Liu 2013[48]
|
26
|
M
|
Bilateral ear stuffy, diplopia, headache, progressive numbness of both lower limbs
|
Mass in sphenoid sinus, abnormal signal in cervical medullary, and cavernous sinus
|
Endoscopic biopsy
|
1, 3
|
–
|
Chemotherapy (V)
|
7
|
Death
|
Shah, 2023[49]
|
68
|
M
|
Progressive blurred vision, periorbital pain, frontal headache, intermittent back
pain
|
Centered in slope, extended to pituitary fossa, entered bilateral sphenoid sinus,
and ethmoid sinus
|
–
|
2, 4
|
–
|
Chemotherapy (VCD)
|
3 wk
|
Alleviate
|
Zuo, 2002[50]
|
44
|
M
|
Hoarseness, diplopia
|
Sphenoid and sella, bottom of sella, ethmoidal sinus
|
Biopsy
|
1, 3
|
–
|
Chemotherapy (M2), Intracranial radiotherapy
|
7
|
Improve
|
Wu, 2006[78]
|
57
|
M
|
Frontal headache, nausea
|
Posterior cranial fossa, straddling transverse sinus, skull base fracture
|
Open procedure excision
|
1, 3
|
IgG-λ
|
Chemotherapy
|
3
|
Stable
|
Qu, 2018[51]
|
61
|
M
|
Unilateral decreased vision
|
Left sphenoid sinus occupied with adjacent bone infiltration
|
Biopsy
|
1, 3, 5, 6
|
λ
|
Chemotherapy (BD-PACE), Allo-SCT intended
|
–
|
Improve
|
Chen, 2003[80]
|
48
|
M
|
Bilateral decreased vision, bone pain, dizziness, headache
|
Sella-slope occupation with skull base fracture
|
Endoscopic biopsy and excision
|
1, 3, 4
|
IgG-λ
|
Chemotherapy (VAD)
|
1
|
Improve
|
Lu, 2009[79]
|
62
|
F
|
Headache, unilateral double vision
|
Sellar region, occipital slope, with bone destruction
|
–
|
3, 4, 5
|
Light chain
|
Chemotherapy (TD)
|
5d
|
Improve
|
Johnson, 2022[52]
|
52
|
M
|
Persistent visual changes, headache, epistaxis, fatigue
|
Invaded the cavernous sinus, displaced the internal carotid artery, extending to the
middle cranial fossa, sphenoid sinus, posterior ethmoidal air chamber and slope, anterior
pontine cisterna
|
Endoscopic biopsy and partial excision
|
1, 3, 6, 7
|
–
|
Local radiotherapy, Palliative radiotherapy, Chemotherapy (CyBorD, VRD), ASCT intended
|
–
|
VGPR
|
Silverman, 2022[53]
|
60
|
M
|
Intermittent diplopia, pain above the left eye, progressive ptosis
|
Left slope mass with cavernous sinus and slope extension with bone erosion
|
Endoscopic biopsy
|
1, 2, 4
|
IgG-λ
|
Pulse steroid + dexamethasone, local radiotherapy, Bortezomib intended
|
5
|
Death
|
Joshi, 2011[54]
|
66
|
M
|
Intermittent imbalance, right ear discomfort with hearing loss, dizziness, diplopia,
right occipital headache, facial numbness
|
Mass located at the right apex of rock, destroyed the condyle of the right occipital
bone, right side of the slope, body of the sphenoid bone, cavernous sinus, and apex
of rock
|
–
|
3, 4
|
λ
|
Radiotherapy, cyclophosphamide, chemotherapy (VAD)
|
–
|
Alleviate
|
Ustuner, 2003[55]
|
39
|
M
|
Progressive paresthesia on the left side of the face and left arm, intermittent diplopia,
dysphagia, hoarseness
|
Mass extends from the ethmoid and sphenoid sinuses to the junction of the slope and
petroclival
|
Endoscopic biopsy
|
1, 2
|
Light chain
|
Local radiotherapy, chemotherapy (VAD), ASCT intended
|
–
|
Stable
|
Hogan, 2002[56]
|
39
|
M
|
Progressive loss of vision to amaurosis in the right eye, numbness in the left mandible,
low fever, fatigue, frontal headache
|
Single epidural lesion of right orbital apex and sphenoid sinus near anterior bed
process, optic nerve compression
|
–
|
2, 3
|
IgA-λ
|
Chemotherapy (VAD), radiotherapy, Allo-BMT
|
24
|
Improve
|
Yamguchi, 2008[57]
|
65
|
F
|
Progressive diplopia
|
Mass invaded sinuses, slopes, rock apex and infratemporal fossa, slopes and sphenoid
bone
|
Endoscopic biopsy and radical excision
|
1, 3, 4
|
IgA-λ
|
Local radiotherapy, chemotherapy (VAD), ASCT, thalidomide
|
17
|
Stable
|
Wein, 2002[58]
|
60
|
F
|
Left frontal headache, dacryorrhea with bulbar conjunctival edema
|
Invasive mass in the left supraorbital region involving the frontal and ethmoid sinuses
|
Biopsy
|
1, 2
|
–
|
Chemotherapy (VAD)
|
–
|
Alleviate
|
Wachter, 2010[19]
|
43
|
F
|
Acute unilateral vision loss
|
Mass in the left optic channel, wrapped optic nerve, calcification around the mass,
sphenoid sinus, and cavernous sinus
|
Open procedure excision
|
1
|
λ
|
Local radiotherapy, intrathecal methotrexate, ASCT intended
|
12
|
Progress
|
Alegre, 1996[59]
|
40
|
F
|
Sudden diplopia and dysarthria
|
Enlarged basal bone tumor of the skull, destroyed the left petroclival region and
extended to sphenoid sinus
|
Biopsy and partial excision
|
1, 3
|
–
|
Local radiotherapy, chemotherapy (VAD), PBSCT
|
18
|
CR
|
Kadiri, 2016[60]
|
56
|
F
|
Temporary headache, diplopia
|
Sphenoid sinus mass invades the sphenoid bone and extends to the left temporal region
and cavernous sinus
|
Endoscopic biopsy
|
1, 2, 4
|
IgA-κ
|
Chemotherapy (dexamethasone + zoledronic acid), decompression radiotherapy
|
8
|
Death
|
Humphrey, 1983[61]
|
60
|
M
|
Left sixth nerve paralysis, left shoulder pain
|
Sphenoid sinus
|
Biopsy
|
1, 4
|
IgD-λ
|
Local radiotherapy, chemotherapy (M2)
|
12
|
Death
|
Hess, 2006[62]
|
58
|
M
|
Pain and swelling in the right jaw
|
Sphenoid sinus mass invaded nasopharynx
|
Biopsy
|
1
|
Light chain
|
Chemotherapy, radiotherapy, ASCT
|
–
|
Alleviate
|
Liu, 2023[63]
|
54
|
F
|
Dizziness, loss of right visual field with nausea and vomiting
|
Soft tissue mass in sphenoid sinus invaded occipital bone
|
–
|
3, 5, 6
|
IgD-λ
|
Chemotherapy (VCD, DVD-R, PLD, DEDP-R)
|
9
|
Death
|
Yazdanpanah, 2020[64]
|
45
|
M
|
Diplopia, headache, cough, and difficulty breathing
|
Involved sphenoid sinus and slopes, extending to the anterior pontine cistus and bilateral
cavernous sinuses (left > right)
|
Endoscopic biopsy and excision
|
2, 4, 6
|
IgG-λ
|
Local radiotherapy, Chemotherapy (E-KRd)
|
–
|
Alleviate
|
Movsas, 2000[65]
|
78
|
F
|
Bilateral horizontal diplopia, headache, lameness in lower limbs
|
Slope mass, right cavernous sinus involvement, extending into sphenoid sinus, with
bone destruction
|
Endoscopic biopsy
|
1, 2, 4, 5
|
IgG-κ
|
Local radiotherapy, chemotherapy (MP)
|
–
|
–
|
Bachmeyer, 1997[66]
|
77
|
M
|
Temporary loss of consciousness, intermittent horizontal diplopia
|
Invaded entire sphenoid sinus and destroyed sphenoid bone, extending to the ethmoid
sinus, slope
|
Biopsy
|
1, 2, 3
|
IgG-λ
|
Radiotherapy, chemotherapy (MP)
|
6
|
Stable
|
Oushy, 2018[67]
|
59
|
F
|
Ear distension, postural vertigo, pulsing tenderness in left ear, hoarseness, dysphagia
|
Internal lesion of left jugular foramen, tumor of left posterior occipital bone
|
Open procedure stereotactic biopsy
|
1, 2, 4
|
κ
|
Chemotherapy (VRd), ASCT
|
–
|
–
|
Reddy, 2021[68]
|
52
|
M
|
Unilateral diplopia, headache, sticky purulent discharge in the right ear, hearing
impairment
|
Slope mass invaded the left cavernous sinus, multiple osteolytic lesions of the skull
|
Endoscopic biopsy
|
1, 2, 4
|
κ
|
Chemotherapy (VCD), local palliative radiotherapy
|
–
|
Alleviate
|
Patel, 2010[69]
|
42
|
F
|
Occipital headache, nausea, vomiting
|
Posterior fossa mass, osteolytic destruction of occipital bone, compression of Sylvius
aqueduct and fourth ventricle, with hydrocephalus
|
Open procedure
|
1, 2, 4
|
IgG-λ
|
Steroid, cytotoxicity, radiotherapy
|
–
|
–
|
Rahman, 2016[70]
|
84
|
F
|
Headache, blurred vision, progressive bilateral horizontal diplopia
|
Slope mass extends to the sphenoid and posterior ethmoid sinuses
|
Endoscopic biopsy
|
1, 2
|
λ
|
Radiotherapy, chemotherapy (V)
|
–
|
–
|
How, 2019[71]
|
29
|
F
|
Distension, hearing loss, unilateral pulsating tinnitus, loss of taste
|
Central mass of the right jugular foramen with extensive bone destruction and an erosive
appearance
|
Open procedure biopsy and excision
|
1, 2, 4, 6, 7
|
IgA-κ
|
Dexamethasone + local palliative radiotherapy, chemotherapy (KRd)
|
–
|
Alleviate
|
Magrassi, 2016[72]
|
57
|
M
|
Sudden diplopia, dizziness
|
Osteolytic clival disease extending to both the great wings of the sphenoid bone and
the right petrous bone, with partial involvement of the inner ear
|
Stereotactic biopsy
|
1, 2
|
IgG-κ
|
Radiotherapy, chemotherapy
|
–
|
–
|
Du, 2015[77]
|
47
|
F
|
Frontal headache, eye distention
|
Mass in the sphenoid sinus, partial fracture of the sinus wall
|
Endoscopic biopsy
|
1, 3, 4
|
IgG
|
Chemotherapy
|
–
|
Alleviate
|
Shenoy, 2010[73]
|
58
|
M
|
Left side hearing loss, dizziness, headache
|
Slope mass invaded rock apex, left jugular bulb, and left cerebellar cornual cisterna
extending to left sigmoid sinus
|
Endoscopic biopsy
|
1, 3, 4
|
–
|
Chemotherapy (TD), local radiotherapy, BMT
|
–
|
–
|
Rezazadeh, 2005[74]
|
62
|
M
|
Progressive cervical pain and diplopia
|
Slope mass extends to the brain stem, left inner ear and internal carotid artery canals,
nasopharynx, sphenoid bone, cavernous sinus
|
Endoscopic stereotactic biopsy
|
1, 3, 4, 5
|
κ
|
Dexamethasone, radiotherapy
|
–
|
–
|
Higurashi, 2004[75]
|
53
|
F
|
Diplopia, left abducent paralysis
|
Osteolytic mass in the left petroclival region invaded left internal carotid artery
|
Open procedure radical excision
|
3
|
–
|
Chemotherapy, ASCT
|
30
|
Stable
|
Nofsinger, 1997[76]
|
79
|
F
|
Unilateral blurred vision and diplopia
|
Slope mass extends to right sphenoid sinus
|
Endoscopic biopsy
|
1, 2
|
IgG-κ
|
Chemotherapy, local radiotherapy
|
–
|
Alleviate
|
Chen, 2023
|
60
|
F
|
Distending pain and diplopia of unilateral eye, blurred vision
|
Lesions in ethmoid sinus and sphenoid sinus, orbital apex with bone absorption
|
Endoscopic biopsy and partial excision
|
1–7
|
IgD-λ
|
Chemotherapy (VRd*1, D-PAD*2)
|
4
|
Death
|