Reliability of Laboratory Tests for the Control of Oral Anticoagulation

Summary

The present study concerned the reproducibility of the so-called prothrombin time as assessed with a series of more commonly used modifications of the Quick’s onestage assay procedure, i.e. the British comparative reagent, homemade human brain thromboplastin, Simplastin, Simplastin A, and Thrombotest. All five procedures were tested manually on pooled lyophilized normal and patients’ plasmas. In addition, Simplastin A and Thrombotest were investigated semiautomatically on individual freshly prepared patients’ plasmas. From the results obtained, the following conclusions may be drawn :

The reproducibility of results obtained with manual reading on lyophilized plasmas is satisfactory for all five test procedures. For Simplastin, the reproducibility of values in the range of insufficient anticoagulation is relatively low due to the low discrimination power of the test procedure in the near-normal range (so-called low sensitivity of rabbit brain thromboplastins). The reproducibility of Thrombotest excels as a consequence of its particularly easily discerned coagulation endpoint.

The reproducibility of Thrombotest, when tested on freshly prepared plasmas using Schnitger’s semiautomatic coagulometer (a fibrinometer-liJce apparatus), is no longer superior to that of Simplastin A.

The constant of proportionality between the coagulation times formed with Simplastin A and Thrombotest was estimated at 0.64.

Reconstituted Thrombotest is stable for 24 hours when stored at 4° C, whereas reconstituted Simplastin A is not.

The Simplastin A method and Thrombotest seem to be equally sensitive to “activation” of blood coagulation upon storage.

• References

• 1 Brozovic M, Howarth D. J, Halem-Visser van L. P, Loeliger E. A. 1973; Stability of freeze-dried plasma prepared from patients on oral anticoagulants. Journal of Clinical Pathology 26: 857.
• 2 Denson K. W. 1961 An investigation of Thrombotest and the preparation of a similar combined reagent. Journal of Medical and Laboratory Technology. October, 1.
• 3 Hemker H. C, Siepel T, Altman R, Loeliger E. A. 1967; Kinetic aspects of the interaction of blood-clotting enzymes. II. The relation between clotting time and plasma concentration in prothrombin time estimations. Thrombosis et Diathesis Haemorrhagica 27: 349.
• 4 Koller F, Loeliger E. A, Dttckert F. 1951; Experiments on a new clotting factor (factor VII). Acta haematologica 06: 1.
• 5 Loeliger E. A, Meeuwisse-Braun J. B, Mtjis H, Buitendijk F. J. J, Veltkamp J. J, Hemker H. C. 1970; Laboratory control of oral anticoagulants. Definition of therapeutic range in terms of different thromboplastin preparations. Thrombosis et Diathesis Haemorrhagica 23: 569.
• 6 Loeliger E. A, Halem-Visser van L. P. 1974 A simplified thromboplastin calibration procedure designed for standardization of anticoagulant control. To be published..
• 7 Miale J. B, Kent J. W. 1973; Performance characteristics of reference thromboplastins. American Journal of Clinical Pathology 60: 453.
• 8 Owren P. A. 1959; Thrombotest. A new method for controlling anticoagulant therapy. Lancet 02: 754.
• 9 Owren P. A, Aas K. 1951; Control of dicoumarol therapy and quantitative determination of prothrombin and proconvertin. Scandinavian Journal of Clinical and Laboratory Investigations 03: 201.
• 10 Quick A. J, Leu M. 1937. Quantitative determination of prothrombin. Journal of Biological Chemistry. 119 Lxxxi.
• 11 Ulldal A, Dybkjaer R. 1972; Reduction of analytical error in measurement of the concentration of coagulation factors in plasma. Scandinavian Journal of Clinical and Laboratory Investigations 29: 413.
• 12 Veltkamp J. J, Muis H, Müller A. D, Hemker H. C, Loeliger E. A. 1971; Additional evidence for the existance of a precursor molecule of the prothrombin complex in oral anticoagulation. Thrombosis et Diathesis Haemorrhagica 25: 312.
• 13 Vries S, de I, Abels J, Haanen C, Loeliger E. A. 1961; De Thrombotest van Owren. Nederlandsch tijdschrift voor geneeskunde 105: 977.
• 14 Ware A. G, Stragnell R. 1952; Improved one-stage prothrombin method. American Journal of Clinical Pathology 22: 791.