Keywords
Immune-related adverse event - immunotherapy - inflammatory arthropathy - nivolumab
- rheumatoid arthritis
Introduction
The immune system's natural capacity to detect and destroy abnormal cells may prevent
the development of many cancers. However, cancer cells have immune escape mechanisms
to avoid host response.[1] Immunotherapy restores the physiological antitumor response by modifying host response.[2] Nivolumab (Opdivo manufactured by Bristol-Myers Squibb), a human IgG4 monoclonal
antibody with high affinity for the programmed death-1 (PD-1) receptor, is the first
PD-1 immune checkpoint inhibitor approved by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA).
This drug is the first-line treatment of metastatic melanoma. In addition to melanoma,
nivolumab is also used as the second-line treatment for other malignancies such as
renal cell carcinoma, squamous cell lung cancer, other advanced nonsmall cell lung
cancers (NSCLCs) and lymphoma.[3] Nivolumab inhibits the interaction between PD-1 and programmed death-ligand-1 (PD-L1)[1],[2],[4],[5] thus inhibiting the cancer immune escape pathway [1],[2],[4],[5] and allowing the immune system to recognize and fight cancer cells.
Case Report
A 65-year-old Caucasian female with Stage IV melanoma (BRAF-positive) was referred
to our Rheumatology Clinic at the University of Kansas Medical Center for arthritis
evaluation after the initiation of nivolumab treatment. She was initially treated
with vemurafenib and ipilimumab. Following progression of the disease with metastatic
lesions to multiple organs despite the initial treatments, intravenous nivolumab was
given between May 2013 and December 2014 with marked improvement. During treatment
with nivolumab, she developed symmetrical polyarthritis with synovitis and swelling
of both Metacarpophalangeal Joints (MCPs) and (PIPs) Proximal Interphalangeal Joints
bilaterally. No synovitis was appreciated outside of the hands. She reported significant
limitations in the daily activities. For example, she complained of morning stiffness
that lasted for an hour, but she reported that this discomfort progressively improved
through the day. Before the referral, she was on both low-dose prednisone and hydroxychloroquine.
Both medications were not effective in controlling her arthritis even after 4 weeks
of therapy. As a result, she had abruptly stopped these medications. She was not able
to recall the initial doses of these medications during our visit. Methotrexate and
leflunomide were attempted, and she did not tolerate them either. Laboratory evaluation
revealed negative rheumatoid factor (<14 IU/mL) and negative anti-CCP IgG (<17 units/mL).
Both C-reactive protein (0.71 mg/L) and SED rate erythrocyte sedimentation rate (9
mm/h) were low. Uric acid was low (3.6 mg/dl). Hand radiographs revealed arthrosis
in MCP with subchondral lucencies and sclerosis, joint space narrowing, and right
first MCP erosions. Hydroxychloroquine was initiated again at 300 mg daily with good
symptom control. The patient also had osteoarthritis and underwent right total hip
arthroplasty during the time that she was receiving nivolumab. Given a history of
metastatic melanoma, no other disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs (DMARDs) were
started. As of April 2017, the patient's symptoms have remained stable and stayed
under control. Her symptom has improved remarkably. She still continues to follow-up
regularly at our clinic.
Discussion
The PD-1/PD-L1 checkpoint plays an important role as a negative regulator of T-cells,
maintaining self-tolerance in the peripheral tissues.[2],[4],[6] This mechanism also prevents the development of autoimmune reactions [2],[7] and controls local inflammation.[4] The PD-1 on T-cells [1],[2],[4] and PD-L1 on tumor cell interaction decreases the release of T-cell cytokines and
evades host immunity in the microenvironment (cancer immune escape phenomena).[1],[4] Tumors such as melanoma, breast cancer, urothelial, gastrointestinal, lung, and
ovarian cancer express PD-L1 which binds to PD-1 and inhibit the immune system response.
Nivolumab enhances the ability of the immune system to recognize tumors which can
lead to loss of self-tolerance and adverse immune effects.[1],[5] Immune-related adverse events (IRAEs) can develop at any time, but the majority
of those side effects happen in the first 4–6 months of treatment.[1],[8] In one study, 17% of metastatic melanoma patients treated with nivolumab had IRAEs.[1] Rash, colitis, pneumonitis, endocrinopathies, nephritis, and hepatitis are the main
IRAEs in patients treated with nivolumab as data from the European Medicines Agency
and FDA have shown.[8] Other IRAEs associated with anti-PD-1 therapy include dermatitis, autoimmune hemolytic
anemia,[9] vitiligo, and thyroiditis. Severe IRAEs such as colitis with intestinal perforation,
anaphylactic shock, insulin-dependent diabetes, immune thrombocytopenia, Guillain-Barré
syndrome, myocarditis, and acute adrenal insufficiency may occur [1],[5] but are rare.
Our patient did not have personal or family history of autoimmune diseases to suggest
a predisposition to such IRAEs. Furthermore, the patient developed atypical arthritis
associated with erosions. It is unclear if the duration of exposure to such medications
contributes to the severity of arthritis. Despite convincing evidence that checkpoint
blockade drugs are associated with immune side effects, the role of nivolumab in inflammatory
joint disease is unclear. One study relates arthralgia after the use of nivolumab
but does not describe inflammatory joint involvement.[1] Recurrent rheumatoid arthritis (RA) in a patient with advanced NSCLC with the previous
clinical and laboratory remission was reported 15 days after the first nivolumab infusion.[10] It is known that defects in PD-1/PD-L1 pathway contribute to synovial inflammation
in RA patients.[6],[11] The studies suggest that the patients with RA have a soluble form of PD-1 (sPD-1)
within the synovial fluid that binds competitively to PD-L1. This phenomena creates
autoinflammation because the sPD-1 interaction with PD-1 is not able to create immunosuppression
as PD-1/PD-L1 pathway does.[6] It is unclear if nivolumab and other anti-PD-1 therapies create similar effects
that lead to the above-mentioned IRAEs. The cause of T-cell reactivity is unclear
either, and it is certainly different from one patient to the other. Furthermore,
different mechanisms have been suggested to cause type 1 diabetes and myocarditis
in patient received anti-PD-1.[12]
The use of corticosteroids and discontinuation of the culprit drug are the mainstay
treatment of immune-related side effects of PD-1 inhibitors.[1],[2],[4],[7],[8] IV steroids should be used in severe IRAEs such as colitis and pneumonitis.[2],[8] Skin immune side effects (rash, erythema, urticaria, vitiligo, and toxic epidermal
necrolysis) were mostly treated with local and oral steroids.[8] Immunosuppressive agents as tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-inhibitors [2],[3] or mycophenolate [2],[8] could be considered if corticosteroids are not effective in treating IRAEs. In patients
with RA and previously treated or untreated skin cancers (melanoma and nonmelanoma),
the American College of Rheumatology recommends the use of DMARDs over TNF-inhibitors
due to lower risk of recurrence of skin cancers.[13]
All in all, our patient had features which were consistent RA. Such traits were supported
by the presentation of her arthritis and imaging studies. To be more specific, we
also reached to the conclusion of seronegative RA by the absence of both rheumatoid
factors and anti-CCP IgG serological markers and the exclusion of other joint diseases.
Conclusion
This case teaches the significance of immunotherapy and its side effects in the treatment
of active cancer. Our case demonstrates that patients can be at risk of acquiring
seronegative RA as a deleterious side effect. We stress the need of further studies
to better understand the association between the toxicity of immunotherapy and the
mechanisms of autoimmune inflammatory arthropathy like RA. In conclusion, we hope
that this case helps increase the awareness of immune-based reactions to cancer immunotherapy
among physicians and patients. Such discussions can facilitate the prevention of debilitating
side-effects and can also translate better patient care in the setting of cancer treatment.
Financial support and sponsorship
Nil.
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
