A Prospective, Randomized Trial Comparing Endoscopic and Surgical Therapy for Chronic Pancreatitis
Submitted 17 April 2001
Accepted after Revision 24 April 2003
24 June 2003 (online)
Background and Study Aims: Invasive treatment for abdominal pain due to chronic pancreatitis may be either surgical or endoscopic, particularly in cases of ductal obstruction. To date, the data published on the effectiveness of these two forms of therapy have been mostly retrospective, and there have been no randomized studies. A prospective, randomized study comparing surgery with endoscopy in patients with painful obstructive chronic pancreatitis was therefore conducted.
Patients and Methods: Consecutive patients with pancreatic duct obstruction and pain were invited to participate in a randomized trial comparing endotherapy and surgery, the latter consisting of resection and drainage procedures, depending on the patient’s individual situation. Patients who did not agree to participation and randomization were also further assessed using the same follow-up protocol.
Results: Of 140 eligible patients, only 72 agreed to be randomized. Surgery consisted of resection (80 %) and drainage (20 %) procedures, while endotherapy included sphincterotomy and stenting (52 %) and/or stone removal (23 %). In the entire group, the initial success rates were similar for both groups, but at the 5-year follow-up, complete absence of pain was more frequent after surgery (37 % vs. 14 %), with the rate of partial relief being similar (49 % vs. 51 %). In the randomized subgroup, results were similar (pain absence 34 % after surgery vs. 15 % after endotherapy, relief 52 % after surgery vs. 46 % after endotherapy). The increase in body weight was also greater by 20 - 25 % in the surgical group, while new-onset diabetes developed with similar frequency in both groups (34 - 43 %), again with no differences between the results for the whole group and the randomized subgroup.
Conclusions: Surgery is superior to endotherapy for long-term pain reduction in patients with painful obstructive chronic pancreatitis. Better selection of patients for endotherapy may be helpful in order to maximize results. Due to its low degree of invasiveness, however, endotherapy can be offered as a first-line treatment, with surgery being performed in case of failure and/or recurrence.
- 1 Díte P, Starý K, Tomanová M. et al . Incidence of chronic pancreatitis in Czech Republic. Czech Slovak Gastroenterol. 2000; 54 167-171
- 2 Pitchumoni C S. Chronic pancreatitis: pathogenesis and management of pain. J Clin Gastroenterol. 1998; 27 101-107
- 3 Sarr M G, Sakorafas G H. Incapacitating pain of chronic pancreatitis: a surgical perspective of what is known and what needs to be known. Gastrointest Endosc. 1999; 49 S85-89
- 4 Glasbrenner B, Adler G. Evaluating pain and the quality of the life in chronic pancreatitis. Int J Pancreatol. 1997; 22 163-170
- 5 Axon A TR, Classen M, Cotton P. et al . Pancreatography in chronic pancreatitis: international definition. Gut. 1984; 25 1107-1112
- 6 Burdick J S, Hogan W J. Chronic pancreatitis: selection of patients for endoscopic therapy. Endoscopy. 1991; 23 155-160
- 7 Rösch T, Daniel S, Scholz M. et al . Endoscopic treatment of chronic pancreatitis: a multicenter study of 1000 patients with long-term follow-up. Endoscopy. 2002; 34 765-771
- 8 Cremer M, Devière J, Delhay M. et al . Stenting in severe chronic pancreatitis: results of medium-term follow-up in 76 patients. Endoscopy. 1991; 23 171-176
- 9 Díte P, Zbořil V, Cikanková E. Endoscopic therapy of chronic pancreatitis. Hepatogastroenterology. 1996; 43 1633-1637
- 10 Bittencourt P L, Delhaye M, Devière J. et al . Immediate and long-term results of pancreatic ductal drainage in severe painful chronic pancreatitis. Gut. 1996; 39 A99
- 11 Hakaim A C, Broughan T A, Vogt D P, Hermann R E. Long-term results of the surgical management of chronic pancreatitis. Am Surg. 1994; 60 306-308
- 12 Izbicki J R, Bloechle C, Broering D C. et al . Extended drainage versus resection in surgery for chronic pancreatitis: a prospective randomized trial comparing the longitudinal pancreaticojejunostomy combined with local pancreatic head excision with the pylorus-preserving pancreatoduodenectomy. Ann Surg. 1998; 228 771-779
- 13 Melzack R. The McGill Pain Questionnaire: major properties and scoring methods. Pain. 1975; 1 277-299
- 14 American Diabetes Association . Report of the expert committee on the diagnosis and classification of diabetes mellitus. Diabetes Care. 1997; 20 1183-1197
- 15 Cotton P B. Randomization is not the (only) answer: a plea for structured objective evaluation of endoscopic therapy. Endoscopy. 2000; 32 402-405
- 16 Prinz R A, Greenlee H B. Pancreatic duct drainage in chronic pancreatitis. Hepatogastroenterology. 1990; 37 295-300
- 17 Prinz R A.
Pancreatic duct drainage. In: Beger HG, Warshaw AL, Büchler MW, et al (eds) The pancreas. Oxford; Blackwell Science 1998: 829-836
- 18 Bradley E L. Long-term results of pancreatojejunostomy in patients with chronic pancreatitis. Am J Surg. 1987; 153 207-213
- 19 Prinz R A.
Surgical drainage procedures. In: Howard JM, Idezuki Y, Ihse I, Prinz RA (eds) Surgical diseases of the pancreas. 3rd ed. Baltimore; Williams and Wilkins 1998: 359-366
- 20 Sarles J C, Nacchiero M, Garani F. et al . Surgical treatment of chronic pancreatitis. Am J Surg. 1982; 144 317-321
- 21 Beger H G, Schlosser W, Friess H M. et al . Duodenum-preserving head resection in chronic pancreatitis changes the natural course of the disease. Ann Surg. 1999; 4 512-523
- 22 Müller M W, Friess H, Beger H G. et al . Gastric emptying following pylorus-preserving Whipple and duodenum-preserving pancreatic head resection in patients with chronic pancreatitis. Am J Surg. 1997; 173 257-263
- 23 Büchler M W, Friess H, Müller M W. et al . Randomized trial of duodenum-preserving pancreatic head resection versus pylorus-preserving Whipple in chronic pancreatitis. Am J Surg. 1995; 169 69-70
- 24 Friess H, Shrikhande S, Büchler M W.
Neurotransmitters and nerve growth factors in chronic pancreatitis. In: Büchler MW, Friess H, Uhl W, Malfertheiner P (eds) Chronic pancreatitis: novel concepts in biology and therapy. Oxford; Blackwell Science 2002
- 25 Zhao P, Tu J, Penninckx F. et al . Early derivation operation can restore the pancreas histology and function in chronic obstructive pancreatitis in the cat. Hepatogastroenterology. 1998; 45 1849-1854
- 26 Kozarek R A. Pancreatic stents can induce ductal changes consistent with chronic pancreatitis. Gastrointest Endosc. 1990; 36 93-95
- 27 Huibregtse K, Schneider B, Vrij A A, Tytgat G NJ. Endoscopic pancreatic drainage in chronic pancreatitis. Gastrointest Endosc. 1988; 34 8-10
- 28 Provansal-Cheylan M, Bernard J P, Mariani A. et al . Occluded pancreatic endoprostheses: analysis of the clogging material. Endoscopy. 1989; 21 63-69
- 29 Sherman S, Alvarez C, Robert M. et al . Polyethylene pancreatic duct stent-induced changes in the normal dog pancreas. Gastrointest Endosc. 1993; 39 658-664
- 30 Binmoeller K F, Jue P, Seifert H. et al . Endoscopic pancreatic stent drainage in pancreatitis and a dominant stricture: long-term results. Endoscopy. 1995; 27 638-644
- 31 Kozarek R A, Patterson D J, Ball T J, Traverso L W. Endoscopic placement of pancreatic stents and drains in the management of pancreatitis. Ann Surg. 1989; 209 261-266
- 32 Ponchon T, Bory R M, Hedelius F. et al . Endoscopic stenting for pain relief in chronic pancreatitis: results of a standardized protocol. Gastrointest Endosc. 1995; 42 452-456
- 33 Okolo P, Pasricha P J, Kalloo A N. What are the long-term results of endoscopic pancreatic sphincterotomy?. Gastrointest Endosc. 2000; 52 15-19
- 34 Schmalz M J, Geenen J E. Therapeutic pancreatic endoscopy. Endoscopy. 1999; 31 88-94
- 35 Smits M E, Rauws E A, Tytgat G N. et al . Endoscopic treatment of pancreatic stones in patients with chronic pancreatitis. Gastrointest Endosc. 1996; 43 556-560
- 36 Layer P, Yamamoto H, Kalthoff L. et al . The different courses of early- and late-onset idiopathic and alcoholic chronic pancreatitis. Gastroenterology. 1994; 107 1481-1487
- 37 Miyake H, Harada H, Kunichika K. et al . Clinical course and prognosis of chronic pancreatitis. Pancreas. 1987; 2 378-385
- 38 Lankisch P G, Löhr-Happe A, Otto J, Creutzfeldt W. Natural course in chronic pancreatitis. Digestion. 1993; 54 148-155
- 39 Ammann R W, Muellhaupt B. The natural history of pain in alcoholic chronic pancreatitis. Gastroenterology. 1999; 116 1132-1140
- 40 McHale A, Buechter K, Cohn I, O’Leary J P. Surgical management of chronic pain from chronic pancreatitis. Am Surg. 1997; 63 1119-1122
- 41 Ružicka M, Díte P, Kala Z. Our approach to the surgical treatment of chronic pancreatitis. Hepatogastroenterology. 1997; 44 1472-1476
- 42 Tuech J J, Duplessis R, Villapadierna F. et al . Anastomose pancréatojéjunale ou pancréaticogastrique après duodénopancréatectomie céphalique: étude comparative retrospective. Chirurgie. 1998; 123 450-455
P. Díte, M.D., .DSc.
Dept. of Medicine and Gastroenterology
University Hospital · Jihlavská Str. 20 ·
63900 Brno · Czech Republic
Fax: +420 5 47193701