The Diversity of Self-Incompatibility Systems in Flowering Plants

Abstract

Flowering plants are the most successful group of land plants and dominate the earth's vegetation with around 300 000 species. This success is, in part, the consequence of a set of unique reproductive innovations that evolved with the flower. Most notable of these innovations were the closed carpel and double fertilization. Closed carpels permitted the evolution of effective mechanisms for pollen selection and discrimination, while double fertilization leading to endosperm formation allowed for more efficient utilization of resources because reserves are only allocated to the seed after fertilization. This review will focus on the most important and best understood mechanism of pollen discrimination, self-incompatibility (SI), a genetically determined pollen recognition system that prevents self-fertilization and fertilization by other individuals with the same incompatibility phenotype. In recent years much progress has been made towards elucidating the molecular mechanisms of SI operating in three distinct SI systems found in the Brassicaceae, Solanaceae and Papaveraceae, respectively. More recent molecular data obtained from the Poaceae, Convolvulaceae and Asteraceae, however, suggest that other molecular mechanisms of SI exist. A survey of classical genetic studies of SI predicts yet further potential molecular mechanisms of SI. We discuss the evolutionary implications of this apparent diversity in molecular pathways leading to SI and stress the need for more molecular studies of different SI systems.

Key words

Self-incompatibility - S genes - S-RNase - S receptor kinase - S-protein

References

• 01 Barrett,  S. C. H., and Cruzan,  M. B.. (1994) Incompatibility in heterostylous plants. Genetic control of incompatibility and reproductive development in flowering plants. Williams, E. G., Knox, R. B., and Clarke, A. E., eds. Netherlands; Kluwer Academic Publishers pp. 189-219
• 02 Baumann,  U.,, Juttner,  J.,, Bian,  X.,, and Langridge,  P.. (2000);  Self-incompatibility in the grasses.  Ann. Bot.. 85 (A) 203-209
• 03 Bower,  M. S.,, Matias,  D. D.,, Fernandes-Carvalho,  E.,, Mazzurco,  M.,, Gu,  T.,, Rothstein,  S.,, and Goring,  D. R.. (1996);  Two members of the thioredoxin-h family interact with the kinase domain of a Brassica S locus receptor kinase.  Plant Cell. 8 1641-1650
• 04 Cabrillac,  D.,, Cock,  M. J.,, Dumas,  C.,, and Gaude,  T.. (2001);  The S-locus receptor kinase is inhibited by thioredoxins and activated by pollen coat proteins.  Nature. 410 220-223
• 05 Craig,  K. L., and Tyers,  M.. (1999);  The F-box: a new motif for ubiquitin dependent proteolysis in cell cycle regulation and signal transduction.  Prog. Biophys. Mol. Biol.. 72 299-328
• 06 Cruz-Garcia,  F.,, and Hancock,  N. C.,, and McClure,  B. A.. (2003);  S-RNase complexes and pollen rejection.  J. Exp. Bot.. 54 123-130
• 07 Darwin,  C.. (1877) The different forms of flowers and plants of the same species. London; John Murray
• 08 de Nettancourt,  D.. (1977) Incompatibility in Angiosperms. Berlin; Springer-Verlag
• 09 Dodds,  P. N.,, Ferguson,  C.,, Clarke,  A. E.,, and Newbigin,  E.. (1999);  Pollen-expressed S-RNases are not involved in self-incompatibility in Lycopersicon peruvianum. .  Sex. Plant Reprod.. 12 76-87
• 10 Foote,  H. C. C.,, Ride,  J. P.,, Franklin-Tong,  V. E.,, Walker,  E. A.,, Lawrence,  M. J.,, and Franklin,  F. C. H.. (1994);  Cloning and expression of a distinctive class of self-incompatibility (S) gene from Papaver rhoeas L.  Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 91 2265-2269
• 11 Franklin-Tong,  V. E.,, Lawrence,  M. J.,, and Franklin,  F. C. H.. (1988);  An in vitro bioassay for the stigmatic product of the self-incompatibility gene in Papaver rhoeas L.  New Phytol.. 110 109-118
• 12 Franklin-Tong,  V. E.,, Ride,  J. P.,, Read,  N. D.,, Trewavas,  A. J.,, and Franklin,  F. C. H.. (1993);  The self-incompatibility response in Papaver rhoeas is mediated by cytosolic free calcium.  Plant J.. 4 163-167
• 13 Franklin-Tong,  V. E.,, Ride,  J. P.,, and Franklin,  F. C. H.. (1995);  Recombinant stigmatic self-incompatibility (S-) protein elicits a Ca²⁺ transient in pollen of Papaver rhoeas. .  Plant J.. 8 299-307
• 14 Franklin-Tong,  V. E.,, Hackett,  G.,, and Hepler,  P. K.. (1997);  Ratio imaging of Ca²⁺ _i in the self-incompatibility response in pollen tubes of Papaver rhoeas. .  Plant J.. 12 1375-1386
• 15 Ganders,  F. R.. (1979);  The biology of heterostyly.  N. Z. J. Bot.. 17 607-635
• 16 Gerstel,  D. U.. (1950);  Self-incompatibility studies in Guayule.  Genetics. 35 482-506
• 17 Golz,  J. F.,, Su,  V.,, Clarke,  A. E.,, and Newbigin,  E.. (1999);  A molecular description of mutations affecting the pollen component of the Nicotiana alata S-locus.  Genetics. 152 1123-1135
• 18 Golz,  J. F.,, Clarke,  A. E.,, and Newbigin,  E.. (2000);  Mutational approaches to the study of self-incompatibility: revisiting the pollen-part mutants.  Ann. Bot.. 85 (A) 95-103
• 19 Golz,  J. F.,, Oh,  H.-Y.,, Su,  V.,, Kusaba,  M.,, and Newbigin,  E.. (2001);  Genetic analysis of Nicotiana pollen-part mutants is consistent with the presence of an S-ribonuclease inhibitor at the S locus.  Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.. 98 15372-15376
• 20 Gu,  T.,, Mazzurco,  M.,, Sulaman,  W.,, Matias,  D. D.,, and Goring,  D. R.. (1998);  Binding of an arm repeat protein to the kinase domain of the S-locus receptor kinase.  Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 95 382-387
• 21 Hayman,  D. L.. (1956);  The genetic control of incompatibility in Phalaris coerulescens DESF.  Australian J. Biol. Sci.. 9 321-331
• 22 Hearne,  M. J.,, Franklin,  F. C. H.,, and Ride,  J. P.. (1996);  Identification of a membrane glycoprotein in pollen of Papaver rhoeas which binds self-incompatibility (S-) proteins.  Plant J.. 9 467-475
• 23 Hiscock,  S. J.. (2000 a);  Genetic control of self-incompatibility in Senecio squalidus L. (Asteraceae): a successful colonizing species.  Heredity. 85 10-19
• 24 Hiscock,  S. J.. (2000 b);  Self-incompatibility in Senecio squalidus L. (Asteraceae).  Ann. Bot.. 85 (A) 181-190
• 25 Hiscock,  S. J.,, McInnis,  S. M.,, Tabah,  D. A.,, Henderson,  C. A.,, and Brennan,  A. C. E.. (2003);  Self-incompatibility in Senecio squalidus L. (Asteraceae) - the search for S.  J. Exp. Bot.. 54 169-174
• 26 Hiscock,  S. J.,, and Kües,  U.. (1999);  Cellular and molecular mechanisms of sexual incompatibility in plants and fungi.  Int. Rev. Cytol.. 193 165-295
• 27 Hughes,  M. B., and Babcock,  E. B.. (1950);  Self-incompatibility in Crepis foetida L. subsp. rhoeadifolia Bieb. Schinz et Keller.  Genetics. 35 570-588
• 28 Huang,  S.,, Lee,  H.-S.,, Karunanandaa,  B.,, and Kao,  T.-H.. (1994);  Ribonuclease activity of Petunia inflata S proteins is essential for rejection of self-pollen.  Plant Cell. 6 1021-1028
• 29 Igic,  B., and Kohn,  J. R.. (2001);  Evolutionary relationships among self-incompatibility RNases.  Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 98 13167-13171
• 30 Joazeiro,  C. A. P., and Weissmann,  A. M.. (2000);  RING finger proteins: mediators of ubiquitin ligase activity.  Cell. 102 549-552
• 31 Jordan,  N. D.,, Ride,  J. P.,, Rudd,  J. J.,, Davies,  E. M.,, Franklin-Tong,  V. E.,, and Franklin,  F. C. H.. (2000 a);  Inhibition of self-incompatible pollen in Papaver rhoeas involves a complex series of cellular events.  Ann. Bot.. 85 (A) 197-202
• 32 Jordan,  N. D.,, Franklin,  F. C. H.,, and Franklin-Tong,  V. E.. (2000 b);  Evidence for DNA fragmentation triggered in the self-incompatibility response in pollen of Papaver rhoeas. .  Plant J.. 23 471-479
• 33 Kachroo,  A.,, Schopfer,  C. R.,, Nasrallah,  M. E.,, and Nasrallah,  J. B.. (2001);  Allele-specific receptor-ligand interactions in Brassica self-incompatibility.  Science. 293 1824-1826
• 34 Kondo,  K.,, Yamamoto,  M.,, Itahashi,  R.,, Sato,  T.,, Egashira,  H.,, Hattori,  T.,, and Kowyama,  Y.. (2002);  Insights into the evolution of self-compatibility in Lycopersicon from the study of stylar factors.  Plant J.. 30 143-153
• 35 Kowyama,  Y.,, Takahashi,  H.,, Muraoka,  K.,, Tani,  T.,, Hara,  K.,, and Shiotani,  I.. (1994);  Number, frequency and dominance relationships of S-alleles in diploid Ipomoea trifida. .  Heredity. 73 275-283
• 36 Kowyama,  Y.,, Kakeda,  K.,, Nakano,  R.,, and Hattori,  T.. (1995);  SLG/SRK-like genes are expressed in the reproductive tissues of Ipomoea trifida. .  Sex. Plant Reprod.. 8 333-338
• 37 Kowyama,  Y.,, Kakeda,  K.,, Kondo,  K.,, Imada,  T.,, and Hattori,  T.. (1996);  A putative receptor protein kinase gene in Ipomoea trifida. .  Plant Cell Physiol.. 37 681-685
• 38 Kowyama,  Y.,, Tsuchiya,  T.,, and Kakeda,  K.. (2000);  Sporophyitc self-incompatibility in Ipomoea trifida: a close relative of sweet potato.  Ann. Bot.. 85 (A) 191-196
• 39 Kurup,  S.,, Ride,  J. P.,, Jordan,  N. D.,, Fletcher,  E. G.,, Franklin-Tong,  V. E.,, and Franklin,  F. C. H.. (1998);  Identification and cloning of related self-incompatibility S-genes in Papaver rhoeas and Papaver nudicaule. .  Sex. Plant Reprod.. 11 192-198
• 40 Kunz,  C.,, Chang,  A.,, Faure,  J.-D.,, Clarke,  A. E.,, Polya,  G. M.,, and Anderson,  M. A.. (1996);  Phosphorylation of style S-RNases by Ca²⁺-dependent protein kinases from pollen tubes.  Sex. Plant Reprod.. 9 25-34
• 41 Kusaba,  M.,, Nishio,  T.,, Satta,  Y.,, Hinata,  K.,, and Ockendon,  D.. (1997);  Striking sequence similarity in inter- and intra-specific comparisons of class I SLG alleles from Brassica oleracea and Brassica campestris: Implications for the evolution and recognition mechanism.  Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 94 7673-7678
• 42 Kusaba,  M.,, Matsushita,  M.,, Okazaki,  K.,, Satta,  Y.,, and Nishio,  T.. (2000);  Sequence and structural diversity of the S-locus genes from different lines with the same self-recognition specificities in Brassica oleracea. .  Genetics. 154 413-420
• 43 Kusaba,  M.,, Tung,  C.-W.,, Nasrallah,  M. E.,, and Nasrallah,  J. B.. (2002);  Monoallelic expression and dominance interactions in anthers of self-incompatible Arabidopsis lyrata. .  Plant Physiol.. 128 17-20
• 44 Lai,  Z.,, Ma,  W.,, Han,  B.,, Liang,  L.,, Zhang,  Y.,, Hong,  G.,, and Xue,  Y.. (2002);  An F-box gene linked to the self-incompatibility (S) locus of Antirrhinum is expressed specifically in pollen and tapetum.  Plant Mol. Biol.. 50 29-42
• 45 Lee,  H.-S.,, Huang,  S.,, and Kao,  T.-H.. (1994);  S proteins control rejection of incompatible pollen in Petunia inflata. .  Nature. 367 560-563
• 46 Lewis,  D.. (1979 a) Sexual Incompatibility in Plants. Edward Arnold
• 47 Lewis,  D.. (1979 b);  Genetic versatility of incompatibility in plants.  N. Z. J. Bot.. 17 637-644
• 48 Lewis,  D.. (1994) Gametophytic-sporophytic incompatibility. Genetic Control of Self-Incompatibility and Reproductive Development in Flowering Plants. Williams, E. G., Clarke, A. E., and Knox, R. B., eds. Dordrecht; Kluwer pp. 88-101
• 49 Li,  X.,, Nield,  J.,, Hayman,  D.,, and Langridge,  P.. (1994);  Cloning a putative self-incompatibility gene from the pollen of the grass Phalaris coerulescens. .  Plant Cell. 6 1923-1932
• 50 Lundqvist,  A.. (1954);  Studies on self-sterility in rye, Secale cereale L.  Hereditas. 40 278-294
• 51 Lundqvist,  A.,, Østerbye,  U.,, Larsen,  K.,, and Linde-Laursen,  I.. (1973);  Complex self-incompatibility systems in Ranunculus acris L. and Beta vulgaris L.  Hereditas. 74 161-168
• 52 Lundqvist,  A.. (1975);  Complex self-incompatibility systems in angiosperms.  Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B.. 188 235-245
• 53 Lundqvist,  A.. (1990);  The complex S-gene system for control of self-incompatibility in the buttercup genus Ranunculus. .  Hereditas. 113 29-46
• 54 Lundqvist,  A.. (1990);  One-locus sporophytic S-gene system with traces of gametophytic pollen control in Cerastium arvense ssp. strictum (Carophyllaceae).  Hereditas. 113 203-215
• 55 Lundqvist,  A.. (1991);  Four-locus S-gene control of self-incompatibility made probable in Lilium martagon (Liliaceae).  Hereditas. 114 57-63
• 56 Lundqvist,  A.. (1994);  “Slow” and “quick” S-alleles without dominance interaction in the sporophytic one-locus self-incompatibility system of Stellaria holostea (Caryophyllaceae).  Hereditas. 120 191-202
• 57 Luu,  D.-T.,, Qin,  X.,, Morse,  D.,, and Cappadocia,  M.. (2000);  S-RNase uptake by compatible pollen tubes in gametophytic self-incompatibility.  Nature. 407 649-651
• 58 Matton,  D. P.,, Maes,  O.,, Laublin,  G.,, Xike,  Q.,, Bertrand,  C.,, Morse,  D.,, and Cappadocia,  M.. (1997);  Hypervariable domains of self-incompatibility RNases mediate allele-specific pollen recognition.  Plant Cell. 9 1756-1766
• 59 McClure,  B. A.,, Haring,  V.,, Ebert,  P. R.,, Anderson,  M. A.,, Simpson,  R. J.,, Sakiyama,  F.,, and Clarke,  A. E.. (1989);  Style self-incompatibility gene products of Nicotiana alata are ribonucleases.  Nature. 342 955-957
• 60 McClure,  B. A.,, Mou,  B.,, Canevascini,  S.,, and Bernatsky,  R.. (1999);  A small asparagine-rich protein required for S-allele-specific pollen rejection in Nicotiana. .  Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 96 13548-13553
• 61 McClure,  B. A.,, Cruz-Garcia,  F.,, Beecher,  B.,, and Sulaman,  W.. (2000);  Factors affecting inter- and intra-specific pollen rejection in Nicotiana. .  Ann. Bot.. 85 (A) 113-123
• 62 McCubbin,  A. G., and Kao,  T.-H.. (2000);  Molecular recognition and response in pollen and pistil interactions.  Ann. Rev. Cell Dev. Biol.. 16 333-364
• 63 Murfett,  J.,, Atherton,  T. L.,, Mou,  B.,, Gasser,  C. S.,, and McClure,  B. A.. (1994);  S-RNase expressed in transgenic Nicotiana causes S-allele-specific pollen rejection.  Nature. 367 563-566
• 64 Nasrallah,  J. B.,, Stein,  J. C.,, Kandasamy,  M. K.,, and Nasrallah,  M. E.. (1994);  Signalling the arrest of pollen tube development in self-incompatible plants.  Science. 266 1505-1508
• 65 Nasrallah,  M. E.,, Liu,  P.,, and Nasrallah,  J. B.. (2002);  Generation of self-incompatible Arabidopsis thaliana by transfer of two S locus genes from A. lyrata. .  Science. 297 247-249
• 66 Ride,  J. P.,, Davies,  E. M.,, Franklin,  F. C. H.,, and Marshall,  D. F.. (1999);  Analysis of Arabidopsis genome reveals a large new gene family in plants.  Plant Mol. Biol.. 39 927-932
• 67 Royo,  J.,, Kunz,  C.,, Kowyama,  Y.,, Anderson,  M.,, Clarke,  A. E.,, Newbigin,  E.. (1994);  Loss of histidine residue at the active site of S-locus ribonuclease is associated with self-compatibility in Lycopersicon peruvianum. .  Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 91 6511-6514
• 68 Rudd,  J. J., and Franklin-Tong,  V. E.. (2003);  Signals and targets of the self-incompatibility response in pollen of Papaver rhoeas. .  J. Exp. Bot.. 54 141-148
• 69 Rudd,  J. J.,, Lord,  J. M.,, Franklin,  F. C. H.,, and Franklin-Tong,  V. E.. (1996);  Increased phosphorylation of a 26 kD pollen protein is induced by the self-incompatibility response in Papaver rhoeas. .  Plant Cell. 8 713-724
• 70 Rudd,  J. J.,, Franklin,  F. C. H.,, and Franklin-Tong,  V. E.. (1997);  Ca²⁺-independent phosphorylation of a 68 kD pollen protein is stimulated by the self-incompatibility response in Papaver rhoeas. .  Plant J.. 12 507-514
• 71 Schopfer,  C. R.,, Nasrallah,  M. E.,, and Nasrallah,  J. B.. (1999);  The male determinant of self-incompatibility in Brassica. .  Science. 266 1697-1700
• 72 Schopfer,  C. R., and Nasrallah,  J. B.. (2000);  Self-incompatibility. Prospects for a novel putative peptide-signaling molecule.  Plant Physiol.. 124 935-939
• 73 Shiba,  H.,, Iwano,  M.,, Entani,  T.,, Ishimoto,  T.,, Che,  F.-S.,, Satta,  Y.,, Ito,  A.,, Takada,  Y.,, Watanabe,  M.,, Isogai,  A.,, and Takayama,  S.. (2002);  The dominance of alleles controlling self-incompatibility in Brassica pollen is regulated at the RNA level.  Plant Cell. 14 491-504
• 74 Sims,  T. L., and Ordanic,  M.. (2001);  Identification of a S-ribonuclease-binding protein in Petunia hybrida. .  Plant Mol. Biol.. 47 771-783
• 75 Snowman,  B. N.,, Geitmann,  A.,, Clarke,  S. R.,, Staiger,  C. J.,, Franklin,  C. H. F.,, Emons,  A. M. C.,, and Franklin-Tong,  V. E.. (2000);  Signalling and the cytoskeleton of pollen tubes of Papaver rhoeas. .  Ann. Bot.. 85 (A) 49-57
• 76 Snowman,  B. N.,, Kovar,  D. R.,, Shevchenko,  G.,, Franklin-Tong,  V. E.,, and Staiger,  C. J.. (2002);  Signal-mediated depolymerization of actin in pollen during the self-incompatibility response.  Plant Cell. 14 2613-2626
• 77 Soltis,  P. S.,, Soltis,  D. E.,, and Chase,  M. W.. (1999);  Angiosperm phylogeny inferred from multiple genes as a tool for comparative biology.  Nature. 402 402-404
• 78 Stephenson,  A. J.,, Doughty,  J.,, Elleman,  C. J.,, Hiscock,  S. J.,, and Dickinson,  H. G.. (1997);  The male determinant of self-incompatibility in Brassica oleracea is located in the pollen-coating.  Plant Journal. 12 1351-1359
• 79 Stone,  S. L.,, Arnoldo,  M.,, and Goring,  D. R.. (1999);  A breakdown of Brassica self-incompatibility in ARC1 antisense transgenic plants.  Science. 286 1729-1731
• 80 Suzuki,  G.,, Kusaba,  M.,, Matsushita,  M.,, Okazaki,  K.,, and Nishio,  T.. (2000);  Characterization of Brassica S-haplotypes lacking S-locus glycoprotein.  FEBS Lett.. 482 102-108
• 81 Takasaki,  T.,, Hatakeyama,  K.,, Suzuki,  G.,, Watanabe,  M.,, Isogai,  A.,, and Hinata,  K.. (2000);  The S receptor kinase determines self-incompatibility in Brassica stigma. .  Nature. 403 913-916
• 82 Takayama,  S.,, Shiba,  H.,, Iwano,  M.,, Shimosato,  H.,, Che,  F.-S.,, Kai,  N.,, Watanabe,  M.,, Suzuki,  G.,, Hinata,  K.,, and Isogai,  A.. (2000);  The pollen determinant of self-incompatibility in Brassica campestris. .  Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci.. 97 1920-1925
• 83 Takayama,  S.,, Shimosato,  H.,, Shiba,  H.,, Funato,  M.,, Che,  F.-E.,, Watanabe,  M.,, Iwano,  M.,, and Isogai,  A.. (2001);  Direct ligand-receptor complex interaction controls Brassica self-incompatibility.  Nature. 413 534-538
• 84 Thien,  L. B.,, White,  D. A.,, and Yatsu,  L. Y.. (1983);  The reproductive biology of a relict - Illicium floridanum. .  Am. J. Bot.. 70 717-727
• 85 Walker,  E. A.,, Ride,  J. P.,, Kurup,  S.,, Franklin-Tong,  V. E.,, Lawrence,  M. J.,, and Franklin,  F. C. H.. (1996);  Molecular analysis of two functional homologues of the S ₃ allele of the Papaver rhoeas incompatibility gene isolated from different populations.  Plant Mol. Biol.. 30 983-994
• 86 Watanabe,  M.,, Ito,  A.,, Takada,  Y.,, Ninmiya,  C.,, Kakizaki,  T.,, Takahata,  Y.,, Hatakeyama,  K.,, Hinata,  K.,, Suzuki,  G.,, Takasaki,  T.,, Satta,  Y.,, Shiba,  H.,, Takayama,  S.,, and Isogai,  A.. (2000);  Highly divergent sequences of the pollen self-incompatibility (S) gene in class-I S haplotypes of Brassica campestris (syn. rapa) L.  FEBS Lett.. 473 139-144
• 87 Whitehouse,  H. L. K.. (1950);  Multiple allelomorph incompatibility of pollen and style in the evolution of angiosperms.  Ann. Bot. N. S.. 14 198-216
• 88 Zurek,  D. M.,, Mou,  B.,, Beecher,  B.,, and McClure,  B.. (1997);  Exchanging sequence domains between S-RNases from Nicotiana alata disrupts pollen recognition.  Plant J.. 11 797-808

Section Editor: L. A. C. J. Voesenek