Are Extraction Methods in Quantitative Assays of Pharmacopoeia Monographs Exhaustive? A Comparison with Pressurized Liquid Extraction

Abstract

The extraction methods in selected monographs of the European and the Swiss Pharmacopoeia were compared to pressurized liquid extraction (PLE) with respect to the yield of constituents to be dosed in the quantitative assay for the respective herbal drugs. The study included five drugs, Belladonnae folium, Colae semen, Boldo folium, Tanaceti herba and Agni casti fructus. They were selected to cover different classes of compounds to be analyzed and different extraction methods to be used according to the monographs. Extraction protocols for PLE were optimized by varying the solvents and number of extraction cycles. In PLE, yields > 97 % of extractable analytes were typically achieved with two extraction cycles. For alkaloid-containing drugs, the addition of ammonia prior to extraction significantly increased the yield and reduced the number of extraction cycles required for exhaustive extraction. PLE was in all cases superior to the extraction protocol of the pharmacopoeia monographs (taken as 100 %), with differences ranging from 108 % in case of parthenolide in Tanaceti herba to 343 % in case of alkaloids in Boldo folium.

Key words

Quantitative analysis - pharmacopoeia - extraction - pressurized liquid extraction (PLE) - accelerated solvent extraction (ASE) - Atropa belladonna - Cola nitida - Vitex agnus-castus - Tanacetum parthenium - Peumus boldus

References

• 1 Raynie D E. Modern extraction techniques.  Anal Chem advanced online publication. 2006;  78 3997-4003
• 2 Adam K P, Becker H. Analytik biogener Arzneistoffe. Stuttgart; Wissenschaftliche Verlagesellschaft 2000
• 3 Kaufmann B, Christen P. Recent extraction techniques for natural products: microwave-assisted extraction and pressurized solvent extraction.  Phytochem Anal. 2002;  13 105-13
• 4 Voigt R. Pharmazeutische Technologie. 7th edition Berlin; Ullstein Mosby 1993: p 537-45
• 5 Huie C W. A review of modern sample-preparation techniques for the extraction and analysis of medicinal plants.  Anal Bioanal Chem. 2002;  373 23-30
• 6 Camel V. Recent extraction techniques for solid matrices - supercritical fluid extraction, pressurized fluid extraction and microwave-assisted extraction: their potential and pitfalls.  Analyst. 2001;  126 1182-93
• 7 Richter B E, Jones B A, Ezzell J L, Porter N L, Avdalovic N, Pohl C. Accelerated solvent extraction: a technique for sample preparation.  Anal Chem. 1996;  68 1033-9
• 8 Hamburger M, Baumann D, Adler S. Supercritical carbon dioxide extraction of selected medicinal plants - Effects of high pressure and added ethanol on yield of extracted substances.  Phytochem Anal. 2004;  15 46-54
• 9 Björklund E, Nilsson T, Bowaldt S. Pressurised liquid extraction of persistent organic pollutants in environmental analysis.  Trends Anal Chem. 2000;  19 434-45
• 10 Kawamura F, Kikuchi Y, Ohira T, Yatagai M. Accelerated solvent extraction of paclitaxel and related compounds from the bark of Taxus cuspidata .  J Nat Prod. 1999;  62 244-7
• 11 Benthin B, Danz H, Hamburger M. Pressurized liquid extraction of medicinal plants.  J Chromatogr A. 1999;  837 211-9
• 12 Carabias-Martinez R, Rodriquez-Gonzalo E, Revilla-Ruiz P, Hernandez-Mendez J. Pressurized liquid extraction in the analysis of food and biological samples.  J Chromatogr A. 2005;  1089 1-17
• 13 Danz H, Baumann D, Hamburger M. Quantitative determination of the dual COX-2/5-LOX inhibitor tryptanthrin in Isatis tinctoria by ESI-LC-MS.  Planta Med. 2002;  68 152-7
• 14 Dawidowicz A L, Wianowska D. PLE in the analysis of plant compounds Part I. The application of PLE for HPLC analysis of caffeine in green tea leaves.  J Pharm Biomed Anal. 2005;  37 1155-9
• 15 Gong Y X, Li A P, Wang Y T, Li P, Yang F Q. Simultaneous determination of anthraquinones in rhubarb by pressurized liquid extraction and capillary zone electrophoresis.  Electrophoresis. 2005;  26 1778-82
• 16 Bergeron C, Gafner S, Clausen E, Carrier D J. Comparison of the chemical composition of extracts from Scutellaria laterifolia using accelerated solvent extraction versus standard hot water or 70 % ethanol extraction.  J Agric Food Chem. 2005;  53 3076-80
• 17 Peres V F, Saffi J, Melecchi M IS, Abad F C, Martinez M M, Oliveira E C. et al . Optimization of pressurized liquid extraction of Piper gaudichianum Kunth leaves.  J Chromatogr A. 2006;  1105 148-53
• 18 Williams F B, Sander L C, Wise S A, Girard J. Development and evaluation of methods for determination of naphthodianthrones and flavonoids in St. John’s wort.  J Chromatogr A. 2006;  1115 93-102
• 19 Directorate for the Quality of Medicines of the Council of Europe. European Pharmacopoeia. 5th edition (5.0) Ligugé; Aubin 2005: p 1058-9
• 20 Directorate for the Quality of Medicines of the Council of Europe. European Pharmacopoeia. 5th edition, 3rd supplement (5.3) Ligugé; Aubin 2005: p 3450-1
• 21 Directorate for the Quality of Medicines of the Council of Europe. European Pharmacopoeia. 5th edition (5.0) Ligugé; Aubin 2005: p 1356-7
• 22 Directorate for the Quality of Medicines of the Council of Europe. European Pharmacopoeia. 5th edition (5.0) Ligugé; Aubin 2005: p 1592-3
• 23 Swissmedic. Pharmacopoea Helvetica. 9th edition, 3rd supplement (9.3) Bern; BBL, Bundesamt für Bauten und Logistik 2003: p 299-300
• 24 Jork H, Funk W, Fischer W, Wimmer H. Dünnschicht-Chromatographie: Reagenzien und Nachweismethoden. Volume 1b Weinheim; VCH 1993: 241-5
• 25 ABDA Bundesvereinigung Deutscher Apothekerverbände. Deutscher Arzneimittel Codex. edition 2003 Stuttgart; Deutscher Apotheker Verlag 2005: p 1-7