Keywords
clinicopathologic spectrum - histopathology - nonneoplastic cysts of brain
Introduction
A true cyst can be defined as an abnormal closed epithelium-lined sac in the body
that contains a liquid or semisolid substance while a pseudo cyst or false cyst is
an abnormal or dilated cavity resembling a true cyst but not lined with epithelium.[1] Intracranial cystic lesions are divided into two types: normal variants, such as
cavum septi pellucidi, cavum veli interpositi, and cavum vergae, and developmental
or congenital lesions.[2] These congenital nonneoplastic cystic lesions of the central nervous system (CNS)
are uncommon, mostly benign, and discovered incidentally during routine radiological
examination or at autopsy.[3] However, they become symptomatic either because of pressure, rupture, or secondary
inflammation. On neuroimaging these may mimic with cystic neoplastic lesions, causing
difficulty in accurate diagnosis. Meanwhile, there is no uniform terminology and classification
scheme to make a consistent diagnosis among pathologists, neurosurgeons, and neuroradiologists.
Though generally of good prognosis, they may recur due to rupture or incomplete surgical
removal. The age, site, cyst wall, and cyst contents provide an insight into their
histogenesis and embryology. In this study, we evaluated epidemiology and clinicopathologic
spectrum of nonneoplastic CNS cysts that presented as symptomatic space-occupying
lesions and highlighted the role of histopathology in the diagnosis of these cystic
lesions. We also compared our data with other institution's data available in literature.
This is the second largest series studying all the nonneoplastic cystic lesions of
the CNS, both developmental and acquired ([Table 1]).
Table 1
Demographic details for all histological types as well as comparison with national
data
Diagnosis
|
SMS, Jaipur (n = 255)
|
NIMHANS, Bangalore6 (n = 538)
|
GB Pant Hospital, New Delhi7 (n = 109)
|
|
Age range (y)
|
Mean age (y)
|
M:F ratio
|
Frequency (%)
|
Age range (y)
|
Mean age (y)
|
M:F ratio
|
Frequency (%)
|
Age range (y)
|
Mean age (y)
|
M:F ratio
|
Frequency (%)
|
Epidermoid cyst
|
4–65
|
30
|
1.24:1
|
61.6
|
3–64
|
33.37
|
1.04:1
|
24.5
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
31.2
|
Colloid cyst
|
9–66
|
28
|
1.4:1
|
9.4
|
9–90
|
34.7
|
|
23.4
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
14.7
|
Arachnoid cyst
|
3–72
|
31
|
1.62:1
|
13.3
|
5 months to 66 years
|
29.5
|
1.01:1
|
20.6
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
24.8
|
Dermoid cyst
|
2–62
|
23
|
4.2:1
|
10.2
|
2–54
|
22.24
|
2.2:1
|
6.1
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
15.6
|
Benign cystic lesion
|
7–74
|
31
|
2.5:1
|
2.7
|
3–66
|
32.7
|
|
2
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
Glioependymal cyst
|
38–42
|
40
|
–
|
0.8
|
6 months to 59 years
|
14.35
|
2.3:1
|
1.9
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
2.7
|
Perineural cyst
|
18
|
18
|
–
|
0.4
|
21–75
|
42.6
|
1.6:1
|
1.5
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
Rathke's cleft cyst
|
NA
|
NA
|
–
|
0.8
|
12–77
|
43.03
|
1:01
|
5.6
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
2.8
|
Neuroenteric cyst
|
NA
|
NA
|
–
|
0.8
|
2–74
|
23.5
|
2.25:1
|
4.8
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
7.3
|
Porencephalic cysts
|
NA
|
NA
|
–
|
NA
|
5–34
|
21.33
|
1:02
|
0.6
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
Neurocysticercosis
|
42–48
|
45
|
–
|
NA
|
6–68
|
33.8
|
1.2:1
|
7.8
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
Hydatid cyst
|
12–29
|
20
|
–
|
NA
|
10–48
|
27.4
|
1:01:03
|
1.3
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
NA
|
Abbreviations: GB, Govind Ballabh; NA, not available; NIMHANS, National Institute
of Mental Health and Neuro-Sciences; M:F, male to female ratio; SMS, Sawai Man Singh
(Medical College).
Materials and Methods
The present study was a retrospective analysis of the data on nonneoplastic cystic
lesions of CNS, which involved the archival tumor blocks and clinicopathological data,
submitted to the Department of Pathology of our Institution—Sawai Man Singh (SMS)
Medical College, Jaipur—between January 2013 and June 2020. All neoplastic cystic
lesions were excluded from the study. The age, site, cyst wall lining, nature of cyst
contents, and location (intracranial and spinal) were noted in all cases for analysis.
These included epidermoid cysts, dermoid cysts, arachnoid cysts, colloid cysts, glioependymal
cysts, perineural cyst, benign cystic lesions (cysts that could not be classified
under above categories), hydatid cysts, and neurocysticercosis.
All collected data were analyzed on SPSS software version 20.0. For continuous variables,
mean value was calculated. Frequency and percentage were calculated for categorical
variables. Since this was a retrospective observational study, ethical approval was
not sought.
Results
During the study period of 7 and ½ years, a total of 255 histologically confirmed
nonneoplastic cystic lesions were reviewed with an incidence of 4.96% (255/5,142 tumor
and tumor-like lesions). Noninfective cysts were much more common (251/255) than infective
cysts (4/255). Epidermoid cysts were the commonest, followed by arachnoid cysts, then
dermoid cysts, and this was closely followed by colloid cysts of the third ventricle.
Among infective cysts, two were hydatid cysts and two were neurocysticercosis ([Fig. 1]).
Fig. 1 Overall distribution of nonneoplastic cystic lesions of central nervous system.
The age range was 2 to 74 years (mean, 28.9 years) with slight male preponderance
(male:female [M:F] ratio = 1.15:1; [Table 1]; [Fig. 2]).
Fig. 2 Number of male and female patients as well as male to female ratio for all histological
subtypes of nonneoplastic cystic lesions of central nervous system.
Majority of intracranial cysts had signs of raised intracranial pressure. Patients
with epidermoid cysts had additional cerebellar signs, visual disturbances, and deafness
due to their posterior fossa location. The spinal cysts of all types presented with
cord compression leading to lower limb weakness. The epidermoid and arachnoid cysts
were more common in the brain, while dermoid cysts in the spinal cord.
Among all nonneoplastic cystic lesions, epidermoid cysts were the most common and
constituted 61.6% (157/255). The overall age range was 4 to 65 years with a mean age
of presentation being 30 years and M:F ratio, 1.24:1. In males, age range was 4 to
63 years, while in females; it was 10 to 65 years. Intracranial location was more
common (78.3%) than spinal one (21.7%). Most common intracranial site was posterior
fossa (49.6%), followed by cerebral hemispheres (30.1%). Equal incidence was found
in ventricles and suprasellar site (5.7%). Other intracranial sites were pineal (2.4%);
interhemispheric and middle cranial fossa base (1.6% each); and anterior cranial fossa
base, brain stem, basal cistern, and quadrigeminal cistern (0.8% each). With the cerebral
hemispheres, temporal lobe (40.5%) was the most common, followed by frontal lobe (21.6%).
Intraspinal cysts were more frequent in lumber (58.8%) location followed by thoracolumbar
(20.6%), thoracic (14.8%), and cervical and lumbosacral (2.9%, each). Of these, 38.2%
were intramedullary and 61.8% were intradural–extra medullary ([Table 2]). Histologically, these cysts were lined by keratinized stratified squamous epithelium
and cyst wall composed of fibrocollagenous connective tissue without skin appendages.
Lumen was filled with acellular lamellated keratinous flakes ([Fig. 3A]). Abscess formation was seen in two of the cases and foreign body giant cell reaction
was noted in seven cases.
Fig. 3 (A) Epidermoid cyst showing keratinized stratified squamous epithelium and acellular
lamellated keratin. (B) Arachnoid cyst showing a single layer of flattened meningothelial cells resting
on fibrocollagenous connective tissue. (C) Dermoid cyst showing keratinized stratified squamous epithelium and pilosebaceous
unit in the cyst wall. (D) Colloid cyst lined by columnar cells with eosinophilic acellular material as cyst
content.
Table 2
Location of noninfective nonneoplastic cysts of central nervous system
Type of cysts
|
Number of cases
|
Location
|
Number of cases
|
Epidermoid cysts
|
157
|
|
|
Intracranial
|
123/157
|
Parenchymal
|
37
|
Inter hemispheric
|
2
|
Sellar and suprasellar
|
7
|
Pineal
|
3
|
Anterior cranial fossa base
|
1
|
Middle cranial fossa base
|
2
|
Posterior fossa
|
61
|
Brain stem
|
1
|
Ventricles
|
7
|
Basal cistern
|
1
|
Quadrigeminal cistern
|
1
|
Spinal
|
34/157
|
Cervical
|
1
|
Thoracic
|
5
|
Thoracolumbar
|
7
|
Lumber
|
20
|
Lumbosacral
|
1
|
Dermoid cysts
|
26
|
|
|
Intracranial
|
8
|
Parenchymal
|
6
|
Sellar
|
1
|
Posterior fossa
|
1
|
Spinal
|
18
|
Cervical
|
1
|
Thoracic
|
1
|
Thoracolumbar
|
2
|
Lumber
|
12
|
Lumbosacral
|
1
|
Sacral
|
1
|
Colloid cysts
|
24
|
|
|
Intracranial
|
|
Third ventricle
|
23
|
|
Posterior fossa
|
1
|
Arachnoid cysts
|
34
|
|
|
Intracranial
|
22
|
Intraparenchymal
|
4
|
Sellar
|
1
|
Ventricular
|
5
|
Posterior fossa
|
12
|
Spinal
|
12
|
Cervical
|
3
|
Cervicothoracic
|
1
|
Thoracic
|
6
|
Lumber
|
2
|
Benign cystic lesion
|
7
|
|
|
Intracranial
|
5
|
Intraparenchymal
|
1
|
Sellar
|
3
|
Ventricle
|
1
|
Spinal
|
2
|
Lumbosacral
|
1
|
Sacrococcygeal
|
1
|
Glioependymal cysts
|
2
|
|
|
Intracranial
|
1
|
Posterior fossa
|
1
|
Spinal
|
1
|
Thoracic
|
1
|
Perineural cyst
|
1
|
|
|
Spinal
|
1
|
Sacral
|
1
|
Second most common cysts were arachnoid cysts constituting 13.3%, with an age range
of 3 to 72 years and mean age 31 years. Among those, 21 were male patients while female
patients were 13 with an M:F ratio of 1.62:1 ([Fig. 2]). Out of 34 cases, 22 (64.7%) were intracranial and remaining 12 (35.3%) were intraspinal.
In cranium locations were posterior fossa (12), ventricular (5), intraparenchymal
(4), and sellar (1). In spine locations were thoracic (6), cervical (3), lumber (2),
and cervicothoracic (1 [[Table 2]]). These cysts presented with pressure symptoms. In histology, cysts were lined
by flattened meningothelial (arachnoidal) cells supported by collagenous cyst wall.
The contents of these cysts were clear fluid, like cerebrospinal fluid (CSF; [Fig. 3B]).
There were 26 cases (10.2%) of dermoid cysts located predominantly in spine (69.2%;
66.7% in lumber). Intracranial compartment accounted for 30.8% of lesions and hemispheric
location was most common (75%; [Table 2]). Out of total 18 cases of spinal region, 13 cases were intradural–extra medullary
while remaining 5 cases were intramedullary. The age range was 2 to 62 years and mean
age of presentation was 23 years ([Table 1]). Male predilection was seen in these with an M:F ratio of 4.2:1 ([Fig. 2]). Histologically, these cysts were lined keratinized stratified squamous epithelium
with hair follicles, sweat, and sebaceous glands in cyst wall. The contents included
keratin flakes, hair, or sebum ([Fig. 3C]).
Colloid cysts constituted 9.4% (24/255) of total cases. For these, overall age range
was 9 to 66 years with a mean age of 28 years and M:F ratio of 1.4:1. All cases were
located in the third ventricle except one, which was in the posterior fossa ([Table 1] and [Table 2]). Morphologically these cysts were lined by cuboidal to columnar epithelium with
or without cilia, supported by delicate collagenous stroma and colloid-like material
in the lumen, which showed periodic acid–Schiff positivity ([Fig. 3D]). There was hemorrhage with hemosiderin laden macrophages and xanthogranulomatous
reaction in five cases.
Less frequently occurring cysts were glioependymal cysts (two cases) and perineural/Tarlov's
cyst (one case). Both glioependymal cysts were found in males of age 38 and 42 years.
One was in posterior fossa of intracranium and one was in thoracic region of spine.
Microscopically, these cysts were lined by cuboidal to columnar ependymal cells resting
on glial tissue ([Fig. 4A]). The single perineural cyst in our series was found in an 18-year-old male in sacral
region of spine. They were characterized by the presence of nerve bundles in the cyst
wall ([Table 2]).
Fig. 4 (A) Glioependymal cyst lined by low cuboidal type epithelium resting in glial tissue.
(B) Neurocysticercosis showing cystic stage. (C) Hydatid cyst showing lamellated membrane.
Only 4 cases of infective cysts were encountered; 2 were of hydatid cysts in males
of age 12 and 29 years and 2 were of neurocysticercosis in males of age 42 and 48
years. Both cases of hydatid cysts were located in cerebral hemispheres, parietal
and occipital; while location of neurocysticercosis was cerebellum and frontal hemisphere.
Microscopically, neurocysticercosis cases were in cystic/vesicular stage and showed
membrane of the cyst showing outer layer covered with microvillus ([Fig. 4B]). Morphologically, hydatid cysts were characterized by presence of lamellated membranes
([Fig. 4C]). In our series, seven cases were put in benign cystic lesion category due to the
absence of specific features of any of the above cystic lesions, in particular, an
indistinct lining.
However, there was no case of neuroenteric cyst, Rathke's cleft cyst, or porencephalic
cyst in the current series.
We also compared clinical parameters as mean age and frequency percentage of cystic
lesions with Indian data: National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro-Sciences (NIMHANS)
and Govind Ballabh (GB) Pant Hospital data ([Table 1]). In all types of cystic lesions, epidermoid cysts were most common in all above
institutions, but frequency percentage was different. Second common cysts were arachnoid
cysts in our study similar to GB Pant data, but in NIMHANS colloid cysts were second
most common. For almost all histologies, the mean age at diagnosis was similar between
the SMS Medical College and NIMHANS data, marginally varying by just 2 to 4 years
for most lesions.
Discussion
Cysts of CNS are usually diagnosed radiologically and confirmed histologically. They
show wide variety of histomorphology. Exact typing of these lesions is crucial and
depends on type of the lining of the cyst wall and anatomical location, as it is essential
for treatment and has prognostic importance.
Epidermoid cysts are uncommon congenital lesions that account for 0.2 to 1.8% of all
intracranial tumors and less than 1% of all intraspinal tumors.[4] They result from inclusion of ectodermal elements during neural tube closure between
the third and fifth weeks of fetal development, and typically present in middle age
due to mass effect on adjacent structures. Less commonly, the cysts may develop later
in life (acquired) when an injury or surgery causes epithelial cells to be trapped
in brain tissue.[5] Mean age of presentation for epidermoid cysts was 30 years similar to the study
done by Bhatt et al, and M:F ratio was 1.24:1 showing slight male preponderance.[6] Upon comparison on location, intracranial epidermoid cysts were more common than
spinal one with a ratio of 14:1.1 to 3. The current series showed an approximate ratio
of 3.62 similar to the studies done by Sidhu et al (3.25:1) and Sundaram et al (5:1).[7]
[8] Most common site in intracranial compartment was posterior fossa (49.5%) and cerebellopontine
angle (42.2%), similar to other studies, followed by cerebral hemispheres (30.1%).
Other sites were ventricular region, pineal, sellar and suprasellar, interhemispheric,
base of anterior cranial and middle cranial fossa, and basal and quadrigeminal cistern.
We also encountered a single case of brain stem epidermoid, which is extremely rare.[8]
[9]
[10] In cerebral hemispheres, temporal lobe was most commonly (15 cases) involved followed
by frontal lobe (8 cases). In intraspinal epidermoid cysts, most common location was
lumber followed by thoracolumbar and thoracic.
In the present series, the second most commonly encountered cyst was arachnoid cysts
similar to the report by Sidhu et al.[7] They can be of two types: primary arachnoid cysts, which are congenital, and secondary
cysts, resulting from head injury or trauma.[11]
[12] They are CSF covered by arachnoid cells and collagen that may develop between the
surface of the brain and the cranial base, or on the arachnoid membrane, one of the
three meningeal layers that cover the brain and the spinal cord.[13]
[14] The mean age of presentation was 31 years, similar to the study performed by Bhatt
et al where mean age was 29.5 years.[6] Arachnoid cysts were founded more commonly in males, similar to the study by Al-Holou
et al, and M:F ratio was 1.62:1. Intracranial arachnoid cysts were more common (64.7%)
than spinal ones (35.3%), similar to the studies by Sidhu et al and Bhatt et al.[6]
[7]
[15] In the spine, lumber region was the commonest location, concordant with Sundaram
et al.[8] The spinal arachnoid cysts are located subdurally and are true arachnoid cysts.
Dermoid cysts constituted 10.2% of all nonneoplastic cystic lesions, and were the
third most common lesion in our series similar to the study by Sidhu et al.[7] They are mal-developmental and a result of the inclusion of ectoderm during neural
tube closure similar to epidermoid cysts. The median location of these tumors can
be explained by the separation of neuroectoderm and its cutaneous counterpart that
occurs dorsally along the midline. However, during the formation of secondary otic
and optic cerebral vesicles, inclusion of ectoderm at a later stage of embryogenesis
leads to lateral location of these lesions.[9]
[16]
[17]
[18] They were found more commonly in males with a mean age of 23 years, similar to the
studies conducted by Din et al and Bhatt et al.[3]
[6] Like other studies, mean age for dermoid cysts was younger compared with that for
epidermoid cysts (23 years compared with 30 years). Similar to other studies, they
were predominantly intraspinal (69.2%) in contrast to epidermoid cysts, with a preferential
location in lumber region.[3]
[6]
[7]
Colloid cysts are well-defined clinicopathologic entity and easily identified on radiological
imaging due to high cholesterol content.[19] They usually present with symptoms of raised intracranial tension resulting from
acute hydrocephalus by obstruction of one or both foramina of Monro due to their specific
site of third ventricle. Regarding origin of these cysts, there are studies that denote
their endodermal origin rather than a neuroepithelial one, as the epithelium of colloid
cysts is immunohistochemically different from normal or neoplastic choroid epithelium.[8]
[20]
[21] Similar to other studies, males were affected more commonly than females and commonly
in third decade of life. They were fourth commonest cysts in the series, similar to
the report by Sidhu et al.[7] We encountered only two cases of glioependymal cysts in the current series. According
to Friede and Yasargil, these cysts arise from displaced segments of the wall of the
neural tube that correspond to the sites from which tela choroidea forms.[22] Histologically, these cysts are lined by columnar or cuboidal epithelium resting
directly on brain parenchyma without a basement membrane and connective tissue. They
formed 0.8% of the series. Only a single case of perineural cyst or Tarlov's cyst
was present in the series in sacral region. They are located along the nerve roots
in perineural space between the perineurium formed by arachnoid and pia mater.[23]
On computed tomography scan most of the noninflammatory cysts appear as well-circumscribed
lesions, being iso- to hypodense, without contrast enhancement, except colloid cyst,
which appears hyperdense with peripheral enhancement. On magnetic resonance imaging,
they have minor differences. Arachnoid cysts and glioependymal cysts have same signal
intensity in T1- and T2-weighted images as CSF and no contrast enhancement. Epidermoid
cysts show low signal in T1-weighted and high signal in T2-weighted sequences and
demonstrate restricted diffusion on diffusion-weighted mages. Dermoid cysts appear
hyperintense in T1-weighted and hypo- to hyperintense in T2-weighted sequences. Colloid
cyst appears hyperintense in T1-weighted and hypointense in T2-weighted imaging with
peripheral contrast enhancement. However, cystic neoplasms differ from noninflammatory
cysts by vasogenic surrounding edema and their solid part show contrast enhancement.[24]
[25]
[26]
[27]
[28]
In our series, we were not able to categorize five intracranial and two spinal cysts
into any category and so put them as a benign cystic lesion because there was no distinct
cell lining and no clue of cyst contents. It may be due to a small biopsy tissue submitted
in our department as soft tissue pieces without any content and their lining was also
not well demarcated to put them in any of the cyst categories, but they were showing
a cyst wall without any mitotic and neoplastic pathology. Immunohistochemical or ultrastructural
studies may help in such cases. These benign cysts of the CNS are being recognized
more frequently with the advent of modern neuroimaging. They are usually mal-developmental,
and malignant transformation of the lining epithelium is extremely rare.
In the present series, there were only four cases of infective cystic lesions. Two
cases were of neurocysticercosis and two were of hydatid cysts. Neurocysticercosis
is the infection of CNS caused by the Taenia solium (pork tapeworm). It can be intraparenchymal (benign) and extraparenchymal (malignant).[29] Location for extraparenchymal neurocysticercosis is the subarachnoid space and basal
cistern. There are four morphological stages of neurocysticercosis, namely: vesicular
stage, which lacks inflammatory reactions; vesicular colloidal state, wherein inflammation
sets in; granular nodular stage, where the parasite is dead and degeneration starts;
and, finally, the nodular calcified stage, wherein the parasite and the capsule are
retracted and calcified.[30] In the current study, both cases of neurocysticercosis were intraparenchymal: one
cerebral hemisphere and other cerebellum.
We encountered two cases of intracranial hydatid cysts, both in cerebral hemispheres:
parietal and occipital. Intracranial hydatid cysts are much more common with an incidence
of 1 to 2% than spinal hydatidosis.[6] The parietal lobe was found to be most commonly involved in studies by Dharker et
al and Balasubramaniam et al.[31]
[32] Usually intracranial hydatid cysts are solitary and spread by hematogenous route.
Both infective cystic lesions in neuroimaging may mimic with other lesions depending
on their location, as hydatid cyst of pineal region may be confused with pineocytoma,
or ventricular region may mimic with choroid plexus tumors. Similarly, neurocysticercal
cysts may mimic abscess, tuberculomas, neoplasms (both primary and metastatic, depending
on the age of presentation), and other parasitic infections. Hence, a histopathological
diagnosis becomes necessary in such cases for making an accurate diagnosis.
On comparing, majority of our data regarding mean age of presentation corroborates
with similar data within India with minor differences, and epidermoid cysts were the
most common among all nonneoplastic cystic lesions.
Conclusion
A variety of cystic lesions occurs in the CNS and presents as mass lesion. They have
overlapped clinical features and imaging findings leading to problem in proper diagnosis.
Morphology of cyst walls has a direct impact on further management, therefore histopathology
has a vital role in diagnosis of these lesions. Our study is reinforcing the existing
literature for the role of histopathology in the management of nonneoplastic cystic
lesions of CNS.