt link the two things at
all, or he didnʼt know. Then, at some point, I went to a Hormone Clinic and
just mentioned in passing that I couldnʼt smell. Then something “clicked”
with the member of staff. Since then, Iʼve just assumed that I have
Kallmann. (Laura, 31 years)
KS was diagnosed in all the Ps via the lack of a sense of smell and by examining
blood test results. When talking about the diagnosis of KS, the Ps describe
feelings between shock and fear, but also relief about the clarification and
hope for improvement.
“But itʼs not all that bad. When itʼs all treated properly, I can still lead
a somewhat fulfilled life.” Thatʼs what he (the doctor, addition by
interviewer) said. And I was so shocked back then because, apart from
this feeling of “something isnʼt right about me, something is strange and
different”, otherwise I didnʼt know anything at all, and then bam!
that gets thrown at you. (Jeannette, 24 years)
When you finally know what it is, you might finally be able to
do something about it. Now that you know what it is, you can tackle it. The
diagnosis itself actually brought out the sun. (Paula, 31 years)
The examinations as part of treatment were described as stressful by all of the
Ps. The lack of support from doctors was addressed by four of the five Ps, as
these did not pay enough attention to their mental stress during hormone
treatment.
Medical treatment began with the diagnosis. It was approximately the same for all
the women. It took place by administering sex hormones. Four Ps tolerated this
treatment well; one P, however, had great difficulties with this treatment,
which expressed themselves in depressive moods and physical symptoms. For one P
initially diagnosed with oestrogen deficiency, medicinal treatment was
nevertheless altered due to depressive moods after KS was diagnosed. KS was
diagnosed in this patient shortly before the interview, and she hoped that the
diagnosis would bring with it optimised medication along with an improvement in
her mental condition.
Physical development following hormone treatment
The Ps perceived the physical development stimulated by medication as a great
relief.
I was so delighted, I was so proud! Oh, my! That first blood-stained sanitary
towel that I had there. I really wanted to stick it into a diary or wave it
in the air! (Jeannette, 24 years)
The following physical developments associated with the hormone treatment were
described: breast growth, growth of the mammary glands, growth of pubic hair,
start of periods, widening of the hips. One P found that the physical
development triggered by medication was not sufficient for her and her body did
not become feminine enough. She subsequently decided to have breast enlargement
surgery.
Sexuality
Four Ps described their sex lives as very problematic and stressful. They
experienced sexual disinterest prior to hormone therapy. Two of them suffered
from low or non-existent libido, even with continued treatment. Two women said
that no libido developed despite the hormone therapy, which led to problems in
their relationships and put the Ps under severe pressure.
At the most, it only played a role in this sense if itʼs linked to Kallmann,
which Iʼm assuming here, that my sexual activity just isnʼt particularly
high. (Laura, 31 years)
In addition to this, both these women and two other women were severely inhibited
as soon as it came to sexual contact. This led to insecurities and avoidance of
contact with the opposite sex.
The average age of the Ps at first sexual intercourse was 19.4 years (range 3
years, median 19 years). The Psʼ first sexual contact without sexual intercourse
(SI) was at 17.2 years (range 5 years, median 18 years). A detailed breakdown is
given in [Table 2].
As I had a really horrible body image, there was naturally no lust felt at
all. Because this embarrassment was in the foreground. (Marie, 44 years)
Yes, the first step, before I got together with the guy, was that I tried to
satisfy myself, which didnʼt really work either. That was the first step and
the first interest in that. Then just a bit of petting with him. But it
wasnʼt much more than that. With my present husband, it took around two
years before we were able to sleep with each other for the first time.
(Laura, 31 years)
First of all, you had to find a guy who didnʼt think you were a child. Then
you had to like him. But whenever it got to the point where he put his hand
under your blouse or even above it, hey! Back off! Back off! So, it wasnʼt
easy. Then it was more about how to endure it, how to bring yourself to do
it and not show the other person that youʼre not like other people. (Paula,
31 years)
Fertility
Introducing ovulation in women with KS requires treatment with HCG, hMG or GnRH
[9], [10]. The chances
of conception are 30 % per ovulation [9]. Treatment
with LH and FSH increases the chances to 70 % [9].
The diagnosis of KS triggered depression and fear in all the women with regard to
pregnancy, as well as uncertainties relating to medical treatment.
What was really bad for me was that when he (the doctor, addition by
interviewer) told me what was wrong with me, he then told me, “itʼs possible
that you wonʼt be able to have children”. Iʼve got to say that was such a
slap in the face. My dream is to have children! (Stephanie, 24 years)
Well, in this respect, Iʼm more worried about the issue of what my child will
inherit or what itʼll be like for him. (Laura, 31 years)
One P resigned herself to not having children. One P, who was already pregnant,
described the corresponding medical treatment as good. Three additional Ps with
a desire to have children said they would rely on appropriate medical support
when the subject of children became relevant for them later on.
Yes, having the certainty or knowing what will happen to my children, if I
should ever have children, so whether they could have this as well and what
this chance is, et cetera. Simply getting more information when the time
comes. (Stephanie, 24 years)
Coping strategies, resources and assistance in handling KS
The Ps found it helpful to have conversations about KS within their family, with
friends, and later with their partners, who handled the subject of KS in an
understanding way. For one patient, the emphasis on normal development by her
parents was particularly valuable. Talking to other sufferers and the
dissemination of information via the Internet also helped to provide relief. It
was important to the Ps that they were well-informed about KS. If treatment
reduced the limitations caused by KS, the Ps perceived this normalisation of
their life situation as especially positive.
In order to reduce fear and uncertainties, three Ps underwent psychotherapy,
during which they achieved good results. Besides psychotherapy, one of these Ps
also made use of additional therapeutic services in the psychosomatic field, to
which she attributed the development of improved body perception and a healthy
self-image.
I would always swear that it has nothing to do with hormones, but itʼs simply
my psychotherapy. (Marie, 44 years)
Discussing her own body perception also helped her to develop a better feeling
about her sexuality.
I kept noticing how this shame side of me became smaller and the lust side
bigger, that suddenly a great deal was going well. (Marie, 44 years)
One P received particularly intensive assistance from her parents before and
after diagnosis, who placed great importance on normalising her development, so
that, consequently and thanks to an early diagnosis, she developed hardly any
insecurities with regard to her body. She also found discussions with her
brother, who is also affected by KS, to be positive.
As I said, from my brother, whoʼs also affected, thatʼs always helped me to
cope with it, how heʼs reacted in the situation. (Stephanie, 24 years)
At the time I was always told: youʼre developing in a really normal way. So,
it was always emphasised that youʼre completely normal. Theyʼre just sort of
being replaced, your hormones. Physical development happens just the same
way as for everyone else. Thatʼs why I thought, itʼll just happen, maybe a
bit later than for others, but itʼll just happen. Thatʼs why it was
completely normal for me, just like every other teenager, too. (Stephanie,
24 years)
The Ps said the following were particularly desirable when handling KS:
-
A comprehensive view of KS including its psychosocial effects
-
Psychotherapeutic support
-
A better and more sensitive explanation of KS as well as more interest
among doctors in an individualʼs problems regarding physical
development
Itʼs not a problem, this whole hormone part of it, you can regulate and
adjust all that. But what it means for a girl to be right in the middle of
it, nobody understood that and no one ever spoke to me about it. At least,
that someone could have drawn my attention to the fact that it also has
social implications and mental ones and also someone could at least have
shown me that I could also get psychological help. I mean, as a child, Iʼm
not going to think of that by myself.” (Jeannette, 24 years)
No one understood that my problem is absolutely not some hormones, but
instead how to get by in my social environment! (Jeannette, 24 years)
Discussion
The interview material made it possible to obtain a differentiated and broad range
of
data concerning the experience of KS among women. The study results support the
statements by Tsimaris et al. [13] on stresses caused by
diagnosis and on later mental pressures [13], [14]. The Ps reported on inhibitions when coming into
contact with the opposite sex and on difficulties in allowing physical proximity and
intimacy, caused by the shame they felt about their own bodies. Two of the five Ps
felt that their quality of life was restricted by their low libido [13] and due to the associated impacts on their
relationships. An adjustment to medication only provided relief to a limited extent
[15], including with regard to depressive moods
before and after hormone therapy. The significance of the results on the influence
of medication on the libido and mood is limited because of the small sample sizes,
as shown in the methodology section, and also the qualitative, explorative research
design. As a result, no further statements about the effects of hormone therapy on
mood, drive and libido can be made as part of this study. The medical literature on
the influence testosterone has on the mood of men affected by KS [15], [17], [29], [30] and the research
findings of the study by Hofmann et al. [1] on men
affected by KS who experience mood swings much more frequently allow us to assume
–
even with regard to the small female patient sample – that even more women with KS
could be affected by depressive moods. Further research into the effect of various
medications, the different dosages and the effect on the libido and mood are
required as part of a larger study.
None of the physical malformations, such as renal agenesis, bimanual synkinesis,
cleft palate, and tooth anomalies, that can occur in KS with a prevalence of 5–10 %
[3], [6], [8], were present in the investigated sample. Stress due to
osteoporosis was not addressed [8].
As part of the study, it became clear that there was a misdiagnosis or initial
diagnosis of oestrogen deficiency in some cases. In the sample, it took an average
of 9.4 years from the initial diagnosis until the diagnosis of KS. The problem of
misdiagnosis or initial diagnosis of oestrogen deficiency has scarcely been
investigated in the corresponding medical literature [9], [13]. Further studies in this regard are
advisable in order to verify how often such misdiagnoses occur in KS in women (which
could also be a reason for the differences in prevalence among the gender groups)
and whether medical treatment could be further optimised through a correct
diagnosis. It can, however, be assumed that most women largely felt they were
receiving adequate medical care with the diagnosis of oestrogen deficiency and thus
did not make any further efforts to obtain a medical diagnosis.
Besides the appropriate coordination of medical treatment, psychotherapeutic support
and, particularly where necessary, support relating to sex therapy and sex education
are to be advised as a matter of urgency [13], [17]. While Han and Bouloux [17]
express this recommendation for men, the present research findings suggest that
support within sex therapy is particularly relevant for women due to the low libido
and dry vagina [13]. Furthermore, the Ps found it
stressful that their bodies did not develop appropriately during puberty, which led
to major insecurities with regard to contact with girls of the same age and, above
all, with boys.
The account of one P can serve as an example of good, successful support for those
affected. During puberty, this P experienced hardly any stress and impacts caused
by
KS and did not feel restricted by KS, even in later life. She stressed that the
people around her always emphasised the normalisation of her development. She also
had the opportunity to exchange experiences with another sufferer, her brother. Her
early diagnosis was followed by appropriate treatment.
This explorative study raises further in-depth research questions that could
contribute to more differentiated findings and better, more appropriate treatment
for those affected:
-
How do the various medications influence the mood and libido of the affected
women?
-
What effects does early appropriate medication have on physical development
and self-perception?
-
Does an early diagnosis help to reduce the mental impacts caused by the lack
of physical development?
-
How relevant, with regard to the applied hormone therapy and mental impacts,
is the difference between the initial diagnosis of oestrogen deficiency and
the final diagnosis of KS?
-
What kinds of psychotherapeutic services are particularly helpful for those
affected and what form does appropriate therapeutic support take?
-
How can support within sex therapy and sex education be shaped?
Further research into the mental impact of KS on women is advised as there are very
few systematic studies in this research field, even fewer than on the mental impacts
of KS among men.
Conclusions
It became clear through the study that there are not only direct mental impacts and
stresses due to the hormone deficiency, but also indirect mental impacts and
stresses due to the lack of physical development, such as low libido or the
development of feelings of shame about oneʼs own body, and as a result of social
difficulties in how to make contact with men. KS should therefore not be viewed as
a
purely somato-medical problem, but instead the psychosocial aspects of KS should
also be perceived and noted as a limitation on quality of life. For women who react
sensitively to hormone treatment with mood swings, provisions should be made to
offer relief in this respect.
Psychological advice or a psychotherapist is to be recommended during the diagnosis
of KS as well as, where required, assistance in the form of sex education or sex
therapy.