Medical Diagnosis from a Clinician’s Point of View

F. T. De Dombal

doi:10.1055/s-0038-1636607

Methods of Information in Medicine, Table of Contents

Methods Inf Med 1978; 17(01): 28-35
DOI: 10.1055/s-0038-1636607

CLINICAL DECISION-MAKING

Schattauer GmbH

Medical Diagnosis from a Clinician’s Point of View

DIE MEDIZINISCHE DIAGNOSE VOM STANDPUNKT DES KLINIKERS AUS

Authors

F. T. De Dombal

¹From the University of Leeds, Dept. of Surgery

Abstract

This paper discusses medical diagnosis from the clinicians point of view. The aim of the paper is to identify areas where computer science and information science may be of help to the practising clinician. Collection of data, analysis, and decision-making are discussed in turn. Finally, some specific recommendations are made for further joint research on the basis of experience around the world to date.

In dieser Arbeit wird die medizinische Diagnose vom klinischen Standpunkt aus erörtert. Ziel der Arbeit ist es, diejenigen Gebiete herauszustellen, in denen die Computerwissenschaft und die Informationswissenschaft dem praktizierenden Kliniker von Nutzen sein können. Datensammlung, Analyse und Entscheidungsfindung werden nacheinander diskutiert. Abschließend werden spezifische Anregungen gegeben zur weiteren gemeinsamen Forschung auf der Grundlage der heute weltweit gemachten Erfahrungen.

Keywords

Computer-aided Diagnosis - Decision-making - Diagnostic Process - Observer Variation - Utility

Schlüssel-Wörter

Computerunterstützte Diagnose - Entscheidungsfindung - diagnostischer Prozeß - Beobachterunterschiede - Nutzen

Full Text

References

References
1 Biörck G. The Essence of the Clinician’s Art. Acta med. seand 201 1977; 145-147.
2 Björn J. C. Physician’s Assistant — Second Level Entrepreneur?. J. Maine med. Ass 62 1971; 133-138.
3 Campbell E. J. M. Basic Science, Science, and Medical Education. Lancet 1976; I: 134-136.
4 Card W. I, Rusinkiewicz M, Phillips C. I. Estimation of the Utilities of States of Health with Different Visual Acuities using a Wagering Technique. In de Dombal F. T, Grémy P. (Eds) Decision Making and Medical Care — Can Information Science Help?. 239-249 Amsterdam: North Holland Publ. Co; 1976
5 Card W. I, Good I. J. A Companion to Medical Studies, Vol. 3. Oxford: Blackwell Sei. Publ; 1974
6 Clarke A. C. 2001: A Space Odyssey. London: Hutchinson; 1968
7 Cochrane A. L, Chapman P. J. Observers’ Errors in Taking Medical Histories. Lancet 1951; I: 1007-1009.
8 Cochrane A. L, Holland W. W. Validation of Screening Procedures. Brit. med. Bull 27 1969; 3-8.
9 Collen M. F, Feldman R, Siegelaub A. B. et al. Dollar Cost per Positive Test for Automated MuUiphasie Screening. New Engl. J. Med 283 1970; 459-463.
10 De Dombal F. T, Horrocks J. C, Staniland J. K, Guillou P. J. Production of Artificial Case Histories Using a Small Desk-top Computer. Brit. med. J 1971; II: 578-581.
11 De Dombal F. T, Horrocks J. C, Staniland J. R, Guxllott P. J. Pattern Recognition: a Comparison of the Performance of Clinicians and Non-clinicians with a Note on the Performance of a Computer-based System. Meth. Inform. Med 11 1972; 32-37.
12 Dixon R. H, Laszlo J. Utilisation of Clinical Chemistry Services by Medical House Staff. Arch. intern. Med 134 1974; 1064-1067.
13 Dudley H. A. F. Payoff, Heuristics and Pattern Recognition in the Diagnostic Process. Lancet 1969; II: 723-726.
14 Durbridge T. C, Edwards F, Edwards R. G, Atkinson M. Evaluation of Benefits of Screening Tests done immediately on Admission to Hospital. Clin. Chem 22 1976; 968-971.
15 Edwards W. A. F. Introduction to Special Issue on Revision of Opinions by Men and Man-machine Systems. I. E. E. E. Transact. Hum. Fact. Electr. HFE 07 1966; 1-6.
16 Edwards D. A. W. History and Symptoms of Oesophageal Disease. In Schwieglc H. (Hrsg.) Handbuch der inneren Medizin, Dritter Band/Erster Teil. 103-118 Berlin: Springer; 1974
17 Emerson P. Decision Theory in the Prevention of ThromboEmbolism after Myocardial Infarction. J. Roy. Coll. Phys. London 02 1975; 238-251.
18 Feinstein A. R. Clinical Judgement. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins; 1967
19 Gill P. W, Leaper D. J, Guillou P. J. et al. Observer Variation in Clinical Diagnosis — a Computer-aided Assessment of its Magnitude and Importance in 552 Patients with Abdominal Pain. Meth. Inform. Med 12 1973; 108-113.
20 Gorry G. A. Knowledge-based Systems for Clinical Problem Solving. In de Dombal F. T, Grémy F. (Eds) Decisionmaking and Medical Care: Can Information Science Help?. 23-33 Amsterdam: North Holland Publ. Co; 1976
21 Griner P. F, Liptzin B. Use of the Laboratory in a Teaching Hospital. Ann. intern. Med 75 1971; 157-163.
22 Hall R, Horrocks J. C, Clamp S. E, de Dombal F. T. Observer Variation in Assessment of Results of Surgery for Peptic Ulceration. Brit. med. J 1976; I: 814-816.
23 Hamilton M. cited by de Dombal [10].
24 Hampton J. R, Harrison M. J. G, Mitchell J. R. A. et al. Relative Contributions of History Taking, Physical Examination and Laboratory Investigation to Diagnosis and Management of Medical Outpatients. Brit. med. J 1975; I: 486-489.
25 Horrocks J. C, de Dombal F. T. Diagnosis of Dyspepsia from Data Collected by a Physician’s Assistant. Brit. med. J 1975; II: 421-423.
26 Jennett B. Epilepsy after Non-missile Head Injury. London: Heinemann; 1975
27 Jennett B, Teasdale G. M, Knill-Jones R. P. Predicting Outcome after Head Injury. J. Roy. Coll. Phys. London 09 1975; 231-237.
28 Kaku K, Gilbert F. I, Sachs R. R. Comparison of Health Appraisals by Nurses and Physicians. Publ. Hlth Rep 85 1970; 1042-1046.
29 Kannee I. The Programmed Physical Examination with or without the Computer. J. Amer. med. Ass 215 1971; 8-13.
30 Keighley M. R. B, Horrocks J. C, Hoare A. M. et al. A Symptomatic Discriminant to Identify Recurrent Ulcer in Patients with Dyspepsia after Gastric Surgery. Lancet 1976; II: 278-279.
31 Korsch B. M, Gozzi E. K, Francis V. Gaps in Patient — Doctor Communication. Paediatrics 42 1968; 855-870.
32 Lasègue : cited by Wulfe. [55].
33 Leaper D. J, Gill P. W, Staniland J. R. et al. Clinical Diagnostic Process: An Analysis. Brit. med. J 1973; II: 569-574.
34 Leaper D. J, Horrocks J. C, Staniland J. R, de Dombal F. T. Computer-assisted Diagnosis of Abdominal Pain Using Estimates Provided by Clinicians. Brit. med. J 1972; II: 350-354.
35 Lindley D. V. Making Decisions. London: Wiley; 1971
36 Lindley D. V. Probability and Medical Diagnosis, and The Role of Utility in Medical Decision Making. J. Roy. Coll. Phys. London. 09. 1975 197–205 and 225–231
37 Lindley D. V. Costs and Utilities. In de Dombal F. T, Grémy F. (Eds) Decision Making and Medical Care — Can Information Science Help?. 101-113 Amsterdam: North Holland Publ. Co; 1976
38 Lucas R. W, Card W. I, Knill-Jones R. P. et al. Computer Interrogation of Patients. Brit. med. J 1976; II: 623-625.
39 Lusted L. B. Introduction to Medical Decision-Making. Springfield/Ill: C. C. Thomas; 1968
40 McAdam W AF. Unpublished Data..
41 McAdam W. A. F, Horrocks J. C, de Dombal F. T. Assessment of the Results of Surgery for Varicose Veins. Brit. J. Surg 63 1976; 137-140.
42 Mager R. F, Pipe P. Analysing Performance Problems. Belmont/Calif: Fearon Publ; 1970
43 Mayne J. G, Weksel W, Sholtz P. W. Towards Automating the Medical History. Mayo Clin. Proceed 43 1968; 1-25.
44 McCrae A. W. Channel Capacity in Absolute Judgement Tasks. Psychol. Bull 73 1970; 112-121.
45 Miller G. A. The Magic Number Seven plus or minus Two: Some Limits on our Capacity for Processing Information. Psychol. Rev 63 1956; 81-97.
46 Morgan A. G, McAdam W. A. F, Walmsley G. L. et al. Clinical Findings, Early Endoscopy and Multivariate Analysis in Patients Bleeding from the Upper Gastrointestinal Tract. Brit. med. J 1977; II: 237-240.
47 Nacke O, Wagner G. Bibliography on the Theme »The Role of Error in Medicine. Quality Control as a Task of Medical Documentation«. Meth. Inform. Med 03 1964; 132-150.
48 Russe H. P. The Use and Abuse of Laboratory Tests. Med. Clin. N. Amer 53 1969; 223-231.
49 Savage L. J. The Foundations of Science. New York: Wiley; 1954
50 Scadding J. G. Diagnosis: The Clinician and the Computer. Lancet 1967; II: 877-S82.
51 Slack W. V, Hicks G. P, Reed C. E. et al. A Computerbased Medical History System. New Engl. J. Med 274 1966; 194-198.
52 Vickery D. M, Morgan T. W, Larsen K. T. et al. Computer Support of Paramedical Personnel: The Question of Quality Control. In Anderson J, Forsythe J. M. (Eds) Proceedings of Medinfo 74. 281-289 Amsterdam: North Holland Publ. Co; 1974
53 Weed L. L. Medical Records, Medical Education and Patient Care. Chicago: Year Book Medical Publishers; 1969
54 Wiener N. Nonlinear Prediction and Dynamics. Proceed. 3rd. Berkeley Symposium on Mathematical Statistics and Probability, Vol. 3, pp. 247ff. Berkeley: Univ. of California Press; 1956
55 Wulff H. Rational Diagnosis and Treatment. Oxford: Blackwell; 1976