A Mechanical Study to Investigate the Free Play of 3 Different Nail Designs Used for Fixation of Subtrochanteric Femoral Fractures

Abstract

Patients with subtrochanteric fractures treated by intramedullary fixation frequently report marked post-treatment pain associated with movement. The free distance, clearly visible in the lateral view X-rays, between the inner cortex of the medullary cavity and outer implant surface shows that anterior-posterior movement is possible when using a single bolt for stabilisation of the nail position. The movement behaviour of three standard nail types (Proximal Femur Nail / Synthes, Gamma Nail / Howmedica, Trochanteric Nail / Howmedica) was investigated by mechanical testing and a mathematical model. The results of mechanical testing closely matched the mathematical model. The nail tip length from the locking bolt axis to its distal end was crucial in determining nail movement. The Proximal femur nail (60 mm) shows the least movement (best performance), the Trochanteric nail (20 mm) shows the largest movements, the movement associated with the Gamma nail (40 mm) was between those of the two other nails. We believe that the Trochanteric nail results in too large a movement and is the least suitable implant for stabilisation of subtrochanteric femoral fractures.

Key words

Mechanical testing - femoral nail design - Proximal Femur Nail - Trochanteric Nail - Gamma Nail - femoral nail tilt behaviour - post-treatment pain

References

• 1 Bulhoff H, David A, Ekkernkamp A. Versorgungsmöglichkeiten subtrochanterer Frakturen.  Zentralbl Chir. 1995;  120 881-886
• 2 Friedl W. Relevance of osteotomy and implant characteristics in inter- and subtrochanteric osteotomies. Experimental examination under alternating and static load after stabilisation with different devices including gamma nail osteosynthesis.  Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 1993;  113 5-11
• 3 Friedl W, Colombo-Benkmann M, Dockter S, Machens H G, Mieck U. Gammanagel-Osteosynthese per- und subtrochanterer Femurfrakturen. 4-Jahres-Erfahrungen und ihre Konsequenzen für die weitere Implantatentwicklung.  Chirurg. 1994;  65 953-963
• 4 Greitbauer M, Heinz T, Vécsei V. Der lange Gammanagel - vom Troubleshooter zum eigenständigen Implantat. Osteo Intern, Leuven University Press 1995: 251-256
• 5 Greitbauer M, Kukla C, Heinz T, Vécsei V. Experience with the long Gamma Nail. A report of 141 cases. Osteo Intern, Louisville Ky (USA) 1997
• 6 Greitbauer M, Kukla C, Heinz T. Pathological fractures of the femur. Therapeutic and prophylactic stabilization with the Gamma Nail. In: Jalovaara P, Vécsei V (Hrsg). Osteo Intern, Druckhaus Mayer Verlag 1996: 367-368
• 7 Heinz T, Vécsei V. Der Gammanagel. Ein neues Implantat zur Versorgung hüftgelenksnaher Frakturen.  Akt Traumatol. 1992;  22 163-169
• 8 Heinz T, Vécsei V. Komplikationen und Fehler bei der Anwendung des Gammanagels. Ursachen und Prävention.  Chirurg. 1994;  65 943-952
• 9 Kempf I, Grosse A, Taglang G, Favreul E. Le clou gamma dans le traitement a foyer ferme des fractures trochanterieenes. Resultats et indications á propos d’une serie de 121 cas.  Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot. 1993;  79 29-40
• 10 Leung K S, So W S, Shen W Y, Hui P W. Gamma nails and dynamic hip screws for pertrochanteric fractures. A randomised prospective study in elderly patients.  J Bone Joint Surg [Br]. 1992;  74 345-351
• 11 Rantanen J, Aro H. Mechanical failure of the intramedullary hip screw in a subtrochanteric femoral fracture.  J Orthop Trauma. 1996;  10 348-350
• 12 Roberts C S, Nawab A, Wang M, Voor M J, Seligson D. Second generation intramedullary nailing of subtrochanteric femur fractures: a biomechanical study of fracture site motion.  J Orthop Trauma. 2002;  16 231-238
• 13 Simmermacher R KJ, Bosch A M, Van der Werken C. The AO / ASIF-proximal femoral nail (PFN): a new device for the treatment of unstable proximal femoral fractures.  Injury. 1999;  30 327-332
• 14 Wang C J, Yettram A L, Yao M S, Procter P. Finite element analysis of a Gamma nail within a fractured femur.  Med Eng Phys. 1998;  20 677-683