Endoscopic versus laparoscopic treatment for choledocholithiasis: a prospective randomized controlled trial

Background and study aims: Overall, 5 % to 15 % of patients undergoing cholecystectomy for cholelithiasis have concomitant bile duct stones, and the incidence of choledocholithiasis increases with age. There is no clear consensus on the best therapeutic approach (endoscopic versus surgical).

Patients and methods: A prospective randomized controlled clinical trial was performed to compare three treatment options for patients with choledocholithiasis at the National Center for Minimally Invasive Surgery in Havana, Cuba from November 2007 to November 2011. The patients were randomized in three groups. Group I: patients who underwent intraoperative cholangiography (IOC) to confirm the choledocholithiasis followed by laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC) associated with intraoperative endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP), group II: patients who underwent preoperative ERCP followed by LC during the same hospital admission and group III: patients who underwent IOC to confirm the choledocholithiasis followed by LC associated with laparoscopic common bile duct exploration (LCBDE).

Results: A total of 300 patients with suspected choledocholithiasis were included in the trial and were randomized. As a result, a total of 134 patients were diagnosed with the presence of choledocholithiasis and treated during the study period. There were no significant differences in success rates of ductal stone clearance, but retained stone, postoperative complications and length of hospital stay were better in group I.

Conclusions: Intraoperative ERCP/ES shows a higher rate of common bile duct stones clearance, a shorter hospital stay, and lower morbidity, but further research with a larger study population is necessary to determine the additional benefits of this procedure. The results to date suggests that in appropriate patients, single-stage treatments are the best options.

• References

• 1 Oddsdottir M, Hunter JG. Gallbladder and extrahepatic biliary system. In: Brunicardi FC, , editor. Schwartz’s Principles of Surgery. Ninth Edition. United States of America: The McGraw-Hill Education; 2010: 821-844
• 2 Mori T, Suzuki Y, Sugiyama M, Atomi Y. Choledocholithiasis. In: Bland KI, Büchler MW, Csendes A, et al., editors General Surgery. Principles and International Practice. Second Edition. London: Springer-Verlag London; 2009: 1061-1073
• 3 Paul A, Millat B, Holthausen U et al. Results of a consensus development conference. Surg Endosc 1998; 12: 856-864
• 4 Neugebauer E, Sauerland S, Fingerhut A et al. EAES Guidelines for Endoscopic Surgery. Twelve years Evidence-Based Surgery in Europe. Germany: Springer; 2006: 311-333
• 5 Clayton ES, Connor S, Alexakis N et al. Meta-analysis of endoscopy and surgery versus surgery alone for common bile duct stones with the gallbladder in situ. Br J Surg 2006; 93: 1185-1191
• 6 Rábago LR, Chico I, Collado D et al. Single-stage treatment with intraoperative ERCP: management of patients with possible choledocholithiasis and gallbladder in situ in a non-tertiary Spanish hospital. Surg Endosc 2012; 26: 1028-1034
• 7 Hong DF, Xin Y, Chen DW. Comparison of laparoscopic cholecystectomy combined with intraoperative endoscopic sphincterotomy and laparoscopic exploration of the common bile duct for cholecystocholedocholithiasis. Surg Endosc 2006; 20: 424-427
• 8 Ghazal AH, Sorour MA, El-Riwini M et al. Single-step treatment of gallbladder and bile duct stones: A combined endoscopic–laparoscopic technique. Int J Surg 2009; 7: 338-346
• 9 Chander J, Vindal A, Lal P et al. Laparoscopic management of CBD stones: an Indian experience. Surg Endosc 2011; 25: 172-181
• 10 Rábago LR, Ortega A, Chico I et al. Intraoperative ERCP: What role does it have in the era of laparoscopic cholecystectomy?. World J Gastrointest Endosc 2011; 3: 248-255
• 11 Martin DJ, Vernon DR, Toouli J. Surgical versus endoscopic treatment of bile duct stones. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2006; CD003327
• 12 Ghazal AH, Sorour MA, El-Riwini M et al. Single-step treatment of gallbladder and bile duct stones: a combined endoscopic-laparoscopic technique. Int J Surg 2009; 7: 338-346
• 13 La Greca G, Barbagallo F, Di Blasi M et al. Laparoendoscopic “Rendezvous” to treat cholecysto-choledocolithiasis: Effective, safe and simplifies the endoscopist’s work. World J Gastroenterol 2008; 14: 2844-2850
• 14 La Greca G, Barbagallo F, Sofia M et al. Simultaneous laparoendoscopic rendezvous for the treatment of cholecystocholedocholithiasis. Surg Endosc 2009; 24: 769-780
• 15 Grizzle JE, Starmer CF, Koch GG. Analysis of categorical data by linear models. Biometrics 1969; 25: 489-450
• 16 Rochon J. The application of the GSK method to the determination of minimum sample sizes. Biometrics 1989; 45: 193-205
• 17 Yaghoobi A, Salimi J, Golfam F et al. Preoperative clinical and paraclinical predictors of choledocholithiasis. Hepatobiliary Pancreat Dis Int 2008; 7: 304-307
• 18 Maple JT, Ikenberry SO, Anderson MA. ASGE Standards of Practice Committee et al. The role of endoscopy in the management of choledocholithiasis. Gastrointest Endosc 2011; 74: 731-744
• 19 Springer J, Enns R, Romagnuolo J et al. Canadian credentialing guidelines for endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography. Can J Gastroenterol 2008; 22: 547-551
• 20 Cohen S, Bacon BR, Berlin JA et al. National Institutes of Health State-of-the-Science Conference Statement: ERCP for diagnosis and therapy, January 14-16, 2002. Gastrointest Endosc 2002; 56: 803-809
• 21 Saccomani G, Durante V, Magnolia MR et al. Combined endoscopic treatment for cholelithiasis associated with choledocholithiasis. Surg Endosc 2005; 19: 910-914
• 22 Guda NM, Freeman ML. 30 years of ERCP and still the same problems?. Endoscopy 2007; 39: 833-835
• 23 Khan OA, Balaji S, Branagan G et al. Randomized clinical trial of routine on-table cholangiography during laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Br J Surg 2011; 98: 362-367
• 24 Petersen BT. Combined approaches to endoscopic retrograde biliary access after failed transpapillary approach. Gastrointest Endosc 2007; 5: 136-140
• 25 La Greca G, Barbagallo F, Di Blasi M et al. Rendezvous technique versus endoscopic retrogradecholangiopancreatography to treat bile duct stones reduces endoscopic time and pancreatic damage. J Laparoendoscop Adv Surgical Techniques 2007; 17: 167-171
• 26 Kharbutli B, Velanovich V. Management of preoperatively suspected choledocholithiasis: a decision analysis. J Gastrointest Surg 2008; 12: 1973-1980
• 27 Cavina E, Franceschi M, Sidoti F et al. Laparo-endoscopic “rendezvous”: a new technique in the choledocholithiasis treatment. Hepatogastroenterology 1998; 45: 1430-1435
• 28 ElGeidie AA, ElEbidy GK, Naeem YM. Preoperative versus intraoperative endoscopic sphincterotomy for management of common bile duct stones. Surg Endosc 2011; 25: 1230-1237
• 29 Byrne M, McLoughlin M, Mitchell R et al. The fate of patients who undergo ‘‘preoperative’’ ERCP to clear known or suspected bile duct stones. Surg Endosc 2009; 23: 74-79
• 30 Silviera ML, Seamon MJ, Porshinsky B et al. Complications related to endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography: A comprehensive clinical review. J Gastrointestin Liver Dis 2009; 18: 73-82
• 31 Mallery JS, Baron TH, Dominitz JA. Complications of ERCP. Gastrointest Endosc 2003; 57: 633-638
• 32 Yasui T, Takahata Sh, Kono H et al. Is cholecystectomy necessary after endoscopic treatment of bile duct stones in patients older than 80 years of age?. J Gastroenterol 2012; 47: 65-70
• 33 Cuschieri A, Lezoche E, Morino M et al. E.A.E.S multicenter prospective randomized trial comparing two stage vs single stage management of patients with gallstones disease and ductal calculi. Surg Endosc 1999; 13: 952-957
• 34 Byrne MF, McLoughlin MT, Mitchell RM et al. The fate of patients who undergo ‘‘preoperative’’ ERCP to clear known or suspected bile duct stones. Surg Endosc 2009; 23: 74-79
• 35 Georgiades CP, Mavromatis TN, Kourlaba GC et al. Is inflammation a significant predictor of bile duct injury during laparoscopic cholecystectomy?. Surg Endosc 2008; 22: 1959-1964
• 36 Noble H, Tranter S, Chesworth T et al. A randomized, clinical trial to compare endoscopic sphincterotomy and subsequent laparoscopic cholecystectomy with primary laparoscopic bile duct exploration during cholecystectomy in higher risk patients with choledocholithiasis. J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech 2009; 19: 713-720
• 37 Rogers SJ, Cello JP, Horn JK et al. Prospective randomized trial of LC/LCBDE vs ERCP/ES/LC for common bile duct stone disease. Arch Surg 2010; 145: 28-33
• 38 Lu J, Cheng Y, Xiong XZ et al. Two-stage vs single-stage management for concomitant gallstones and common bile duct stones. World J Gastroenterol 2012; 18: 3156-3166
• 39 Wang B, Guo Z, Liu Z et al. Preoperative versus intraoperative endoscopic sphincterotomy in patients with gallbladder and suspected common bile duct stones: system review and meta-analysis. Surg Endosc 2013; 27: 2454-2465