Treatment of Proximal Hamstring Ruptures – A Systematic Review

Abstract

Proximal hamstring ruptures are increasingly treated surgically, despite little high-level supporting evidence. We sought to determine whether there are differences in clinical outcome after surgical vs. non-surgical treatment of proximal hamstring tendinous avulsions/ruptures and acute vs. chronic surgical repair of tendinous avulsions. Multiple medical databases were searched for Level I–IV evidence. 18 studies were included. 298 subjects (300 proximal hamstring injuries) were analyzed with mean age of 39.7 years. 286 injuries were managed with surgical repair vs. 14 non-operative. 95 surgical cases were performed within 4 weeks of the injury (acute), while 191 were performed beyond 4 weeks (chronic). 292 injuries were tendinous avulsions while 8 were bony tuberosity avulsions. Surgical repair resulted in significantly (p<0.05) better subjective outcomes, greater rate of return to pre-injury level of sport, and greater strength/endurance than non-surgical management. Similarly, acute surgical repair had significantly better patient satisfaction, subjective outcomes, pain relief, strength/endurance, and higher rate of return to pre-injury level of sport than chronic repair (p<0.001) with reduced risk of complications and re-rupture (p<0.05). Chronic surgical repair also improves outcomes, strength and endurance, and return-to-sport, but not as well as acute repair. Non-operative treatment results in reduced patient satisfaction, with significantly lower rates of return to pre-injury level of sport and reduced hamstring muscle strength.

Key words

ischial tuberosity - semitendinosus rupture - semimembranosus rupture - biceps femoris rupture

References

• 1 Anzel J, Covey K, Weiner A. Disruption of muscles and tendons. An analysis of 1 014 cases.  Surgery. 1959;  45 406-414
• 2 Arnason A, Sigurdsson S, Gudmundsson A, Holme I, Engebretsen L, Bahr R. Risk factors for injuries in football.  Am J Sports Med. 2004;  32 5S-16S
• 3 Blasier R, Morawa L. Complete rupture of the hamstring origin from water skiing injury.  Am J Sports Med. 1990;  18 435-437
• 4 Brandser E, El-Khoury G, Kathol M, Callaghan J, Tearse D. Hamstring injuries: Radiographic, conventional tomographic, CT, and MR imaging characteristics.  Musculoskeletal Radiol. 1995;  197 257-262
• 5 Brucker P, Imhoff A. Functional assessment after acute and chronic complete ruptures of the proximal hamstring tendons.  Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2005;  13 411-418
• 6 Carmichael J, Packham I, Trikha S, Wood D. Avulsion of the proximal hamstring origin. Surgical technique.  J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2009;  91 249-256
• 7 Chakravarthy J, Ramisetty N, Pimpalnerkar A. Surgical repair of complete proximal hamstring tendon ruptures in water skiers and bull riders: a report of four cases and review of the literature.  Br J Sports Med. 2005;  39 569-572
• 8 Cohen S, Bradley J. Acute proximal hamstring rupture.  J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2007;  15 350-355
• 9 Connell D, Schneider-Kolsky M, Hoving J. Longitudinal study comparing sonographic and MRI assessments of acute and healing hamstring injuries.  Am J Roentgenol. 2004;  183 975-984
• 10 Cross M, Vandersluis R, Wood D. Surgical repair of chronic complete hamstring tendon rupture in the adult patient.  Am J Sports Med. 1998;  26 785-788
• 11 DePalma A, Silberstein C. Avulsion fracture of the ischial tuberosity in siblings.  Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1965;  38 120-122
• 12 DeSmet A, Best T. MR imaging of the distribution and location of acute hamstring injuries in athletes.  Am J Roentgenol. 2000;  174 393-399
• 13 Engebretsen A, Myklebust G, Holme I, Engebretsen L, Bahr R. Intrinsic risk factors for hamstring injuries among male soccer players.  Am J Sports Med. 2010;  38 1147-1153
• 14 Floor S, van der Veen A, Devilee R. Two patients with a complete proximal rupture of the hamstring.  Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 2010;  130 523-526
• 15 Folsom G, Larson C. Surgical treatment of acute versus chronic complete proximal hamstring ruptures – results of a new allograft technique for chronic reconstructions.  Am J Sports Med. 2007;  36
• 16 Gidwani S, Bircher M. Avulsion injuries of the hamstring origin – a series of 12 patients and management algorithm.  Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 2007;  89 394-399
• 17 Gidwani S, Jagiello J, Bircher M. Avulsion fracture of the ischial tuberosity in adolescents-an easily missed diagnosis.  Br Med J. 2004;  329 99-100
• 18 Harris W. Traumatic arthritis of the hip after dislocation and acetabular fractures: treatment by mold arthroplasty. An end-result study using a new method of result evaluation.  J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1969;  51 737-755
• 19 Ishikawa K, Kai K, Mizuta H. Avulsion of the hamstring muscles from the ischial tuberosity.  Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1988;  232 153-155
• 20 Klingele K, Sallay P. Surgical repair of complete proximal hamstring tendon ruptures.  Am J Sports Med. 2002;  30 742-747
• 21 Konan S, Haddad F. Successful return to high level sports following early surgical repair of complete tears of the proximal hamstring tendons.  Int Orthop. 2010;  34 119-123
• 22 Koulouris G, Connell D. Evaluation of the hamstring muscle complex following acute injury.  Skeletal Radiol. 2003;  32 582-589
• 23 Kujala U, Orava S, Karpakka J, Leppavuori J, Mattila K. Ischial tuberosity apophysitis and avulsion among athletes.  Int J Sports Med. 1997;  18 149-155
• 24 Kurosawa H, Nakasita K, Nakasita H, Sasaki S, Takeda S. Complete avulsion of the hamstring tendons from the ischial tuberosity. A report of two cases sustained in judo.  Br J Sports Med. 1996;  30 72-74
• 25 Lempainen L, Sarimo J, Orava S. Recurrent and chronic complete ruptures of the proximal origin of the hamstring muscles repaired with fascia lata autograft augmentation.  Arthroscopy. 2007;  23 441.e441-441.e445
• 26 Levine W, Bergfeld J, Tessendorf W, Moorman C. Intramuscular corticosteroid injection for hamstring injuries: a 13-year experience in the NFL.  Am J Sports Med. 2000;  28 297-300
• 27 Marx R, Fives G, Chu S, Daluiski A, Wolfe S. Allograft reconstruction for symptomatic chronic complete proximal hamstring tendon avulsion.  Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2009;  17 19-23
• 28 McGregor C, Ghosh S, Young D, Maffulli N. Traumatic and overuse injuries of the ischial origin of the hamstrings.  Disabil Rehabil. 2008;  30 1597-1601
• 29 Mica L, Schwaller A, Stoupis C, Penka I, Vomela J, Vollenweider A. Avulsion of the hamstring muscle group: a follow-up of 6 adult non-athletes with early operative treatment: a brief report.  World J Surg. 2009;  33 1605-1610
• 30 Murray P, Lowe W. Achilles allograft reconstruction of a chronic complete proximal hamstring rupture.  Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2009;  17 1360-1363
• 31 Obremskey W, Pappas N, Attallah-Wasif E, Tornetta P, Bhandari M. Levels of evidence in orthopaedic journals.  J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2005;  87 2632-2638
• 32 Orava S, Kujala U. Rupture of the ischial origin of the hamstring muscles.  Am J Sports Med. 1995;  23 702-705
• 33 Orchard J, Best T. The management of muscle strain injuries: an early return versus the risk of recurrence.  Clin J Sports Med. 2002;  12 3-5
• 34 Rossi F, Dragoni S. Acute avulsion fracture of the pelvis in adolescent competitive athletes: prevalence, location and sports distribution of 203 cases collected.  Skeletal Radiol. 2001;  30 127-131
• 35 Sallay P, Ballard G, Hamersly S, Schrader M. Subjective and functional outcomes following surgical repair of complete ruptures of the proximal hamstring complex.  Orthopedics. 2008;  31 1-8
• 36 Sallay P, Friedman R, Coogan P, Garrett W. Hamstring muscle injuries among water skiers.  Am J Sports Med. 1996;  24 130-136
• 37 Sarimo J, Lempainen L, Mattila K, Orava S. Complete proximal hamstring avulsions: A series of 41 patients with operative treatment.  Am J Sports Med. 2008;  36 1110-1115
• 38 Schlonsky J, Olix M. Functional disability following avulsion fracture of the ischial epiphysis: report of two cases.  J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1972;  54 641-644
• 39 Servant C, Jones C. Displaced avulsion of the ischial apophysis: a hamstring injury requiring internal fixation.  Br J Sports Med. 1998;  32 255-257
• 40 Slavotinek J, Verrall G, Fon G. Hamstring injury in athletes: using MR imaging measurements to compare extent of muscle injury with amount of time lost from competition.  Am J Roentgenol. 2002;  179 1621-1628
• 41 Stradley S, Backs R, Grosel J, Kaeding C. Hamstring avulsion repair without using a flexion splint.  J Am Acad Physician Assist. 2008;  21 33-37
• 42 Witvrouw E, Danneels L, Asselman P, D’Have T, Cambier D. Muscle flexibility as a risk factor for developing muscle injuries in male professional soccer players: A prospective study.  Am J Sports Med. 2003;  31 41-46
• 43 Wood D, Packham I, Trikha S, Linklater J. Avulsion of the proximal hamstring origin.  J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2008;  90 2365-2374
• 44 Wootton J, Cross M, Holt K. Avulsion of the ischial apophysis.  J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1990;  72B 625-627

Correspondence