Keywords regional limb perfusion - horse - amikacin sulphate - radiocarpal joint - tourniquet
Introduction
Intravenous regional limb perfusion (IVRLP) is an effective technique for delivering
high concentrations of antimicrobial agents to synovial structures of the distal limb
in horses suffering from septic arthritis or osteomyelitis.[1 ] Septic arthritis and osteomyelitis are challenging to treat and require immediate
aggressive treatment to save the career and even the life of affected horses.[2 ]
[3 ] Therapeutically effective antimicrobial tissue and synovial fluid concentrations
in the distal limb are difficult to reach through systemic routes of administration.[4 ] Also, administration of systemic antimicrobials may result in potentially fatal
side effects such as antibiotic-induced colitis, which can be avoided through local
administration.[5 ]
Amikacin sulphate is the most commonly used antimicrobial in IVRLP in both clinical
and experimental settings.[6 ]
[7 ]
[8 ]
[9 ]
[10 ]
[11 ]
[12 ]
[13 ]
[14 ]
[15 ]
[16 ] Amikacin sulphate is a concentration-dependent antibiotic medication of the aminoglycoside
class of antimicrobials that is active against most common aerobic pathogens isolated
from equine orthopaedic infections.[17 ] It is the most common choice of antimicrobial in cases of septic arthritis or osteomyelitis
prior to obtaining culture and sensitivity results.[18 ] Additionally, the concentration-dependent pharmacological activity of amikacin sulphate,
including its a long post-antibiotic effect, makes it a suitable candidate for delivery
of regional high concentrations.[19 ] The bactericidal effect and extent of post-antibiotic effect of amikacin sulphate
are dependent on the maximum concentration:minimum inhibitory concentration ratio
(Cmax :MIC) achieved in synovial fluid after administration.[19 ] A Cmax :MIC ratio of 8:1–10:1 has been suggested for effective treatment of orthopaedic infections
with amikacin sulphate in horses.[13 ]
[20 ]
Administration of amikacin sulphate through IVRLP avoids nephrotoxic effects associated
with prolonged systemic administration of aminoglycosides in horses, with expected
low serum concentrations also after the release of the tourniquet.[16 ] On the contrary to described positive aspects of a local administration, a recent
study concluded that intra-articular administration with as low as 250 mg amikacin
sulphate was markedly cytotoxic to joint cells.[21 ] Adverse effects of high amikacin sulphate concentrations to joint cells delivered
through IVRLP have not been investigated.
Intravenous regional limb perfusion in standing horses requires heavy sedation due
to pain and discomfort caused by the tourniquet.[22 ] Post-sedation effects are a concern in continuous treatment when daily heavy sedation
is required for an extended period, causing delayed gastric emptying which could lead
to colic.[23 ]
[24 ] Additionally, the use of tourniquets in human medicine has been associated with
ischaemia-reperfusion injuries, neural ischaemia and wound hypoxia, leading to a recommended
tourniquet application time of less than 1 hour.[25 ]
[26 ] In cattle, side effects due to reperfusion injury have been observed after 90 minutes
of tourniquet application time.[27 ] These adverse effects, although not investigated, could also be present in the equine
population advocating for the tourniquet application time to be as short as possible.
The current recommended tourniquet application time for standing horses in regional
limb perfusion is 30 minutes in clinical settings and in experimental studies.[1 ]
[28 ]
Several studies have investigated the ideal tourniquet application time for IVRLP
by comparing synovial fluid concentrations at different time points post-infusion.
Previously it has been suggested that the time to peak concentration (Tmax ) occurs 15 minutes post-infusion after IVRLP with 1.25 g of amikacin sulphate in
the lateral/medial palmar/plantar vein of horses under general anaesthesia.[9 ] A recent report concluded that 20 minutes of tourniquet application time resulted
in similar synovial fluid antimicrobial concentrations in both the radiocarpal joint
and metacarpophalangeal joint as did a 30 minute application time, when 1 g of amikacin
sulphate was infused in cephalic IVRLP utilizing a pneumatic tourniquet.[10 ] The same group found no significant difference in synovial fluid concentrations
of amikacin sulphate in the radiocarpal joint and metacarpophalangeal joint following
a 10 and a 30 minutes tourniquet application time.[29 ] In these studies, the joints were evaluated separately, only two time points were
compared and the synovial fluid amikacin sulphate concentration throughout the complete
tourniquet application time was not evaluated.
Based on a current literature search, there are no studies investigating the appropriate
tourniquet application time for cephalic IVRLP by synovial fluid sampling of the radiocarpal
joint in 5 minutes intervals. Such a model is needed to collect more data and enable
comparison between several time points throughout the first 30 minutes of tourniquet
application time. The aim of this study was to establish the time to peak concentration
(Tmax ) of amikacin sulphate in synovial fluid of the radiocarpal joint after cephalic IVRLP
with 2 g of amikacin sulphate in standing, sedated horses. Our hypothesis was that
the Tmax would occur before the 30-minute time point in all horses.
Materials and Methods
Animals
Six (n = 6) adult mixed breed mares were used in the study. The ages of the participating
horses ranged from 2 to18 years (median: 9.5 years) and their body weight ranged from
285 to 470 kg (median: 372 kg). Prior to commencement of the study, all horses underwent
thorough physical examinations and their haematology were assessed. Only horses with
no observed lameness at a walk, no evidence of orthopaedic problems on palpation and
normal clinical and haematological values were included. All horses were given tetanus
and influenza vaccinations 2 weeks prior to the initiation of the study and were housed
individually with hay and water ad libitum . The study was approved by the University Animal Care and Use Committee (MD-16–14812–3).
Regional Limb Perfusion and Sampling
One forelimb of each horse (n = 6) was randomly assigned to treatment (by coin toss). The area of the medial, palmar
and dorsal radius was aseptically prepared and local peri-neural anaesthesia was performed
with mepivacaine HCl 2% (Mepivacaine, Ceva Animal Health, Glenorie, Australia), to
desensitize the ulnar, median and musculocutaneous nerves, with a volume of 10 mL
at each location.[30 ] A 10 × 5 cm area overlying the cephalic vein at the level of the chestnut was clipped
and aseptically prepared. All horses received IV detomidine hydrochloride (Domosedan,
Orion Pharma Animal Health, Espoo, Finland) 0.01mg/kg and IV butorphanol tartrate
(Butomidor, Richter Pharma AG, Wels, Austria) 0.01 mg/kg, one time through IV injection,
prior to tourniquet application.
Two 10 cm rolled non-elastic gauze bandages (Sion Medical, Sderot, Israel) were placed
over the vasculature proximal to the prepared infusion site in the cephalic vein and
an 8 cm wide rubber Esmarch's tourniquet (Degania Medical, Degania Bet, Israel) was
placed on top of the gauze with the distal border of the tourniquet 5 cm proximal
to the chestnut. A 23 gauge and 2 cm long butterfly catheter was inserted in an aseptic
manner in the cephalic vein and directed distally. After blood flow into the extension
set was observed, the catheter was secured to the skin with cyanoacrylate adhesive.
Subsequently, the catheter was used for infusion of 4 mL (2 g) of amikacin sulphate
(Amikacin, Anfarm Hellas, Attiki, Greece), diluted in 96 mL of 0.9% NaCl to a total
volume of 100 mL.[16 ] The solution was manually infused continuously over ∼2 minutes, using five 20 mL
syringes.
The dorsal aspect of the carpus was clipped, and aseptically prepared one time. Synovial
fluid (1 mL) was collected percutaneously from the radiocarpal joint using a 21-gauge,
4 cm long needle between the distal radius and the proximal articular surface of the
radiocarpal bone, lateral to the extensor carpi radialis tendon while lifting the
forelimb in a slightly flexed position. Samples were collected in empty urine collection
tubes (BD Vacutainer, New Jersey, United States) before infusion (time 0) and at 5,
10, 15, 20, 25 and 30 minutes post perfusion. The tourniquet was kept in place during
the synovial sampling and removed 30 minutes after termination of the antimicrobial
infusion. Samples were centrifuged and the supernatant frozen at –80°C in empty 2 mL
plastic vials until processed for amikacin sulphate concentration determination 8
weeks after the samples were obtained.
After sampling was completed, all horses received phenylbutazone at 2.2 mg/kg IV twice
daily for 2 days. They were walked and evaluated daily for 7 days for lameness or
other complications related to venipuncture and arthrocentesis.
Synovial Fluid Preparation
Samples were prepared and analyzed using liquid chromatography/tandem mass-spectrometry
as previously described.[16 ] Briefly, synovial fluid samples were mixed with double-distilled water, followed
by acetonitrile for protein precipitation. The extract was mixed with hexane and dichloromethane
and finally, the aqueous phase was analysed by liquid chromatography/tandem mass-spectrometry.
Agilent 1200 (Agilent Technologies, Waldbronn, Germany) liquid chromatography system
(binary pump, degasser, heated column compartment and autosampler) connected to Applied
Biosystems API 4000 (Applied Biosystems, Toronto, ON, Canada) mass spectrometer was
utilized. The chromatographic separation was performed on a Symmetry C18 column (3.5
µ, 2.1 × 100 mm, Waters, Massachusetts, United States)
Calibration curves were prepared by adding known amounts of amikacin sulphate to drug-free
synovial fluid within the range of 0.5 to 2500 µg/mL.
Each calibration curve was prepared on three occasions, in triplicate on three different
days. The accuracy, intra-day and inter-day precision were calculated for the lower
level of quantification, the mid-level of quantification and the high level of quantification
(0.5, 250, 2,500 µg/mL).
Statistical Methods
Cmax and Tmax were determined by visual observation of the data. The sphericity assumption of the
data was assessed using Mauchly test of sphericity. Repeated measure analysis of variance
(ANOVA) test was used to assess the effects of time on synovial fluid amikacin sulphate
concentrations. The correlation between body weight and synovial fluid amikacin sulphate
concentration was assessed using Spearman correlation. Post-hoc analysis was performed
through repeated measures ANOVA pair wise comparisons default (Least Significant Difference
test). Statistical analyses were performed using statistical software program SPSS
(IBM SPSS STATISTICS software version 25, IBM, New York, United States). Statistical
significance was set at p < 0.05.
Results
All baseline synovial fluid amikacin sulphate concentrations were 0 µg/mL. The mean
synovial fluid amikacin sulphate Tmax was 15 minutes (range: 10–20 minutes) and the mean highest concentration (Cmax ) was 1153 µg/mL (range: 588–1950 µg/mL) ([Table 1 ]). There was no significant correlation between synovial fluid amikacin sulphate
concentration and body weight (Rho = 0.143, p = 0.79).
Table 1
Amikacin sulphate concentrations in radiocarpal joint synovial fluid from 5 to 30 minutes
after cephalic intravenous regional limb perfusion with 2 g of amikacin sulphate in
6 horses
Synovial fluid amikacin sulphate concentration over time
Time (min)
Horse A
310 kg µg/mL
Horse B
327 kg µg/mL
Horse C
470 kg µg/mL
Horse D
285 kg µg/mL
Horse E
466 kg µg/mL
Horse F
376 kg µg/mL
Mean
372 kg µg/mL
Standard deviation
5
185
115
337
437
807
175
343
256.6
10
442
479
849
561
1950
630
818
572.7
15
961
588
1010
616
1490
495
860
373.2
20
746
539
1110
1680
1720
343
1023
582.8
25
918
278
1040
680
1380
399
783
413.2
30
753
307
783
386
1030
534
632
272.6
Note: Maximum concentration (Cmax) in each horse is indicated with bold numbers. Standard
deviations are given to the mean Cmax at each time point. Values are given in µg/mL.
The mean synovial fluid amikacin sulphate concentration increased until 20 minutes
and, subsequently, decreased until 30 minutes which was the last sampling point ([Fig. 1 ]). The overall change in mean amikacin sulphate concentration was significant over
time. In post-hoc analysis mean amikacin sulphate synovial fluid concentrations at
all time points were significantly different to Time 0 and to the 5-minute time point.
For the remaining time points, significant differences were found in the mean amikacin
sulphate synovial fluid concentration only when comparing the concentration at 15 minutes
to 30 minutes ([Fig. 1 ]).
Fig. 1 Mean synovial fluid amikacin sulphate concentration at each time point with standard
error bars. The mean synovial fluid amikacin sulphate concentration increased until
20 minutes and, subsequently decreased until 30 minutes. Results of repeated measures
analysis of variance pair wise comparisons default (Least Significant Difference test)
showed significant differences between time points 0 and 5 minutes and all other time
points marked with “*” in the graph. p -Values for comparing time point 0 and other time points ranged between p = 0.002 and 0.022. p -Values for comparing time point 5 and other time points were between p = 0.003 and 0.022. A significant difference between time point 15 minutes and 30 minutes
is marked in the graph with “*.” p -Value for the difference between 15 and 30 minutes was p = 0.018.
No significant arthrocentesis or venipuncture related adverse effects were observed
throughout the study. Two horses had mild visible swelling at the site of infusion
throughout the IVRLP and were suspected to have minor perivascular administration
of the perfusate. All samples were obtained and analysed successfully. Accuracy of
the synovial fluid analysis was within the range of 92 to 107% and the precision was
within the range of 7.6 to 14.3%.
Discussion
The time of peak concentration of amikacin sulphate in the synovial fluid of the radiocarpal
joint, following IVRLP in standing horses, was observed between 10 and 20 minutes
from the completion of the amikacin sulphate infusion. This supports our hypothesis
that Tmax of amikacin sulphate in synovial fluid would occur before the 30-minute time point
when delivered through cephalic IVRLP in the current formulation. The findings of
this study were in agreement with the recent reports suggesting that 20 minutes of
tourniquet application time for IVRLP are sufficient to reach Tmax of amikacin sulphate in the distal interphalangeal and metacarpophalangeal joints.[9 ]
[10 ]
[31 ] Thus, the widely used and reported 30-minute tourniquet application time appears
excessive, when measuring concentrations of amikacin sulphate in the radiocarpal joint
and other joints. The accumulated data, from the current study and several other recent
studies,[9 ]
[10 ]
[31 ] may lead to an adjusted recommendation for shorter tourniquet application time but
should be interpreted with the knowledge that the study protocols in the current and
previous studies were not identical regarding dose of amikacin sulphate and perfusate
volume.
The findings of the current study differ from previous publications that found no
difference in synovial fluid amikacin sulphate concentrations between the 30-minute
time point and earlier sampling time points.[10 ]
[29 ] We found a significant reduction in the mean amikacin sulphate synovial fluid concentration
between the 15- and 30-minute time point and none of the included horses had a Tmax greater than 20 minutes. Although the highest mean synovial fluid concentration was
observed at the 20-minute time point, it was not significantly different to the 30-minute
time point. This is most likely due to the large standard error accompanying the mean
along with the small sample size ([Fig. 1 ]).
Repeated sedation is commonly needed to limit discomfort and movement throughout the
typically used 30 minutes tourniquet application time when performing IVRLP.[10 ] A shorter tourniquet application time results in a decreased amount of sedation
required for the procedure. In horses receiving daily IVRLP, the accompanying sedation
could increase the risk of colic since detomidine hydrochloride in combination with
butorphanol tartrate significantly delays gastric emptying rate.[23 ]
[24 ]
In addition, the risk of tourniquet side effects would potentially be decreased. Tourniquet
side effects have not been investigated in horses but are well known in human medicine
as post-tourniquet syndrome. Pain from neural ischaemia and complications in wound
healing due to wound hypoxia are complications associated with reperfusion injury
following prolonged tourniquet application (> 45–60 minutes).[25 ]
[26 ] The risk of these complications could all be decreased with a shorter tourniquet
application time. However, the clinical significance of shortening the time from 30 minutes
to 20 is speculative and both time points are shorter than the maximal recommended
tourniquet duration of 1 hour.[25 ]
[26 ]
In the present study, and in several previous IVRLP studies evaluating synovial fluid
amikacin sulphate concentrations in various joints in standing horses, synovial fluid
concentration varied widely among horses.[8 ]
[13 ]
[15 ]
[32 ] The large variability of antimicrobial synovial fluid concentrations in IVRLP has
been suggested to occur due to multiple reasons including tourniquet failure and drug
leakage to the systemic circulation caused by limb movement or faulty application
of the tourniquet.[8 ]
[13 ]
[15 ]
[32 ] The significance of the variability in synovial concentrations, is questionable
in the current study since concentrations achieved, did not indicate tourniquet failure
and reached above the MIC values of susceptible pathogens most commonly isolated from
orthopaedic infections.[17 ]
[18 ] Reported MIC of amikacin sulphate of commonly isolated pathogens from musculoskeletal
infections ranges between 16 and 64 µg/mL.[20 ] Although some strains of methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus have a reported MIC of 500 µg/mL the median MIC for amikacin sulphate for methicillin-resistant-Staphylococcus aureus in one study was reported to be 32 µg/mL.[19 ] Hence, the recommended Cmax :MIC ratio of 8:1 was reached in all horses but a 10:1 ratio for the most resistant
pathogens (> 64 µg/mL) was only reached in 4/6 horses advocating for a higher dosage
in horses suffering from resistant infections. The reported dosage of amikacin sulphate
in IVRLP ranges between 500 mg and 3 g.[6 ]
[7 ]
[8 ]
[10 ]
[12 ]
[13 ]
[14 ]
[15 ]
[16 ]
[20 ] We choose to use 2 g in this study based on our clinical experience and previous
studies that reached desirable MIC levels of synovial fluid amikacin sulphate with
this dose.[6 ]
[16 ] To avoid potential cytotoxicity of amikacin sulphate described after intra-articular
administration, the dose could be titrated according to MIC of the cultured pathogens,
keeping in mind that bacteriology samples from equine orthopaedic infections frequently
yield negative growth.[17 ]
In the current and previous studies sampling synovial fluid from the carpal joints,
the forelimb was flexed during the arthrocentesis. This movement does not appear to
influence the synovial fluid amikacin sulphate concentration.[8 ]
[10 ]
[13 ]
[15 ]
[20 ]
[29 ]
[33 ]
[34 ] The influence of repeated sampling of synovial fluid on the amikacin sulphate synovial
fluid concentration is unknown, not accounted for in previous studies, and should
be further investigated. The two horses with suspected perivascular leakage had similar
synovial fluid concentrations to the other horses, and the swelling disappeared shortly
after tourniquet removal. Therefore, the leakage did not interfere with reaching therapeutic
amikacin sulphate synovial fluid concentrations.
Peri-neural anaesthesia of the ulnar, median and musculocutaneous nerves was performed
to minimize pain caused by the tourniquet. This is suggested to be the most efficient
anaesthetic method in IVRLP.[8 ] Several studies have evaluated the IVRLP efficacy under general anaesthesia to control
for the influence of movement on perfusion.[8 ]
[9 ]
[10 ]
[19 ] A study comparing synovial fluid amikacin sulphate concentrations between anaesthetized
and sedated horses, in the radiocarpal joint and metacarpophalangeal joint, did not
find significant difference between the two methods. Actually, in that study, general
anaesthesia had the effect of decreasing metacarpophalangeal joint synovial fluid
concentrations of amikacin sulphate.[10 ] Another study concluded that their results did not support the use of general anaesthesia
in IVRLP as it had no positive effect on the pharmacokinetics of amikacin sulphate
in synovial fluid following IVRLP compared with standing horses and failed to be a
clinically relevant solution.[8 ]
An Esmarch's wide rubber tourniquet was used in this study. Although with the pneumatic
tourniquet the pressure is measurable and more consistent,[14 ] the wide Esmarch's tourniquet is effective in sustaining haemostasis of the distal
limb and allowing accumulation of high concentration of antibiotic medications.[14 ]
[16 ]
[32 ]
The high concentration of synovial fluid amikacin sulphate reached in this study is
consistent with the findings of other recent studies from our laboratory. This is
likely supportive of the technique we are implementing, including the use of the cephalic
vein, a wide Esmarch's tourniquet, 2 g of amikacin sulphate in 100 mL volume; divided
in five 20mL syringes, and peripheral nerve anaesthesia. The accuracy and precision
of the analysis of the synovial fluid amikacin concentration were ± 15%, except for ± 20%
in lower level of quantification. These values are in agreement with recommended acceptance
criteria (guidance for industry, Food and Drug Administration [FDA]).[35 ]
There are several limitations to this study, including a small study group with large
variation in the results. The same dose of antibiotic medication and perfusate volume
was used throughout the study group despite variations in body weight. This uniform
dosage could have affected the results, although no significant correlation was found
between body weight and synovial fluid amikacin sulphate concentration. Previous studies
administering precise dosages did not avoid large variations in synovial fluid antimicrobial
concentrations through individual dosages.[13 ] Additionally, since only radiocarpal joint synovial fluid was sampled, these results
cannot be applied to other synovial structures, subcutaneous tissue, skin or bone.
At last, although the study protocol was completely uniform, four different veterinary
surgeons applied the tourniquet, performed the IVRLP and sampled the radiocarpal joint.
The results of the present study support the reduction in tourniquet application time
from 30 to 20 minutes for cephalic vein IVRLP with 2 g of amikacin sulphate in 100 mL
volume when targeting the radiocarpal joint. However, further investigations are required
to evaluate if this is applicable to perfusion of other tissues and other synovial
structures and to ensure the clinical validity of this protocol.