Abstract
Objective In an effort to reduce the primary cesarean delivery (CD) rate, the American College
of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) recommended new labor guidelines in 2014
that allow longer duration of labor times. There are little data on the impact of
these guidelines on CD rates and pregnancy outcomes in a predominantly Hispanic population.
This study aimed to compare the primary CD rates and maternal and neonatal outcomes
in patients undergoing primary CD for arrest of labor before and after implementation
of the 2014 guidelines.
Study Design This was a retrospective cohort study of term patients who underwent a CD for an
arrest disorder between January 2011 and April 2017 at a county teaching hospital.
Our primary outcome was the composite maternal and neonatal morbidities (CMM and CNM,
respectively). Differences in the demographic and clinical characteristics, CMM, and
CNM stratified by time period (pre- vs. postimplementation) were examined.
Results There were 4,976 deliveries in the study period: 525 (11%) underwent primary CD for
arrest disorder; 298 (6%) prior to 2014, and 227 (5%) after 2014 (p = 0.62). There was no significant difference in the rate of CD between the two periods
(13.4 vs. 13.3%, p = 0.81). In patients undergoing CD for arrest of dilation (n = 389), the CMM and CNM did not significantly change between both groups (63.3 vs.
56%, p = 0.15). In patients who had a CD for arrest of descent (n = 136), the rate of CMM significantly increased from 50 to 75% (p = 0.02) with no significant change in the CNM (13.2 vs. 20%, p = 0.3).
Conclusion Despite significant changes in labor management after the publication of the 2014
guidelines, our primary CD rate was not reduced, and we noticed an increase in CMM
in patients who had CD for arrest of descent. A randomized controlled trial is needed
to further evaluate the effect of these guidelines nationally.
Key Points
-
The Obstetric Care Consensus statement aims to decrease the rate of cesarean delivery
(CD).
-
We observed an increase in morbidity in CD if done for arrest of descent (pre/post
the consensus).
-
A randomized controlled trial is needed to further assess the impact of the guidelines
on morbidity.
Keywords
cesarean delivery - arrest of labor - outcomes
