Assessing the Implementation of Workplace Health Programs Outside of Controlled Environments

Abstract

The study explored the implementation of workplace health programmes in 14 NHS Trusts (hospitals). It sought to identify different approaches to implementation and measures that could be used to guide future development. The study comprised inter-related elements examining the process of implementing workplace health and the impact on staff. An innovative action research approach was applied to the evaluation. The aims of the evaluation were to generate activity and learning within the organisations which was sustainable (long term) and transferable outside the study organisations. The study is described in terms of the multiple methods and the ways in which these have been brought together in the analysis. The approach has been informed by a shift from an individualistic perspective towards one which sees the health of workers within the broader context of organisational development and management. The research identified a number of dilemmas for workplace health with its focus on the health of the individual. A typology was developed which describes different approaches to workplace health and their impact on sustaining such initiatives. It suggests that for workplace health to be successful it must address the organisational context as well as individual staff needs. Results from a survey of staff in the 14 trusts seems to demonstrate an association between the approaches, described in the typology, and an impact on staff. Workplace health programmes need to shift towards approaches where the individual’s health is seen within the wider context of the organisation.

Keywords

Workplace Health - Research - Evaluation - Organisational Health, Typology - Case-Studies - Health at Work - Settings

• REFERENCES

• 1 Health Education Authority.. Survey of hospital activity. London: HEA; 1995
• 2 Health Education Authority.. Survey of community and ambulance trusts. London: HEA; 1997
• 3 Health Education Authority.. Working for your health: a survey of NHS Trust staff. London: HEA; 1997
• 4 Health Education Authority.. Assessing health at work: typologies and implementation strategies for the NHS. London: HEA; 1999
• 5 Health Education Authority.. Telling it like it is: workplace health case studies in two NHS Trusts. London: HEA; 1999
• 6 Health Education Authority.. Up the down escalator? Health at work implementation programmes in selected NHS Trusts. An evaluation and framework for understanding.
• 7 Health Education Authority.. More to work than this: developing and sustaining work-place health in the NHS. London: HEA; 1999
• 8 Seccombe I, Patch A. Health at Work in the NHS: key indicators. London: HEA; 1995
• 9 Prochaska J, DiClemente C. The trans-theoretical approach: crossing traditional boundaries of therapy. Krieger: Malabar, Fla.; 1984
• 10 Stokols D, Pelletier K, Fielding J. The ecology of work and health: research and policy directions for promotion of employee health. Health Education Journal 1996; 23 (Suppl. 02) 137-58.
• 11 Peterson M, Wilson J. A culture-work health model: a theoretical conceptualization. American Journal of Health Behaviour 1998; 22 (Suppl. 05) 378-89.