Pearls and Pitfalls of Ethical Issues in Neurology

ABSTRACT

The growth of bioethics as a practical, meaningful player in the arena of health care has paralleled that of clinical neurology not only in time but also in interaction between the two disciplines. Almost every advance in neurology has spawned an ethical dilemma, the unraveling of which has brought new insights to both fields of endeavor. The myriad ways in which this parallel growth has touched one clinical neurologist, the persons with whom he has been privileged to work, and those for whom they have cared is offered in reflection on the meaning of ethics, the essence of concepts such as ``brain death,'' the pain of truth telling, the complexity of informed consent, the societal dimension of the ``vegetative state,'' and finally, even the business of medicine. Should readers not find any pearls of wisdom in this offering, the author can at least hope it will prevent them from falling into the same pits.

KEYWORD

Bioethics - brain death - informed consent - health care reform

REFERENCES

• 1 Rothman D J. Strangers at the Bedside: A History of How Law and Bioethics Transformed Medical Decisionmaking.  New York: Basic Books; 1991
• 2 . In re Quinlan. 70 NJ 10, 355 A2d 647 (1976)
• 3 . Cruzan v Director. Missouri Department of Health, 110 SCt 2841 (1990)
• 4 . A definition of irreversible coma: Report of the Ad Hoc Committee of the Harvard Medical School to Examine the Definition of Brain Death.  JAMA. 1968;  205 337-340
• 5 Castenada C J. A new question amid suicide debate. USA Today. August 23, 1996;3A
• 6 President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research. Screening and Counseling for Genetic Conditions: The Ethical, Social, and Legal Implications of Counseling and Education Programs.  Washington, DC: Government Printing Office; 1968
• 7 McQuillen M P, Leone M G. A treatment carol: thymectomy revisited.  Neurology . 1977;  27 1103-1106
• 8 Khatri B O, McQuillen M P, Harrington G J, Schmoll D, Hoffman R G. Chronic progressive multiple sclerosis: double-blind controlled study of plasmapheresis in patients taking immunosuppressive drugs.  Neurology . 1985;  35 312-319
• 9 Bernat J L. Ethical Issues in Neurology. Boston: Butterworth-Heinemann 2002
• 10 Beauchamp T L, Childress J F. Principles of Biomedical Ethics.  4th ed. New York: Oxford University Press 1994
• 11 Lo B. Resolving Ethical Dilemmas: A Guide for Clinicians.  Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins 1995
• 12 Fletcher J C, Lombardo P A, Marshall M F, Miller F G. Introduction to Clinical Ethics. 2nd ed. Frederick, MD: University Publishing Group 1997
• 13 Baumgarth W P, Regan R J. St. Thomas Aquinas. On Law, Morality, and Politics.  Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Publishing Company 1988
• 14 Fletcher J C, Quist N, Jonsen A R. Ethics Consultation in Health Care. Ann Arbor, MI: Health Administration Press 1989
• 15 Emanuel L L. Ethics and the structure of health care.  Camb Q Healthc Ethics . 2000;  9 151-168
• 16 Ropper A M. Unusual spontaneous movements in brain-dead patients.  Neurology . 1984;  34 1089-1092
• 17 Glick R S. Brain death, religious freedom, and public policy: New Jersey's landmark legislative initiative.  Kennedy Inst Ethics J . 1991;  1 275-288
• 18 . 10 NYCRR $400.16. (Department of Health Regulations)
• 19 Younger S J, Arnold R M, Shapiro R. The Definition of Death: Contemporary Controversies.  Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press 1999
• 20 Wu A W, Folkman S, McPhee S J, Lo B. Do house officers learn from their mistakes?.  JAMA . 1991;  265 2089-2094
• 21 . Schloendorff v Society of N.Y. Hospital. 211 NY 125, 105 NE 92 (1914)
• 22 Pellegrino E D. Words can hurt you: some reflections on the metaphors of managed care.  J Am Board Fam Pract . 1994;  7 505-510
• 23 Brody H. The Healer's Power.  New Haven, CT: Yale University Press 1992
• 24 Grilli T, Magrini N, Perma A, Mura G, Liberati A. Practice guidelines developed by specialty societies: the need for a critical appraisal.  Lancet . 2000;  355 103-106
• 25 Maynard A. Evidence-based medicine: an incomplete method for informing treatment choices.  Lancet . 1997;  349 126-128
• 26 Emery D D, Schneidermann L J. Cost-effectiveness analysis in health care.  Hastings Cent Rep . 1989;  19 8-13
• 27 Dunphy S M, Cross J H. Medical decision-making for incompetent persons: the Massachusetts substituted judgment model.  West N E Law Rev . 1987;  9 152-167
• 28 Wikler D. Patient interests: clinical implications of philosophical distinctions.  J Am Geriatr Soc . 1985;  33 951-958
• 29 Buchanan A E, Brock D W. Deciding for Others: The Ethics of Surrogate Decision Making.  Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press 1989
• 30 Steinbock B. Recovery from persistent vegetative state? The case of Carrie Coons.  Hastings Cent Rep . 1989;  19 14-15
• 31 Jennett B, Plum F. Persistent vegetative state after brain damage: a syndrome in search of a name.  Lancet . 1972;  1 734-737
• 32 Multi-Society Task Force on PVS. Medical aspects of the persistent vegetative state.  N Engl J Med . 1994;  330 1499-1579
• 33 Andrews K. Patients in the persistent vegetative state: problems in their long-term management.  BMJ . 1993;  306 1600-1602
• 34 American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine. Recommendations for use of uniform nomenclature pertinent to patients with severe alterations in consciousness.  Arch Phys Med Rehabil . 1995;  76 205-209
• 35 Schneidermann L J. Exile and PVS.  Hastings Cent Rep . 1990;  20 5-6
• 36 Bauby J D. The Diving Bell and the Butterfly.  New York: Vintage Books 1997
• 37 Keneally T. Schindler's List.  New York: Simon & Schuster 1994
• 38 Tresch D D, Sims F H, Duthie Jr H E, Goldstein M D. Patients in a persistent vegetative state: attitudes and reactions of family members.  J Am Geriatr Soc . 1991;  39 17-21
• 39 McQuillen M P. The persistent vegetative state: consensus or confusion?.  Neurologist . 1996;  2 169-175
• 40 Lamm R D. Redrawing the ethics map.  Hastings Cent Rep . 1999;  29 28-29
• 41 . Pegram et al v Herdrich. 98 SCt 1949 (2000)
• 42 Angell M. The doctor as double agent.  Kennedy Inst Ethics J . 1993;  3 279-286
• 43 Osler W. Aequanimitas with Other Addresses.  Philadelphia: Blakiston 1952