Georg Thieme Verlag Stuttart, New York · Masson Editeur Paris
Ventricular Shunting for Hydrocephalus in Children: Patients, Procedures, Surgeons and Institutions in English Canada, 1989 - 2001
Received: 2 August 2002
13 March 2003 (online)
Introduction and Purpose
Ventricular shunting remains the principle and most generally applicable method to treat hydrocephalus in children. This paper describes the demographics of this treatment in English Canada during the period of 1989 to March 2001.
Hospital discharge records were obtained for patients less than 18 years who had a shunt inserted or revised. A database was constructed relating patients and procedures to hospital discharges based on scrambled patient identifiers, year of birth, sex, postal code and diagnoses.
5947 patients underwent ventricular shunting procedures for hydrocephalus in this period. 261 surgeons working in 73 institutions provided 12 106 interventions (Shunt insertions: ventriculoperitoneal - 5009, ventriculoatrial - 119, ventriculopleural - 28. Revisions: 6950). Infection was deemed to have occurred in 1059 procedures.
Over the study period, the median number of procedures performed per surgeon per year was 2, with 75 % of surgeons performing 5 or fewer procedures in children per year. Although many surgeons operated on children throughout the thirteen years of the study, many did not acquire substantive cumulative experience.
Overall infection rate was 8.6 %. Surgeon infection rates were greater than or equal to 20 % during the first four years of practice and thereafter they fell to and remained in the 10 % range.
The mean shunt survival at 12 months of individual surgeons varied between 50 - 60 %, regardless of the number of years of experience of the surgeon; however, performance variability as measured by the standard deviation of 12 month survival rates for all surgeons, adjusted for years of experience, ranged widely until the fifth year of practice.
The average number of procedures per year for treating hospitals was 2 with 75 %, providing 12 or fewer services annually. Over the entire study, 50 % of institutions provided 10 or fewer procedures. The mean institutional infection rate was 11.4 % (SD 23, median - 6.0).
Quality monitoring of infection rate and duration of shunt function remains critical as many surgeons and hospitals provide care to children with hydrocephalus infrequently. Variability in infection rates and shunt survival at 12 months are a function of surgeon experience, measured by years in practice. Variability in outcome decreases with increasing surgeon experience.
Surgeon volume - Outcome - Shunt function - Infection rate - Surgical experience - Hydrocephalus
- 1 An organisation with a memory report of an expert group on learning from adverse events in the NHS chaired by the Chief Medical Officer executive summary. London; Department of Health 2000
- 2 Specialized Pediatric Services Review .Report of the Minister's Advisory Committee. Toronto; Ministry of Health 2002
- 3 Birkmeyer J D, Finlayson S R, Tosteson A N, Sharp S M, Warshaw A L, Fisher E S. Effect of hospital volume on in-hospital mortality with pancreaticoduodenectomy. Surgery. 1999; 125 250-256
- 4 Birkmeyer J D, Warshaw A L, Finlayson S R, Grove M R, Tosteson A N. Relationship between hospital volume and late survival after pancreaticoduodenectomy. Surgery. 1999; 126 178-183
- 5 Crawford F A, Anderson R P, Clark R E, Grover F L, Kouchoukos N T, Waldhausen J A. et al . Volume requirements for cardiac surgery credentialing: a critical examination. The Ad Hoc Committee on Cardiac Surgery Credentialing of The Society of Thoracic Surgeons. Ann Thorac Surg. 1996; 61 12-16
- 6 Ellison L M, Heaney J A, Birkmeyer J D. The effect of hospital volume on mortality and resource use after radical prostatectomy. J Urol. 2000; 163 867-869
- 7 Espehaug B, Havelin L I, Engesaeter L B, Vollset S E. The effect of hospital-type and operating volume on the survival of hip replacements. A review of 39 505 primary total hip replacements reported to the Norwegian Arthroplasty Register, 1988 - 1996. Acta Orthop Scand. 1999; 70 12-18
- 8 George R, Leibrock L, Epstein M. Long-term analysis of cerebrospinal fluid shunt infections: A 25 year experience. J Neurosurg. 1979; 51 804-811
- 9 Hillner B E, Smith T J, Desch C E. Hospital and physician volume or specialization and outcomes in cancer treatment: importance in quality of cancer care. J Clin Oncol. 2000; 18 2327-2340
- 10 Kestle J, Milner R, Drake J. The shunt design trial: variation in surgical experience did not influence shunt survival. Pediatr Neurosurg. 1999; 30 283-287
- 11 Kohn L, Janet Corrigan J, Donaldson (eds) M. To Err Is Human. Building a Safer Health System. Washington; National Academy Press 1999
- 12 Luft H S, Garnick D W, Mark D H, McPhee S J. Hospital Volume, Physician Volume, and Patient Outcomes. Assessing the Evidence. Ann Arbor; Health Administration Press 1990
- 13 Lund-Johansen M, Svendsen F, Wester K. Shunt failures and complications in adults as related to shunt type, diagnosis, and the experience of the surgeon. (discussion 844). Neurosurgery. 1994; 35 839-844
- 14 Munoz E, Boiardo R, Mulloy K, Goldstein J, Tenenbaum N, Wise L. Economics of scale, physician volume for neurosurgery patients and the diagnosis related group prospective hospital payment system. Neurosurgery. 1990; 26 156-161
- 15 O'Neill L, Lanska D J, Hartz A. Surgeon characteristics associated with mortality and morbidity following carotid endarterectomy. Neurology. 2000; 55 773-781
- 16 Parry J M, Collins S, Mathers J, Scott N A, Woodman C B. Influence of volume of work on the outcome of treatment for patients with colorectal cancer. Br J Surg. 1999; 86 475-481
- 17 Pearce W H, Parker M A, Feinglass J, Ujiki M, Manheim L M. The importance of surgeon volume and training in outcomes for vascular surgical procedures. (discussion 777-768). J Vasc Surg. 1999; 29 768-776
- 18 Pollock J R, Hayward R D. Adverse operative events in neurosurgical training: incidence, trends and proposal for prevention. Br J Neurosurg. 2001; 15 312-318
- 19 Sinclair M. The Report of the Manitoba Pediatric Surgery Inquest. Winnipeg; Provincial Court of Manitoba 2001
- 20 Sosa J A, Bowman H M, Gordon T A, Bass E B, Yeo C J, Lillemoe K D. et al . Importance of hospital volume in the overall management of pancreatic cancer. Ann Surg. 1998; 228 429-438
- 21 Sosa J A, Bowman H M, Tielsch J M, Powe N R, Gordon T A, Udelsman R. The importance of surgeon experience for clinical and economic outcomes from thyroidectomy. Ann Surg. 1998; 228 320-330
- 22 Williams S V, Nash D B, Goldfarb N. Differences in mortality from coronary artery bypass graft surgery at five teaching hospitals. Jama. 1991; 266 810-815
M. D. FRCS(C) D. D. Cochrane
Children's and Women's Health Center of British Columbia
4480 Oak Street